Resources

In a classical plant physiology laboratory practical, students investigate the differential growth response of dark-grown wheat (Triticum aestivum) coleoptile tips. Tips of length L0=2.00 mmL_0 = 2.00\text{ mm} were excised and placed on divided agar capture blocks (shaded receiver block SS vs. illuminated receiver block II) separated by a thin mica glass plate under unilateral directional light (450 nm450\text{ nm}) for 3.00 hours3.00\text{ hours}. The total diffusible auxin captured in both blocks was determined via a standardized indolic α\alpha-pyrone fluorescence assay against a calibrated standard curve: [IAA]=(1.45×10−2 nM/RFU)×F[\text{IAA}] = (1.45\times 10^{-2}\text{ nM/RFU}) \times F, where FF is relative fluorescence units. The assay yielded FS=352 RFUF_S = 352\text{ RFU} in the 0.500 mL0.500\text{ mL} shaded block extract and FI=128 RFUF_I = 128\text{ RFU} in the 0.500 mL0.500\text{ mL} illuminated block extract. (a) Calculate the exact molar quantity of auxin collected in the shaded block (nSn_S) and illuminated block (nIn_I) in picomoles (pmol\text{pmol}). (b) Calculate the lateral transport ratio nSnI\frac{n_S}{n_I} and the percentage of total translocated auxin directed toward the shaded side.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) nS=2.55 pmoln_S = 2.55\text{ pmol} and nI=0.928 pmoln_I = 0.928\text{ pmol}; (b) nSnI=2.75\frac{n_S}{n_I} = 2.75, with 73.3%73.3\% of total captured auxin translocated to the shaded side.

Steps

Biological Mechanism: Cholodny–Went Hypothesis

When a plant shoot or coleoptile tip is exposed to unilateral directional blue light (∼450 nm\sim 450\text{ nm}), phototropins are activated on the illuminated side. This photoperception establishes an asymmetric distribution of auxin (indole-3-acetic acid, or IAA) across the tip via lateral polar auxin transport toward the shaded side.


Part (a): Calculating Molar Quantities of Auxin (nSn_S and nIn_I)

  1. Calculate the Auxin Concentrations:
    Using the linear standard curve formula [IAA]=(1.45×10−2 nM/RFU)×F[\text{IAA}] = (1.45 \times 10^{-2}\text{ nM/RFU}) \times F:

    • For the shaded block (SS): [IAA]S=(1.45×10−2 nM/RFU)×352 RFU=5.104 nM[\text{IAA}]_S = (1.45 \times 10^{-2}\text{ nM/RFU}) \times 352\text{ RFU} = 5.104\text{ nM}
    • For the illuminated block (II): [IAA]I=(1.45×10−2 nM/RFU)×128 RFU=1.856 nM[\text{IAA}]_I = (1.45 \times 10^{-2}\text{ nM/RFU}) \times 128\text{ RFU} = 1.856\text{ nM}
  2. Convert Concentration to Absolute Molar Quantity:
    The volume of each extract is V=0.500 mL=0.500×10−3 LV = 0.500\text{ mL} = 0.500 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L}.
    Since 1 nM=1 nmol/L=10−3 pmol/mL1\text{ nM} = 1\text{ nmol/L} = 10^{-3}\text{ pmol/mL} (or directly, 1 nM×1 mL=1 pmol1\text{ nM} \times 1\text{ mL} = 1\text{ pmol}): n=[IAA]×Vn = [\text{IAA}] \times V

    • For the shaded block: nS=5.104 nmol/L×(0.500×10−3 L)=2.552×10−3 nmol=2.552 pmol≈2.55 pmoln_S = 5.104\text{ nmol/L} \times (0.500 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L}) = 2.552 \times 10^{-3}\text{ nmol} = 2.552\text{ pmol} \approx 2.55\text{ pmol}
    • For the illuminated block: nI=1.856 nmol/L×(0.500×10−3 L)=0.928×10−3 nmol=0.928 pmoln_I = 1.856\text{ nmol/L} \times (0.500 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L}) = 0.928 \times 10^{-3}\text{ nmol} = 0.928\text{ pmol}

Common Pitfall: A frequent error is confusing concentration ([IAA][\text{IAA}] in nM\text{nM}) with absolute amount (nn in pmol\text{pmol}). Always multiply concentration by the extraction volume (0.500 mL0.500\text{ mL}).


Part (b): Lateral Transport Ratio and Distribution Percentage

  1. Calculate the Lateral Transport Ratio:
    nSnI=2.552 pmol0.928 pmol=2.75\frac{n_S}{n_I} = \frac{2.552\text{ pmol}}{0.928\text{ pmol}} = 2.75 (Equivalently, because volumes and constants are identical, nSnI=FSFI=352128=2.75\frac{n_S}{n_I} = \frac{F_S}{F_I} = \frac{352}{128} = 2.75.)
  2. Calculate the Total Auxin and the Percentage Translocated to the Shaded Side:

    • Total captured auxin: ntotal=nS+nI=2.552 pmol+0.928 pmol=3.48 pmoln_{\text{total}} = n_S + n_I = 2.552\text{ pmol} + 0.928\text{ pmol} = 3.48\text{ pmol}
    • Percentage allocated to the shaded receiver block: PercentageS=(nSntotal)×100%=(2.552 pmol3.48 pmol)×100%≈73.3%\text{Percentage}_S = \left(\frac{n_S}{n_{\text{total}}}\right) \times 100\% = \left(\frac{2.552\text{ pmol}}{3.48\text{ pmol}}\right) \times 100\% \approx 73.3\%

This confirms that directional light induces a pronounced lateral redistribution of diffusible auxin toward the shaded side rather than destroying auxin on the illuminated side.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses molar concentration with molar quantity by omitting multiplication by the extract volume (0.500 mL).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    [IAA]S=1.45×10−2×352=5.104 nM  ⟹  nS=5.104 pmol[\text{IAA}]_S = 1.45 \times 10^{-2} \times 352 = 5.104\text{ nM} \implies n_S = 5.104\text{ pmol}

    Correct

    [IAA]S=1.45×10−2×352=5.104 nM  ⟹  nS=[IAA]S×V=5.104 nmol/L×0.500×10−3 L=2.55 pmol[\text{IAA}]_S = 1.45 \times 10^{-2} \times 352 = 5.104\text{ nM} \implies n_S = [\text{IAA}]_S \times V = 5.104\text{ nmol/L} \times 0.500 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L} = 2.55\text{ pmol}

    You correctly determined the shaded concentration as 5.104 nM5.104\text{ nM}, but you set nSn_S equal to the concentration value. To obtain the molar amount, you need to multiply the concentration by the extract volume (V=0.500 mLV = 0.500\text{ mL}).

  2. Step 2

    [IAA]I=1.45×10−2×128=1.856 nM  ⟹  nI=1.856 pmol[\text{IAA}]_I = 1.45 \times 10^{-2} \times 128 = 1.856\text{ nM} \implies n_I = 1.856\text{ pmol}

    Correct

    [IAA]I=1.45×10−2×128=1.856 nM  ⟹  nI=[IAA]I×V=1.856 nmol/L×0.500×10−3 L=0.928 pmol[\text{IAA}]_I = 1.45 \times 10^{-2} \times 128 = 1.856\text{ nM} \implies n_I = [\text{IAA}]_I \times V = 1.856\text{ nmol/L} \times 0.500 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L} = 0.928\text{ pmol}

    You correctly found the illuminated concentration to be 1.856 nM1.856\text{ nM}, but you omitted multiplication by the volume (V=0.500 mLV = 0.500\text{ mL}), which resulted in double the actual molar amount.

  3. Step 3

    nSnI=5.1041.856=2.75\frac{n_S}{n_I} = \frac{5.104}{1.856} = 2.75

    Correct

    nSnI=2.552 pmol0.928 pmol=2.75\frac{n_S}{n_I} = \frac{2.552\text{ pmol}}{0.928\text{ pmol}} = 2.75

    You correctly set up and calculated the ratio of shaded to illuminated auxin. Because the volume factor cancels out in the numerator and denominator, your final ratio of 2.752.75 is numerically correct despite using the unadjusted molar values.

  4. Step 4

    Percentage to shaded=5.1045.104+1.856×100%=73.3%\text{Percentage to shaded} = \frac{5.104}{5.104 + 1.856} \times 100\% = 73.3\%

    Correct

    Percentage to shaded=2.552 pmol2.552 pmol+0.928 pmol×100%=73.3%\text{Percentage to shaded} = \frac{2.552\text{ pmol}}{2.552\text{ pmol} + 0.928\text{ pmol}} \times 100\% = 73.3\%

    You correctly applied the percentage allocation formula. As with the ratio, the volume factor cancels out across all terms, giving the correct value of 73.3%73.3\%.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the linear standard curve formula to obtain the auxin concentrations [IAA]S[\text{IAA}]_S and [IAA]I[\text{IAA}]_I.

You set up the ratio and relative percentage expressions accurately in part (b).

You carried out all algebraic division and rounding with high numerical precision.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing concentration with absolute molar quantity

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the molar concentration value in nM\text{nM} (nmol/L) as if it directly represented the absolute molar quantity in pmol\text{pmol} without multiplying by the solution volume V=0.500 mLV = 0.500\text{ mL}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Volume Multiplication Check
  • n=C×Vn = C \times V, where CC is molar concentration and VV is the total solution volume.

  • Always verify whether a question requests a concentration ([IAA][\text{IAA}]) or an absolute molar amount (nn), and multiply by volume when converting from concentration to moles.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply the shaded block concentration by the extract volume: nS=5.104 nmol/L×0.500×10−3 L=2.552 pmol≈2.55 pmoln_S = 5.104\text{ nmol/L} \times 0.500 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L} = 2.552\text{ pmol} \approx 2.55\text{ pmol}.

  2. Multiply the illuminated block concentration by the extract volume: nI=1.856 nmol/L×0.500×10−3 L=0.928 pmoln_I = 1.856\text{ nmol/L} \times 0.500 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L} = 0.928\text{ pmol}.

Final answer

(a) nS=2.55 pmoln_S = 2.55\text{ pmol} and nI=0.928 pmoln_I = 0.928\text{ pmol}; (b) nSnI=2.75\frac{n_S}{n_I} = 2.75, with 73.3%73.3\% directed toward the shaded side.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice dimensional analysis for converting nanomolar concentration (nmol/L\text{nmol/L}) into picomoles (pmol\text{pmol}) across various extraction volumes.

  • Re-read experimental prompts carefully to distinguish between intensity/concentration measurements and total captured analyte quantities.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misinterprets the percentage of total translocated auxin as the relative ratio compared to the illuminated block alone rather than the total captured auxin.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    [IAA]S=1.45×10−2×352=5.104 nM  ⟹  nS=5.104 nM×0.500 mL=2.552 pmol[\text{IAA}]_S = 1.45 \times 10^{-2} \times 352 = 5.104\text{ nM} \implies n_S = 5.104\text{ nM} \times 0.500\text{ mL} = 2.552\text{ pmol}

  2. Step 2

    [IAA]I=1.45×10−2×128=1.856 nM  ⟹  nI=1.856 nM×0.500 mL=0.928 pmol[\text{IAA}]_I = 1.45 \times 10^{-2} \times 128 = 1.856\text{ nM} \implies n_I = 1.856\text{ nM} \times 0.500\text{ mL} = 0.928\text{ pmol}

  3. Step 3

    nSnI=2.5520.928=2.75\frac{n_S}{n_I} = \frac{2.552}{0.928} = 2.75

  4. Step 4

    Percentage directed to shaded=(nSnI)×100%=2.75×100%=275%\text{Percentage directed to shaded} = \left(\frac{n_S}{n_I}\right) \times 100\% = 2.75 \times 100\% = 275\%

    Correct

    PercentageS=(nSnS+nI)×100%=(2.552 pmol2.552 pmol+0.928 pmol)×100%≈73.3%\text{Percentage}_S = \left(\frac{n_S}{n_S + n_I}\right) \times 100\% = \left(\frac{2.552\text{ pmol}}{2.552\text{ pmol} + 0.928\text{ pmol}}\right) \times 100\% \approx 73.3\%

    You calculated the ratio of shaded auxin to illuminated auxin as a percentage rather than finding the fraction of total captured auxin (nS+nIn_S + n_I). A component percentage of a total pool cannot exceed 100%100\%.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the fluorescence calibration equation to determine auxin concentrations.

You properly accounted for the 0.500 mL0.500\text{ mL} extraction volume to find the molar quantities in picomoles.

You computed the lateral transport ratio nSnI=2.75\frac{n_S}{n_I} = 2.75 accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ratio vs. Part-to-Whole Confusion

You converted the relative ratio nSnI\frac{n_S}{n_I} directly into a percentage instead of dividing by the total captured auxin.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated a relative part-to-part comparison (the lateral transport ratio nS:nIn_S : n_I) with a part-to-whole distribution percentage (the proportion of total translocated auxin, nSntotal\frac{n_S}{n_{\text{total}}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Part-to-Part Ratio vs. Part-to-Whole Percentage
  • A relative ratio compares two subgroups (A/BA/B), whereas a percentage of a total distribution must have the sum of all parts in the denominator: AA+B×100%\frac{A}{A + B} \times 100\%.

  • Whenever a question asks for the percentage of total substance or distribution, sum all capture fractions to find ntotaln_{\text{total}} before computing the percentage.

Sanity Check on Component Proportions
  • The percentage of a partitioned total pool allocated to any single compartment must be strictly between 0%0\% and 100%100\%.

  • If your calculated distribution percentage exceeds 100%100\%, check whether you divided by another subgroup rather than the total.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Sum the molar quantities from both blocks to find the total captured auxin: ntotal=nS+nI=2.552 pmol+0.928 pmol=3.480 pmoln_{\text{total}} = n_S + n_I = 2.552\text{ pmol} + 0.928\text{ pmol} = 3.480\text{ pmol}.

  2. Compute the proportion directed toward the shaded side relative to this total: PercentageS=nSntotal×100%=2.552 pmol3.480 pmol×100%≈73.3%\text{Percentage}_S = \frac{n_S}{n_{\text{total}}} \times 100\% = \frac{2.552\text{ pmol}}{3.480\text{ pmol}} \times 100\% \approx 73.3\%.

Final answer

(a) nS=2.55 pmoln_S = 2.55\text{ pmol}, nI=0.928 pmoln_I = 0.928\text{ pmol}; (b) nSnI=2.75\frac{n_S}{n_I} = 2.75, with 73.3%73.3\% of total captured auxin directed to the shaded side.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying whether biological partitioning problems ask for a relative ratio (part-to-part) or an allocation fraction (part-to-whole).

  • Perform a quick boundary check on every percentage: an individual compartment's share of an overall pool cannot be greater than 100%100\%.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the ratio by calculating illuminated relative to shaded (n_I / n_S) instead of lateral transport toward the shaded side (n_S / n_I).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    [IAA]S=1.45×10−2×352=5.104 nM  ⟹  nS=5.104 nM×0.500 mL=2.552 pmol[\text{IAA}]_S = 1.45\times 10^{-2}\times 352 = 5.104\text{ nM} \implies n_S = 5.104\text{ nM}\times 0.500\text{ mL} = 2.552\text{ pmol}

  2. Step 2

    [IAA]I=1.45×10−2×128=1.856 nM  ⟹  nI=1.856 nM×0.500 mL=0.928 pmol[\text{IAA}]_I = 1.45\times 10^{-2}\times 128 = 1.856\text{ nM} \implies n_I = 1.856\text{ nM}\times 0.500\text{ mL} = 0.928\text{ pmol}

  3. Step 3

    Ratio=nInS=0.9282.552=0.364\text{Ratio} = \frac{n_I}{n_S} = \frac{0.928}{2.552} = 0.364

    Correct

    nSnI=2.552 pmol0.928 pmol≈2.75\frac{n_S}{n_I} = \frac{2.552\text{ pmol}}{0.928\text{ pmol}} \approx 2.75

    The prompt specifically defined the lateral transport ratio as nSnI\frac{n_S}{n_I} (shaded relative to illuminated), but you inverted the numerator and denominator to calculate nInS\frac{n_I}{n_S}.

  4. Step 4

    Percentage directed to shaded=2.5522.552+0.928×100%=73.3%\text{Percentage directed to shaded} = \frac{2.552}{2.552 + 0.928}\times 100\% = 73.3\%

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the linear fluorescence equation to calculate both auxin concentrations.

You accurately accounted for the extraction volume to obtain molar quantities in picomoles.

You correctly computed the total auxin and the resulting percentage directed to the shaded receiver block.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Ratio

You inverted the numerator and denominator when evaluating the lateral transport ratio.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You set up the ratio as illuminated over shaded (nInS\frac{n_I}{n_S}) instead of following the requested definition of lateral transport toward the shaded side (nSnI\frac{n_S}{n_I}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verify Ratio Orientation
  • When evaluating a ratio defined as AB\frac{A}{B} or 'ratio of A to B', the quantity of interest (AA) must be in the numerator and the reference baseline (BB) must be in the denominator.

  • Check whether the question specifies nSnI\frac{n_S}{n_I} or nInS\frac{n_I}{n_S}, and ensure the enriched side (nS>nIn_S > n_I) yields a ratio greater than 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the specified ratio formula from part (b): nSnI\frac{n_S}{n_I}.

  2. Substitute the molar values: nSnI=2.552 pmol0.928 pmol\frac{n_S}{n_I} = \frac{2.552\text{ pmol}}{0.928\text{ pmol}}.

  3. Perform the division: 2.5520.928≈2.75\frac{2.552}{0.928} \approx 2.75.

Final answer

(a) nS=2.55 pmoln_S = 2.55\text{ pmol}, nI=0.928 pmoln_I = 0.928\text{ pmol}; (b) nSnI=2.75\frac{n_S}{n_I} = 2.75, with 73.3%73.3\% directed toward the shaded side.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always reread the explicit fraction symbol AB\frac{A}{B} in the prompt before plugging in values.

  • Confirm that your ratio reflects the biological expectation: directional phototropism concentrates auxin on the shaded side, so nSnI\frac{n_S}{n_I} must be >1> 1.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A coleoptile diffusion experiment yields an auxin concentration of [IAA]=6.40 nM[\text{IAA}] = 6.40\text{ nM} in a receiver agar block extracted into a final volume of 0.250 mL0.250\text{ mL}. Calculate the total amount of auxin captured in picomoles (pmol\text{pmol}).

Answer

n=C×V=(6.40 nmol/L)×(0.250×10−3 L)=1.60×10−3 nmol=1.60 pmoln = C \times V = (6.40\text{ nmol/L}) \times (0.250 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L}) = 1.60 \times 10^{-3}\text{ nmol} = 1.60\text{ pmol}.

02

In a unilateral light assay, the shaded agar block extract (0.400 mL0.400\text{ mL}) has [IAA]S=3.60 nM[\text{IAA}]_S = 3.60\text{ nM}, while the illuminated block extract (0.800 mL0.800\text{ mL}) has [IAA]I=0.900 nM[\text{IAA}]_I = 0.900\text{ nM}. Calculate (a) the molar quantity in each block (nSn_S and nIn_I) in pmol\text{pmol}, and (b) the transport ratio nSnI\frac{n_S}{n_I}.

Answer

(a) nS=3.60 pmol/mL×0.400 mL=1.44 pmoln_S = 3.60\text{ pmol/mL} \times 0.400\text{ mL} = 1.44\text{ pmol}; nI=0.900 pmol/mL×0.800 mL=0.720 pmoln_I = 0.900\text{ pmol/mL} \times 0.800\text{ mL} = 0.720\text{ pmol}. (b) nSnI=1.44 pmol0.720 pmol=2.00\frac{n_S}{n_I} = \frac{1.44\text{ pmol}}{0.720\text{ pmol}} = 2.00.

03

Two coleoptile receiver blocks, Shaded (SS) and Illuminated (II), each of volume 0.500 mL0.500\text{ mL}, are analyzed. The fluorescence reading gives FS=420 RFUF_S = 420\text{ RFU} and FI=140 RFUF_I = 140\text{ RFU} with calibration slope k=2.00×10−2 nM/RFUk = 2.00 \times 10^{-2}\text{ nM/RFU}. If phototropic curvature requires at least 2.0 pmol2.0\text{ pmol} differential auxin (Δn=nS−nI)(\Delta n = n_S - n_I), determine whether this threshold is reached.

Answer

[IAA]S=420×0.0200=8.40 nM[\text{IAA}]_S = 420 \times 0.0200 = 8.40\text{ nM}; [IAA]I=140×0.0200=2.80 nM[\text{IAA}]_I = 140 \times 0.0200 = 2.80\text{ nM}. Then nS=8.40 nmol/L×0.500×10−3 L=4.20 pmoln_S = 8.40\text{ nmol/L} \times 0.500 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L} = 4.20\text{ pmol} and nI=2.80 nmol/L×0.500×10−3 L=1.40 pmoln_I = 2.80\text{ nmol/L} \times 0.500 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L} = 1.40\text{ pmol}. The difference is Δn=4.20−1.40=2.80 pmol≥2.0 pmol\Delta n = 4.20 - 1.40 = 2.80\text{ pmol} \ge 2.0\text{ pmol}. Yes, the threshold is exceeded.

Loading workspace…