Resources

A behavioral ecologist studies foraging boldness in a wild population of black-capped chickadees (Poecile atricapillus). The trait exhibits a broad-sense heritability of H2=0.420H^2 = 0.420. Phenotypic assessment of the population yields a total phenotypic variance of VP=28.5 units2V_P = 28.5\text{ units}^2. Assuming no genotype-environment interaction (VG×E=0V_{G \times E} = 0) and no genotype-environment correlation (Cov(G,E)=0Cov(G,E) = 0), calculate the absolute variance attributable strictly to environmental differences (VEV_E). Round your final answer to three significant figures with appropriate units.

Answer and steps

Final answer

VE=16.5 units2V_E = 16.5\text{ units}^2

Steps

01

Identify the components of phenotypic variance

In quantitative genetics, total phenotypic variance (VPV_P) partitions into genetic variance (VGV_G) and environmental variance (VEV_E). When there is no genotype-environment interaction (VG×E=0V_{G \times E} = 0) and no genotype-environment correlation (Cov(G,E)=0Cov(G, E) = 0), the relationship simplifies to:

VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E

02

Relate environmental variance to broad-sense heritability

Broad-sense heritability (H2H^2) measures the proportion of total phenotypic variance that is attributable to genetic variation:

H2=VGVPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P}

Rearranging for genetic variance gives:

VG=H2⋅VPV_G = H^2 \cdot V_P

Substitute this back into the total variance equation to solve directly for the environmental variance (VEV_E):

VE=VP−VG=VP−H2⋅VP=VP(1−H2)V_E = V_P - V_G = V_P - H^2 \cdot V_P = V_P(1 - H^2)

This shows that the environmental proportion of the variance is simply 1−H21 - H^2.

03

Calculate the numerical value of VEV_E

Given values:

  • VP=28.5 units2V_P = 28.5\text{ units}^2
  • H2=0.420H^2 = 0.420

Substitute these values into the derived equation:

VE=28.5⋅(1−0.420)V_E = 28.5 \cdot (1 - 0.420) VE=28.5⋅0.580=16.53 units2V_E = 28.5 \cdot 0.580 = 16.53\text{ units}^2

Rounding to three significant figures gives:

VE=16.5 units2V_E = 16.5\text{ units}^2

Common Pitfall: Ensure you calculate environmental variance (VEV_E) rather than genetic variance (VGV_G). Calculating VG=0.420⋅28.5=11.97 units2V_G = 0.420 \cdot 28.5 = 11.97\text{ units}^2 gives the variation due to genes, not the environment.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses environmental variance with genetic variance by directly calculating H² × V_P.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    VE=H2×VPV_E = H^2 \times V_P

    Correct

    VE=(1−H2)VPV_E = (1 - H^2)V_P  or \text{ or } VG=H2×VPV_G = H^2 \times V_P

    Broad-sense heritability is defined as the proportion of phenotypic variance due to genetics, H2=VGVPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P}. Therefore, multiplying H2×VPH^2 \times V_P yields genetic variance (VGV_G), not environmental variance (VEV_E).

  2. Step 2

    VE=0.420×28.5  ⟹  VE=11.97 units2=12.0 units2V_E = 0.420 \times 28.5 \implies V_E = 11.97\text{ units}^2 = 12.0\text{ units}^2

    Correct

    VE=(1−0.420)×28.5=0.580×28.5=16.53 units2≈16.5 units2V_E = (1 - 0.420) \times 28.5 = 0.580 \times 28.5 = 16.53\text{ units}^2 \approx 16.5\text{ units}^2

    Your arithmetic and rounding were accurate for the numbers you multiplied, but the result represents VG=12.0 units2V_G = 12.0\text{ units}^2 rather than VEV_E.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the given values for heritability and total phenotypic variance from the problem.

You accurately multiplied the values and rounded your calculated result to three significant figures with proper units.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula confusion: $V_E$ vs. $V_G$

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You equated broad-sense heritability (H2H^2) with the environmental proportion of phenotypic variance rather than the genetic proportion. In quantitative genetics, heritability describes variation attributable to genes (VG/VPV_G/V_P), meaning the environmental fraction is the complement, e2=1−H2=VE/VPe^2 = 1 - H^2 = V_E/V_P.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Heritability Definition
  • H2=VGVPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P}, which means VG=H2⋅VPV_G = H^2 \cdot V_P.

  • Always verify whether the question asks for genetic variance (VGV_G) or environmental variance (VEV_E) before selecting your formula.

Partitioning Phenotypic Variance
  • When VG×E=0V_{G \times E} = 0 and Cov⁡(G,E)=0\operatorname{Cov}(G,E) = 0, VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E, so VE=VP(1−H2)V_E = V_P(1 - H^2).

  • Subtract the genetic proportion from 1 to find the environmental proportion: VE=(1−H2)VPV_E = (1 - H^2)V_P.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall the variance partitioning formula: VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E.

  2. Express environmental variance in terms of heritability: VE=VP−VG=VP−H2VP=VP(1−H2)V_E = V_P - V_G = V_P - H^2 V_P = V_P(1 - H^2).

  3. Substitute the given values: VE=28.5⋅(1−0.420)=28.5⋅0.580=16.53 units2V_E = 28.5 \cdot (1 - 0.420) = 28.5 \cdot 0.580 = 16.53\text{ units}^2.

  4. Round to three significant figures: VE=16.5 units2V_E = 16.5\text{ units}^2.

Final answer

VE=16.5 units2V_E = 16.5\text{ units}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definitions of broad-sense heritability (H2H^2) and environmental variance (VEV_E).

  • Practice decomposing total phenotypic variance into its genetic and environmental components before calculating.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student interprets broad-sense heritability H² as being already squared and squares 0.420 before subtracting it from 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    VE=(1−(H2)2)×VP  ⟹  VE=(1−0.4202)×28.5V_E = (1 - (H^2)^2) \times V_P \implies V_E = (1 - 0.420^2) \times 28.5

    Correct

    VE=(1−H2)×VP=(1−0.420)×28.5V_E = (1 - H^2) \times V_P = (1 - 0.420) \times 28.5

    In quantitative genetics, H2H^2 is a single composite symbol representing broad-sense heritability (VG/VP=0.420V_G / V_P = 0.420). The superscript 2 is part of standard genetic notation, not an algebraic operation. You should subtract 0.4200.420 directly from 11 rather than squaring it to 0.42020.420^2.

  2. Step 2

    VE=(1−0.1764)×28.5  ⟹  VE=0.8236×28.5V_E = (1 - 0.1764) \times 28.5 \implies V_E = 0.8236 \times 28.5

    Correct

    VE=0.580×28.5V_E = 0.580 \times 28.5

    Your arithmetic evaluation inside the parentheses followed logically from your formula, but the value was affected by the erroneous squaring of 0.4200.420 in the previous step.

  3. Step 3

    VE=23.5 units2V_E = 23.5\text{ units}^2

    Correct

    VE=16.5 units2V_E = 16.5\text{ units}^2

    You carried out the multiplication and rounding accurately based on your intermediate values, but the final value is incorrect due to the initial formula error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that environmental variance (VEV_E) and genetic variance (VGV_G) sum to total phenotypic variance (VPV_P) in the absence of interaction and covariance terms.

You properly carried appropriate units of units2\text{units}^2 through to your final answer.

You executed the arithmetic and rounding to three significant figures accurately based on your chosen expressions.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Notation Misinterpretation (Heritability Squared Symbol)

You squared the given heritability value 0.4200.420 because the symbol for broad-sense heritability contains a superscript 2 (H2H^2).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing standard population genetic notation with an algebraic squaring instruction. In quantitative genetics, H2H^2 (broad-sense) and h2h^2 (narrow-sense) are unitary variable symbols denoting proportions of variance, not quantities waiting to be raised to the power of 2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Interpret heritability symbols as unitary values
  • The symbols H2H^2 and h2h^2 denote variance ratios (VG/VPV_G/V_P and VA/VPV_A/V_P). A value given as H2=0.420H^2 = 0.420 means the proportion itself equals 0.4200.420.

  • Use the given number directly as H2=0.420H^2 = 0.420 without squaring or taking square roots unless you explicitly need the correlation coefficient (HH).

Partition variance by proportions
  • VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E, meaning 1=H2+VEVP1 = H^2 + \frac{V_E}{V_P}. Therefore, the environmental fraction is directly (1−H2)(1 - H^2).

  • Multiply total phenotypic variance by (1−H2)(1 - H^2) directly to find VEV_E.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express environmental variance as VE=VP(1−H2)V_E = V_P(1 - H^2).

  2. Substitute the given heritability directly: VE=28.5×(1−0.420)V_E = 28.5 \times (1 - 0.420).

  3. Compute the environmental proportion: 1−0.420=0.5801 - 0.420 = 0.580.

  4. Multiply: VE=28.5×0.580=16.53 units2V_E = 28.5 \times 0.580 = 16.53\text{ units}^2.

Final answer

VE=16.5 units2V_E = 16.5\text{ units}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review quantitative genetics notation conventions to remember that H2H^2 and h2h^2 represent fractions of variance, not squared numerical values.

  • Practice partitioning phenotypic variance into genetic and environmental components using the complement rule: fraction environmental =1−H2= 1 - H^2.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates environmental variance by dividing total phenotypic variance by heritability instead of multiplying by the environmental proportion.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    VE=VP1−H2V_E = \frac{V_P}{1 - H^2}

    Correct

    VE=VP(1−H2)V_E = V_P(1 - H^2)

    You inverted the algebraic relationship between total variance and environmental variance. By definition, VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E and H2=VGVPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P}, which means VE=VP−VG=VP(1−H2)V_E = V_P - V_G = V_P(1 - H^2).

  2. Step 2

    VE=28.51−0.420V_E = \frac{28.5}{1 - 0.420}

    Correct

    VE=28.5⋅(1−0.420)V_E = 28.5 \cdot (1 - 0.420)

    You substituted the correct numerical values of VP=28.5V_P = 28.5 and H2=0.420H^2 = 0.420 into the inverted formula from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    VE=49.1 units2V_E = 49.1\text{ units}^2

    Correct

    VE=16.5 units2V_E = 16.5\text{ units}^2

    Your final numerical calculation followed directly from the division error in Step 1. Notice that your result of 49.1 units249.1\text{ units}^2 exceeds the total phenotypic variance of 28.5 units228.5\text{ units}^2, which signals that division occurred instead of multiplication.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the environmental fraction corresponds to 1−H21 - H^2.

You correctly calculated the numerical difference 1−0.420=0.5801 - 0.420 = 0.580.

You included the correct squared units in your final answer.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted algebraic formula for variance component

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the proportion equation as 1−H2=VPVE1 - H^2 = \frac{V_P}{V_E} rather than the part-to-whole relationship VEVP=1−H2\frac{V_E}{V_P} = 1 - H^2, leading you to divide the whole by the proportion rather than taking a fraction of the whole.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Part-to-Whole Sanity Check
  • When Cov(G,E)=0Cov(G,E) = 0 and VG×E=0V_{G \times E} = 0, VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E. Since variances cannot be negative, VE≤VPV_E \le V_P must always hold.

  • Check whether your calculated component exceeds the total phenotypic variance. If VE>VPV_E > V_P, verify whether you divided instead of multiplied.

Variance Component Derivation
  • H2=VGVP  ⟹  VG=H2VPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} \implies V_G = H^2 V_P, so VE=VP−VG=VP(1−H2)V_E = V_P - V_G = V_P(1 - H^2).

  • Multiply the total phenotypic variance VPV_P by the environmental proportion (1−H2)(1 - H^2) to find absolute environmental variance.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Start from the additive variance partitioning equation: VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E.

  2. Express environmental variance as the remaining fraction of phenotypic variance: VE=VP(1−H2)V_E = V_P(1 - H^2).

  3. Substitute the given values into the product: VE=28.5⋅(1−0.420)=28.5⋅0.580V_E = 28.5 \cdot (1 - 0.420) = 28.5 \cdot 0.580.

  4. Multiply and round to three significant figures: VE=16.53 units2≈16.5 units2V_E = 16.53\text{ units}^2 \approx 16.5\text{ units}^2.

Final answer

VE=16.5 units2V_E = 16.5\text{ units}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the quantitative genetics definitions showing that heritability (H2H^2) and environmental proportion (e2e^2) are fractions of total phenotypic variance (VPV_P).

  • Before finishing any variance problem, compare your component variance (VEV_E or VGV_G) against total variance (VPV_P) to verify that the part is smaller than the whole.

  • Complete the three targeted practice exercises below to practice finding component variances from proportional heritability values.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A population of deer mice has a total phenotypic variance for running endurance of VP=45.0 s2V_P = 45.0\text{ s}^2. If broad-sense heritability is H2=0.600H^2 = 0.600 and there is no interaction or correlation between genes and environment, calculate the environmental variance (VEV_E).

Answer

VE=VP(1−H2)=45.0×(1−0.600)=45.0×0.400=18.0 s2V_E = V_P(1 - H^2) = 45.0 \times (1 - 0.600) = 45.0 \times 0.400 = 18.0\text{ s}^2.

02

In a study of web-building diameter in orb-weaving spiders, total phenotypic variance is VP=64.0 cm2V_P = 64.0\text{ cm}^2 and genetic variance is measured directly as VG=16.0 cm2V_G = 16.0\text{ cm}^2. Assuming VG×E=0V_{G \times E} = 0, determine both the broad-sense heritability (H2H^2) and the environmental variance (VEV_E).

Answer

First, calculate heritability: H2=VGVP=16.064.0=0.250H^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{16.0}{64.0} = 0.250. Next, find environmental variance: VE=VP−VG=64.0−16.0=48.0 cm2V_E = V_P - V_G = 64.0 - 16.0 = 48.0\text{ cm}^2.

03

In a population of fruit flies, total phenotypic variance for wing length is VP=12.5 mm2V_P = 12.5\text{ mm}^2 with broad-sense heritability H2=0.720H^2 = 0.720. Following an environmental disturbance, the absolute environmental variance (VEV_E) doubles, while genetic variance (VGV_G) remains unchanged. Assuming no gene-environment interaction, calculate the new total phenotypic variance (VP′V_P') and the new heritability (H′2{H'}^2). Round to three significant figures.

Answer
  1. Find initial components: VG=0.720×12.5=9.00 mm2V_G = 0.720 \times 12.5 = 9.00\text{ mm}^2, and initial VE=12.5−9.00=3.50 mm2V_E = 12.5 - 9.00 = 3.50\text{ mm}^2.
  2. Compute new environmental variance: VE′=2×3.50=7.00 mm2V_E' = 2 \times 3.50 = 7.00\text{ mm}^2.
  3. New total variance: VP′=VG+VE′=9.00+7.00=16.0 mm2V_P' = V_G + V_E' = 9.00 + 7.00 = 16.0\text{ mm}^2.
  4. New heritability: H′2=VGVP′=9.0016.0=0.563{H'}^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P'} = \frac{9.00}{16.0} = 0.563.
Loading workspace…