Resources

In an evolution experiment evaluating compensatory mutations, a plasmid conferring resistance carries a biological fitness cost ss such that the relative growth rate of resistant cells compared to wild-type is w=1−sw = 1 - s. The selection coefficient depends on metabolic burden via s(g)=0.350g1.00+gs(g) = \frac{0.350 g}{1.00 + g}, where gg represents the plasmid copy number per cell. (a) Evaluate the asymptotic limit of the fitness cost as plasmid copy number becomes extremely large, lim⁡g→∞s(g)\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g). (b) If g=25.0 copies/cellg = 25.0\text{ copies/cell}, calculate the exact value of s(25.0)s(25.0) and the resulting relative fitness ww.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) lim⁡g→∞s(g)=0.350\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g) = 0.350 (a maximum fitness cost of 35.0%35.0\%); (b) s(25.0)=0.337s(25.0) = 0.337 and w=0.663w = 0.663.

Steps

Part (a): Determine the Asymptotic Limit of the Fitness Cost

The metabolic burden of maintaining plasmid copies imposes a selection coefficient (fitness cost) s(g)s(g) defined by a hyperbolic (saturation-type) function: s(g)=0.350g1.00+gs(g) = \frac{0.350 g}{1.00 + g}

To find the asymptotic fitness cost as the plasmid copy number becomes arbitrarily large (g→∞g \to \infty), divide the numerator and denominator by gg: lim⁡g→∞s(g)=lim⁡g→∞0.350g−1+1\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g) = \lim_{g \to \infty} \frac{0.350}{g^{-1} + 1}

As g→∞g \to \infty, the term 1g→0\frac{1}{g} \to 0: lim⁡g→∞s(g)=0.3500+1=0.350\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g) = \frac{0.350}{0 + 1} = 0.350

Biological Meaning: Even at extremely high copy numbers, the plasmid metabolic burden approaches an upper bound of 0.3500.350, meaning resistant cells experience a maximum fitness penalty of 35.0%35.0\% compared to wild-type cells in the absence of antibiotics.


Part (b): Calculate the Fitness Cost and Relative Fitness for g=25.0g = 25.0

  1. Calculate the fitness cost s(25.0)s(25.0): Substitute g=25.0g = 25.0 into the fitness cost function: s(25.0)=0.350⋅25.01.00+25.0=8.7526.0≈0.3365s(25.0) = \frac{0.350 \cdot 25.0}{1.00 + 25.0} = \frac{8.75}{26.0} \approx 0.3365 Rounding to three significant figures gives: s(25.0)=0.337s(25.0) = 0.337
  2. Calculate the relative fitness ww: The relative fitness ww of the resistant strain compared to the wild-type strain (w0=1w_0 = 1) is: w=1−sw = 1 - s w=1−0.3365=0.6635w = 1 - 0.3365 = 0.6635 Rounding to three significant figures gives: w=0.663w = 0.663

Pitfall Note: Be careful not to round intermediate values prematurely. Carry full precision when computing w=1−s(25.0)w = 1 - s(25.0) to avoid rounding discrepancies in the third decimal place.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the asymptotic limit as g -> infinity by dividing coefficients incorrectly, treating the constant 1.00 as the dominant term in the denominator or taking the limit as g -> 0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    lim⁡g→∞s(g)=0.350/1.00=0.350g  ⟹  As g→∞, s(g)→∞\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g) = 0.350 / 1.00 = 0.350 g \implies \text{As } g \to \infty,\ s(g) \to \infty

    Correct

    lim⁡g→∞s(g)=lim⁡g→∞0.350g−1+1=0.350\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g) = \lim_{g \to \infty} \frac{0.350}{g^{-1} + 1} = 0.350

    When taking the limit as g→∞g \to \infty, the variable term gg in the denominator dominates the constant 1.001.00. Dividing both numerator and denominator by gg shows that 0.3501/g+1→0.350\frac{0.350}{1/g + 1} \to 0.350, so the fitness cost approaches a horizontal asymptote rather than growing to infinity.

  2. Step 2

    s(25.0)=0.350⋅25.01.00+25.0=8.7526.0=35104s(25.0) = \frac{0.350 \cdot 25.0}{1.00 + 25.0} = \frac{8.75}{26.0} = \frac{35}{104}

  3. Step 3

    w=1−35104=69104w = 1 - \frac{35}{104} = \frac{69}{104}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the given copy number into the metabolic burden formula.

You simplified the decimal fraction to its exact reduced rational form 35104\frac{35}{104}.

You correctly applied the relation w=1−sw = 1 - s to compute relative fitness.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Limits at infinity for rational saturation functions

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You ignored the highest-degree variable gg in the denominator when taking the limit as g→∞g \to \infty, dividing only by the constant term 1.001.00 and incorrectly leaving an uncancelled gg in the numerator.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate rational functions as $x \to \infty$
  • For a rational function axb+x\frac{a x}{b + x}, divide every term by the highest power of xx (here, xx) to find the horizontal asymptote: lim⁡x→∞ab/x+1=a0+1=a\lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{a}{b/x + 1} = \frac{a}{0 + 1} = a.

  • Always compare the degrees of numerator and denominator before concluding whether a function saturates or diverges.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the limit expression: lim⁡g→∞s(g)=lim⁡g→∞0.350g1.00+g\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g) = \lim_{g \to \infty} \frac{0.350 g}{1.00 + g}.

  2. Divide both numerator and denominator by gg: lim⁡g→∞0.3501.00g+1\lim_{g \to \infty} \frac{0.350}{\frac{1.00}{g} + 1}.

  3. Evaluate the limit as g→∞g \to \infty, noting that 1.00g→0\frac{1.00}{g} \to 0: 0.3500+1=0.350\frac{0.350}{0 + 1} = 0.350.

Final answer

(a) lim⁡g→∞s(g)=0.350\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g) = 0.350; (b) s(25.0)=35104≈0.337s(25.0) = \frac{35}{104} \approx 0.337 and w=69104≈0.663w = \frac{69}{104} \approx 0.663

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review horizontal asymptotes of Michaelis-Menten-style hyperbolic functions Vmax⁡xKm+x\frac{V_{\max} x}{K_m + x}.

  • Practice dividing numerator and denominator by the leading power of the variable when evaluating limits at infinity.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses fitness cost s with relative fitness w and adds s to 1 instead of subtracting it.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    lim⁡g→∞0.350g1.00+g=0.350\lim_{g \to \infty} \frac{0.350 g}{1.00 + g} = 0.350

  2. Step 2

    s(25.0)=0.350⋅25.01.00+25.0=8.7526.0=35104s(25.0) = \frac{0.350 \cdot 25.0}{1.00 + 25.0} = \frac{8.75}{26.0} = \frac{35}{104}

  3. Step 3

    w=1+s  ⟹  w=1+35104=139104w = 1 + s \implies w = 1 + \frac{35}{104} = \frac{139}{104}

    Correct

    w=1−s=1−35104=69104≈0.663w = 1 - s = 1 - \frac{35}{104} = \frac{69}{104} \approx 0.663

    A fitness cost reduces the organism's relative fitness compared to the wild type (w0=1w_0 = 1), so you must subtract the cost: w=1−sw = 1 - s. Adding ss incorrectly indicates that maintaining the plasmid provides a fitness benefit.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly evaluated the limit of the rational function as g→∞g \to \infty.

You substituted the copy number g=25.0g = 25.0 accurately and reduced the resulting fraction to simplest form.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in relative fitness formula

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused a fitness cost (selection penalty, s>0s > 0) with a selective advantage. A biological burden lowers reproductive fitness below baseline (w=1−s<1w = 1 - s < 1), whereas adding ss implies an increased fitness (w>1w > 1).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Fitness Cost vs. Advantage
  • When a mutation or plasmid imposes a fitness cost ss, the relative fitness is w=1−sw = 1 - s. Only a selective advantage increases fitness (w=1+sw = 1 + s).

  • Verify whether ss represents a metabolic penalty or an advantage, and ensure that a fitness cost brings ww below 11 in antibiotic-free media.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the relationship between relative fitness and fitness cost: w=1−sw = 1 - s.

  2. Substitute s=35104s = \frac{35}{104}: w=1−35104=69104w = 1 - \frac{35}{104} = \frac{69}{104}.

  3. Convert to decimals: s(25.0)≈0.337s(25.0) \approx 0.337 and w=69104≈0.663w = \frac{69}{104} \approx 0.663.

Final answer

(a) lim⁡g→∞s(g)=0.350\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g) = 0.350; (b) s(25.0)=35104≈0.337s(25.0) = \frac{35}{104} \approx 0.337 and w=69104≈0.663w = \frac{69}{104} \approx 0.663

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always perform a sanity check on ww: if a trait carries a metabolic burden or cost, ww must be less than 1.001.00.

  • Practice distinguishing between selection coefficients that confer a penalty (w=1−sw = 1 - s) versus a selective benefit (w=1+sw = 1 + s).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to add 1.00 to g in the denominator when calculating s(25.0), dividing by g instead of 1.00 + g.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    lim⁡g→∞s(g)=0.3501=0.350\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g) = \frac{0.350}{1} = 0.350

  2. Step 2

    s(25.0)=0.350⋅25.025.0=0.350s(25.0) = \frac{0.350 \cdot 25.0}{25.0} = 0.350

    Correct

    s(25.0)=0.350⋅25.01.00+25.0=8.7526.0≈0.337s(25.0) = \frac{0.350 \cdot 25.0}{1.00 + 25.0} = \frac{8.75}{26.0} \approx 0.337

    You wrote gg alone in the denominator instead of 1.00+g1.00 + g. The denominator should be 1.00+25.0=26.01.00 + 25.0 = 26.0.

  3. Step 3

    w=1−0.350=0.650w = 1 - 0.350 = 0.650

    Correct

    w=1−0.3365≈0.663w = 1 - 0.3365 \approx 0.663

    You applied the relative fitness formula w=1−sw = 1 - s correctly, but your result was altered by the incorrect value of s(25.0)s(25.0) from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly evaluated the limit as g→∞g \to \infty to determine the maximum metabolic burden.

You correctly identified and applied the relationship w=1−sw = 1 - s between fitness cost and relative fitness.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Denominator Constant

You replaced the entire denominator 1.00+g1.00 + g with just gg, canceling out the copy number and mistakenly equating s(25.0)s(25.0) to the asymptotic maximum 0.3500.350.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating finite-value evaluation with the asymptotic limit: after dividing leading terms in part (a) where 1.001.00 becomes negligible as g→∞g \to \infty, you treated 1.00+g1.00 + g as simply gg even at a finite value (g=25.0g = 25.0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluating Saturation Functions at Finite Inputs
  • In Michaelis-Menten / Hill-type saturation formulas of the form f(x)=Vmax⁡xK+xf(x) = \frac{V_{\max} x}{K + x}, you cannot drop the constant KK for finite xx.

  • Always evaluate the sum in the denominator (K+x)(K + x) completely before simplifying or dividing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute g=25.0g = 25.0 into the complete denominator: 1.00+25.0=26.01.00 + 25.0 = 26.0.

  2. Evaluate s(25.0)=0.350⋅25.026.0=8.7526.0≈0.3365s(25.0) = \frac{0.350 \cdot 25.0}{26.0} = \frac{8.75}{26.0} \approx 0.3365.

  3. Compute relative fitness: w=1−s(25.0)=1−0.3365=0.6635w = 1 - s(25.0) = 1 - 0.3365 = 0.6635.

Final answer

(a) lim⁡g→∞s(g)=0.350\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g) = 0.350; (b) s(25.0)=0.337s(25.0) = 0.337 and w=0.663w = 0.663.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice substituting finite values into hyperbolic saturation functions without dropping baseline constants.

  • Double-check that any calculated fitness cost s(g)s(g) at a finite copy number is strictly less than its horizontal asymptote.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A bacterial strain carries a transposon with metabolic cost function s(n)=0.200n5.00+ns(n) = \frac{0.200 n}{5.00 + n}, where nn is insertion copy number. Find the theoretical upper bound on this fitness cost, lim⁡n→∞s(n)\lim_{n \to \infty} s(n).

Answer

lim⁡n→∞s(n)=0.200\lim_{n \to \infty} s(n) = 0.200. Divide numerator and denominator by nn: lim⁡n→∞0.2005.00n+1=0.2000+1=0.200\lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{0.200}{\frac{5.00}{n} + 1} = \frac{0.200}{0 + 1} = 0.200 (a maximum fitness cost of 20.0%20.0\%).

02

For the same transposon system s(n)=0.200n5.00+ns(n) = \frac{0.200 n}{5.00 + n}, calculate the exact fitness cost s(15.0)s(15.0) and the resulting relative fitness w=1−s(15.0)w = 1 - s(15.0) for n=15.0n = 15.0 insertions.

Answer

s(15.0)=0.200⋅15.05.00+15.0=3.0020.0=0.150s(15.0) = \frac{0.200 \cdot 15.0}{5.00 + 15.0} = \frac{3.00}{20.0} = 0.150. Relative fitness w=1−0.150=0.850w = 1 - 0.150 = 0.850.

03

A resistance plasmid imposes fitness cost s(g)=0.400g29.00+g2s(g) = \frac{0.400 g^2}{9.00 + g^2}. (a) Determine lim⁡g→∞s(g)\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g). (b) If compensatory mutations reduce the plateau cost by 50%50\% to s∗(g)=0.200g29.00+g2s^*(g) = \frac{0.200 g^2}{9.00 + g^2}, find the new relative fitness w∗w^* at g=3.00g = 3.00.

Answer

(a) lim⁡g→∞s(g)=lim⁡g→∞0.4009.00/g2+1=0.400\lim_{g \to \infty} s(g) = \lim_{g \to \infty} \frac{0.400}{9.00/g^2 + 1} = 0.400. (b) For g=3.00g = 3.00, s∗(3.00)=0.200⋅9.009.00+9.00=1.8018.0=0.100s^*(3.00) = \frac{0.200 \cdot 9.00}{9.00 + 9.00} = \frac{1.80}{18.0} = 0.100. Thus w∗=1−0.100=0.900w^* = 1 - 0.100 = 0.900.

Loading workspace…