Resources
An undergraduate biology cohort conducts a laboratory hybridization trial with two wild species of sunflower, and . In the control group, intraspecific crosses of produce viable seeds from ovules. In the experimental group, hand-pollinated heterospecific crosses () yield ovules, but only develop into mature seeds due to seed abortion caused by endosperm developmental failure. Furthermore, of the germinated hybrids, pollen staining reveals that only individuals produce viable gametes (mean pollen viability of compared to in controls). (a) Calculate the percentage reduction in seed set efficiency in the heterospecific cross relative to the intraspecific control. (b) Categorize the specific postzygotic barriers demonstrated by (i) seed abortion from endosperm failure and (ii) low pollen viability in surviving adults. (c) In a diagnostic chi-square () test evaluating whether hybrid seed germination ( successes out of ) matches the expected control proportion ( out of ), state the formal statistical conclusion when at (specifically avoiding the phrase 'accept the null hypothesis').
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) reduction (). (b) (i) Hybrid inviability (embryo/endosperm mortality). (ii) Hybrid sterility (defective gametogenesis/meiotic abnormalities). (c) Reject the null hypothesis () (there is a statistically significant reduction in seed set efficiency for the interspecific cross); if , the required collegiate/AP terminology is to 'fail to reject the null hypothesis ()'. Never state 'accept the null hypothesis'.
Steps
(a) Percentage Reduction in Seed Set Efficiency
The seed set efficiency in the intraspecific control cross is viable seeds per ovules, whereas in the heterospecific cross it is viable seeds per ovules.
To determine the relative percentage reduction:
Common Pitfall: Do not divide by the total number of ovules () when calculating a relative reduction between two experimental conditions; the reference baseline is the control performance ().
(b) Classification of Postzygotic Reproductive Barriers
Postzygotic reproductive isolating mechanisms occur after fertilization and are classified by the developmental stage at which the barrier manifests:
- (i) Hybrid inviability: The arrest of developmental growth, endosperm breakdown, or early seed abortion prevents the zygote from completing normal embryonic development into a healthy, viable individual.
- (ii) Hybrid sterility: The hybrid reaches adult maturity but cannot reproduce successfully because chromosomal mismatches or meiotic errors disrupt gametogenesis, resulting in non-viable gametes (as seen in the pollen viability).
(c) Formal Statistical Conclusion
When the calculated test statistic exceeds the critical value at the specified significance level ( at ):
- Conclusion: Reject the null hypothesis (). There is a statistically significant difference (a significant reduction) in seed set efficiency between the heterospecific cross and the intraspecific control.
- Terminology note: In hypothesis testing, data can never conclusively prove a null hypothesis true. If , standard scientific convention requires stating that one "fails to reject the null hypothesis", never that one "accepts the null hypothesis."
Typical errors
01 The student calculates the absolute percentage point difference (82% - 4.1% = 77.9%) rather than the relative percentage reduction based on the control group.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Control seed set = Hybrid seed set = Reduction =
CorrectYou found the absolute percentage point drop between the two groups () instead of the percentage reduction relative to the control group baseline of seeds (or ).
- Step 2
(i) Hybrid inviability (ii) Hybrid sterility
- Step 3
Reject the null hypothesis; there is significant evidence that hybrid seed success differs from the control.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the individual seed set proportions for both the control and hybrid crosses.
You accurately distinguished hybrid inviability from hybrid sterility based on the developmental timing of reproductive failure.
You correctly provided the standard collegiate statistical conclusion when the calculated test statistic exceeds the critical value.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou computed an absolute difference in percentages rather than dividing by the control baseline to find relative reduction.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing an absolute change (percentage points) with a relative percentage change (). When asked for relative change compared to a control, the denominator must always be the control value.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Establish the Reference Baseline
Relative percentage reduction is always calculated as .
Always identify the control value as your baseline denominator before calculating a percentage change.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the baseline control yield: viable seeds (or ).
Determine the absolute reduction: viable seeds.
Divide the reduction by the control baseline: .
(a) reduction; (b) (i) Hybrid inviability, (ii) Hybrid sterility; (c) Reject the null hypothesis ().
02 The student confuses the postzygotic barrier categories, incorrectly classifying seed failure before maturity as hybrid breakdown and adult sterility as hybrid inviability.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
(i) Hybrid breakdown
Correct(i) Hybrid inviability
Seed abortion during endosperm development represents embryonic/developmental arrest in the generation itself, which defines hybrid inviability. Hybrid breakdown only manifests in later generations ( or backcross progeny) after an initial viable, fertile generation.
- Step 3
(ii) Hybrid inviability
Correct(ii) Hybrid sterility
Because the plants successfully germinated and reached adulthood but produced defective gametes ( pollen viability), they survived but cannot reproduce. This inability of surviving adult hybrids to produce functional gametes is hybrid sterility.
- Step 4
Reject the null hypothesis; there is a statistically significant difference between the observed hybrid and control seed proportions.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou set up and evaluated the relative percentage reduction correctly using the control seed set as the baseline.
You articulated the formal statistical conclusion accurately without using incorrect phrases such as 'accept the null hypothesis'.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou shifted the categories of postzygotic isolation down by one developmental stage, labeling embryonic lethality as breakdown and gametic failure as inviability.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the developmental and generational timelines that distinguish postzygotic barriers: hybrid inviability occurs when embryos fail to develop or survive to reproductive age; hybrid sterility occurs when adults survive but cannot form functional gametes; and hybrid breakdown occurs only when fertile individuals produce inviable or sterile or backcross offspring.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Stage of Failure Check
If failure occurs during embryonic, seed, or juvenile development in the immediate cross, the barrier is hybrid inviability.
Check whether the organism dies before reaching adult reproductive maturity.
- Gamete Viability in Adults Check
If the hybrid survives to reproductive adulthood but exhibits meiotic breakdown or defective gametes, the barrier is hybrid sterility.
Check if an adult organism is present but sterile (such as low pollen or sperm viability).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration(b)(i) Because the hybrid seeds abort during early endosperm development before maturing into viable plants, the barrier is hybrid inviability.
(b)(ii) Because surviving adults develop successfully but fail to produce functional pollen, the barrier is hybrid sterility.
(a) reduction. (b) (i) Hybrid inviability; (ii) Hybrid sterility. (c) Reject the null hypothesis ().
03 The student commits a statistical phrasing error by concluding that the alternative hypothesis is proven true rather than stating a rejection of the null hypothesis supported by evidence.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Control seed set = Hybrid seed set =
- Step 2
(i) Hybrid inviability (ii) Hybrid sterility
- Step 3
Prove the alternative hypothesis that hybrid seed germination is definitely lower than the control.
CorrectReject the null hypothesis (). There is statistically significant evidence that hybrid seed set efficiency differs from the control proportion.
In inferential statistics, empirical tests never prove hypotheses or establish absolute certainty. When , the formal conclusion is to reject the null hypothesis ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the control value as the denominator to compute the percentage reduction.
You correctly distinguished developmental seed abortion from adult reproductive failure as hybrid inviability and hybrid sterility.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote that the alternative hypothesis is proven true instead of rejecting the null hypothesis.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating statistical significance with absolute proof. Hypothesis testing evaluates whether observed data are sufficiently improbable under the null hypothesis, resulting in rejecting or failing to reject , rather than proving any hypothesis definitely true.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Formal Decision Rule
When the test statistic exceeds the critical value ( at ), the only valid formal decision regarding hypotheses is to reject the null hypothesis ().
State 'Reject ' followed by 'There is statistically significant evidence of a difference.' Never claim that an alternative hypothesis is 'proven' or 'definitely true'.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationNote that at the significance level.
Make the formal statistical decision: reject the null hypothesis ().
State the biological interpretation: there is statistically significant evidence that the interspecific cross has a lower seed set efficiency than the intraspecific control.
(a) reduction. (b) (i) Hybrid inviability, (ii) Hybrid sterility. (c) Reject the null hypothesis () (there is statistically significant evidence that seed set efficiency is reduced in the heterospecific cross).
Lock it in
What is the mathematical formula for calculating the relative percentage reduction of an experimental treatment compared to a control group?
. The denominator must be the control baseline, not the overall sample size.
Similar question
In a pollination study, self-pollinated flowers produce seeds per plant, whereas interspecific cross-pollinated flowers produce only seeds per plant. Calculate the relative percentage reduction in seed production resulting from interspecific crossing.
Answer
. Baseline control = , experimental = . .
A fish hatchery observes that of fertilized eggs from intraspecific matings hatch, compared to only of eggs from hybrid crosses. (a) What is the percentage point difference in hatching success? (b) What is the relative percentage reduction in hatching success caused by hybridization?
Answer
(a) percentage points (). (b) relative reduction ().
Two closely related frog species hybridize in a laboratory. In the control cross, out of tadpoles reach metamorphosis. In the hybrid cross, out of reach metamorphosis, and none of the surviving adults produce functional sperm. (a) Calculate the percentage reduction in metamorphic success relative to control. (b) Identify the two distinct postzygotic barriers present.
Answer
(a) reduction (). (b) Hybrid inviability (failure of most tadpoles to reach metamorphosis/survive to adulthood) and hybrid sterility (inability of surviving adult hybrids to form functional gametes).