Resources
Flow cytometric analysis of a human tumor biopsy reveals a distinct subpopulation of diploid cells arrested with a uniform DNA content of exactly per nucleus. Laboratory calibration of control normal diploid cells () from the same patient establishes that the baseline DNA content is . Microscopic analysis of the arrested tumor cells shows intact nuclear envelopes, decondensed chromatin, duplicate centrosomes positioned adjacent to the nucleus, and unseparated sister chromatids. Deduce backwards: (a) in which specific cell-cycle phase are these tumor cells arrested, (b) which cell-cycle checkpoint failed to permit progression into the subsequent phase, and (c) what is the exact chromosome and chromatid count per cell during this arrest?
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) phase (DNA content is with intact nuclear envelope and decondensed chromatin); (b) DNA damage/replication checkpoint; (c) replicated chromosomes consisting of sister chromatids.
Steps
Determine the DNA Content and Replication State
In normal diploid () human somatic cells:
- The baseline phase DNA content represents the unreplicated genome ():
- The measured DNA content in the arrested tumor subpopulation is:
Because the DNA content has exactly doubled (), DNA replication during the synthesis (S) phase is complete.
Deduce the Specific Cell-Cycle Phase (Part a)
A cell with DNA content could theoretically reside in late S phase, phase, or early/mid-mitosis (prophase, metaphase, anaphase):
- Chromatin status: The chromatin is still decondensed (not condensed into distinct visible mitotic chromosomes characteristic of prophase).
- Nuclear envelope: The nuclear envelope remains completely intact.
- Centrosomes: The centrosomes are duplicated but remain clustered adjacent to the nucleus, having not yet separated to form opposing mitotic spindle poles.
Together, these morphological features confirm that mitosis (M phase) has not begun. Therefore, the cells are arrested in the phase.
Identify the Arrest Checkpoint (Part b)
The transition from the completion of interphase into mitosis is governed by the checkpoint (also called the DNA damage/replication checkpoint).
This checkpoint monitors the fidelity of DNA replication and screens for un-repaired DNA damage before activating the cyclin B–CDK1 complex (Maturation Promoting Factor, MPF) to trigger entry into prophase. Because progression into M phase was blocked, this checkpoint failed to clear the cells for mitotic entry.
Count Chromosomes and Chromatids (Part c)
- Chromosome Count: Chromosomes are defined and counted by the number of functional centromeres. DNA replication doubles the amount of genetic material without altering the number of individual chromosomes. In a diploid human cell, ; thus, there are replicated chromosomes.
- Chromatid Count: Each replicated chromosome consists of two identical sister chromatids held together at the centromere by cohesin proteins:
Common Pitfall: Do not confuse DNA amount (-value) or chromatid count with chromosome ploidy (). A cell does not become chromosomes after S phase; it remains diploid (), with each chromosome comprising two sister chromatids.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses chromosome count with chromatid count after DNA replication, incorrectly believing that doubling DNA content doubles the number of chromosomes from 46 to 92.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Baseline , arrested , so S phase is complete Intact nuclear envelope and decondensed chromatin mean the cells have not entered M phase Arrest phase: phase
- Step 2
The transition blocked is from to M phase Checkpoint: checkpoint
- Step 3
DNA content doubled from to , so chromosome number doubled from to
CorrectDNA replication doubles the amount of DNA () and forms sister chromatids, but the number of chromosomes remains because chromosomes are counted by functional centromeres.
Doubling DNA content during S phase creates sister chromatids held together at a single centromere per replicated chromosome. It does not double the chromosome number.
- Step 4
Chromosome count: chromosomes Chromatid count: chromatids
CorrectChromosome count: replicated chromosomes; Chromatid count: sister chromatids.
Because of the previous misconception, you reported chromosomes instead of . Your chromatid count of is correct, but each pair of sister chromatids constitutes one replicated chromosome.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou accurately compared DNA mass to establish that DNA synthesis was completed.
You used nuclear envelope and chromatin morphology to rule out mitosis and isolate the phase.
You correctly named the checkpoint governing the transition into mitosis.
You correctly calculated the total number of sister chromatids as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated total DNA mass (-value) with chromosome ploidy/number (), assuming that duplicating DNA during S phase doubles the chromosome count from to rather than producing two sister chromatids per chromosome.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Count Centromeres to Count Chromosomes
The number of chromosomes in a cell equals the number of functional centromeres, regardless of whether each chromosome consists of one or two sister chromatids.
Always count one chromosome per centromere. A human diploid cell has chromosomes in (unreplicated, chromatids) and still chromosomes in (replicated, chromatids).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIn diploid human cells, chromosomes.
During S phase, each chromosome replicates into two identical sister chromatids attached at a common centromere.
Because centromeres have not yet split in , there are still chromosomes, consisting of sister chromatids.
(a) phase; (b) checkpoint; (c) chromosomes and sister chromatids.
02 The student misidentifies the arrest phase as M phase (mitosis) because the DNA content is fully duplicated (4C), leading to the incorrect checkpoint and spindle assembly checkpoint misidentification.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
DNA content = , which is DNA, indicating the cell is dividing in mitosis. Arrest phase: M phase
CorrectArrest phase: phase
You correctly calculated that represents doubled () DNA content, but doubled DNA alone does not mean the cell has entered mitosis. The morphological hallmarks—specifically an intact nuclear envelope, decondensed chromatin, and unseparated centrosomes clustered adjacent to the nucleus—demonstrate that the cell has not yet entered prophase and is arrested in phase.
- Step 2
Cells arrested in mitosis fail to pass the spindle assembly checkpoint (M checkpoint). Checkpoint: Spindle assembly checkpoint (M checkpoint)
CorrectCheckpoint: checkpoint (DNA damage/replication checkpoint)
Because you concluded the cells were in mitosis, you named the spindle assembly checkpoint. Since the cells are actually halted at the boundary between interphase and mitosis, the checkpoint that prevented mitotic entry is the transition checkpoint.
- Step 3
Diploid human cells before anaphase have 46 chromosomes. Each chromosome has two sister chromatids, giving 92 chromatids. Chromosome count: chromosomes, Chromatid count: chromatids
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that is double the baseline amount (), corresponding to DNA content.
You clearly distinguished between chromosome count () and sister chromatid count () in post-replication cells.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou initially wrote phase and crossed it out, falsely assuming that DNA content uniquely defines mitosis.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing post-replication DNA quantity () with mitotic division, while failing to integrate structural cytology (intact nuclear envelope, decondensed chromatin, unseparated centrosomes) that delineates interphase from mitotic M phase.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Morphological Distinctions Between $G_2$ and Prophase
Both and early M phase contain DNA. However, cells exhibit decondensed chromatin, an intact nuclear envelope, and duplicate centrosomes that have not yet migrated apart.
Always check nuclear envelope integrity and chromatin condensation before concluding a cell with DNA has entered mitosis.
- Checkpoint Target Matching
The checkpoint governs the entry from into prophase; the spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC / M checkpoint) operates during metaphase to govern the transition to anaphase.
Select the checkpoint when progression into mitosis is blocked prior to chromosome condensation and spindle formation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate nuclear and centrosomal morphology: decondensed chromatin, intact nuclear envelope, and unseparated centrosomes place the cell strictly prior to prophase, identifying the arrest phase as phase.
Identify the gatekeeper controlling mitotic entry: failure to initiate mitosis indicates arrest at the checkpoint.
Confirm chromosome and chromatid numbers: replicated chromosomes held as sister chromatids.
(a) phase; (b) checkpoint; (c) chromosomes and chromatids.
03 The student misinterprets the 14.4 pg arrest as occurring at the G1/S checkpoint due to confusing replication initiation with post-replication arrest.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
DNA content is elevated and chromatin is decondensed with an intact nuclear envelope. The cells are arrested prior to division in G1 phase. Arrest phase: G1 phase
CorrectThe baseline DNA content is (). A DNA content of corresponds to , meaning DNA replication has finished. Combined with an intact nuclear envelope and decondensed chromatin, the cells are arrested in the phase.
You recognized the intact nuclear envelope and decondensed chromatin, but you assigned the cells to phase. Because the DNA content has fully doubled from to , the cells have already completed S phase and entered phase.
- Step 2
Progression from G1 phase is regulated by the restriction point / G1 checkpoint. Checkpoint: G1/S checkpoint
CorrectThe transition blocked is the entry from into mitosis, which is governed by the checkpoint (DNA damage/replication checkpoint).
Your checkpoint choice followed logically from your prior conclusion that the cells were arrested in . Because the cells are actually halted at the boundary between and mitosis, the checkpoint preventing entry into M phase is the checkpoint.
- Step 3
In G1 arrest, chromosomes have not replicated, so there is 1 chromatid per chromosome. Chromosome count: 46 chromosomes Chromatid count: 46 chromatids
CorrectDiploid human cells have chromosomes. In phase, each replicated chromosome consists of sister chromatids, yielding chromosomes and sister chromatids.
You correctly maintained that the chromosome count is , but your chromatid count of was based on the assumed arrest. Because the genome has duplicated (), each of the chromosomes consists of two sister chromatids, totaling chromatids.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou observed key cytological features including the decondensed chromatin and intact nuclear envelope.
You correctly identified that a diploid human cell contains chromosomes.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou crossed out the correct checkpoint and reverted to the checkpoint after assuming the cells had not yet entered division.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou interpreted interphase morphology (intact nuclear envelope and decondensed chromatin) as evidence for phase, without calculating the exact fold-change in DNA content (), which defines a post-replicative state ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Calculate the DNA C-value fold change
Baseline somatic content is . A doubling to indicates completion of S phase ( or M phase).
Divide the observed DNA mass by the baseline mass: , confirming the cell is in the post-replicative state.
- Distinguish G2 phase from M phase
Both and early M phase contain DNA, but is characterized by decondensed chromatin, an intact nuclear envelope, and unseparated centrosomes.
Confirm interphase nuclear morphology alongside DNA content to place the arrest definitively in phase.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate relative DNA content: , establishing complete post-replicative interphase ().
Identify the checkpoint blocking the next transition: entry into mitosis is arrested at the checkpoint.
Determine chromosome and chromatid numbers: chromosomes, each with sister chromatids, giving chromosomes and chromatids.
(a) phase; (b) checkpoint; (c) chromosomes and chromatids
Lock it in
How do you determine the exact number of chromosomes in a eukaryotic cell?
Count the number of functional centromeres. One functional centromere equals one chromosome, regardless of whether it has one or two chromatids.
Similar question
A diploid organism has chromosomes and a baseline nuclear DNA content of . What are the chromosome count, chromatid count, and total DNA mass in a single cell arrested at metaphase of mitosis?
Answer
12 chromosomes, 24 chromatids, and of DNA. Key step: S phase doubles DNA content () and creates sister chromatids (), but centromeres have not split, so the chromosome count remains .
In the same organism (, ), anaphase begins and cohesin is cleaved, separating sister chromatids to opposite poles. What are the chromosome count and chromatid count in the cell during anaphase, just before cytokinesis?
Answer
24 chromosomes and 0 chromatids (or 24 individual single-chromatid chromosomes). Key step: When centromeres split and sister chromatids separate, each chromatid is now an independent individual chromosome ( centromeres/chromosomes).
A flow cytometry experiment tracks a mammalian cell line with . In a subpopulation with DNA content, fluorescent microscopy shows condensed individual chromosomes aligned along the equatorial plate with bipolar spindle attachment. Deduce the exact phase, the checkpoint that must be satisfied before exiting this phase, and the chromosome count.
Answer
Phase: Metaphase; Checkpoint: Spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC / M checkpoint); Chromosome count: 20 chromosomes (consisting of 40 chromatids). Key step: Alignment at the equatorial plate indicates metaphase; the SAC verifies proper kinetochore-microtubule attachment before permitting sister chromatid separation.