Resources
A standard three-generation human pedigree displays the transmission of a neuromuscular trait. Generation consists of an affected male () and an unaffected, non-carrier female (). They produce two daughters ( and ) and two sons ( and ); all four offspring are phenotypically unaffected. Daughter partners with an unaffected male () with no family history of the condition. They have three children: an affected son (), an unaffected son (), and an unaffected daughter (). Rather than determining the mode of inheritance, calculate the conditional probability that the unaffected daughter in Generation (Individual ) carries the mutant allele, given that the trait is governed by an X-linked recessive gene with complete penetrance.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(or )
Steps
Assign Genotypes to Generations and
Let represent the dominant normal allele and represent the recessive mutant allele causing the neuromuscular trait.
- Individual (Affected male): Males have one X chromosome, so his genotype is .
- Individual (Unaffected, non-carrier female): Her genotype is .
When () and () reproduce:
- All daughters receive an chromosome from each parent: from the mother and from the father.
- Therefore, daughter is an obligate carrier with genotype .
Determine the Cross in Generation
Individual () partners with individual , an unaffected male with genotype .
A Punnett square for the cross produces the following potential offspring:
Calculate the Conditional Probability for Individual
We are given that individual is an unaffected daughter.
-
Identify the possible genotypes for female offspring: Every female offspring receives a normal chromosome from the unaffected father (). Because the condition is X-linked recessive, having one allele guarantees that any female child is phenotypically unaffected.
- Probability of receiving from mother:
- Probability of receiving from mother:
- Evaluate the condition: Since of female offspring from this cross are unaffected, knowing that is unaffected does not rule out either female genotype.
- Compute the conditional probability:
Common Pitfall: Do not confuse this with autosomal recessive inheritance. In autosomal recessive crosses between two carriers (), an unaffected child has a carrier probability of because the affected genotype () is eliminated. In an X-linked recessive cross with an unaffected father (), no female offspring can be affected (), so the sample space for females remains split equally between non-carrier () and carrier ().
Typical errors
01 The student conditions on all possible offspring of the mating rather than restricting the sample space to daughters, concluding the carrier probability is 1/4.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
is and is , so is an obligate carrier .
- Step 2
Partner is unaffected, so his genotype is . Cross yields: , , , .
- Step 3
Carrier daughter represents out of total offspring.
CorrectIndividual is already known to be a daughter. Because her sex is fixed, the sample space must be restricted only to the two female genotypes ( and ), both of which are phenotypically unaffected.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly traced the inheritance of the allele to deduce that is an obligate carrier.
You accurately identified the unaffected father's genotype as .
You correctly constructed all four potential offspring genotypes from the mating.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou calculated the unconditioned probability of having a carrier daughter from a random conception ( out of ) rather than applying conditional probability to the known condition that individual is already a daughter ( out of ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Conditioning on Sex
When a question specifies the sex or phenotype of an individual, reduce the denominator (sample space) to only the outcomes that meet that condition.
Identify the subset of offspring matching the known sex first, then calculate the fraction within that subset.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRestrict the sample space to female offspring: the possible genotypes are (non-carrier daughter) and (carrier daughter).
Both female genotypes result in an unaffected phenotype because the father contributes a normal allele.
Among the equally likely female genotypes, exactly carries the mutant allele: .
02 The student misapplies an autosomal recessive 2/3 carrier risk to an X-linked pedigree, assuming the unaffected female can only be from three unaffected genotypes.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
inherited the mutant allele from , so is a carrier.
- Step 2
and have children, one of whom is affected. For an unaffected child born to carrier parents, the carrier probability is .
CorrectIn the cross , all female offspring inherit from the father, so every daughter is phenotypically unaffected: and .
You treated this mating as an autosomal recessive cross between two carriers (). In an X-linked cross between a carrier female () and an unaffected male (), the father always passes a normal allele to his daughters. Because no daughter can be affected (), both possible female genotypes ( and ) are unaffected, leaving the sample space for daughters split equally at .
- Step 3Correct
This numerical answer follows directly from the misapplied autosomal ratio in the previous step.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly traced the transmission of the mutant allele from the affected father to his daughter .
You correctly identified that individual is an obligate heterozygous carrier.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated X-linked recessive inheritance with autosomal recessive inheritance by applying the familiar unaffected carrier ratio, overlooking that the unaffected father's chromosome guarantees that all female offspring are phenotypically normal.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Autosomal vs. Sex-Linked Crosses
In an autosomal cross between two carriers (), unaffected offspring have genotypes , giving a carrier risk of . In an X-linked cross (), daughters only receive from the father and either or from the mother, giving a ratio of .
Always write out sex chromosomes ( and ) explicitly in a Punnett square when working with X-linked traits.
- Define the Conditional Sample Space
Conditioning on an unaffected daughter only eliminates genotypes that would make a female affected (). Since the father is , was never possible.
Check whether the observed phenotype actually eliminates any of the sex-specific genotypes before recalculating probabilities.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the genotypes of the parents in Generation : mother is and father is .
Determine the possible female offspring genotypes: each daughter receives from the father and either (probability ) or (probability ) from the mother.
Note that both female genotypes ( and ) result in an unaffected phenotype because the mutant allele is recessive.
Compute the conditional probability: .
(or )
03 The student unnecessarily multiplies by the prior probability of 1/2 that II-1 is a carrier, failing to recognize that II-1 is an obligate carrier.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
An affected male has genotype and transmits his single chromosome () to all of his daughters. Therefore, individual inherits the mutant allele with certainty (), making her an obligate carrier.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
Because the prior probability that is a carrier is rather than , multiplying your transmission probability by produces an incorrect final answer.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated that a heterozygous carrier mother passes her mutant chromosome to a daughter with probability .
You correctly applied the multiplication rule for independent transmission events.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the transmission of an X-linked allele from a father to a daughter as an event with probability , confusing it with autosomal inheritance or maternal transmission where either of two homologous chromosomes can be passed down. In biological sex determination, a male passes his single chromosome to of his daughters and his chromosome to of his sons.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Paternal X-Chromosome Transmission
A biological male () always contributes his single chromosome to all biological daughters and his chromosome to all biological sons.
When a father displays an X-linked recessive trait (), set the probability of any daughter inheriting the mutant allele to .
- Corroborating Pedigree Evidence
A female who gives birth to an affected son () while paired with an unaffected male must carry the mutant allele on one of her chromosomes.
Check downstream offspring in the pedigree; since produced an affected son (), her carrier status is verified as certain.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the genotypes of the parents in Generation : father is and mother is .
Because father passes his only chromosome () to all female offspring, daughter is an obligate carrier with genotype , so .
Set up the cross between carrier mother () and unaffected father ().
Daughter receives from her father and has equal chances of receiving or from her mother: and .
Compute the final probability: .
Lock it in
In an X-linked cross, when should you divide by 2 instead of 4 to find an offspring's genotype probability?
Divide by 2 whenever the sex of the child is already known, restricting the sample space to only that sex.
Similar question
A woman who is a carrier for red-green color blindness () has a child with a normal-vision man (). If ultrasound reveals that the fetus is male, what is the probability that the child will be color-blind?
Answer
. Key steps: Restrict the sample space to male offspring ( and ). The probability of receiving the mutant allele from the mother is .
Hemophilia A is an X-linked recessive disorder. A phenotypically normal couple has a son with hemophilia A. They subsequently have a phenotypically normal daughter. What is the probability that this daughter is a carrier for hemophilia A?
Answer
. Key steps: Having an affected son proves the mother is a carrier (); the father is . Female offspring are either or . Because both are phenotypically normal, the probability that the daughter is a carrier is .
In a family with an X-linked recessive condition, individual II-2 is a carrier female () and individual II-3 is an affected male (). They have a child who is phenotypically unaffected. What is the probability that this child is a female carrier?
Answer
. Key steps: The possible offspring are (unaffected carrier female), (affected female), (unaffected male), and (affected male). Given that the child is unaffected, eliminate and , leaving possible unaffected outcomes ( and ). Exactly of these is a female carrier, yielding .