Resources

In a study on phenotypic plasticity, a cloned cohort of genetically identical water fleas (Daphnia pulex\textit{Daphnia pulex}) is exposed to varying concentrations of predator-released chemical kairomones (CC) measured in arbitrary units (a.u.\text{a.u.}). The percentage of the population displaying defensive neck teeth (PP) follows the dose-response model P=100⋅C2Kd2+C2P = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{K_d^2 + C^2}, where Kd=4.0 a.u.K_d = 4.0\text{ a.u.} is the half-maximal response threshold. Calculate the exact environmental kairomone concentration CC required to induce defensive neck-teeth development in exactly 80.0%80.0\% of the clone population. Express your answer to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

C=8.00 a.u.C = 8.00\text{ a.u.}

Steps

Biological Background: Phenotypic Plasticity and Dose-Response

Phenotypic plasticity allows genetically identical organisms to express different morphological, physiological, or behavioral phenotypes depending on environmental cues. In Daphnia pulex, chemical cues (kairomones) released by predators activate signaling pathways that regulate gene expression, triggering the development of defensive structures like "neck teeth." The relationship between cue concentration and population-level phenotypic induction is modeled using a sigmoidal Hill equation:

P=100⋅C2Kd2+C2P = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{K_d^2 + C^2}

where:

  • PP is the percentage of the population displaying neck teeth,
  • CC is the kairomone concentration,
  • Kd=4.0 a.u.K_d = 4.0\text{ a.u.} is the concentration yielding a half-maximal induction (P=50%P = 50\%).

Step-by-Step Derivation

  1. Substitute the known values into the dose-response equation: For P=80.0%P = 80.0\% and Kd=4.0 a.u.K_d = 4.0\text{ a.u.}: 80.0=100⋅C2(4.0)2+C280.0 = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{(4.0)^2 + C^2}
  2. Simplify the denominator: 80.0=100⋅C216.0+C280.0 = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{16.0 + C^2}
  3. Clear the fraction by multiplying both sides by (16.0+C2)(16.0 + C^2): 80.0⋅(16.0+C2)=100⋅C280.0 \cdot (16.0 + C^2) = 100 \cdot C^2 1280+80.0⋅C2=100⋅C21280 + 80.0 \cdot C^2 = 100 \cdot C^2
  4. Isolate the C2C^2 terms: 1280=100⋅C2−80.0⋅C21280 = 100 \cdot C^2 - 80.0 \cdot C^2 1280=20.0⋅C21280 = 20.0 \cdot C^2
  5. Solve for C2C^2 and then CC: C2=128020.0=64.0C^2 = \frac{1280}{20.0} = 64.0 C=64.0=8.00 a.u.C = \sqrt{64.0} = 8.00\text{ a.u.}

(Note: We discard the negative root because concentration must be non-negative.)


Common Pitfall to Avoid

  • Percentages vs. Decimals: Ensure consistency in units. The formula uses 100100 in the numerator, so PP must be entered as a percentage (80.080.0), not as a decimal fraction (0.8000.800). If PP were entered as 0.8000.800, the calculation would yield an incorrect concentration.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats the dose-response equation as a linear Michaelis-Menten or Hill equation without squaring the terms, setting P = 100 · C / (Kd + C) to find C = 16.0 a.u.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    P=100⋅C/(Kd+C)  ⟹  80.0=100⋅C/(4.0+C)P = 100 \cdot C / (K_d + C) \implies 80.0 = 100 \cdot C / (4.0 + C)

    Correct

    P=100⋅C2Kd2+C2  ⟹  80.0=100⋅C2(4.0)2+C2P = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{K_d^2 + C^2} \implies 80.0 = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{(4.0)^2 + C^2}

    You omitted the power of 22 on CC and KdK_d. The given Hill-type model has a Hill coefficient of n=2n = 2, which accounts for the sigmoidal switch-like phenotypic response.

  2. Step 2

    80.0(4.0+C)=100⋅C  ⟹  320+80.0C=100C  ⟹  20.0C=32080.0(4.0 + C) = 100 \cdot C \implies 320 + 80.0 C = 100 C \implies 20.0 C = 320

    Correct

    80.0(16.0+C2)=100⋅C2  ⟹  1280+80.0C2=100C2  ⟹  20.0C2=128080.0(16.0 + C^2) = 100 \cdot C^2 \implies 1280 + 80.0 C^2 = 100 C^2 \implies 20.0 C^2 = 1280

    Your algebra in clearing the fraction and grouping like terms was mathematically valid, but it operated on the unsquared expression from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    C=16.0 a.u.C = 16.0\text{ a.u.}

    Correct

    C2=64.0  ⟹  C=64.0=8.00 a.u.C^2 = 64.0 \implies C = \sqrt{64.0} = 8.00\text{ a.u.}

    Because the terms were not squared, solving for CC directly yielded 16.0 a.u.16.0\text{ a.u.} instead of the true threshold concentration 8.00 a.u.8.00\text{ a.u.}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the percentage value 80.080.0 and the parameter Kd=4.0 a.u.K_d = 4.0\text{ a.u.}.

You demonstrated strong algebraic manipulation skills when cross-multiplying and isolating the unknown variable.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula Transcription Error (Omitted Exponents)

You dropped the exponent 22 from the concentration and KdK_d terms, treating a sigmoidal Hill function as a simple Michaelis-Menten hyperbolic function.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the cooperative Hill coefficient (n=2n = 2) in nonlinear biological dose-response curves leads to linearizing the denominator terms and overestimating the concentration needed to trigger a threshold-dependent developmental switch.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Examine the Hill Exponent
  • In sigmoidal dose-response models of the form P=100⋅CnKdn+CnP = \frac{100 \cdot C^n}{K_d^n + C^n}, the exponent nn must be applied to both the cue concentration CC and the half-maximal constant KdK_d.

  • Always verify whether the equation represents simple binding (n=1n = 1) or cooperative/switch-like induction (n>1n > 1) before beginning algebraic operations.

Solve for the Squared Term First
  • When solving P=100⋅C2Kd2+C2P = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{K_d^2 + C^2} for CC, isolate C2C^2 before taking the positive square root.

  • Rearrange to C2=P⋅Kd2100−PC^2 = \frac{P \cdot K_d^2}{100 - P} and take the square root as the final step.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute P=80.0P = 80.0 and Kd=4.0 a.u.K_d = 4.0\text{ a.u.} into the correct quadratic dose-response model: 80.0=100⋅C2(4.0)2+C280.0 = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{(4.0)^2 + C^2}.

  2. Simplify (4.0)2=16.0(4.0)^2 = 16.0 and clear the denominator: 80.0(16.0+C2)=100C280.0(16.0 + C^2) = 100 C^2.

  3. Distribute and collect like terms: 1280+80.0C2=100C2  ⟹  20.0C2=12801280 + 80.0 C^2 = 100 C^2 \implies 20.0 C^2 = 1280.

  4. Isolate C2C^2: C2=128020.0=64.0C^2 = \frac{1280}{20.0} = 64.0.

  5. Take the principal square root: C=64.0=8.00 a.u.C = \sqrt{64.0} = 8.00\text{ a.u.}.

Final answer

C=8.00 a.u.C = 8.00\text{ a.u.}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the difference in curve shape between hyperbolic (n=1n = 1) and sigmoidal (n=2n = 2) environmental induction models.

  • Practice rewriting the algebraic solution symbolically as C=KdP100−PC = K_d \sqrt{\frac{P}{100 - P}} before plugging in numbers.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student squares the variable C but forgets to square Kd in the denominator, using 4.0 instead of 16, resulting in C = 4.00 a.u.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    80.0=100⋅C24.0+C280.0 = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{4.0 + C^2}

    Correct

    80.0=100⋅C2(4.0)2+C2  ⟹  80.0=100⋅C216.0+C280.0 = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{(4.0)^2 + C^2} \implies 80.0 = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{16.0 + C^2}

    The formula specifies Kd2K_d^2 in the denominator. Since Kd=4.0 a.u.K_d = 4.0\text{ a.u.}, you need to square this value to obtain 16.016.0, rather than writing 4.04.0.

  2. Step 2

    80.0(4.0+C2)=100C2  ⟹  320+80.0C2=100C2  ⟹  20.0C2=320  ⟹  C2=16.080.0(4.0 + C^2) = 100 C^2 \implies 320 + 80.0 C^2 = 100 C^2 \implies 20.0 C^2 = 320 \implies C^2 = 16.0

    Correct

    80.0(16.0+C2)=100C2  ⟹  1280+80.0C2=100C2  ⟹  20.0C2=1280  ⟹  C2=64.080.0(16.0 + C^2) = 100 C^2 \implies 1280 + 80.0 C^2 = 100 C^2 \implies 20.0 C^2 = 1280 \implies C^2 = 64.0

    Your algebraic steps to clear the denominator, collect like terms, and isolate C2C^2 were mathematically sound, but they inherited the incorrect constant from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    C=4.00 a.u.C = 4.00\text{ a.u.}

    Correct

    C=64.0=8.00 a.u.C = \sqrt{64.0} = 8.00\text{ a.u.}

    Taking the square root of your C2C^2 value was performed correctly, but the result differs from the true concentration due to the early substitution error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the given percentage P=80.0P = 80.0 directly into the equation.

You correctly cleared the denominator and grouped like terms to isolate C2C^2.

You reported your final answer with units and proper three-significant-figure precision.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Exponent during Parameter Substitution

You wrote 4.04.0 instead of (4.0)2=16.0(4.0)^2 = 16.0 for the Kd2K_d^2 term in the denominator.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When substituting numerical values into Hill or sigmoidal dose-response models with Hill coefficients n>1n > 1, constant parameters like KdK_d carry the same power nn as the variable CC. Overlooking the exponent on the constant alters the effective half-maximal threshold of the model.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Exponents on Constants
  • In the Hill equation P=100⋅CnKdn+CnP = \frac{100 \cdot C^n}{K_d^n + C^n}, both the concentration CC and the threshold KdK_d are raised to the power nn.

  • Write out (Kd)n(K_d)^n explicitly with parentheses before substituting the numerical value.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute Kd=4.0 a.u.K_d = 4.0\text{ a.u.} into the denominator as (4.0)2=16.0(4.0)^2 = 16.0: 80.0=100⋅C216.0+C280.0 = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{16.0 + C^2}.

  2. Multiply both sides by (16.0+C2)(16.0 + C^2): 80.0(16.0+C2)=100C280.0(16.0 + C^2) = 100 C^2.

  3. Expand and rearrange terms: 1280+80.0C2=100C2  ⟹  20.0C2=12801280 + 80.0 C^2 = 100 C^2 \implies 20.0 C^2 = 1280.

  4. Divide by 20.020.0: C2=64.0C^2 = 64.0.

  5. Take the principal square root: C=64.0=8.00 a.u.C = \sqrt{64.0} = 8.00\text{ a.u.}.

Final answer

C=8.00 a.u.C = 8.00\text{ a.u.}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the algebraic formula with explicit parentheses around squared parameters, such as (Kd)2(K_d)^2, before inserting numbers.

  • Check your answer against biological intuition: because 80.0%80.0\% response is greater than the 50%50\% half-maximal threshold (Kd=4.0 a.u.K_d = 4.0\text{ a.u.}), the required concentration CC must be strictly greater than KdK_d.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student correctly solves for C² = 64 but forgets to take the square root at the final step, stating the answer as 64.0 a.u.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    80.0=100⋅C24.02+C280.0 = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{4.0^2 + C^2}

  2. Step 2

    80.0(16+C2)=100C2  ⟹  1280+80.0C2=100C280.0(16 + C^2) = 100 C^2 \implies 1280 + 80.0 C^2 = 100 C^2

  3. Step 3

    20.0C2=128020.0 C^2 = 1280

  4. Step 4

    C=64.0 a.u.C = 64.0\text{ a.u.}

    Correct

    C2=128020.0=64.0  ⟹  C=64.0=8.00 a.u.C^2 = \frac{1280}{20.0} = 64.0 \implies C = \sqrt{64.0} = 8.00\text{ a.u.}

    Dividing 12801280 by 20.020.0 gives C2=64.0C^2 = 64.0, not CC. You need to take the square root of 64.064.0 to solve for CC, which gives C=8.00 a.u.C = 8.00\text{ a.u.}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the given population percentage and KdK_d value into the sigmoidal dose-response equation.

You cleared the fraction and expanded algebraic terms without any arithmetic mistakes.

You successfully isolated the C2C^2 term on one side of the equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted square root

You evaluated 128020.0=64.0\frac{1280}{20.0} = 64.0 and directly labeled it as CC instead of C2C^2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Losing track of the variable's exponent during algebraic rearrangement, causing you to treat the isolated value of C2C^2 as the final linear variable CC.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Track Variable Powers
  • When isolating a squared term, write C2=…C^2 = \dots explicitly before writing C=…C = \dots.

  • Write an explicit intermediate line: C2=64.0C^2 = 64.0, then write C=64.0C = \sqrt{64.0} to ensure you do not skip the final extraction step.

Dimensional and Scale Check
  • Since Kd=4.0 a.u.K_d = 4.0\text{ a.u.} produces a 50%50\% response, an 80%80\% response should require a concentration on the same order of magnitude (around 2×Kd2 \times K_d), not an order of magnitude larger like 64.0 a.u.64.0\text{ a.u.}.

  • Compare your final numerical value against KdK_d to verify whether the concentration magnitude biologically makes sense for an 80%80\% induction.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide both sides by 20.020.0: C2=128020.0=64.0C^2 = \frac{1280}{20.0} = 64.0

  2. Take the positive square root because concentration must be non-negative: C=64.0=8.00 a.u.C = \sqrt{64.0} = 8.00\text{ a.u.}

Final answer

C=8.00 a.u.C = 8.00\text{ a.u.}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the intermediate step x2=valuex^2 = \text{value} before taking the square root to avoid conflating the squared variable with the linear variable.

  • Perform a sanity check against KdK_d: for a Hill coefficient of n=2n = 2, an 80%80\% response occurs at C=Kd8020=2Kd=8.00 a.u.C = K_d \sqrt{\frac{80}{20}} = 2 K_d = 8.00\text{ a.u.}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A cloned cohort of Daphnia expresses defensive neck teeth according to the model P=100⋅C2Kd2+C2P = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{K_d^2 + C^2} with Kd=6.0 a.u.K_d = 6.0\text{ a.u.} Calculate the kairomone concentration CC required to induce neck teeth in exactly 25.0%25.0\% of the population. Express your answer to three significant figures.

Answer

C=3.46 a.u.C = 3.46\text{ a.u.}

Key steps:

  1. 25.0=100⋅C236.0+C2  ⟹  25.0(36.0+C2)=100C225.0 = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{36.0 + C^2} \implies 25.0(36.0 + C^2) = 100 C^2.
  2. 900+25.0C2=100C2  ⟹  75.0C2=900900 + 25.0 C^2 = 100 C^2 \implies 75.0 C^2 = 900.
  3. C2=12.0  ⟹  C=12.0≈3.46 a.u.C^2 = 12.0 \implies C = \sqrt{12.0} \approx 3.46\text{ a.u.}
02

A different predator species secretes a kairomone that induces spines via a sharper cooperative switch: P=100⋅C4Kd4+C4P = \frac{100 \cdot C^4}{K_d^4 + C^4}, where Kd=2.0 a.u.K_d = 2.0\text{ a.u.} Determine the kairomone concentration CC needed to achieve 80.0%80.0\% spine induction. Express your answer to three significant figures.

Answer

C=2.83 a.u.C = 2.83\text{ a.u.}

Key steps:

  1. Set up the ratio: P100−P=80.020.0=4.00\frac{P}{100 - P} = \frac{80.0}{20.0} = 4.00.
  2. C4=Kd4⋅4.00=2.04⋅4.00=16.0⋅4.00=64.0C^4 = K_d^4 \cdot 4.00 = 2.0^4 \cdot 4.00 = 16.0 \cdot 4.00 = 64.0.
  3. C=(64.0)1/4=8.00≈2.83 a.u.C = (64.0)^{1/4} = \sqrt{8.00} \approx 2.83\text{ a.u.}
03

Two strains of Daphnia have the same Kd=5.0 a.u.K_d = 5.0\text{ a.u.}, but Strain A follows a hyperbolic response PA=100⋅CKd+CP_A = \frac{100 \cdot C}{K_d + C} while Strain B follows a cooperative response PB=100⋅C2Kd2+C2P_B = \frac{100 \cdot C^2}{K_d^2 + C^2}. Find the ratio CA/CBC_A / C_B of concentrations needed to reach 90.0%90.0\% phenotypic induction in each strain.

Answer

CA/CB=3.00C_A / C_B = 3.00

Key steps:

  1. For Strain A (n=1n=1): 90.0=100CA5.0+CA  ⟹  CA=5.0⋅90.010.0=45.0 a.u.90.0 = \frac{100 C_A}{5.0 + C_A} \implies C_A = 5.0 \cdot \frac{90.0}{10.0} = 45.0\text{ a.u.}
  2. For Strain B (n=2n=2): 90.0=100CB225.0+CB2  ⟹  CB=5.0⋅90.010.0=5.0⋅3.00=15.0 a.u.90.0 = \frac{100 C_B^2}{25.0 + C_B^2} \implies C_B = 5.0 \cdot \sqrt{\frac{90.0}{10.0}} = 5.0 \cdot 3.00 = 15.0\text{ a.u.}
  3. Ratio CACB=45.015.0=3.00\frac{C_A}{C_B} = \frac{45.0}{15.0} = 3.00.
Loading workspace…