Resources
In a controlled mesocosm experiment investigating zooplankton dynamics, an ecologist establishes six tanks with increasing initial densities of Ceriodaphnia dubia: individuals. Across all tanks, water temperature is held at and food (Chlorella algae) is provided at a fixed daily ration of per tank. On Day 7, census data reveal per capita female fecundity (mean number of viable eggs per female, ) across the six tanks to be and , respectively. On Day 8, an unintended incubator mechanical malfunction causes temperature to spike to for , resulting in the death of and individuals across the respective tanks. (a) Construct a linear or qualitative assessment of per capita fecundity as a function of density to identify whether fecundity is density-dependent or density-independent. (b) Calculate the per capita mortality rate caused by the heat spike across all six tanks, state whether thermal stress acts as a density-dependent or density-independent factor, and explain why identifying the regulatory mechanism requires evaluating per capita rates rather than raw counts.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Per capita fecundity declines monotonically from at down to at due to exploitative resource competition for the fixed algal food supply (); therefore, fecundity is a strongly density-dependent regulatory factor. (b) Per capita heat-spike mortality rates: , , , , , and . The mean mortality is , which remains invariant across a 32-fold increase in population density; therefore, thermal stress acts as a density-independent factor. Per capita rates normalize for population size, revealing that the abiotic disturbance eliminates a fixed fraction regardless of density, whereas raw death counts ( vs. ) merely reflect cohort magnitude.
Steps
Part (a): Assessing Per Capita Fecundity vs. Population Density
A demographic rate (such as birth rate, death rate, or fecundity) is defined as density-dependent if its per capita value systematically changes as population density changes. If the per capita rate remains constant regardless of population density, it is density-independent.
-
Examine the observed fecundity across densities:
- At :
- At :
- At :
- At :
- At :
- At :
- Qualitative and Mechanistic Interpretation: As the population size increases by a factor of (from to individuals in a constant volume), per capita fecundity drops monotonically from down to . Because each tank receives the same fixed daily ration of food ( of Chlorella algae), each individual receives a progressively smaller share of energy as density increases, leaving less energy available for reproduction (exploitative competition).
- Conclusion: Because per capita fecundity is an inverse function of population density, fecundity in this system is a density-dependent regulatory factor.
Part (b): Evaluating Thermal Stress and Mortality Rates
-
Calculate per capita mortality () for each tank: The per capita mortality rate is given by the ratio of deaths () to initial population size ():
- Tank 1 ():
- Tank 2 ():
- Tank 3 ():
- Tank 4 ():
- Tank 5 ():
- Tank 6 ():
- Determine factor classification: The per capita mortality rate remains essentially constant across all treatments at approximately , showing no upward or downward trend across a -fold increase in density. Therefore, thermal stress acts as a density-independent factor.
-
Importance of Per Capita Rates vs. Raw Counts:
- Pitfall: Looking solely at absolute deaths ( in Tank 1 vs. in Tank 6) might give the false impression that denser tanks experienced disproportionately higher mortality.
- Resolution: Absolute numbers of deaths scale directly with initial cohort size (). Population regulation depends on the proportion (or per capita probability) of individuals dying. By calculating per capita mortality, we normalize for sample size, revealing whether the biological impact per organism changes with crowding. Since the proportion killed is invariant to density, the physical disturbance acts uniformly across all populations.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses raw mortality counts with per capita rates, falsely concluding that thermal stress is density-dependent because more individuals died in higher-density tanks.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
As density increases from to , fecundity drops from to . Because per capita fecundity decreases as density increases, fecundity is density-dependent.
- Step 2
Deaths per tank: . Mortality increases as density increases from deaths at to deaths at . Thermal stress is a density-dependent factor. Evaluating raw counts shows that higher density causes significantly more individuals to die from heat stress.
CorrectPer capita mortality rates: , , , , , and . Because the proportion of individuals dying is constant at across all densities, thermal stress is density-independent. Per capita rates normalize for population size, showing whether an individual's probability of dying changes with crowding.
You looked at absolute death counts instead of calculating per capita mortality rates (deaths divided by total individuals). Because a fixed percentage of a larger population naturally yields a larger count of deaths, raw counts can create the illusion of density dependence.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou accurately tracked the trend in per capita fecundity across densities.
You correctly defined the qualitative condition for density dependence in part (a).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou evaluated raw death counts ( to ) instead of computing per capita mortality rates ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating absolute death numbers with per capita demographic rates: density dependence is defined by how per capita probabilities (percentages) change with density, not by raw totals.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Density Dependence Definition
A demographic factor is density-dependent if and only if its per capita rate (fraction or percentage) changes with population density.
Always divide total events by the total population size () before evaluating density dependence.
- Abiotic Disturbance Invariance
Abiotic disturbances typically affect a constant fraction of individuals regardless of group size, meaning raw death numbers scale proportionally with .
Check whether remains constant across treatments.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDivide the number of deaths in each tank by its initial population size: , , , , , and .
Observe that the per capita mortality rate remains essentially constant at approximately across all six densities.
Conclude that because the per capita risk of death does not change with density, thermal stress is a density-independent factor.
(a) Fecundity is density-dependent. (b) Per capita mortality rates are across all tanks; thermal stress is density-independent because per capita mortality does not change with density, whereas raw death counts merely scale with initial population size.
02 The student misinterprets a declining per capita rate as density-independent under the belief that density dependence only applies when a rate increases with density.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Per capita fecundity decreases from to as population density increases.
- Step 2
Fecundity is density-independent because it does not increase with higher density.
CorrectBecause per capita fecundity changes systematically with density (specifically, declining due to intraspecific resource competition), fecundity is a density-dependent regulatory factor.
A vital rate is density-dependent if its per capita value varies with population density in any direction. Fecundity decreasing as density increases represents classic negative density dependence, not density independence.
- Step 3
Mortality rates: , , , , , . The per capita mortality rate is roughly constant at across all densities.
- Step 4
Thermal stress acts as a density-independent factor. Per capita rates are required because total deaths increase with population size regardless of whether the hazard rate depends on density.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou observed the negative relationship between per capita fecundity and population density.
You accurately calculated the per capita mortality rates across all six mesocosm treatments.
You correctly classified thermal stress as density-independent based on an invariant mortality rate.
You clearly explained why evaluating per capita rates rather than raw counts is essential to distinguish regulatory mechanisms.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that 'density dependence' requires a rate to increase as density increases. In ecology, density dependence refers to any per capita demographic rate (birth, death, or fecundity) that is a non-constant function of density. When per capita fecundity decreases as density increases (negative density dependence), it serves as a primary regulatory feedback mechanism through resource competition.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Defining Density Dependence
A demographic factor is density-dependent if the per capita rate changes (increases OR decreases) as population density changes. It is density-independent only if the per capita rate remains constant regardless of density.
Check whether the per capita rate is a function of density (). If it varies systematically, classify it as density-dependent regardless of whether the slope is positive or negative.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that density dependence means the per capita rate changes with population density ().
Observe that per capita fecundity drops from down to as density increases from to individuals.
Conclude that because the per capita rate decreases systematically with density (negative density dependence via resource competition), fecundity is a density-dependent regulatory factor.
Per capita fecundity is density-dependent because it systematically declines as density increases.
03 The student calculates surviving proportions rather than mortality rates due to misinterpreting the mortality calculation.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Per capita fecundity declines monotonically from to as density rises. Fecundity is density-dependent.
- Step 2
Survivors: , , , , , . Rates: , , , , , . Per capita mortality rate is constant at across all tanks.
CorrectPer capita mortality rate : , , , , , and , yielding an average mortality rate of .
You calculated the per capita survival rate (survivors divided by initial population, ) instead of the per capita mortality rate (deaths divided by initial population, ).
- Step 3
Thermal stress acts as a density-independent factor. Evaluating per capita rates is necessary because absolute numbers scale with total population size.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that a declining per capita rate indicates density dependence.
You recognized that an invariant proportional rate across densities signals density independence.
You clearly articulated why raw counts must be normalized to per capita rates when assessing population regulation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou subtracted deaths to find survivors and divided those by the initial population, calculating survival proportion rather than mortality rate.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the complement demographic metric (survival proportion, ) with the requested metric (mortality rate, ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define the Target Rate Explicitly
Mortality rate is the proportion of the population that dies: . Survival rate is .
Before computing, write down the formula for the specific demographic parameter requested (deaths vs. survivors).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate per capita mortality for each tank:
Tank 1:
Tank 2:
Tank 3:
Tank 4:
Tank 5:
Tank 6:
Note that the mean mortality rate is (which is ).
Per capita mortality rates across the six tanks are , , , , , and (averaging ).
Lock it in
What distinguishes a density-dependent factor from a density-independent factor?
A factor is density-dependent if per capita birth or death rates change with population density; it is density-independent if per capita rates remain constant.
Similar question
A fungal pathogen infects three populations of pine seedlings: at density , seedlings die; at , seedlings die; at , seedlings die. Calculate per capita mortality for each population and classify the pathogen as density-dependent or density-independent.
Answer
Per capita mortality rates: , , and . Because the per capita mortality rate increases as density increases, the fungal pathogen is a density-dependent factor.
In a river survey, a chemical spill kills fish in a reach with individuals and fish in an adjacent reach with individuals. An angler claims the chemical spill is density-dependent because three times as many fish died in the second reach. Evaluate the angler's claim with calculations.
Answer
The angler's claim is incorrect. In reach 1, per capita mortality is . In reach 2, it is . Because the per capita death rate is identical () in both reaches, the chemical spill acts as a density-independent factor; the higher raw death count merely reflects the larger initial population.
A population ecologist models per capita mortality as a function of density using the equation . If population A has and population B has , calculate (a) the per capita mortality rate for each population and (b) the total number of deaths in each population. State which calculation directly demonstrates density dependence.
Answer
(a) Population A: (). Population B: (). (b) Total deaths: Population A has deaths; Population B has deaths. Demonstration: Part (a) directly demonstrates density dependence because the per capita probability of mortality increases from to as density increases from to .