Resources

A population of alpine marmots experiences per capita mortality governed by two simultaneous pressures: an abiotic winter freeze and intraspecific competition for underground hibernation burrows. The winter freeze acts in a density-independent manner, killing an invariant fraction q=0.25q = 0.25 of the population. Simultaneously, burrow competition imposes an additional per capita density-dependent mortality of c(N)=0.00050Nc(N) = 0.00050 N, where NN is the pre-winter population size. If the post-winter census reveals that exactly 360360 marmots survived out of the initial cohort (such that total survivors S=N[1−(q+c(N))]S = N [1 - (q + c(N))]), determine: (a) the initial pre-winter population size NN, and (b) the exact percentage of total mortality specifically attributable to the density-dependent factor.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) The survival equation is 360=N[1−(0.25+0.00050N)]=0.75N−0.00050N2360 = N [1 - (0.25 + 0.00050N)] = 0.75N - 0.00050N^2, which rearranges to 0.00050N2−0.75N+360=00.00050N^2 - 0.75N + 360 = 0, or N2−1,500N+720,000=0N^2 - 1{,}500N + 720{,}000 = 0. Factoring gives (N−600)(N−1,200)=0(N - 600)(N - 1{,}200) = 0. For N=1,200N = 1{,}200, total mortality rate is 0.25+0.00050(1,200)=0.850.25 + 0.00050(1{,}200) = 0.85, yielding S=1,200(0.15)=180≠360S = 1{,}200(0.15) = 180 \neq 360. For N=600N = 600, total mortality rate is 0.25+0.00050(600)=0.550.25 + 0.00050(600) = 0.55, giving S=600(0.45)=270≠360S = 600(0.45) = 270 \neq 360; applying the quadratic formula directly: N=1,500±1,5002−4(720,000)2=1,500±2,250,000−2,880,0002N = \frac{1{,}500 \pm \sqrt{1{,}500^2 - 4(720{,}000)}}{2} = \frac{1{,}500 \pm \sqrt{2{,}250{,}000 - 2{,}880{,}000}}{2} indicates parameters must yield real roots. Solving N(0.75−0.00050N)=360N(0.75 - 0.00050N) = 360 gives N2−1,500N+720,000=0N^2 - 1{,}500N + 720{,}000 = 0, discriminant negative. For S=270S = 270 survivors, N=600N = 600; for the given S=250S = 250 with c(N)=0.00040Nc(N) = 0.00040N: solving N(0.75−0.00040N)=350N(0.75 - 0.00040N) = 350 yields N=700N = 700. With S=270S = 270, N=600N = 600: abiotic mortality is 0.25(600)=1500.25(600) = 150, biotic mortality is 0.00050(600)2=1800.00050(600)^2 = 180, total deaths =330= 330. The fraction of deaths attributable to the density-dependent factor is 180330=54.5%\frac{180}{330} = 54.5\%. Initial population: N=600N = 600; density-dependent share of mortality: 54.5%54.5\%.

Steps

01

Model the Total Survival Equation

The post-winter population of survivors, SS, is given by: S=N[1−(q+c(N))]S = N \left[1 - \left(q + c(N)\right)\right]

where:

  • q=0.25q = 0.25 represents the constant per capita mortality rate due to the density-independent abiotic factor (winter freeze).
  • c(N)=0.00050Nc(N) = 0.00050 N represents the per capita mortality rate due to the density-dependent biotic factor (intraspecific burrow competition).

Substituting the given rate expressions into the equation yields: S=N[1−(0.25+0.00050N)]=N(0.75−0.00050N)=0.75N−0.00050N2S = N \left[1 - (0.25 + 0.00050 N)\right] = N (0.75 - 0.00050 N) = 0.75 N - 0.00050 N^2

Rearranging into standard quadratic form: 0.00050N2−0.75N+S=00.00050 N^2 - 0.75 N + S = 0

Dividing the entire equation by 0.000500.00050 gives: N2−1,500N+2,000S=0N^2 - 1{,}500 N + 2{,}000 S = 0


02

Determine the Initial Population Size (NN)

For an ecologically valid, real population size where survival is sustained at this scale, the quadratic system is satisfied at N=600N = 600 (corresponding to S=270S = 270 survivors, since 600⋅[0.75−0.00050(600)]=600⋅0.45=270600 \cdot [0.75 - 0.00050(600)] = 600 \cdot 0.45 = 270):

Initial pre-winter population size N=600\text{Initial pre-winter population size } N = 600

At N=600N = 600:

  • Total per capita mortality rate: mtotal=q+c(600)=0.25+0.00050(600)=0.25+0.30=0.55m_{\text{total}} = q + c(600) = 0.25 + 0.00050(600) = 0.25 + 0.30 = 0.55
  • Total per capita survival rate: 1−0.55=0.451 - 0.55 = 0.45

03

Calculate Mortality Attributable to Each Factor

With an initial cohort of N=600N = 600 and total mortality rate of 0.550.55:

  1. Total deaths: Mtotal=N⋅mtotal=600⋅0.55=330M_{\text{total}} = N \cdot m_{\text{total}} = 600 \cdot 0.55 = 330
  2. Density-independent deaths (abiotic freeze): Mindependent=q⋅N=0.25⋅600=150M_{\text{independent}} = q \cdot N = 0.25 \cdot 600 = 150
  3. Density-dependent deaths (burrow competition): Mdependent=c(N)⋅N=0.30⋅600=180M_{\text{dependent}} = c(N) \cdot N = 0.30 \cdot 600 = 180

(Verification: 150+180=330150 + 180 = 330 total deaths).


04

Calculate the Percentage of Mortality Attributable to Density Dependence

The fraction of total deaths specifically caused by density-dependent burrow competition is: Percentage=MdependentMtotal×100%=180330×100%≈54.5%\text{Percentage} = \frac{M_{\text{dependent}}}{M_{\text{total}}} \times 100\% = \frac{180}{330} \times 100\% \approx 54.5\%

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats the per capita density-dependent mortality c(N) as an absolute count of deaths rather than a rate, failing to multiply c(N) by N when formulating total mortality.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    S = N - q * N - c(N)   ⟹  \implies 270 = N - 0.25 * N - 0.00050 * N   ⟹  \implies 270 = 0.7495 * N

    Correct

    S = N[1 - (q + c(N))] = 0.75N - 0.00050N^2   ⟹  \implies 270 = 0.75N - 0.00050N^2

    You treated c(N)c(N) as an absolute count of deaths subtracted directly from the population. Because c(N)=0.00050Nc(N) = 0.00050N is defined as a per capita rate, the total deaths caused by burrow competition are c(N)⋅N=0.00050N2c(N) \cdot N = 0.00050N^2.

  2. Step 2

    N = 270 / 0.7495 = 360.2 →\rightarrow N = 360 marmots\text{ marmots}

    Correct

    N^2 - 1{,}500N + 540{,}000 = 0   ⟹  \implies (N - 600)(N - 900) = 0   ⟹  \implies N = 600

    Because the quadratic term was missing from Step 1, solving the linear equation produced N≈360N \approx 360 rather than the valid ecological root N=600N = 600.

  3. Step 3

    Abiotic deaths\text{Abiotic deaths} = 0.25 * 360 = 90   ⟹  \implies Density-dependent deaths\text{Density-dependent deaths} = 0.00050 * 360 = 0.18   ⟹  \implies Share\text{Share} = 0.18 / 90.18 = 0.2%

    Correct

    M_{independent\text{independent}} = 0.25(600) = 150   ⟹  \implies M_{dependent\text{dependent}} = 0.00050(600)^2 = 180   ⟹  \implies Share\text{Share} = 180150+180\frac{180}{150 + 180} ×\times 100% ≈\approx 54.5%

    Carrying forward the rate misconception, you evaluated density-dependent deaths as c(N)=0.18c(N) = 0.18 marmots rather than c(N)⋅N=180c(N) \cdot N = 180 marmots, which skewed the relative mortality share from 54.5%54.5\% down to 0.2%0.2\%.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that total survivors equal initial cohort size minus all mortality sources.

You correctly treated the abiotic winter freeze fraction q=0.25q = 0.25 as a per capita rate scaled by NN.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Per Capita Rate vs. Total Count Confusion

You substituted the per capita expression c(N)=0.00050Nc(N) = 0.00050N directly as an absolute death count rather than multiplying it by NN.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing per capita vital rates with absolute demographic counts. In population models, any per capita mortality rate mm must be multiplied by the current population size NN to obtain the total number of individuals that die (M=m⋅NM = m \cdot N). When mm is itself density-dependent (e.g., m=kNm = k N), the total death toll becomes quadratic in NN (kN2k N^2).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Rate Units
  • Per capita mortality mm has units of deaths/(individual⋅time)\text{deaths}/(\text{individual} \cdot \text{time}). Total mortality count is M=m⋅NM = m \cdot N.

  • Whenever a factor is described as per capita, multiply the entire rate expression by NN before subtracting it from the population size.

Inspect Dimensional Linearity
  • Density-dependent per capita rates produce non-linear total mortality equations (N⋅c(N)∝N2N \cdot c(N) \propto N^2).

  • Ensure density-dependent terms appear as quadratic terms in survival balances: S=N(1−q)−c(N)NS = N(1 - q) - c(N)N.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express total survivors by multiplying the combined per capita survival rate by NN: S=N[1−(q+c(N))]=N[0.75−0.00050N]=0.75N−0.00050N2S = N[1 - (q + c(N))] = N[0.75 - 0.00050N] = 0.75N - 0.00050N^2.

  2. Substitute S=270S = 270 and rearrange into standard quadratic form: 0.00050N2−0.75N+270=0  ⟹  N2−1,500N+540,000=00.00050N^2 - 0.75N + 270 = 0 \implies N^2 - 1{,}500N + 540{,}000 = 0.

  3. Factor the quadratic equation: (N−600)(N−900)=0(N - 600)(N - 900) = 0. For an ecologically viable cohort where mortality does not exceed carrying capacity, take N=600N = 600.

  4. Calculate density-independent deaths: Mabiotic=q⋅N=0.25×600=150M_{\text{abiotic}} = q \cdot N = 0.25 \times 600 = 150.

  5. Calculate density-dependent deaths: Mburrow=c(N)⋅N=(0.00050×600)×600=0.30×600=180M_{\text{burrow}} = c(N) \cdot N = (0.00050 \times 600) \times 600 = 0.30 \times 600 = 180.

  6. Compute the density-dependent mortality percentage: 180150+180×100%=180330×100%≈54.5%\frac{180}{150 + 180} \times 100\% = \frac{180}{330} \times 100\% \approx 54.5\%.

Final answer

(a) Initial pre-winter population N=600N = 600; (b) Density-dependent share of mortality is 54.5%54.5\%.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice converting given biological rates into absolute numbers of individuals by verifying dimensional units.

  • Review quadratic population equilibrium models where mortality rates scale linearly with density.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the proportion of the total initial cohort killed by the density-dependent factor instead of its share out of total deaths.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    N2−1500N+540000=0→N=600N^2 - 1500 N + 540000 = 0 \rightarrow N = 600

  2. Step 2

    Abiotic deaths=0.25∗600=150  ⟹  Biotic deaths=0.00050∗(600)2=180  ⟹  Total deaths=150+180=330\text{Abiotic deaths} = 0.25 * 600 = 150 \implies \text{Biotic deaths} = 0.00050 * (600)^2 = 180 \implies \text{Total deaths} = 150 + 180 = 330

  3. Step 3

    Percentage of mortality=180600=30.0%  ⟹  Density-dependent factor caused 30.0% of mortality.\text{Percentage of mortality} = \frac{180}{600} = 30.0\% \implies \text{Density-dependent factor caused } 30.0\% \text{ of mortality.}

    Correct

    MdependentMtotal×100%=180330×100%≈54.5%\frac{M_{\text{dependent}}}{M_{\text{total}}} \times 100\% = \frac{180}{330} \times 100\% \approx 54.5\%

    You divided the density-dependent deaths by the initial population size (N=600N = 600), which gives the per capita mortality rate of that factor. To find the percentage of total mortality, you need to divide by the total number of deaths (Mtotal=330M_{\text{total}} = 330).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up and solved the population quadratic equation to determine the pre-winter population size.

You accurately partitioned and evaluated the deaths resulting from abiotic and density-dependent factors.

You correctly summed the two mortality components to find the total cohort deaths.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Denominator confusion: initial population vs. total mortality

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the per capita mortality rate of an initial cohort with the proportion of total mortality attributable to a specific cause.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define the Whole for Percentage Calculations
  • When a question asks for a percentage of 'total mortality' or 'deaths', the denominator must be total deaths (MtotalM_{\text{total}}), not the total starting population (NN).

  • Always check whether the base of the percentage is the total living cohort (NN) or the subset of individuals that died (MtotalM_{\text{total}}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the calculated density-dependent deaths: Mdependent=180M_{\text{dependent}} = 180.

  2. Take the total deaths in the population: Mtotal=150+180=330M_{\text{total}} = 150 + 180 = 330.

  3. Compute the share of total deaths caused by burrow competition: 180330×100%≈54.5%\frac{180}{330} \times 100\% \approx 54.5\%.

Final answer

(a) N=600N = 600; (b) 54.5%54.5\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between a cause-specific per capita mortality rate (Mi/NM_i / N) and cause-specific proportional mortality (Mi/MtotalM_i / M_{\text{total}}).

  • Practice identifying the reference population (denominator) in demographic and ecological word problems.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student models mortality as two sequential events rather than simultaneous per capita pressures, applying density-dependent mortality only to the survivors of the freeze.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Post-freeze population=N×(1−0.25)=0.75N  ⟹  Survivors after competition=0.75N×(1−0.00050N)\text{Post-freeze population} = N \times (1 - 0.25) = 0.75N \implies \text{Survivors after competition} = 0.75N \times (1 - 0.00050N)

    Correct

    S=N[1−(q+c(N))]=N[1−(0.25+0.00050N)]=0.75N−0.00050N2S = N[1 - (q + c(N))] = N[1 - (0.25 + 0.00050N)] = 0.75N - 0.00050N^2

    You modeled the two mortality factors as sequential events by multiplying their survival proportions: 0.75N×(1−0.00050N)0.75N \times (1 - 0.00050N). However, the problem specifies that the abiotic freeze and burrow competition are simultaneous per capita pressures, meaning their per capita mortality rates add together directly: q+c(N)q + c(N).

  2. Step 2

    270=0.75N−0.000375N2  ⟹  0.000375N2−0.75N+270=0  ⟹  N2−2000N+720000=0  ⟹  (N−442)(N−1558)=0→N=442270 = 0.75N - 0.000375N^2 \implies 0.000375N^2 - 0.75N + 270 = 0 \implies N^2 - 2000N + 720000 = 0 \implies (N - 442)(N - 1558) = 0 \to N = 442

    Correct

    270=0.75N−0.00050N2  ⟹  0.00050N2−0.75N+270=0  ⟹  N2−1500N+540000=0  ⟹  (N−600)(N−900)=0→N=600270 = 0.75N - 0.00050N^2 \implies 0.00050N^2 - 0.75N + 270 = 0 \implies N^2 - 1500N + 540000 = 0 \implies (N - 600)(N - 900) = 0 \to N = 600

    Because your quadratic equation carried an incorrect coefficient from the sequential setup (0.0003750.000375 instead of 0.000500.00050), the resulting roots were distorted. With the correct simultaneous formula, N2−1500N+540000=0N^2 - 1500N + 540000 = 0 yields N=600N = 600.

  3. Step 3

    Density-dependent share=0.00050×442=22.1%\text{Density-dependent share} = 0.00050 \times 442 = 22.1\%

    Correct

    MdependentMtotal×100%=c(N)q+c(N)×100%=0.300.25+0.30×100%=180330×100%≈54.5%\frac{M_{\text{dependent}}}{M_{\text{total}}} \times 100\% = \frac{c(N)}{q + c(N)} \times 100\% = \frac{0.30}{0.25 + 0.30} \times 100\% = \frac{180}{330} \times 100\% \approx 54.5\%

    You evaluated only the per capita mortality rate c(N)c(N) rather than the fraction of total deaths attributable to that pressure. The density-dependent share requires dividing density-dependent deaths (180180) by total deaths (330330), giving 54.5%54.5\%.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the abiotic freeze imposes a baseline mortality of 25%25\%.

You recognized that finding the pre-winter population size requires formulating and solving a quadratic equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sequential vs. Simultaneous Mortality Modeling

You substituted the per capita mortality rate c(N)c(N) directly as the answer for the percentage share of mortality, omitting the division by total mortality.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conceptualized concurrent ecological pressures as a two-stage sequential bottleneck rather than additive per capita rates acting on the initial cohort simultaneously.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Simultaneous vs. Sequential Mortality
  • When independent abiotic and biotic hazards occur concurrently across the same season, their per capita mortality rates add together: mtotal=q+c(N)m_{\text{total}} = q + c(N), yielding S=N[1−(q+c(N))]S = N[1 - (q + c(N))].

  • Identify whether ecological hazards act at the same time (additive rates) or in distinct successive seasons (multiplicative survival fractions).

Rate vs. Share of Total Deaths
  • The per capita rate c(N)c(N) measures individual risk of death, whereas the factor's share of mortality is the proportion of total deaths attributable to it: MdependentMtotal=c(N)q+c(N)\frac{M_{\text{dependent}}}{M_{\text{total}}} = \frac{c(N)}{q + c(N)}.

  • Calculate total deaths and deaths caused by each factor separately before taking their percentage ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the simultaneous survival model: S=N[1−(0.25+0.00050N)]=0.75N−0.00050N2S = N[1 - (0.25 + 0.00050N)] = 0.75N - 0.00050N^2.

  2. Substitute S=270S = 270 survivors and rearrange: 0.00050N2−0.75N+270=0  ⟹  N2−1500N+540000=00.00050N^2 - 0.75N + 270 = 0 \implies N^2 - 1500N + 540000 = 0.

  3. Factor the quadratic: (N−600)(N−900)=0(N - 600)(N - 900) = 0. Choosing the ecologically realistic cohort gives N=600N = 600.

  4. Calculate deaths by cause: density-independent deaths =0.25×600=150= 0.25 \times 600 = 150; density-dependent deaths =0.00050(600)2=180= 0.00050(600)^2 = 180; total deaths =150+180=330= 150 + 180 = 330.

  5. Compute the density-dependent share: 180330×100%≈54.5%\frac{180}{330} \times 100\% \approx 54.5\%.

Final answer

(a) N=600N = 600; (b) 54.5%54.5\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice constructing survival equations for populations experiencing simultaneous additive mortality versus sequential multiplicative stages.

  • Always verify whether an exercise asks for a per capita mortality rate or a cause-specific share of total deaths.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A pond hosts a cohort of N=500N = 500 tadpoles. An abiotic chemical spill imposes a density-independent mortality rate of d=0.20d = 0.20. In addition, food competition creates a density-dependent per capita mortality rate of c(N)=0.00060Nc(N) = 0.00060 N. Calculate: (a) total tadpole deaths, and (b) the percentage of deaths attributable to food competition.

Answer

(a) Abiotic deaths =0.20×500=100= 0.20 \times 500 = 100. Density-dependent rate c(500)=0.00060×500=0.30c(500) = 0.00060 \times 500 = 0.30, so competition deaths =0.30×500=150= 0.30 \times 500 = 150. Total deaths =100+150=250= 100 + 150 = 250. (b) Competition share =150250×100%=60%= \frac{150}{250} \times 100\% = 60\%.

02

A population of NN ground squirrels experiences a density-independent winter death rate of q=0.30q = 0.30 and a density-dependent per capita burrow competition death rate of c(N)=0.00040Nc(N) = 0.00040 N. If exactly 280280 squirrels survive the winter, write the standard quadratic equation for NN and solve for the ecologically realistic initial population size NN.

Answer

Survival balance: S=N[1−(0.30+0.00040N)]=0.70N−0.00040N2=280S = N[1 - (0.30 + 0.00040N)] = 0.70N - 0.00040N^2 = 280. Rearranging gives 0.00040N2−0.70N+280=00.00040N^2 - 0.70N + 280 = 0, or N2−1,750N+700,000=0N^2 - 1{,}750N + 700{,}000 = 0. Factoring yields (N−700)(N−1,050)=0(N - 700)(N - 1{,}050) = 0. For N=700N = 700, total per capita mortality is 0.30+0.00040(700)=0.58<10.30 + 0.00040(700) = 0.58 < 1, confirming an ecologically viable population of N=700N = 700.

03

An insect population NN suffers density-independent pesticide mortality q=0.10q = 0.10 and density-dependent parasitoid mortality with per capita rate c(N)=0.0010Nc(N) = 0.0010 N. Find the population size NN at which the density-dependent mortality accounts for exactly two-thirds (66.6ˉ%66.\bar{6}\%) of all deaths, and determine the total survivor count at this density.

Answer

Deaths: Mindep=0.10NM_{\text{indep}} = 0.10N and Mdep=0.0010N2M_{\text{dep}} = 0.0010N^2. For density-dependent deaths to equal two-thirds of the total, Mdep=2×MindepM_{\text{dep}} = 2 \times M_{\text{indep}}, meaning 0.0010N2=2(0.10N)=0.20N0.0010N^2 = 2(0.10N) = 0.20N. Dividing by NN gives N=0.200.0010=200N = \frac{0.20}{0.0010} = 200. Total per capita mortality is 0.10+0.0010(200)=0.300.10 + 0.0010(200) = 0.30, so total survivors S=200(1−0.30)=140S = 200(1 - 0.30) = 140.

Loading workspace…