Resources

In a marine biodiversity survey of macroinvertebrates, two distinct tide pools are sampled, each yielding exactly N=500N = 500 individuals across four species (AA, BB, CC, and DD). Pool 1 contains 470470 individuals of species AA, 1010 of BB, 1010 of CC, and 1010 of DD. Pool 2 contains 125125 individuals of each of the four species. Using Simpson's Diversity Index defined as D=1−∑pi2D = 1 - \sum p_i^2 (where pip_i is the relative abundance of species ii), compute DD for Pool 1 and Pool 2 to three significant figures, and explain whether equal species richness implies equal community diversity.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Pool 1: D=0.116D = 0.116; Pool 2: D=0.750D = 0.750; No, equal species richness (S=4S = 4 for both) does not imply equal diversity because community evenness differs dramatically.

Steps

01

Understand the Components of Simpson's Diversity Index

Simpson's Index of Diversity is given by: D=1−∑i=1Spi2D = 1 - \sum_{i=1}^{S} p_i^2

where:

  • SS is the species richness (the total number of distinct species).
  • pi=niNp_i = \frac{n_i}{N} is the relative abundance (proportion) of species ii.
  • nin_i is the number of individuals of species ii, and N=∑niN = \sum n_i is the total number of individuals.
  • DD ranges from 00 (no diversity; complete dominance by a single species) to near 11 (high diversity and evenness).

02

Calculate DD for Pool 1

Pool 1 has a total population of N=500N = 500 individuals distributed as:

  • Species AA: nA=470  ⟹  pA=470500=0.94n_A = 470 \implies p_A = \frac{470}{500} = 0.94
  • Species BB: nB=10  ⟹  pB=10500=0.02n_B = 10 \implies p_B = \frac{10}{500} = 0.02
  • Species CC: nC=10  ⟹  pC=10500=0.02n_C = 10 \implies p_C = \frac{10}{500} = 0.02
  • Species DD: nD=10  ⟹  pD=10500=0.02n_D = 10 \implies p_D = \frac{10}{500} = 0.02

Now calculate the sum of squared relative abundances: ∑pi2=(0.94)2+3⋅(0.02)2=0.8836+3⋅(0.0004)=0.8836+0.0012=0.8848\sum p_i^2 = (0.94)^2 + 3 \cdot (0.02)^2 = 0.8836 + 3 \cdot (0.0004) = 0.8836 + 0.0012 = 0.8848

Rounding the dominance value to three decimal places gives ∑pi2≈0.884\sum p_i^2 \approx 0.884. Then: D=1−0.8848≈0.116 (to three significant figures)D = 1 - 0.8848 \approx 0.116 \text{ (to three significant figures)}


03

Calculate DD for Pool 2

Pool 2 has N=500N = 500 individuals distributed equally among all four species:

  • For each species (A,B,C,DA, B, C, D): ni=125  ⟹  pi=125500=0.25n_i = 125 \implies p_i = \frac{125}{500} = 0.25

Calculate the sum of squared relative abundances: ∑pi2=4⋅(0.25)2=4⋅0.0625=0.250\sum p_i^2 = 4 \cdot (0.25)^2 = 4 \cdot 0.0625 = 0.250

Subtract from 11: D=1−0.250=0.750D = 1 - 0.250 = 0.750


04

Compare Species Richness and Community Diversity

  • Species Richness (SS): Both tide pools have identical richness, S=4S = 4, because both contain the same four species (A,B,C,DA, B, C, D).
  • Species Evenness: In Pool 1, species AA accounts for 94%94\% of all individuals (extreme dominance, very low evenness). In Pool 2, all four species are equally abundant at 25%25\% each (maximum evenness).

Because overall community diversity depends on both richness (number of species) and evenness (relative distribution of individuals among species), equal species richness does not imply equal community diversity. Pool 2 is substantially more diverse (D=0.750D = 0.750) than Pool 1 (D=0.116D = 0.116).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates Simpson's dominance index Σp_i² rather than the diversity index D = 1 - Σp_i², mistakenly concluding that Pool 1 is more diverse.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    pA=470500=0.94,  pB=pC=pD=10500=0.02  ⟹  D=0.942+3(0.022)  ⟹  D=0.8836+0.0012=0.885p_A = \frac{470}{500} = 0.94,\; p_B = p_C = p_D = \frac{10}{500} = 0.02 \implies D = 0.94^2 + 3(0.02^2) \implies D = 0.8836 + 0.0012 = 0.885

    Correct

    pA=0.94,  pB=pC=pD=0.02  ⟹  D=1−(0.942+3(0.022))=1−0.8848=0.116p_A = 0.94,\; p_B = p_C = p_D = 0.02 \implies D = 1 - \left(0.94^2 + 3(0.02^2)\right) = 1 - 0.8848 = 0.116

    You found the relative abundances and computed the sum of squares accurately, but you calculated the dominance index ∑pi2\sum p_i^2 instead of Simpson's diversity index D=1−∑pi2D = 1 - \sum p_i^2.

  2. Step 2

    pA=pB=pC=pD=125500=0.25  ⟹  D=4(0.252)  ⟹  D=4(0.0625)=0.250p_A = p_B = p_C = p_D = \frac{125}{500} = 0.25 \implies D = 4(0.25^2) \implies D = 4(0.0625) = 0.250

    Correct

    pA=pB=pC=pD=0.25  ⟹  D=1−4(0.252)=1−0.250=0.750p_A = p_B = p_C = p_D = 0.25 \implies D = 1 - 4(0.25^2) = 1 - 0.250 = 0.750

    You determined the equal proportions correctly, but you repeated the formula omission by calculating ∑pi2\sum p_i^2 rather than subtracting the sum from 11.

  3. Step 3

    Equal richness does not imply equal diversity because community diversity depends on how individuals are distributed across species, giving Pool 1 a higher diversity index of 0.885 compared to 0.250 for Pool 2.

    Correct

    Equal richness does not imply equal diversity because Pool 2 has much higher species evenness, resulting in a higher diversity index (D=0.750D = 0.750) than Pool 1 (D=0.116D = 0.116).

    You correctly recognized that richness alone does not dictate diversity because evenness matters. However, due to your inverted values from Steps 1 and 2, your final comparison mistakenly named Pool 1 as the more diverse community.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the relative abundances pip_i for all four species in both pools with complete accuracy.

You correctly squared and summed the relative abundances to find the dominance values for both communities.

You correctly understood that species richness alone does not account for differences in species evenness.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula Substitution Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated Simpson's dominance index (λ=∑pi2\lambda = \sum p_i^2) with Simpson's index of diversity (D=1−∑pi2D = 1 - \sum p_i^2). A higher sum of squared proportions indicates higher dominance (lower diversity), which is why the formula subtracts the sum from 11 to reflect community diversity.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Simpson's Diversity Definition
  • D=1−∑i=1Spi2D = 1 - \sum_{i=1}^{S} p_i^2

  • Always subtract the sum of squared relative abundances from 11 when using the index form given in the problem.

Biological Intuition for Evenness
  • High species evenness yields high diversity (D→1D \to 1), whereas strong single-species dominance yields low diversity (D→0D \to 0).

  • Sanity-check whether an evenly distributed community produces a value closer to 11 than a community dominated by one species.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. For Pool 1, subtract the dominance value from 11: D1=1−0.8848=0.1152≈0.116D_1 = 1 - 0.8848 = 0.1152 \approx 0.116.

  2. For Pool 2, subtract the dominance value from 11: D2=1−0.250=0.750D_2 = 1 - 0.250 = 0.750.

  3. Compare the resulting values: Pool 2 has much greater evenness and therefore a higher diversity index (0.750>0.1160.750 > 0.116) despite both communities having equal species richness (S=4S = 4).

Final answer

Pool 1: D=0.116D = 0.116; Pool 2: D=0.750D = 0.750; No, equal species richness does not imply equal diversity because community evenness differs dramatically.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying the difference between Simpson's dominance index (∑pi2\sum p_i^2) and Simpson's diversity index (1−∑pi21 - \sum p_i^2).

  • Perform a quick sanity check after every biodiversity calculation to ensure the more evenly balanced community has the higher diversity score.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student squares individual counts n_i directly instead of relative abundances p_i = n_i/N in the summation formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    D=1−(4702+102+102+102)  ⟹  −(220900+300)=−221199D = 1 - (470^2 + 10^2 + 10^2 + 10^2) \implies -(220900 + 300) = -221199

    Correct

    pA=470500=0.94p_A = \frac{470}{500} = 0.94, pB=pC=pD=10500=0.02  ⟹  D=1−(0.942+3×0.022)=0.116p_B = p_C = p_D = \frac{10}{500} = 0.02 \implies D = 1 - (0.94^2 + 3 \times 0.02^2) = 0.116

    You squared the raw individual counts rather than the species proportions pi=niNp_i = \frac{n_i}{N}. Because pip_i represents relative abundance, each value must lie between 00 and 11, keeping the final index DD strictly between 00 and 11.

  2. Step 2

    pA=pB=pC=pD=125500=0.25  ⟹  D=1−4(0.252)=0.750p_A = p_B = p_C = p_D = \frac{125}{500} = 0.25 \implies D = 1 - 4(0.25^2) = 0.750

  3. Step 3

    Equal species richness does not imply equal community diversity because diversity also depends on species evenness, which differs between the two pools.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the relative abundances and Simpson's Diversity Index for Pool 2.

You correctly explained the biological distinction between species richness and species evenness.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Raw counts substituted for relative abundances

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You substituted the raw population counts nin_i directly into D=1−∑pi2D = 1 - \sum p_i^2 for Pool 1 instead of first dividing each count by the total population N=500N = 500 to get the proportion pip_i.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Definition of Relative Abundance
  • pi=niNp_i = \frac{n_i}{N}, where N=∑niN = \sum n_i and ∑pi=1\sum p_i = 1

  • Convert every species tally into a proportion of the total community before squaring.

Range of Simpson's Index
  • 0≤∑pi2≤1  ⟹  0≤D<10 \le \sum p_i^2 \le 1 \implies 0 \le D < 1

  • If your calculated value of DD is negative or greater than 11, immediately verify whether raw counts were squared instead of proportions.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the total population of Pool 1: N=470+10+10+10=500N = 470 + 10 + 10 + 10 = 500.

  2. Calculate relative abundances: pA=470500=0.94p_A = \frac{470}{500} = 0.94, and pB=pC=pD=10500=0.02p_B = p_C = p_D = \frac{10}{500} = 0.02.

  3. Compute the sum of squared relative abundances: ∑pi2=0.942+3(0.022)=0.8836+0.0012=0.8848\sum p_i^2 = 0.94^2 + 3(0.02^2) = 0.8836 + 0.0012 = 0.8848.

  4. Evaluate D=1−∑pi2=1−0.8848=0.1152≈0.116D = 1 - \sum p_i^2 = 1 - 0.8848 = 0.1152 \approx 0.116.

Final answer

Pool 1: D=0.116D = 0.116; Pool 2: D=0.750D = 0.750; No, equal species richness does not imply equal community diversity because community evenness differs dramatically.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always calculate and record each species proportion pi=niNp_i = \frac{n_i}{N} explicitly before squaring.

  • Use the sanity check 0≤D<10 \le D < 1 to catch raw-count substitution errors early.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assumes community diversity depends solely on species richness, incorrectly concluding that the communities have equal diversity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    p_A = 470500\frac{470}{500} = 0.94,; p_B = p_C = p_D = 10500\frac{10}{500} = 0.02   ⟹  \implies D = 1 - (0.94^2 + 3(0.02^2)) = 1 - 0.8848 = 0.115

  2. Step 2

    p_A = p_B = p_C = p_D = 125500\frac{125}{500} = 0.25   ⟹  \implies D = 1 - 4(0.25^2) = 1 - 0.25 = 0.750

  3. Step 3

    Equal species richness [does not crossed out] imply equal community diversity because both pools contain exactly four species, meaning they have the same total number of species regardless of individual counts.

    Correct

    No, equal species richness does not imply equal community diversity because diversity also depends on species evenness. Even though both pools have S=4S = 4, Pool 2 is much more diverse (D=0.750D = 0.750) than Pool 1 (D≈0.115D \approx 0.115 or 0.1160.116) due to equal relative abundances versus extreme dominance by species AA.

    You crossed out 'does not' and concluded that richness alone determines community diversity. Community diversity measures both species richness (the number of different species) and species evenness (the equitability of species abundances). Your own numerical calculations demonstrated that Pool 2 (D=0.750D = 0.750) is far more diverse than Pool 1 (D≈0.115D \approx 0.115).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the relative species abundances for both tide pools.

You correctly applied Simpson's Diversity Index formula D=1−∑pi2D = 1 - \sum p_i^2 to both data sets.

You correctly recognized that both tide pools share the same species richness (S=4S = 4).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equating species richness with overall community diversity

None

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated species richness (the count of distinct species) as synonymous with community diversity, ignoring the role of species evenness and failing to use your calculated DD values to inform your verbal conclusion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Richness vs. Evenness
  • Community diversity is a function of both species richness (how many species are present) and species evenness (how equally individuals are distributed among those species).

  • Always evaluate both richness and relative abundance distribution before determining community diversity.

Interpreting Simpson's Index
  • Simpson's Diversity Index D=1−∑pi2D = 1 - \sum p_i^2 ranges from 00 (a monoculture) toward 11 (high richness and high evenness).

  • When a question asks you to calculate an index and draw a conclusion, compare your calculated values (0.1150.115 vs. 0.7500.750) to support your ecological conclusion.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State whether equal species richness implies equal community diversity: No, it does not.

  2. Define the two components of biodiversity: species richness (number of distinct species, S=4S = 4 for both pools) and species evenness (distribution of individuals among species).

  3. Contrast the evenness of Pool 1 (heavily dominated by species AA at 94%94\%, D≈0.115D \approx 0.115) with Pool 2 (completely even at 25%25\% each, D=0.750D = 0.750).

  4. Conclude that because evenness differs dramatically, overall community diversity is substantially higher in Pool 2 despite identical richness.

Final answer

Pool 1: D=0.116D = 0.116 (or 0.1150.115); Pool 2: D=0.750D = 0.750; No, equal species richness does not imply equal community diversity because community evenness differs dramatically between the two pools.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the ecological definitions of species richness, species evenness, and proportional abundance.

  • Practice comparing ecological communities that have identical richness but contrasting dominance profiles.

  • Ensure you cross-check verbal biological conclusions against quantitative diversity metrics calculated earlier in the problem.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A forest patch has three tree species with abundances nA=80n_A = 80, nB=10n_B = 10, and nC=10n_C = 10. Calculate Simpson's Diversity Index D=1−∑pi2D = 1 - \sum p_i^2 to two decimal places.

Answer

D=0.34D = 0.34. Total N=100N = 100. Proportions are pA=0.8p_A = 0.8, pB=0.1p_B = 0.1, pC=0.1p_C = 0.1. Then ∑pi2=0.82+0.12+0.12=0.64+0.01+0.01=0.66\sum p_i^2 = 0.8^2 + 0.1^2 + 0.1^2 = 0.64 + 0.01 + 0.01 = 0.66. Finally, D=1−0.66=0.34D = 1 - 0.66 = 0.34.

02

Two grassland plots each contain S=5S = 5 plant species. Plot X has relative abundances (0.20,0.20,0.20,0.20,0.20)(0.20, 0.20, 0.20, 0.20, 0.20), while Plot Y has relative abundances (0.80,0.05,0.05,0.05,0.05)(0.80, 0.05, 0.05, 0.05, 0.05). Calculate Simpson's Diversity Index D=1−∑pi2D = 1 - \sum p_i^2 for both plots and state which plot has greater diversity.

Answer

Plot X: D=0.80D = 0.80; Plot Y: D=0.35D = 0.35; Plot X has greater diversity. For Plot X, ∑pi2=5×(0.2)2=0.20  ⟹  D=1−0.20=0.80\sum p_i^2 = 5 \times (0.2)^2 = 0.20 \implies D = 1 - 0.20 = 0.80. For Plot Y, ∑pi2=0.82+4×(0.05)2=0.64+0.01=0.65  ⟹  D=1−0.65=0.35\sum p_i^2 = 0.8^2 + 4 \times (0.05)^2 = 0.64 + 0.01 = 0.65 \implies D = 1 - 0.65 = 0.35.

03

A wetland stream contains 4 insect species with counts n1=30n_1 = 30, n2=30n_2 = 30, n3=20n_3 = 20, and n4=20n_4 = 20. An adjacent disturbed stream contains 4 insect species with counts n1=91n_1 = 91, n2=3n_2 = 3, n3=3n_3 = 3, and n4=3n_4 = 3. Both total N=100N = 100 individuals. Using D=1−∑pi2D = 1 - \sum p_i^2, determine the difference in Simpson's diversity (ΔD=Dwetland−DdisturbedΔD = D_{\text{wetland}} - D_{\text{disturbed}}) to three decimal places.

Answer

ΔD=0.584ΔD = 0.584. For the wetland stream: proportions are 0.3,0.3,0.2,0.20.3, 0.3, 0.2, 0.2, so ∑pi2=2(0.09)+2(0.04)=0.26  ⟹  D=1−0.26=0.740\sum p_i^2 = 2(0.09) + 2(0.04) = 0.26 \implies D = 1 - 0.26 = 0.740. For the disturbed stream: proportions are 0.91,0.03,0.03,0.030.91, 0.03, 0.03, 0.03, so ∑pi2=0.8281+3(0.0009)=0.8308  ⟹  D=1−0.8308=0.1692≈0.169\sum p_i^2 = 0.8281 + 3(0.0009) = 0.8308 \implies D = 1 - 0.8308 = 0.1692 \approx 0.169. The difference is 0.740−0.1692=0.57080.740 - 0.1692 = 0.5708 (or 0.740−0.169=0.5710.740 - 0.169 = 0.571; using exact fractions yields 0.7400−0.1692=0.5710.7400 - 0.1692 = 0.571).

Loading workspace…