Resources
An undergraduate biology student hypothesizes that purifying viral RNA genomes away from their viral capsids and envelopes will render all viral genomes completely non-infectious when directly microinjected into the cytoplasm of a susceptible host cell. To test this, the student microinjects separately: (A) purified from a poliovirus (Picornaviridae), and (B) purified from a vesicular stomatitis virus (Rhabdoviridae), with no viral proteins added. Explain which viral genome is capable of producing infectious progeny virions, identify the critical host-dependence mechanism that accounts for this difference, and calculate the number of functional proteins directly translatable by host ribosomes from genome (B) immediately upon microinjection.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Genome (A) is infectious; host ribosomes can directly translate to produce viral RdRp, whereas host ribosomes cannot translate and host cells lack an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase; proteins can be translated from Genome (B).
Steps
Identify which genome is infectious on its own
- Genome (A) (Poliovirus, ) is capable of producing infectious progeny virions when introduced as naked RNA.
- Genome (B) (Vesicular stomatitis virus, ) is non-infectious on its own.
Explain the mechanism and host dependence
Viral replication depends strictly on host machinery, but standard host eukaryotic cells lack an enzyme that synthesizes RNA from an RNA template—namely, an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp).
-
Replication of (Genome A):
- A positive-sense single-stranded RNA molecule has the same polarity as host messenger RNA ().
- Upon microinjection, host cytoplasmic ribosomes immediately recognize and translate the sequence into viral proteins, including the viral RdRp.
- Once synthesized, this RdRp transcribes the into full-length intermediates, which then serve as templates to produce abundant new genomes and structural proteins, successfully generating complete infectious virions.
-
Replication barrier for (Genome B):
- A negative-sense single-stranded RNA molecule is the complementary strand of mRNA. Host ribosomes cannot read or translate it into functional viral proteins.
- For a virus to replicate naturally, it must package pre-formed viral RdRp molecules inside its capsid/envelope during virion assembly. Upon standard infection, this packaged RdRp transcribes the into .
- Because Genome (B) was purified away from all viral proteins, no RdRp is present. The host cell cannot transcribe or translate the negative-sense strand, terminating the viral life cycle immediately.
Number of directly translatable functional proteins from Genome (B)
- Because eukaryotic ribosomes only recognize and translate bearing appropriate translational signals (such as a cap or an internal ribosome entry site) in the correct reading frame:
Common Pitfall: Do not assume host cell DNA-dependent RNA polymerases can transcribe viral RNA templates. Eukaryotic host cells exclusively use DNA templates for RNA synthesis; replication of an RNA genome always requires a viral RdRp.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses positive-sense and negative-sense viral RNA, concluding that (-)ssRNA is directly infectious because it serves as the direct template for synthesizing (+)ssRNA.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Vesicular stomatitis virus produces infectious progeny, while Genome (A) does not.
CorrectGenome (A) (poliovirus, ) is capable of producing infectious progeny virions, while Genome (B) is non-infectious on its own.
Poliovirus possesses a positive-sense single-stranded RNA genome that can function immediately as mRNA inside the host cell cytoplasm, making naked inherently infectious. Vesicular stomatitis virus is a virus and cannot initiate infection as naked RNA.
- Step 2
Host cell RNA polymerases immediately recognize the negative strand to transcribe viral mRNAs ⟹ Genome (A) cannot direct protein synthesis because it requires reverse transcription first.
CorrectHost cells lack an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp). Host ribosomes directly translate (Genome A) to synthesize viral RdRp, whereas (Genome B) requires pre-packaged viral RdRp to transcribe viral mRNAs.
Eukaryotic host cell RNA polymerases are strictly DNA-dependent and cannot transcribe an RNA template. Furthermore, poliovirus is not a retrovirus and does not use reverse transcriptase; its positive strand is recognized directly by ribosomes to produce viral proteins, including its own RdRp.
- Step 3
0 functional proteins are directly translated from genome (B) since transcription must precede translation.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that zero functional proteins can be translated directly from the negative-sense RNA genome.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that eukaryotic host RNA polymerases can transcribe RNA templates into mRNA and conflated positive-sense RNA replication with retroviral reverse transcription, leading to an inverted conclusion about which naked viral genome is infectious.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Host Polymerase Capabilities
Eukaryotic host RNA polymerases (Pol I, II, III) are DNA-dependent; host cells do not possess an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp).
Always verify whether an incoming viral genome requires a specialized viral enzyme (such as an RdRp) before transcription can occur.
- Positive vs. Negative Sense RNA Polarity
has the same sense as mRNA and is directly translatable by host ribosomes, whereas is complementary to mRNA and cannot be translated.
Deduce infectivity of naked RNA by checking if host ribosomes can immediately synthesize the viral replicase from the injected strand.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine the polarity of Genome (A): poliovirus is a virus whose RNA acts directly as mRNA.
Recall host cell machinery: host ribosomes directly translate to produce viral proteins, notably viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp).
Evaluate Genome (B): vesicular stomatitis virus is a virus. Host cells possess only DNA-dependent RNA polymerases, so without packaged viral RdRp, the negative strand cannot be transcribed or translated.
Conclude that purified Genome (A) is infectious, purified Genome (B) is non-infectious, and Genome (B) yields directly translatable proteins.
Genome (A) is infectious; host cells lack an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, so host ribosomes directly translate to produce viral RdRp while cannot be read or transcribed; proteins can be directly translated from Genome (B).
02 The student mistakenly assumes that host ribosomes can translate (-)ssRNA directly into the five structural proteins of vesicular stomatitis virus.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Genome (A) is capable of producing infectious virions, but genome (B) cannot.
- Step 2
Genome (A) is which acts directly as mRNA in the cytoplasm to make viral RdRp. Genome (B) cannot initiate replication because the virion lacks the required viral polymerase protein.
- Step 3
Host ribosomes read the five open reading frames on the viral RNA genome directly. Number of functional proteins
CorrectHost eukaryotic ribosomes can only recognize and translate positive-sense RNA with appropriate translation initiation signals. Because is complementary (antisense) to mRNA, host ribosomes cannot translate functional proteins from it, yielding proteins.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that Genome (A) is infectious while Genome (B) is non-infectious.
You clearly explained that positive-sense single-stranded RNA acts directly as mRNA to produce viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp).
You recognized that negative-sense single-stranded RNA viruses normally rely on a virion-associated polymerase.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the negative-sense viral genome as if host ribosomes could directly read antisense RNA strands, overlooking that eukaryotic ribosomes exclusively translate positive-sense (mRNA-polarity) sequences.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Ribosomal Polarity Requirement
Eukaryotic host ribosomes exclusively translate sequences that possess appropriate translation initiation features.
Check whether the viral genome strand is sense or sense before determining if host ribosomes can synthesize viral proteins from it directly.
- Host Enzymatic Limitations
Eukaryotic host cells lack an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) and cannot transcribe into .
Confirm whether purified viral RNA carries its own polymerase protein; naked introduced alone is completely inert in the host cytoplasm.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that Genome (B) is , which is complementary (antisense) to functional viral .
Note that host cytoplasmic ribosomes cannot recognize or translate negative-sense RNA into functional polypeptides.
Conclude that without a pre-existing RdRp to transcribe templates, host ribosomes synthesize no proteins.
Number of functional proteins directly translatable from Genome (B)
03 The student accepts the undergraduate's original hypothesis that removing capsids prevents infection for all viral genomes due to lack of receptor-mediated entry.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Neither genome (A) nor genome (B) is capable of producing infectious progeny virions.
CorrectGenome (A) (poliovirus ) is capable of producing infectious progeny virions.
You concluded that neither naked RNA genome can produce progeny virions. However, has the same polarity as eukaryotic mRNA, so microinjecting it directly into the cytoplasm bypasses the requirement for a capsid or envelope during cell entry and successfully initiates infection.
- Step 2
Viral capsids and envelopes are essential for genome stability and without them cytoplasmic nucleases degrade any naked injected RNA before translation or transcription can occur.
CorrectHost ribosomes can immediately translate into viral proteins (including viral RdRp), whereas host ribosomes cannot translate and uninfected host cells lack an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase.
You attributed the block to immediate degradation by cytoplasmic nucleases. While nucleases exist, the primary biological barrier is informational: host ribosomes read only positive-sense sequences, and host eukaryotic cells lack an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase to copy into translatable strands.
- Step 3
functional proteins are translated because the unprotected RNA is degraded immediately.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated that functional proteins can be directly translated from the genome.
You recognized that microinjection delivers the viral genomes directly into the host cytoplasm.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou initially considered that only Genome (A) might be infectious before crossing it out to argue that all naked RNA is immediately degraded.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that viral capsids are strictly required to protect naked viral RNA from instant destruction inside the cell, overlooking that is functionally equivalent to host mRNA and can be immediately translated by cytoplasmic ribosomes into an essential viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- mRNA Polarity and Ribosome Recognition
Host ribosomes recognize and translate directly, but they cannot translate .
Check whether the viral genome possesses positive sense (same polarity as mRNA) or negative sense (complementary to mRNA).
- Host Polymerase Limitations
Eukaryotic host cells lack an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) to transcribe RNA from an RNA template.
Remember that viruses must package pre-formed RdRp in their virion, whereas viruses synthesize RdRp de novo from their translatable genome.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that purified poliovirus possesses mRNA polarity and appropriate translation elements (e.g., an internal ribosome entry site, IRES).
Deduce that host cytoplasmic ribosomes immediately translate into viral polyproteins, generating viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp).
Recognize that newly synthesized RdRp copies into intermediates to amplify genomes and assemble complete infectious virions.
Conclude that Genome (A) alone is infectious, whereas Genome (B) is non-infectious because cannot be translated by host ribosomes and the host lacks RdRp.
Genome (A) is infectious; host ribosomes directly translate to synthesize viral RdRp, whereas host ribosomes cannot translate and host cells lack RdRp; functional proteins are translated from Genome (B).
Lock it in
Can eukaryotic host cell RNA polymerases transcribe viral RNA templates into mRNA?
No. Eukaryotic host RNA polymerases are strictly DNA-dependent; synthesizing RNA from an RNA template requires a viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp).
Similar question
A researcher transfects purified naked genomic RNA of Zika virus (Flaviviridae, positive-sense single-stranded RNA) into cultured human cells with no viral proteins added. Will this transfection result in productive viral replication? Explain why or why not.
Answer
Yes. Because Zika virus is a virus, its genomic RNA has mRNA polarity. Host cytoplasmic ribosomes immediately bind and translate the genome to produce viral proteins, including the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp), which then replicates the genome and leads to infectious progeny virions.
Influenza A virus possesses a segmented genome and replicates in the nucleus. If all 8 purified RNA segments are microinjected into the nucleus of a permissive host cell without any viral proteins, explain why replication fails to occur even though nuclear host RNA polymerase II is present.
Answer
Replication fails because host nuclear RNA polymerase II is a DNA-dependent RNA polymerase that cannot use RNA as a template. Because host cells lack an endogenous RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, the segments cannot be transcribed into viral mRNA or complementary templates without the pre-packaged viral RNA polymerase complex (PB1, PB2, PA).
Certain single-stranded RNA viruses are ambisense, meaning part of the RNA strand is sense and part is sense (e.g., Arenaviruses). Explain why naked purified ambisense genomic RNA remains non-infectious when microinjected into a cell, despite having a sense open reading frame.
Answer
Although an open reading frame is in the positive orientation, the gene encoding the viral RdRp is located in the negative orientation (or requires primary transcription before translation can occur in the ambisense genomic context). Because host cells lack an RdRp to transcribe the sense region and synthesize the essential replicase, the life cycle cannot proceed without virion-packaged RdRp.