Resources
A student monitors the infection kinetics of an enveloped retrovirus possessing a positive-sense single-stranded RNA genome. During replication, host cell enzymes and viral enzymes synthesize viral components. Identify the net change in cellular nucleic acid inventory that violates central dogma conventions if incorrectly labeled: A student writes down that during the eclipse phase, the viral titer decreases by and that the host cell directly transcribes the viral genome using host DNA-dependent RNA polymerase II without a DNA intermediate. If an initial intracellular inoculum contains infectious viral cores, determine the expected number of infectious extracellular virions present during the absolute eclipse phase, and state whether host RNA polymerase II can directly use viral as a template.
Answer and steps
Final answer
; No, host RNA polymerase II requires a double-stranded DNA template, not .
Steps
Understanding the Eclipse Phase in Viral Replication
In a one-step viral growth cycle:
- Attachment and Uncoating: Upon entry into the host cell, the viral envelope and capsid disassemble (uncoating), releasing the viral genome into the host cytoplasm or nucleus.
- Eclipse Phase: This phase is defined as the period between viral uncoating and the assembly of the first new mature, infectious virions. Because the virion structure is dismantled to allow replication and protein synthesis to proceed, no intact, infectious extracellular virions are present or released during this window.
Therefore, regardless of the initial inoculum of intracellular cores, the expected number of infectious extracellular virions during the absolute eclipse phase is .
Template Specificity of Host RNA Polymerase II
Retroviruses are positive-sense single-stranded RNA () viruses, but they replicate via an obligate DNA intermediate:
- Reverse Transcription: The virally encoded enzyme reverse transcriptase (an RNA-dependent DNA polymerase) converts the viral into double-stranded DNA ().
- Integration: The resulting viral is integrated into the host cell's nuclear genome as a provirus by viral integrase.
- Transcription: Host cell RNA polymerase II is a DNA-dependent RNA polymerase. Its active site and promoter-recognition machinery specifically require a double-stranded DNA template. It cannot bind or transcribe directly from single-stranded RNA.
Thus, host RNA polymerase II cannot directly use viral as a template; it requires a double-stranded DNA template produced by reverse transcription.
Common Pitfall
Do not confuse translation by host ribosomes with transcription by host RNA polymerases:
- While host ribosomes can directly translate certain viral genomes (as seen in picornaviruses), host RNA polymerases are strictly DNA-dependent and cannot synthesize RNA from an RNA template.
- Retroviruses do not rely on host transcription until their genome is reverse-transcribed into double-stranded proviral DNA.
Typical errors
01 The student misinterprets the eclipse phase as retaining the original intact inoculum particles rather than recognizing that uncoating and disassembly reduce infectious extracellular virion counts to zero.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Inoculum contains infectious viral cores During the eclipse phase, infectious virions
CorrectDuring the eclipse phase of a viral infection cycle, virions undergo uncoating and capsid disassembly to release their genomes. Because intact virions are dismantled and new progeny have not yet assembled, the number of infectious virions (both intracellular and extracellular) drops to .
- Step 2
No, host RNA polymerase II requires a DNA template, so reverse transcriptase must make cDNA first.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that host RNA polymerase II is strictly DNA-dependent and requires a double-stranded DNA intermediate produced by reverse transcription.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the initial inoculum cores as persisting intact particles rather than accounting for viral uncoating.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating the presence of viral nucleic acids inside a host cell with intact infectious virions, overlooking that virions must physically disassemble (uncoat) during the eclipse phase to allow replication to occur.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Eclipse Phase Definition
In a viral one-step growth curve, the eclipse phase spans from uncoating until the assembly of the first mature progeny virion; no intact, infectious virions exist during this interval.
Always set the count of infectious virions during the absolute eclipse phase to regardless of the initial inoculum size.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that infection begins with viral entry followed by uncoating.
During uncoating, viral envelopes and protein capsids disassemble, releasing bare viral and enzymes into the host cytoplasm.
Because infectious capacity requires an intact capsid and receptor-binding machinery, dismantled viral cores are no longer infectious particles.
Conclude that during the absolute eclipse phase, exactly infectious extracellular virions are detectable.
; No, host RNA polymerase II requires a double-stranded DNA template, not .
02 The student confuses retroviral replication with positive-sense ssRNA viral translation, incorrectly believing host RNA polymerase II can directly transcribe RNA templates.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
During eclipse phase, infectious extracellular virions = 0
- Step 2
Yes, because (+)ssRNA has the same sense as mRNA and can be directly transcribed by RNA polymerase II.
CorrectNo, host RNA polymerase II requires a double-stranded DNA template, not .
Host RNA polymerase II is a DNA-dependent RNA polymerase, meaning it can only bind and transcribe a DNA template. In retroviruses, the genome must first undergo reverse transcription into double-stranded DNA before host RNA polymerase II can transcribe it.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that no infectious virions exist extracellularly during the eclipse phase.
You recognized that shares the same polarity as host mRNA.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused translation by host ribosomes (which can directly use positive-sense single-stranded RNA) with transcription by host RNA polymerase II (which is strictly DNA-dependent and requires double-stranded DNA).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Enzyme template dependency
Host RNA polymerase II is a DNA-dependent RNA polymerase and cannot use an RNA molecule as a template.
Always check the enzyme's template specificity before proposing a nucleic acid synthesis step.
- Retroviral replication pathway
Retroviruses require viral reverse transcriptase to convert into dsDNA provirus prior to host-mediated transcription.
Include the intermediate reverse transcription step whenever analyzing retroviral transcription.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine whether host RNA polymerase II can use single-stranded RNA as a template.
Recall that host RNA polymerase II is DNA-dependent and strictly requires a double-stranded DNA template.
Identify that retroviruses must first convert their genome into double-stranded DNA via reverse transcriptase before host RNA polymerase II can transcribe it.
; No, host RNA polymerase II cannot directly use viral because it requires a double-stranded DNA template.
Lock it in
What defines the eclipse phase of a one-step viral growth curve, and how many infectious virions are detectable during this phase?
The eclipse phase is the period between viral uncoating and the intracellular assembly of the first new progeny virions; exactly infectious virions are detectable.
Similar question
A culture of bacterial cells is infected with bacteriophage T4 at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of phages per cell. Five minutes after injection, when all viral genomes have entered the cytoplasm and replication has initiated, the cells are artificially lysed and the lysate is assayed for infectious plaque-forming units (PFU). What is the expected PFU count per cell, and why?
Answer
. Key steps: (1) Phage T4 injects its DNA, leaving empty protein coats outside. (2) During this eclipse phase, no intact virions exist inside or outside the cell. (3) Lysing the cells at this stage releases disassembled components and naked DNA, which cannot form plaques.
An influenza A virus () infects an epithelial cell. Compare the template requirement of the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) with that of host cellular RNA polymerase II during the synthesis of viral messenger RNA.
Answer
Viral RdRp uses the viral as a direct template to synthesize . In contrast, host RNA polymerase II can only transcribe from double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) and cannot recognize or bind single-stranded RNA templates.
In a one-step growth experiment with a poliovirus (), researchers measure both intracellular viral RNA copies and extracellular infectious virions over time. At hour 2 (within the eclipse period), viral RNA copies are detected inside each cell, but no extracellular virions are found. Explain this apparent discrepancy.
Answer
During the eclipse phase, the viral genome is actively replicated and translated by host machinery, causing intracellular viral RNA copy numbers to increase. However, new capsid assembly and packaging have not yet completed, and host cell lysis has not occurred, meaning intact, infectious virions have been released into the extracellular medium.