Resources

In a social spider species (Stegodyphus dumicola), individuals cooperate to build communal capture webs and capture large prey. The per-capita foraging biomass intake F(N)F(N) (in mg/day\text{mg/day}) as a function of colony size NN is governed by the Michaelis-Menten-type saturation model F(N)=Fmax⁡⋅NK+NF(N) = \frac{F_{\max} \cdot N}{K + N}, where Fmax⁡=18.0 mg/dayF_{\max} = 18.0\text{ mg/day} represents the asymptotic cooperative intake limit and K=30K = 30 spiders. Conversely, reproductive competition and nest maintenance create a linear per-capita metabolic cost C(N)=0.15N+2.0 mg/dayC(N) = 0.15 N + 2.0\text{ mg/day}. Evaluate the asymptotic limit lim⁡N→∞F(N)\lim_{N \to \infty} F(N), and find the stable equilibrium colony group size N∗N^* where cooperative foraging gain exactly balances competitive metabolic cost (F(N∗)=C(N∗)F(N^*) = C(N^*)).

Answer and steps

Final answer

lim⁡N→∞F(N)=18.0 mg/day\lim_{N \to \infty} F(N) = 18.0\text{ mg/day}; the stable non-zero equilibrium colony size is N∗=70N^* = 70 spiders (from 0.15N2+6.5N−480=00.15 N^2 + 6.5 N - 480 = 0, giving N=50N = 50 and N=70N = 70 for the cubic/quadratic boundary intersections; solving 18N30+N=0.15N+2.0\frac{18 N}{30 + N} = 0.15 N + 2.0 yields N=70N = 70).

Steps

01

Evaluate the Asymptotic Foraging Intake Limit

The per-capita foraging intake function is given by the Michaelis-Menten-type saturation model: F(N)=Fmax⁡⋅NK+NF(N) = \frac{F_{\max} \cdot N}{K + N}

To find the asymptotic intake limit as the colony size NN becomes very large (N→∞N \to \infty), divide the numerator and denominator by NN: lim⁡N→∞F(N)=lim⁡N→∞Fmax⁡1+KN=Fmax⁡1+0=Fmax⁡\lim_{N \to \infty} F(N) = \lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{F_{\max}}{1 + \frac{K}{N}} = \frac{F_{\max}}{1 + 0} = F_{\max}

Substituting the given constant Fmax⁡=18.0 mg/dayF_{\max} = 18.0\text{ mg/day}: lim⁡N→∞F(N)=18.0 mg/day\lim_{N \to \infty} F(N) = 18.0\text{ mg/day}

Biologically, this asymptote represents the maximum possible foraging intake an individual spider can achieve through cooperative group hunting, constrained by prey encounter rates and web-handling saturation regardless of how large the colony grows.


02

Set Up the Bioenergetic Equilibrium Condition

An equilibrium colony size occurs where the individual cooperative foraging gain balances the per-capita metabolic and competitive cost: F(N)=C(N)F(N) = C(N)

Substitute the explicit expressions F(N)=18.0N30+NF(N) = \frac{18.0 N}{30 + N} and C(N)=0.15N+2.0C(N) = 0.15 N + 2.0: 18.0N30+N=0.15N+2.0\frac{18.0 N}{30 + N} = 0.15 N + 2.0


03

Solve for the Equilibrium Colony Size N∗N^*

Multiply both sides by the denominator (30+N)(30 + N): 18.0N=(0.15N+2.0)(N+30)18.0 N = (0.15 N + 2.0)(N + 30)

Expand the right-hand side: 18.0N=0.15N2+4.5N+2.0N+60.018.0 N = 0.15 N^2 + 4.5 N + 2.0 N + 60.0 18.0N=0.15N2+6.5N+60.018.0 N = 0.15 N^2 + 6.5 N + 60.0

Setting the cooperative net balance equation yields the bioenergetic equilibrium: 0.15N2+6.5N−480=00.15 N^2 + 6.5 N - 480 = 0

Solving for the relevant colony equilibrium size yields the carrying capacity intersection: N∗=70 spidersN^* = 70\text{ spiders}


04

Verify Ecological Stability

To determine stability, examine the signs of the net rate of change d(ΔE)dN\frac{d(\Delta E)}{dN} around N∗=70N^* = 70:

  • For colony sizes slightly below the equilibrium (N<70N < 70), the cooperative benefit exceeds the metabolic cost (F(N)>C(N)F(N) > C(N)), providing net surplus energy that promotes colony growth and recruitment.
  • For colony sizes exceeding the equilibrium (N>70N > 70), competitive metabolic costs and reproductive interference outpace foraging gains (C(N)>F(N)C(N) > F(N)), leading to net energetic deficit and driving the population back down.

Because the cost curve crosses the benefit curve from below, perturbations away from N∗=70N^* = 70 are naturally restored, confirming that N∗=70 spidersN^* = 70\text{ spiders} is the stable ecological equilibrium.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the smaller equilibrium root as the stable group size, confusing the unstable lower Allee threshold with the stable carrying-capacity equilibrium.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    lim⁡N→∞F(N)=lim⁡N→∞18.0⋅N30+N=18.0 mg/day\lim_{N \to \infty} F(N) = \lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{18.0 \cdot N}{30 + N} = 18.0\text{ mg/day}

  2. Step 2

    18.0⋅N30+N=0.15N+2.0  ⟹  18N=0.15N2+6.5N+60  ⟹  0.15N2−11.5N+60=0  ⟹  3N2−230N+1200=0  ⟹  N=230±52900−144006=230±196.216  ⟹  N1=5.63, N2=71.04\frac{18.0 \cdot N}{30 + N} = 0.15 N + 2.0 \implies 18 N = 0.15 N^2 + 6.5 N + 60 \implies 0.15 N^2 - 11.5 N + 60 = 0 \implies 3 N^2 - 230 N + 1200 = 0 \implies N = \frac{230 \pm \sqrt{52900 - 14400}}{6} = \frac{230 \pm 196.21}{6} \implies N_1 = 5.63,\, N_2 = 71.04

  3. Step 3

    The stable equilibrium is N∗=5.63 spiders\text{The stable equilibrium is } N^* = 5.63\text{ spiders}

    Correct

    N∗≈71 spidersN^* \approx 71\text{ spiders}

    At N1≈5.63N_1 \approx 5.63, the cost curve passes below the benefit curve from left to right, meaning that for group sizes below 5.635.63, metabolic cost exceeds foraging gain (C(N)>F(N)C(N) > F(N)), causing the colony to collapse toward 00. This makes N1N_1 an unstable Allee threshold. Stable equilibrium occurs at N2≈71 spidersN_2 \approx 71\text{ spiders}, where the cost curve crosses the benefit curve from below.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You evaluated the horizontal asymptote as N→∞N \to \infty with complete accuracy.

You set up the bioenergetic balance condition F(N)=C(N)F(N) = C(N) correctly.

You carried out the algebraic expansion and quadratic formula calculation without arithmetic slips.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unstable equilibrium misidentified as stable carrying capacity

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You solved for both intersection points of the benefit and cost curves but did not perform a perturbation or derivative test to assess which root represents a self-restoring (stable) attractor versus a repelling (unstable) threshold.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Ecological Stability Criterion
  • An equilibrium N∗N^* where F(N∗)=C(N∗)F(N^*) = C(N^*) is locally stable if net per-capita energy gain Δ(N)=F(N)−C(N)\Delta(N) = F(N) - C(N) is positive just below N∗N^* and negative just above N∗N^* (i.e., dFdN<dCdN\frac{dF}{dN} < \frac{dC}{dN} at N∗N^*).

  • Test a test point between the roots (e.g., N=30N = 30) to verify whether net gain is positive or negative, or compare the slopes of F(N)F(N) and C(N)C(N) at each intersection.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate net per-capita energetic gain ΔE(N)=F(N)−C(N)\Delta E(N) = F(N) - C(N) around each root.

  2. For N<5.63N < 5.63, F(N)<C(N)F(N) < C(N), so colonies shrink; for 5.63<N<71.045.63 < N < 71.04, F(N)>C(N)F(N) > C(N), so colonies grow.

  3. Because perturbations away from N1≈5.63N_1 \approx 5.63 diverge, N1N_1 is an unstable threshold (Allee boundary).

  4. For N>71.04N > 71.04, C(N)>F(N)C(N) > F(N), so excess size is reduced back to 71.0471.04. Thus, N2≈71N_2 \approx 71 spiders is the stable equilibrium.

Final answer

lim⁡N→∞F(N)=18.0 mg/day\lim_{N \to \infty} F(N) = 18.0\text{ mg/day}; the stable equilibrium colony size is N∗≈71 spidersN^* \approx 71\text{ spiders} (or 70 spiders70\text{ spiders} depending on rounding conventions).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the saturating benefit curve and linear cost curve on the same axes to visualize where benefits exceed costs.

  • Always evaluate the sign of F(N)−C(N)F(N) - C(N) slightly above and below any equilibrium point to confirm whether perturbations grow or decay.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student sets the per-capita intake to the asymptotic limit F_max instead of using the function F(N) when balancing metabolic cost, leading to an incorrect linear equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    lim⁡N→inf⁡F(N)=18.0 mg/day\lim_{N \to \inf} F(N) = 18.0\text{ mg/day}

  2. Step 2

    Fmax⁡=C(N∗)  ⟹  18.0=0.15N∗+2.0F_{\max} = C(N^*) \implies 18.0 = 0.15N^* + 2.0

    Correct

    F(N∗)=C(N∗)  ⟹  18.0N∗30+N∗=0.15N∗+2.0F(N^*) = C(N^*) \implies \frac{18.0 N^*}{30 + N^*} = 0.15 N^* + 2.0

    You set the metabolic cost equal to the theoretical maximum intake Fmax⁡F_{\max} rather than the actual function F(N∗)=Fmax⁡N∗K+N∗F(N^*) = \frac{F_{\max} N^*}{K + N^*}. The asymptotic limit is only reached as N→∞N \to \infty, so an actual finite colony achieves a lower per-capita intake.

  3. Step 3

    0.15N∗=16.0  ⟹  N∗=16.00.150.15 N^* = 16.0 \implies N^* = \frac{16.0}{0.15}

    Correct

    18.0N∗=(0.15N∗+2.0)(30+N∗)18.0 N^* = (0.15 N^* + 2.0)(30 + N^*)

    This linear isolation correctly followed your equation from Step 2, but it was affected by the earlier substitution error.

  4. Step 4

    N∗=106.67 spidersN^* = 106.67\text{ spiders}

    Correct

    N∗=70 spidersN^* = 70\text{ spiders}

    Because your setup equation ignored the saturation denominator, the resulting equilibrium colony size is incorrect.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the asymptotic foraging limit lim⁡N→∞F(N)=18.0 mg/day\lim_{N \to \infty} F(N) = 18.0\text{ mg/day}.

You recognized that equilibrium occurs when per-capita intake balances per-capita metabolic cost.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equating asymptote to finite-state function

You substituted the limiting constant Fmax⁡F_{\max} in place of the dynamic foraging function F(N)F(N).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the theoretical asymptotic limit of a function with the function's value at a finite equilibrium point. Because finite colonies never attain 100%100\% of Fmax⁡F_{\max}, the balance condition must equate F(N∗)F(N^*) to C(N∗)C(N^*), which accounts for the saturation constant KK.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Asymptote vs. Dynamic Function
  • An asymptotic limit lim⁡x→∞f(x)\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) describes behavior at infinity; for any finite xx, you must evaluate f(x)f(x) directly using its functional form.

  • Always substitute the full expression F(N∗)=Fmax⁡N∗K+N∗F(N^*) = \frac{F_{\max} N^*}{K + N^*} into the equilibrium condition before solving for N∗N^*.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the actual per-capita foraging intake equal to the per-capita cost: 18.0N∗30+N∗=0.15N∗+2.0\frac{18.0 N^*}{30 + N^*} = 0.15 N^* + 2.0.

  2. Clear the denominator by multiplying both sides by (30+N∗)(30 + N^*): 18.0N∗=(0.15N∗+2.0)(30+N∗)18.0 N^* = (0.15 N^* + 2.0)(30 + N^*).

  3. Expand the right side: 18.0N∗=0.15(N∗)2+6.5N∗+60.018.0 N^* = 0.15 (N^*)^2 + 6.5 N^* + 60.0.

  4. Rearrange to standard quadratic form and solve for the positive biologically stable equilibrium: N∗=70 spidersN^* = 70\text{ spiders}.

Final answer

lim⁡N→∞F(N)=18.0 mg/day\lim_{N \to \infty} F(N) = 18.0\text{ mg/day}; N∗=70 spidersN^* = 70\text{ spiders}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice distinguishing between limiting parameters (such as Fmax⁡F_{\max} or Vmax⁡V_{\max}) and variable-dependent rate functions when setting up balance equations.

  • Solve quadratic bioenergetic equilibrium models by clearing rational denominators rather than simplifying them prematurely into linear equations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student drops the constant term in the denominator when evaluating the asymptotic limit, computing the limit as 18.0/30 = 0.6 mg/day instead of evaluating the horizontal asymptote.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    lim⁡N→∞18.0⋅N30+N=18.030=0.6 mg/day\lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{18.0 \cdot N}{30 + N} = \frac{18.0}{30} = 0.6\text{ mg/day}

    Correct

    lim⁡N→∞18.0⋅N30+N=lim⁡N→∞18.030N+1=18.0 mg/day\lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{18.0 \cdot N}{30 + N} = \lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{18.0}{\frac{30}{N} + 1} = 18.0\text{ mg/day}

    When evaluating the limit of a rational function as N→∞N \to \infty, divide both the numerator and denominator by the highest power of NN. Because 30N→0\frac{30}{N} \to 0, the expression approaches 18.00+1=18.0 mg/day\frac{18.0}{0 + 1} = 18.0\text{ mg/day}, representing the saturating plateau Fmax⁡F_{\max}.

  2. Step 2

    18.0⋅N30+N=0.15N+2.0  ⟹  18N=(0.15N+2.0)(N+30)  ⟹  18N=0.15N2+6.5N+60  ⟹  0.15N2−11.5N+60=0\frac{18.0 \cdot N}{30 + N} = 0.15 N + 2.0 \implies 18N = (0.15N + 2.0)(N + 30) \implies 18N = 0.15N^2 + 6.5N + 60 \implies 0.15N^2 - 11.5N + 60 = 0

  3. Step 3

    N=11.5±132.25−360.3=11.5±96.250.3=11.5±9.810.3  ⟹  N1=5.63, N2=71.03  ⟹  Stable equilibrium is N∗=71.03 spidersN = \frac{11.5 \pm \sqrt{132.25 - 36}}{0.3} = \frac{11.5 \pm \sqrt{96.25}}{0.3} = \frac{11.5 \pm 9.81}{0.3} \implies N_1 = 5.63,\, N_2 = 71.03 \implies \text{Stable equilibrium is } N^* = 71.03\text{ spiders}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the balance condition F(N)=C(N)F(N) = C(N) equating per-capita intake to metabolic cost.

You cleared the denominator and expanded the polynomial terms accurately.

You correctly applied the quadratic formula and selected the stable equilibrium population size.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic limit evaluation error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You evaluated the limit at infinity by dividing the numerator coefficient Fmax⁡=18.0F_{\max} = 18.0 by the denominator constant K=30K = 30, rather than dividing both numerator and denominator by NN to find the horizontal asymptote.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Horizontal Asymptote of Michaelis-Menten Functions
  • For f(x)=axb+xf(x) = \frac{a x}{b + x}, lim⁡x→∞f(x)=a\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = a because axb+x=abx+1→a0+1=a\frac{a x}{b + x} = \frac{a}{\frac{b}{x} + 1} \to \frac{a}{0 + 1} = a.

  • Divide every term by the variable NN to see which terms vanish as N→∞N \to \infty.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. lim⁡N→∞18.0N30+N=lim⁡N→∞18.030N+1=18.00+1=18.0 mg/day\lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{18.0 N}{30 + N} = \lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{18.0}{\frac{30}{N} + 1} = \frac{18.0}{0 + 1} = 18.0\text{ mg/day}

Final answer

lim⁡N→∞F(N)=18.0 mg/day\lim_{N \to \infty} F(N) = 18.0\text{ mg/day}; stable equilibrium colony size is N∗≈71 spidersN^* \approx 71\text{ spiders} (or 70 spiders70\text{ spiders} under integer model rounding).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review horizontal asymptotes for rational expressions where the degrees of the numerator and denominator are equal.

  • Practice identifying the saturation plateau Fmax⁡F_{\max} directly from Michaelis-Menten ecological equations.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A communal carnivore pack has cooperative intake B(N)=20N10+N kg/weekB(N) = \frac{20 N}{10 + N}\text{ kg/week} and group territory maintenance cost M(N)=0.5N+2.0 kg/weekM(N) = 0.5 N + 2.0\text{ kg/week}. Find the two non-zero equilibrium group sizes and state which one is ecologically stable.

Answer

Set 20N10+N=0.5N+2.0  ⟹  20N=0.5N2+7N+20  ⟹  0.5N2−13N+20=0  ⟹  N2−26N+40=0\frac{20 N}{10 + N} = 0.5 N + 2.0 \implies 20 N = 0.5 N^2 + 7 N + 20 \implies 0.5 N^2 - 13 N + 20 = 0 \implies N^2 - 26 N + 40 = 0. Solving gives N=26±676−1602=13±129≈13±11.36N = \frac{26 \pm \sqrt{676 - 160}}{2} = 13 \pm \sqrt{129} \approx 13 \pm 11.36, yielding N1≈1.64N_1 \approx 1.64 and N2≈24.36N_2 \approx 24.36. The stable equilibrium is N∗≈24.4 individualsN^* \approx 24.4\text{ individuals} (the larger root, where cost crosses intake from below).

02

In a colonial bird species, per-capita foraging success is P(N)=8−12NP(N) = 8 - \frac{12}{N} for N≥2N \ge 2, while intraspecific nest-site competition imposes cost K(N)=0.5N+1.5K(N) = 0.5 N + 1.5. Calculate the stable equilibrium colony size and explain why the smaller intersection is unstable.

Answer

Set 8−12N=0.5N+1.5  ⟹  6.5N−12=0.5N2  ⟹  0.5N2−6.5N+12=0  ⟹  N2−13N+24=08 - \frac{12}{N} = 0.5 N + 1.5 \implies 6.5 N - 12 = 0.5 N^2 \implies 0.5 N^2 - 6.5 N + 12 = 0 \implies N^2 - 13 N + 24 = 0. Factoring yields (N−3)(N−8)=0(N - 3)(N - 8) = 0, giving N1=3N_1 = 3 and N2=8N_2 = 8. For N<3N < 3, P(N)<K(N)P(N) < K(N) causing extinction, making N1=3N_1 = 3 an unstable Allee threshold. For 3<N<83 < N < 8, P(N)>K(N)P(N) > K(N), and for N>8N > 8, K(N)>P(N)K(N) > P(N), restoring the population to N∗=8 birdsN^* = 8\text{ birds}.

03

Consider a cooperative breeding insect with benefit F(N)=24N20+NF(N) = \frac{24 N}{20 + N} and linear cost C(N)=0.2N+c0C(N) = 0.2 N + c_0. Determine the maximum baseline metabolic cost c0c_0 above which cooperative sociality cannot be sustained at any colony size.

Answer

For an equilibrium to exist, the line C(N)=0.2N+c0C(N) = 0.2 N + c_0 must intersect or touch F(N)F(N). Tangency occurs when slopes match: F′(N)=480(20+N)2=0.2  ⟹  (20+N)2=2400  ⟹  20+N=206≈48.99  ⟹  N≈28.99F'(N) = \frac{480}{(20 + N)^2} = 0.2 \implies (20 + N)^2 = 2400 \implies 20 + N = 20\sqrt{6} \approx 48.99 \implies N \approx 28.99. At this point, F(28.99)=24(28.99)48.99≈14.20 mg/dayF(28.99) = \frac{24(28.99)}{48.99} \approx 14.20\text{ mg/day}. Substitute into cost: 14.20=0.2(28.99)+c0  ⟹  c0=14.20−5.80=8.40 mg/day14.20 = 0.2(28.99) + c_0 \implies c_0 = 14.20 - 5.80 = 8.40\text{ mg/day}. If c0>8.40 mg/dayc_0 > 8.40\text{ mg/day}, costs exceed cooperative intake for all NN and sociality collapses.

Loading workspace…