Resources
In tomato plants, red fruit () is dominant over yellow fruit (), and tall vines () are dominant over dwarf vines (). A geneticist crosses a homozygous red, dwarf plant () with a yellow, heterozygous tall plant (). Among the resulting progeny, instead of determining phenotype frequencies, calculate: (a) the exact phenotypic ratio of red-fruited tall plants to red-fruited dwarf plants, and (b) the conditional probability that an plant has the genotype , given that it displays the red-fruited and tall phenotype.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) , (b)
Steps
Identify Parental Genotypes and Gametes
The problem defines two traits with complete dominance:
- Fruit color: Red () is dominant over yellow ().
- Plant height: Tall () is dominant over dwarf ().
The parents in this cross are:
- Parent 1 (homozygous red, dwarf):
- Parent 2 (yellow, heterozygous tall):
Next, determine the gametes each parent can produce via meiosis:
- Parent 1 (): Can only produce gametes carrying alleles and , so of its gametes are .
- Parent 2 (): Carries alleles for color, and or for height in equal proportions. It produces two types of gametes:
Determine the Progeny Genotypes and Phenotypes
Combine the gametes to find the offspring in the generation:
-
- Phenotype: Red fruit () and tall vines ().
- Proportion: ()
-
- Phenotype: Red fruit () and dwarf vines ().
- Proportion: ()
Calculate the Phenotypic Ratio (Part a)
Comparing the frequencies of the two observed phenotypes:
Calculate the Conditional Probability (Part b)
We are asked for the conditional probability:
By definition of conditional probability:
- For an offspring to have genotype , it must receive an allele from both parents.
- However, Parent 1 has the genotype and carries only the recessive allele for height; it cannot contribute a allele.
- Therefore, the probability of producing the genotype in this cross is .
- All red and tall progeny strictly have the heterozygous genotype .
Common Pitfall: Do not confuse phenotypic appearance with homozygous dominance. While an individual displaying the dominant trait could theoretically be or , you must check whether both dominant alleles are available from the parental genotypes.
Typical errors
01 The student misapplies standard dihybrid F2 cross expectations to an F1 test-like cross, assuming that 1/3 of dominant-phenotype individuals are homozygous dominant.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Parent cross: Progeny: (red tall) and (red dwarf) Ratio of red tall to red dwarf
- Step 2
Red tall plants have dominant alleles at both loci For a dominant phenotype, are homozygous and are heterozygous
CorrectThe rule that of individuals with a dominant phenotype are homozygous applies specifically to an self-cross of heterozygotes (). In this cross, the homozygous dwarf parent () only donates a recessive allele , making it impossible for any offspring to inherit two alleles.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the parental cross as .
You correctly determined that the progeny consist of and .
You correctly calculated the phenotypic ratio of red tall to red dwarf as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed that any dominant phenotype has a probability of being homozygous dominant, which only holds for an monohybrid cross ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou applied a memorized ratio from an monohybrid cross without checking whether the parental cross could supply two dominant alleles at the height locus. Because parent can only pass on , the genotype cannot form.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Parental Gamete Check
An offspring genotype can only contain alleles that both parents are capable of donating.
Check each parent's genotype to verify whether the alleles required for the target genotype are present before calculating probabilities.
- Conditional Probability in Crosses
.
Use the actual offspring distribution from your Punnett square or gamete combinations rather than memorized textbook ratios.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFrom your progeny list in Step 1, all red and tall offspring have the genotype .
Parent 1 () produces only gametes, meaning every offspring inherits allele at the vine-length locus.
Because no offspring can receive a second allele, the probability of obtaining is .
Compute the conditional probability: .
(a) , (b)
02 The student calculates the unconditional joint probability of having red fruit and genotype RrTT rather than conditioning on the red-tall phenotype, though incorrectly assigning a probability to an impossible genotype.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
produces gametes; produces and gametes.
- Step 2
genotypes: (red, tall), (red, dwarf) Ratio of red tall to red dwarf is
- Step 3
Possible genotypes with red fruit and tall vines are . Neither parent has a genotype to produce offspring.
CorrectYou correctly reasoned that is impossible because Parent 1 () can only contribute a allele. However, when evaluating the conditional probability , the denominator must represent the conditioning event (the red and tall plants, which account for of the progeny or out of the outcomes), rather than the total sample space of . Additionally, the final probability must be simplified to .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly determined the types and frequencies of gametes produced by both parents.
You found the correct offspring genotypes and phenotypes.
You calculated the exact phenotypic ratio of for part (a).
You deduced that the genotype is impossible because Parent 1 carries only recessive alleles.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the reduced sample space of a conditional probability with the total sample space of the cross. For , the denominator must be restricted to the given condition (red and tall plants, ), not the total number of all possible outcomes.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Restrict the Denominator to the Given Condition
In genetic conditional probability , the denominator must be the total probability (or count) of offspring displaying that specified phenotype, not the entire generation.
Identify the conditioning phenotype first, sum all genotypes that produce that phenotype to form your denominator, and place the specific target genotype in the numerator.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSince Parent 1 () cannot pass on a allele,
Apply the conditional probability formula:
(a) , (b)
03 The student confuses the requested phenotypic ratio of red-tall to red-dwarf plants with a classic Mendelian 9:3:3:1 or 3:1 ratio, incorrectly writing 3:1.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
gives all (red).
- Step 2
gives tall and dwarf.
Correct(tall) and (dwarf)
You applied the phenotypic ratio of a monohybrid cross () to a testcross (). Crossing with yields gametes or from the first parent and only from the second parent, producing equal proportions of and (rac{1}{2} tall and rac{1}{2} dwarf).
- Step 3
Ratio of red tall to red dwarf
CorrectRatio of red tall to red dwarf
Because of the previous error in the height cross, the ratio of red tall to red dwarf was calculated as instead of .
- Step 4
Parent only passes ; parent passes or . No individual can receive two alleles to form .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly broke down the dihybrid cross into independent monohybrid crosses.
You deduced that Parent 1 cannot pass a dominant allele, leading to the correct conditional probability of in part (b).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted the familiar Mendelian ratio from a self-cross into a backcross/testcross.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the expected phenotypic frequencies of a heterozygous-by-heterozygous cross () with those of a heterozygous-by-homozygous recessive cross ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Cross Type Identification
A cross of yields a phenotypic ratio, whereas a cross of yields a phenotypic ratio.
Before writing down phenotypic fractions, check the genotypes of both parents to confirm whether the cross is or a testcross .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the Punnett square for the height cross : gametes from are and ; gametes from are all .
Combine gametes to obtain genotypes: (tall) and (dwarf).
Combine with color (): red tall () = , red dwarf () = .
Compare the counts: .
(a) , (b)
Lock it in
When does a dominant phenotype have a chance of being homozygous dominant?
Only in the offspring of two heterozygotes (). If either parent lacks the dominant allele, that ratio does not apply.
Similar question
In pea plants, purple flowers () are dominant over white flowers (). A heterozygous purple plant () is test-crossed with a white-flowered plant (). What is the conditional probability that a purple-flowered offspring is homozygous ()?
Answer
. In the cross , the white parent only contributes , so all purple progeny are . Thus, .
In guinea pigs, black coat () is dominant to white coat (), and short hair () is dominant to long hair (). A cross between and yields black, short-haired offspring. What is the conditional probability that a black, short-haired pup has the genotype ?
Answer
. For the color locus (), all black pups are (probability ). For the hair locus (), short-haired pups have genotypes and in a ratio, so . Thus, .
In fruit flies, gray body () is dominant over black body (), and red eyes () are dominant over brown eyes (). A male with genotype is mated with a female with genotype . What is the conditional probability that an offspring displaying the dominant gray-body, red-eyed phenotype has the homozygous genotype ?
Answer
. For body color (), gray offspring are () or (), so . For eye color (), red-eyed offspring are with probability (). Multiplying the independent loci gives .