Resources

A student investigating cellular thermodynamics evaluates the standard Gibbs free energy change of glucose oxidation: C6H12O6+6O2→6CO2+6H2O\text{C}_6\text{H}_{12}\text{O}_6 + 6\text{O}_2 \rightarrow 6\text{CO}_2 + 6\text{H}_2\text{O}, where ΔG∘=−2870 kJ/mol\Delta G^\circ = -2870\text{ kJ/mol}. The student asserts: 'Because living systems must maintain high internal organization and decrease internal entropy (ΔSorganism<0\Delta S_{\text{organism}} < 0), the overall process violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics (ΔSuniverse<0\Delta S_{\text{universe}} < 0).' Using the thermodynamic relationship ΔSuniverse=ΔSsystem+ΔSsurroundings\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{system}} + \Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} and heat dissipation qp=−ΔHq_p = -\Delta H, identify the thermodynamic error in the student's assertion and calculate the entropy change of the surroundings (ΔSsurroundings\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}}) at T=310.0 KT = 310.0\text{ K} given an enthalpy release of ΔH=−2805 kJ/mol\Delta H = -2805\text{ kJ/mol}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

ΔSsurroundings=+9.05×103 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = +9.05\times 10^3\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) (or +9.05 kJ/(mol⋅K)+9.05\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})). Living systems are open systems; the negative internal entropy is offset by a much larger positive entropy increase in the surroundings through metabolic heat dissipation, so ΔSuniverse>0\Delta S_{\text{universe}} > 0.

Steps

01

Identify the Thermodynamic Error

The student's assertion fails to recognize that a living organism is an open system, not an isolated system:

  • The Second Law of Thermodynamics applies to isolated systems or the universe as a whole, stating that spontaneous processes always lead to an increase in total entropy: ΔSuniverse=ΔSsystem+ΔSsurroundings>0\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{system}} + \Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} > 0
  • While an organism may maintain low internal entropy (ΔSorganism<0\Delta S_{\text{organism}} < 0) by sustaining highly ordered structures and metabolic processes, it continuously exchanges energy and matter with its environment.
  • The local decrease in entropy within the organism is more than compensated for by the release of thermal energy (heat) into the surroundings, resulting in a large positive ΔSsurroundings\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} such that the net change ΔSuniverse\Delta S_{\text{universe}} remains positive. Therefore, the process does not violate the Second Law.

02

Calculate the Entropy Change of the Surroundings (ΔSsurroundings\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}})

At constant temperature (TT) and pressure, the heat transferred to the surroundings (qsurroundingsq_{\text{surroundings}}) is equal and opposite to the enthalpy change of the reaction system: qsurroundings=−ΔHq_{\text{surroundings}} = -\Delta H

The entropy change of the surroundings is defined as: ΔSsurroundings=qsurroundingsT=−ΔHT\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{q_{\text{surroundings}}}{T} = \frac{-\Delta H}{T}

Substitute the given values:

  • ΔH=−2805 kJ/mol=−2.805×106 J/mol\Delta H = -2805\text{ kJ/mol} = -2.805 \times 10^6\text{ J/mol}
  • T=310.0 KT = 310.0\text{ K}

ΔSsurroundings=−(−2805 kJ/mol)310.0 K=+2805 kJ/mol310.0 K≈+9.05 kJ/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-(-2805\text{ kJ/mol})}{310.0\text{ K}} = \frac{+2805\text{ kJ/mol}}{310.0\text{ K}} \approx +9.05\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})

Expressed in standard base units: ΔSsurroundings=+9.05×103 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = +9.05 \times 10^3\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})


03

Conclusion

Because the surroundings gain +9.05 kJ/(mol⋅K)+9.05\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) of entropy via heat dissipation, this substantial positive increase readily offsets any small decrease in internal entropy (ΔSsystem<0\Delta S_{\text{system}} < 0), ensuring that: ΔSuniverse=ΔSsystem+ΔSsurroundings>0\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{system}} + \Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} > 0 Thus, life maintains order strictly in full compliance with the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats the surroundings' entropy change with the wrong sign by omitting the negative sign in ΔS_surroundings = -ΔH / T.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    The student forgets that heat is transferred to the surroundings, so ΔSsurroundings\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} must be positive and greater in magnitude than any internal entropy decrease, keeping ΔSuniverse>0\Delta S_{\text{universe}} > 0.

  2. Step 2

    ΔSsurroundings=ΔHT  ⟹  ΔSsurroundings=−2805000 J/mol310.0 K=−9048.4 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{\Delta H}{T} \implies \Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-2805000\text{ J/mol}}{310.0\text{ K}} = -9048.4\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})

    Correct

    ΔSsurroundings=−ΔHT=−(−2.805×106 J/mol)310.0 K=+9.05×103 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-\Delta H}{T} = \frac{-(-2.805 \times 10^6\text{ J/mol})}{310.0\text{ K}} = +9.05 \times 10^3\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})

    At constant temperature and pressure, the heat absorbed by the surroundings is qsurroundings=−ΔHq_{\text{surroundings}} = -\Delta H. Therefore, the entropy change is ΔSsurroundings=−ΔHT\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-\Delta H}{T}. Because the reaction is exothermic (ΔH<0\Delta H < 0), the surroundings gain heat and must have a positive entropy change.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that living systems dissipate metabolic heat into their surroundings.

You clearly stated that ΔSsurroundings\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} must be positive to ensure that ΔSuniverse>0\Delta S_{\text{universe}} > 0.

You converted the enthalpy value from kilojoules to joules correctly before carrying out the division.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign Error in Surrounding Entropy Formula

Omitting the negative sign in ΔSsurroundings=−ΔHT\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-\Delta H}{T}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the heat lost by the system (ΔH\Delta H) with the heat gained by the surroundings (qsurroundings=−ΔHq_{\text{surroundings}} = -\Delta H), leading to using ΔHT\frac{\Delta H}{T} instead of −ΔHT\frac{-\Delta H}{T}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Heat Flow Sign Convention
  • For a process at constant pressure, heat exchanged with surroundings is opposite in sign to system enthalpy: qsurroundings=−ΔHsystemq_{\text{surroundings}} = -\Delta H_{\text{system}}.

  • Always verify whether heat is entering or leaving the surroundings before setting up the quotient.

Sign Check for Exothermic Reactions
  • An exothermic reaction (ΔH<0\Delta H < 0) releases thermal energy to the surroundings, which must increase thermal disorder in the surroundings: ΔSsurroundings>0\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} > 0.

  • Compare your computed mathematical sign against your conceptual prediction; here, your explanation stated ΔSsurroundings\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} must be positive, which directly contradicts a negative numerical answer.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the relationship between heat gained by the surroundings and system enthalpy change: qsurroundings=−ΔHq_{\text{surroundings}} = -\Delta H.

  2. Write the formula for the entropy change of the surroundings: ΔSsurroundings=−ΔHT\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-\Delta H}{T}.

  3. Substitute ΔH=−2.805×106 J/mol\Delta H = -2.805 \times 10^6\text{ J/mol} and T=310.0 KT = 310.0\text{ K}: ΔSsurroundings=−(−2.805×106 J/mol)310.0 K\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-(-2.805 \times 10^6\text{ J/mol})}{310.0\text{ K}}.

  4. Divide to obtain the final value: ΔSsurroundings=+9.05×103 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = +9.05 \times 10^3\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) (or +9.05 kJ/(mol⋅K)+9.05\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})).

Final answer

ΔSsurroundings=+9.05×103 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = +9.05 \times 10^3\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out qsurroundings=−ΔHq_{\text{surroundings}} = -\Delta H explicitly before writing ΔSsurroundings=qsurroundingsT\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{q_{\text{surroundings}}}{T}.

  • Perform a quick physical sanity check: exothermic reactions always heat the surroundings, raising surrounding entropy.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses the standard Gibbs free energy change ΔG° instead of the enthalpy change ΔH to calculate the entropy change of the surroundings.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    The student overlooks that entropy decrease inside an organism is compensated by a large entropy increase in the surroundings due to metabolic heat release, so ΔSuniverse\Delta S_{\text{universe}} remains positive.

  2. Step 2

    ΔSsurroundings=−ΔGT\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-\Delta G}{T}

    Correct

    ΔSsurroundings=qsurroundingsT=−ΔHT\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{q_{\text{surroundings}}}{T} = \frac{-\Delta H}{T}

    Entropy change of the surroundings is determined by the reversible heat transferred across the system boundary at constant pressure (qsurroundings=−ΔHq_{\text{surroundings}} = -\Delta H), not by the Gibbs free energy change (ΔG\Delta G).

  3. Step 3

    ΔSsurroundings=−−2870000 J/mol310.0 K=+9258.1 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = -\frac{-2870000\text{ J/mol}}{310.0\text{ K}} = +9258.1\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})

    Correct

    ΔSsurroundings=−−2805×103 J/mol310.0 K≈+9.05×103 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = -\frac{-2805\times 10^3\text{ J/mol}}{310.0\text{ K}} \approx +9.05\times 10^3\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})

    Your arithmetic was carried out accurately according to the formula you wrote, but substituting ΔG∘=−2870 kJ/mol\Delta G^\circ = -2870\text{ kJ/mol} instead of ΔH=−2805 kJ/mol\Delta H = -2805\text{ kJ/mol} led to an incorrect numerical value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly explained the open-system nature of living organisms and why local order does not violate the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

You correctly converted kilojoules to joules when setting up your numerical calculation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula confusion between Gibbs free energy and enthalpy

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the driving force for a reaction with heat exchange, confusing ΔG\Delta G (which accounts for the total non-expansion work potential of the system and universe) with qp=−ΔHq_p = -\Delta H (which directly measures the heat transferred to the thermal surroundings).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Surroundings Entropy Definition
  • At constant temperature and pressure, ΔSsurroundings=qsurroundingsT=−ΔHsystemT\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{q_{\text{surroundings}}}{T} = \frac{-\Delta H_{\text{system}}}{T}.

  • Always identify heat transfer (qp=−ΔHq_p = -\Delta H) when computing surroundings entropy, reserving ΔG=ΔH−TΔS\Delta G = \Delta H - T\Delta S for system spontaneity.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the definition of surroundings entropy change at constant temperature and pressure: ΔSsurroundings=−ΔHT\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-\Delta H}{T}.

  2. Substitute the given enthalpy value ΔH=−2805 kJ/mol=−2.805×106 J/mol\Delta H = -2805\text{ kJ/mol} = -2.805\times 10^6\text{ J/mol} and temperature T=310.0 KT = 310.0\text{ K}: ΔSsurroundings=−(−2805×103 J/mol)310.0 K\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-(-2805\times 10^3\text{ J/mol})}{310.0\text{ K}}.

  3. Evaluate the quotient: ΔSsurroundings≈+9.05×103 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} \approx +9.05\times 10^3\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) (or +9.05 kJ/(mol⋅K)+9.05\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})).

Final answer

ΔSsurroundings=+9.05×103 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = +9.05\times 10^3\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between system free energy change (ΔG\Delta G) and surroundings heat flow (−ΔH-\Delta H).

  • Practice deriving ΔGsystem=−TΔSuniverse\Delta G_{\text{system}} = -T\Delta S_{\text{universe}} from ΔSuniverse=ΔSsystem+−ΔHT\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{system}} + \frac{-\Delta H}{T} to see why −ΔH-\Delta H, not −ΔG-\Delta G, defines the surroundings term.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to convert kilojoules to joules when calculating entropy, reporting ΔS_surroundings in J/(mol·K) off by a factor of 1000.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Living organisms do not violate the Second Law because they export entropy into the environment via heat dissipation, ensuring ΔSuniverse>0\Delta S_{\text{universe}} > 0.

  2. Step 2

    ΔSsurroundings=−ΔHT\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-\Delta H}{T}

  3. Step 3

    ΔSsurroundings=−(−2805)310.0 K=+9.05 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-(-2805)}{310.0\text{ K}} = +9.05\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})

    Correct

    ΔSsurroundings=−(−2805 kJ/mol)310.0 K=+9.05 kJ/(mol⋅K)=+9.05×103 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-(-2805\text{ kJ/mol})}{310.0\text{ K}} = +9.05\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) = +9.05 \times 10^3\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})

    Because ΔH\Delta H was given in kilojoules (−2805 kJ/mol-2805\text{ kJ/mol}), dividing directly by 310.0 K310.0\text{ K} yields +9.05 kJ/(mol⋅K)+9.05\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}). Labeling the result with J/(mol⋅K)\text{J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) makes your value 1,000 times too small.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly explained why open biological systems comply with the Second Law of Thermodynamics through heat dissipation.

You selected the exact formula relating reaction enthalpy to surroundings entropy change.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit Conversion Omission

You divided enthalpy in kilojoules directly by temperature but attached joules instead of kilojoules to your final unit.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the prefix 'kilo-' when substituting ΔH\Delta H without explicit unit tracking, leading to a mismatched unit in the quotient.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Unit Consistency Check
  • Entropy values are commonly reported in J/(mol⋅K)\text{J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}), whereas enthalpy values are typically tabulated in kJ/mol\text{kJ}/\text{mol}.

  • Always convert kJ\text{kJ} to J\text{J} (multiply by 10310^3) before dividing by temperature, or write kJ/(mol⋅K)\text{kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) if retaining kilojoules.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert enthalpy to base SI units: ΔH=−2805 kJ/mol=−2.805×106 J/mol\Delta H = -2805\text{ kJ/mol} = -2.805 \times 10^6\text{ J/mol}.

  2. Substitute into the quotient: ΔSsurroundings=−(−2.805×106 J/mol)310.0 K=+9048.4 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-(-2.805 \times 10^6\text{ J/mol})}{310.0\text{ K}} = +9048.4\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}).

  3. Round to three significant figures: ΔSsurroundings=+9.05×103 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = +9.05 \times 10^3\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) (or +9.05 kJ/(mol⋅K)+9.05\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})).

Final answer

ΔSsurroundings=+9.05×103 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = +9.05 \times 10^3\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) (or +9.05 kJ/(mol⋅K)+9.05\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Include explicit units inside your calculation steps so prefixes like 'kilo-' are not dropped unintentionally.

  • Double-check whether standard thermodynamic tables report ΔS\Delta S in J/(mol⋅K)\text{J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) versus kJ/(mol⋅K)\text{kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) before finalizing your response.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

During cellular respiration, palmitic acid undergoes complete combustion with ΔH=−9977 kJ/mol\Delta H = -9977\text{ kJ/mol} at physiological temperature T=310.0 KT = 310.0\text{ K}. Calculate the entropy change of the surroundings, ΔSsurroundings\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}}, in kJ/(mol⋅K)\text{kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}).

Answer

ΔSsurroundings=−ΔHT=−(−9977 kJ/mol)310.0 K=+32.18 kJ/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-\Delta H}{T} = \frac{-(-9977\text{ kJ/mol})}{310.0\text{ K}} = +32.18\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}).

02

A bacterial culture in an open vessel synthesizes a complex polypeptide with ΔHsystem=+125 kJ/mol\Delta H_{\text{system}} = +125\text{ kJ/mol} at T=298.0 KT = 298.0\text{ K}. Calculate ΔSsurroundings\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} and state whether the surroundings gain or lose entropy.

Answer

ΔSsurroundings=−(+125 kJ/mol)298.0 K=−0.419 kJ/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-(+125\text{ kJ/mol})}{298.0\text{ K}} = -0.419\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) (or −419 J/(mol⋅K)-419\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})). The surroundings lose entropy because the endothermic reaction absorbs heat from the surroundings.

03

A metabolic reaction inside a cell has an internal entropy change of ΔSsystem=−180 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{system}} = -180\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) and releases heat such that ΔH=−75.0 kJ/mol\Delta H = -75.0\text{ kJ/mol} at T=300.0 KT = 300.0\text{ K}. Calculate ΔSuniverse\Delta S_{\text{universe}} and explain whether this process complies with the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

Answer

First, calculate ΔSsurroundings=−(−75000 J/mol)300.0 K=+250 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = \frac{-(-75000\text{ J/mol})}{300.0\text{ K}} = +250\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}). Next, calculate ΔSuniverse=ΔSsystem+ΔSsurroundings=−180+250=+70 J/(mol⋅K)\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{system}} + \Delta S_{\text{surroundings}} = -180 + 250 = +70\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}). Because ΔSuniverse>0\Delta S_{\text{universe}} > 0, the process spontaneously complies with the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

Loading workspace…