Resources

A population geneticist evaluates whether a phenotypic shift in thermal tolerance within a captive colony of N=1000N = 1000 Drosophila melanogaster represents microevolution or physiological acclimation. In Generation 00, the mean critical thermal maximum is CTmax=38.0∘C\text{CT}_{\text{max}} = 38.0^\circ\text{C} with narrow-sense heritability h2=0.350h^2 = 0.350. (a) If thermal stress is applied such that individuals surviving to reproduce have a mean CTmax=40.0∘C\text{CT}_{\text{max}} = 40.0^\circ\text{C} (selection differential S=2.00∘CS = 2.00^\circ\text{C}), calculate the expected evolutionary response RR in the offspring generation using the Breeder's Equation. (b) What is the theoretical threshold boundary value of narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2) below which zero genetic evolutionary change occurs in the population despite strong phenotypic selection on individuals?

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Expected evolutionary response R=h2S=0.350×2.00∘C=0.700∘CR = h^2 S = 0.350 \times 2.00^\circ\text{C} = 0.700^\circ\text{C}, yielding an offspring population mean CTmax=38.7∘C\text{CT}_{\text{max}} = 38.7^\circ\text{C}; (b) The critical threshold boundary is h2=0.000h^2 = 0.000. If variation in individual survival is entirely non-heritable (VA=0V_A = 0), individual differential survival produces zero generational evolution in the population.

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Evolutionary Response (RR)

  1. Identify the Given Values and Relationship:

    • Initial parental population mean thermal tolerance: zˉ0=38.0∘C\bar{z}_0 = 38.0^\circ\text{C}
    • Mean thermal tolerance of selected breeders: zˉ∗=40.0∘C\bar{z}^* = 40.0^\circ\text{C}
    • Selection differential (SS): S=zˉ∗−zˉ0=40.0∘C−38.0∘C=2.00∘CS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0 = 40.0^\circ\text{C} - 38.0^\circ\text{C} = 2.00^\circ\text{C}
    • Narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2): h2=0.350h^2 = 0.350
  2. Apply the Breeder's Equation: The evolutionary response to selection across generations is given by: R=h2SR = h^2 S Substituting the values into the equation: R=0.350⋅2.00∘C=0.700∘CR = 0.350 \cdot 2.00^\circ\text{C} = 0.700^\circ\text{C}
  3. Determine the New Offspring Generation Mean: The new population mean (zˉ1\bar{z}_1) in the offspring generation is: zˉ1=zˉ0+R=38.0∘C+0.700∘C=38.7∘C\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R = 38.0^\circ\text{C} + 0.700^\circ\text{C} = 38.7^\circ\text{C}

Part (b): Heritability Threshold and Population-Level Evolution

  1. Theoretical Threshold Boundary: From the Breeder's equation, R=h2SR = h^2 S. Even when selection on individuals is exceptionally strong (S>0S > 0), the evolutionary response of the population equals zero (R=0R = 0) if and only if: h2=0.000h^2 = 0.000
  2. Biological Basis:

    • Narrow-sense heritability is defined as the proportion of total phenotypic variance (VPV_P) attributable to additive genetic variance (VAV_A): h2=VAVPh^2 = \frac{V_A}{V_P}
    • When h2=0h^2 = 0, VA=0V_A = 0. This indicates that all observed phenotypic differences among individuals are driven entirely by non-additive effects or non-heritable environmental acclimation.
    • Common Pitfall: Conflating individual survival or phenotypic plasticity with evolution. While individuals are the targets of selection (differential survival under heat stress), populations evolve across generations. If the trait has no additive genetic basis (h2=0.000h^2 = 0.000), individual selection produces no shift in the offspring population's genetic makeup, meaning no microevolution occurs.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the evolutionary response R with the absolute mean phenotype of the offspring generation, adding the initial mean to R.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    R=h2×S  ⟹  R=0.350×2.00∘C=0.700∘CR = h^2 \times S \implies R = 0.350 \times 2.00^\circ\text{C} = 0.700^\circ\text{C}

  2. Step 2

    R=38.0∘C+0.700∘C=38.7∘CR = 38.0^\circ\text{C} + 0.700^\circ\text{C} = 38.7^\circ\text{C}

    Correct

    R=0.700∘CR = 0.700^\circ\text{C} (and zˉ1=zˉ0+R=38.7∘C\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R = 38.7^\circ\text{C})

    You labeled the new offspring population mean as RR. The evolutionary response RR is specifically the change in the mean phenotype across generations, Δzˉ=0.700∘C\Delta \bar{z} = 0.700^\circ\text{C}, not the absolute post-selection mean (38.7∘C38.7^\circ\text{C}).

  3. Step 3

    h2=0h^2 = 0

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the Breeder's Equation R=h2SR = h^2 S.

You correctly calculated the numerical product 0.350×2.00∘C=0.700∘C0.350 \times 2.00^\circ\text{C} = 0.700^\circ\text{C}.

You correctly recognized that h2=0h^2 = 0 represents the threshold boundary where selection produces no microevolutionary response.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating evolutionary change with absolute phenotype

You substituted the initial population mean into an expression for RR instead of reporting RR as the difference between generation means.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the variable RR as the final offspring population mean rather than the generational difference or shift (zˉ1−zˉ0\bar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Response vs. Population Mean
  • In quantitative genetics, R=zˉ1−zˉ0R = \bar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0 represents the change in the population mean, whereas zˉ1=zˉ0+R\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R is the new mean.

  • Report RR directly as the difference (h2Sh^2 S); only add the parental mean if the problem specifically asks for the offspring generation's mean.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. The evolutionary response is defined as R=h2S=0.700∘CR = h^2 S = 0.700^\circ\text{C}.

  2. The new offspring population mean is zˉ1=zˉ0+R=38.0∘C+0.700∘C=38.7∘C\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R = 38.0^\circ\text{C} + 0.700^\circ\text{C} = 38.7^\circ\text{C}.

  3. Keep RR as the change value when answering part (a).

Final answer

(a) R=0.700∘CR = 0.700^\circ\text{C} (with offspring mean zˉ1=38.7∘C\bar{z}_1 = 38.7^\circ\text{C}); (b) h2=0h^2 = 0

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out symbols with clear definitions: let R=ΔzˉR = \Delta \bar{z} and zˉ1=zˉ0+R\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R to prevent variable conflation.

  • Double-check whether the prompt asks for the response to selection (RR) or the resulting generation's mean phenotype.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student divides the selection differential by narrow-sense heritability instead of multiplying them according to the Breeder's Equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    R=Sh2  ⟹  R=2.00∘C0.350=5.71∘CR = \frac{S}{h^2} \implies R = \frac{2.00^\circ\text{C}}{0.350} = 5.71^\circ\text{C}

    Correct

    R=h2S=0.350×2.00∘C=0.700∘CR = h^2 S = 0.350 \times 2.00^\circ\text{C} = 0.700^\circ\text{C}

    The Breeder's Equation states that evolutionary response equals heritability multiplied by selection differential (R=h2SR = h^2 S), not divided by heritability (R=Sh2R = \frac{S}{h^2}). Dividing by h2h^2 produced an evolutionary response greater than the selection differential itself, which is impossible since narrow-sense heritability cannot exceed 11.

  2. Step 2

    h2=0h^2 = 0

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that narrow-sense heritability must be zero for evolutionary response to vanish entirely under selection.

You correctly substituted the numerical value of the selection differential (S=2.00∘CS = 2.00^\circ\text{C}).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Breeder's Equation formula inversion

You wrote R=Sh2R = \frac{S}{h^2} instead of R=h2SR = h^2 S.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You misremembered the Breeder's Equation as a quotient rather than a product. Because heritability represents the fraction of phenotypic divergence transmitted to offspring (h2=RSh^2 = \frac{R}{S}), the response across generations must scale as R=h2SR = h^2 S, which is always less than or equal to SS.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verify proportional response with heritability
  • R=h2SR = h^2 S, where 0≤h2≤10 \le h^2 \le 1

  • Check whether your calculated response RR is smaller than or equal to the selection differential SS. If R>SR > S, the formula has likely been inverted.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall the definition of narrow-sense heritability as the slope of the regression of offspring on mid-parent values: h2=RSh^2 = \frac{R}{S}.

  2. Rearrange the relation to isolate response: R=h2SR = h^2 S.

  3. Substitute h2=0.350h^2 = 0.350 and S=2.00∘CS = 2.00^\circ\text{C}: R=0.350×2.00∘C=0.700∘CR = 0.350 \times 2.00^\circ\text{C} = 0.700^\circ\text{C}.

  4. Add RR to the parental mean to get the new offspring generation mean: 38.0∘C+0.700∘C=38.7∘C38.0^\circ\text{C} + 0.700^\circ\text{C} = 38.7^\circ\text{C}.

Final answer

(a) R=0.700∘CR = 0.700^\circ\text{C}; (b) h2=0.000h^2 = 0.000

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the Breeder's Equation as R=h2SR = h^2 S, checking that R≤SR \le S whenever h2≤1h^2 \le 1.

  • Practice solving for each variable (RR, h2h^2, and SS) from given data sets to reinforce algebraic manipulation.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the absence of evolutionary response (h² = 0) with complete heritability (h² = 1.0) where response equals the selection differential.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    R=h2×S  ⟹  R=0.350×2.00∘C=0.700∘CR = h^2 \times S \implies R = 0.350 \times 2.00^\circ\text{C} = 0.700^\circ\text{C}

  2. Step 2

    h2=1.0h^2 = 1.0

    Correct

    h2=0.000h^2 = 0.000

    You gave the boundary for perfect heritability where R=SR = S, but zero evolutionary response occurs when additive genetic variance is zero, which corresponds to h2=0h^2 = 0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled the Breeder's Equation R=h2SR = h^2 S and multiplied the given values accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse Boundary Misconception

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the condition for zero evolutionary response (h2=0h^2 = 0) with the condition for maximum or complete response (h2=1h^2 = 1). Selection acts on individuals, but evolution requires additive genetic variation (VA>0V_A > 0) in the population. When all variation is environmental or non-additive (h2=0h^2 = 0), R=0R = 0 regardless of how strong selection SS is.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate Zero Response in the Breeder's Equation
  • From R=h2SR = h^2 S, if selection is strong (S>0S > 0) but generational evolutionary response is zero (R=0R = 0), then h2h^2 must equal 00.

  • Set R=0R = 0 in R=h2SR = h^2 S to solve for the boundary heritability value.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the evolutionary response in the offspring population to zero: R=0R = 0.

  2. Substitute into the Breeder's Equation: 0=h2×S0 = h^2 \times S.

  3. Since phenotypic selection on individuals is non-zero (S>0S > 0), divide by SS to find h2=0.000h^2 = 0.000.

Final answer

h2=0.000h^2 = 0.000

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between h2=0h^2 = 0 (no additive genetic variance, phenotypic differences do not pass to the next generation) and h2=1h^2 = 1 (all phenotypic variance is additive genetic).

  • Practice identifying whether a question asks for the maximum threshold or the zero-evolution threshold.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A population of sunflowers has a mean height of 150 cm150\text{ cm}. Breeders select plants with a mean height of 170 cm170\text{ cm} to reproduce. If narrow-sense heritability for height is h2=0.40h^2 = 0.40, calculate (a) the selection differential SS, (b) the evolutionary response RR, and (c) the mean height of the next generation.

Answer

(a) S=170 cm−150 cm=20 cmS = 170\text{ cm} - 150\text{ cm} = 20\text{ cm}; (b) R=h2S=0.40×20 cm=8 cmR = h^2 S = 0.40 \times 20\text{ cm} = 8\text{ cm}; (c) zˉ1=150 cm+8 cm=158 cm\bar{z}_1 = 150\text{ cm} + 8\text{ cm} = 158\text{ cm}.

02

In a population of beetles, average horn length increases from 12.0 mm12.0\text{ mm} in Generation 0 to 13.5 mm13.5\text{ mm} in Generation 1 following directional selection. If the breeding parents had an average horn length of 15.0 mm15.0\text{ mm}, determine the narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2) of horn length.

Answer

S=15.0 mm−12.0 mm=3.0 mmS = 15.0\text{ mm} - 12.0\text{ mm} = 3.0\text{ mm}; R=13.5 mm−12.0 mm=1.5 mmR = 13.5\text{ mm} - 12.0\text{ mm} = 1.5\text{ mm}. Using R=h2SR = h^2 S, h2=RS=1.5 mm3.0 mm=0.50h^2 = \frac{R}{S} = \frac{1.5\text{ mm}}{3.0\text{ mm}} = 0.50.

03

Under an intense drought, only large-beaked finches survive, yielding a selection differential of S=1.8 mmS = 1.8\text{ mm}. However, parent-offspring regression reveals that beak size variation is entirely due to developmental nutrition (VA=0V_A = 0, VP>0V_P > 0). State the expected offspring population mean beak depth if the pre-drought population mean was 9.5 mm9.5\text{ mm}, and explain why microevolution did not occur.

Answer

h2=VAVP=0h^2 = \frac{V_A}{V_P} = 0, so R=h2S=0 mmR = h^2 S = 0\text{ mm}. The offspring mean remains 9.5 mm9.5\text{ mm}. Microevolution did not occur because selection acted on phenotypic variation with no additive genetic basis, leaving the population gene pool unchanged.

Loading workspace…