Resources

In yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae), entry into mitosis requires activation of the cyclin-dependent kinase Cdc28/Cdk1\text{Cdc28/Cdk1} by cyclin Clb2\text{Clb2}. Active Cdk1-Clb2\text{Cdk1-Clb2} complexes undergo an abrupt switch-like activation when the inhibitory kinase Wee1\text{Wee1} is inactivated and the dual-specificity phosphatase Cdc25\text{Cdc25} is activated. Suppose a critical threshold concentration of [active Cdk1]=45.0 nM[\text{active Cdk1}] = 45.0\text{ nM} is required to trigger nuclear envelope breakdown and mitotic entry. If active Cdk1\text{Cdk1} increases according to [Cdk1](t)=1201+e−0.60(t−14.0) nM[\text{Cdk1}](t) = \frac{120}{1 + e^{-0.60(t - 14.0)}}\text{ nM}, where tt is time in minutes after entering late G2G_2: (a) find the exact time tcritt_{\text{crit}} (in minutes) at which the cell passes the mitotic commitment threshold, and (b) determine the state of phosphorylation on the tyrosine-1515 (Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15}) residue of Cdk1\text{Cdk1} immediately before versus immediately after crossing tcritt_{\text{crit}}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) tcrit≈13.1 minutest_{\text{crit}} \approx 13.1\text{ minutes}; (b) Immediately before tcritt_{\text{crit}}, Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} is phosphorylated (inhibited by Wee1\text{Wee1}); immediately after tcritt_{\text{crit}}, Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} is dephosphorylated (activated by Cdc25\text{Cdc25}).

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Critical Time (tcritt_{\text{crit}})

To determine the exact time at which the cell enters mitosis, set the active Cdk1\text{Cdk1} concentration equal to the required threshold value of 45.0 nM45.0\text{ nM}:

1201+e−0.60(tcrit−14.0)=45.0\frac{120}{1 + e^{-0.60(t_{\text{crit}} - 14.0)}} = 45.0

  1. Divide both sides into 120120 to isolate the denominator: 1+e−0.60(tcrit−14.0)=12045.0=831 + e^{-0.60(t_{\text{crit}} - 14.0)} = \frac{120}{45.0} = \frac{8}{3}
  2. Subtract 11 from both sides: e−0.60(tcrit−14.0)=83−1=53e^{-0.60(t_{\text{crit}} - 14.0)} = \frac{8}{3} - 1 = \frac{5}{3}
  3. Take the natural logarithm (ln⁡\ln) of both sides: −0.60(tcrit−14.0)=ln⁡(53)≈0.5108-0.60(t_{\text{crit}} - 14.0) = \ln\left(\frac{5}{3}\right) \approx 0.5108
  4. Solve for tcritt_{\text{crit}}: tcrit−14.0=−0.51080.60≈−0.8514t_{\text{crit}} - 14.0 = -\frac{0.5108}{0.60} \approx -0.8514 tcrit=14.0−0.8514≈13.1 minutest_{\text{crit}} = 14.0 - 0.8514 \approx 13.1\text{ minutes}

Thus, the cell crosses the mitotic commitment threshold at approximately tcrit≈13.1 minutest_{\text{crit}} \approx 13.1\text{ minutes}.


Part (b): Phosphorylation State of Cdk1 at Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15}

During the cell cycle, the entry into mitosis (G2/MG_2/M transition) is governed by a bistable molecular switch involving two opposing regulatory enzymes acting on the tyrosine-1515 (Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15}) residue of Cdk1\text{Cdk1}:

  • Immediately before tcritt_{\text{crit}} (Late G2G_2 Phase):

    • The inhibitory kinase Wee1\text{Wee1} is predominantly active, while the phosphatase Cdc25\text{Cdc25} is kept inactive.
    • Wee1\text{Wee1} places an inhibitory phosphate group onto Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15}, keeping the accumulated Cdk1-Clb2\text{Cdk1-Clb2} complexes in an inactive, phosphorylated state.
  • Immediately after tcritt_{\text{crit}} (Mitotic Entry):

    • Crossing the activation threshold triggers mutual positive feedback loops: active Cdk1-Clb2\text{Cdk1-Clb2} phosphorylates and activates its activator (Cdc25\text{Cdc25}), while phosphorylating and inactivating its inhibitor (Wee1\text{Wee1}).
    • Cdc25\text{Cdc25} rapidly removes the phosphate group from Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15}, converting Cdk1\text{Cdk1} into its fully active, dephosphorylated state to drive the cell irreversibly into mitosis.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student inverts the biological regulatory roles of phosphorylation by Wee1 and dephosphorylation by Cdc25, concluding that activating Cdk1 requires phosphorylation of Tyr-15.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1201+e−0.60(t−14.0)=45.0  ⟹  1+e−0.60(t−14.0)=83  ⟹  e−0.60(t−14.0)=53  ⟹  −0.60(t−14.0)=ln⁡(53)  ⟹  tcrit=14.0−ln⁡(5/3)0.60≈13.15 min\frac{120}{1 + e^{-0.60(t - 14.0)}} = 45.0 \implies 1 + e^{-0.60(t - 14.0)} = \frac{8}{3} \implies e^{-0.60(t - 14.0)} = \frac{5}{3} \implies -0.60(t - 14.0) = \ln\left(\frac{5}{3}\right) \implies t_{\text{crit}} = 14.0 - \frac{\ln(5/3)}{0.60} \approx 13.15\text{ min}

  2. Step 2

    Before tcritt_{\text{crit}}, Cdk1 is inactive and therefore dephosphorylated at Tyr-15. After tcritt_{\text{crit}}, Cdk1 is activated and therefore phosphorylated at Tyr-15.

    Correct

    Immediately before tcritt_{\text{crit}}, Cdk1\text{Cdk1} is phosphorylated at Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} (inhibited by Wee1\text{Wee1}). Immediately after tcritt_{\text{crit}}, Cdk1\text{Cdk1} is dephosphorylated at Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} (activated by Cdc25\text{Cdc25}).

    You assumed that protein phosphorylation always acts as an activating modification. Phosphorylation of Cdk1\text{Cdk1} at Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} by the kinase Wee1\text{Wee1} is inhibitory, while dephosphorylation by the phosphatase Cdc25\text{Cdc25} relieves this inhibition and activates the kinase.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the threshold equation using the logistic concentration function.

You carried out every algebraic step and natural logarithm evaluation accurately to find tcrit≈13.15 mint_{\text{crit}} \approx 13.15\text{ min}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misidentifying inhibitory phosphorylation as activating phosphorylation

You associated active Cdk1\text{Cdk1} directly with phosphorylation rather than dephosphorylation at the Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} site.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated phosphorylation as universally activating across cell signaling, overlooking the fact that Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} phosphorylation by Wee1\text{Wee1} is an inhibitory modification that must be removed by Cdc25\text{Cdc25} to activate Cdk1\text{Cdk1}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dual Nature of Phosphorylation
  • Phosphorylation can either stimulate or inhibit enzymatic activity depending on the specific residue and kinase.

  • Always verify whether an upstream enzyme (such as Wee1\text{Wee1}) is an inhibitory kinase before deducing the activation state.

G2/M Switch Mechanism
  • Wee1\text{Wee1} adds an inhibitory phosphate to Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} of Cdk1\text{Cdk1}; Cdc25\text{Cdc25} removes that phosphate to trigger mitotic entry.

  • Identify inactive Cdk1\text{Cdk1} in late G2G_2 as Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15}-phosphorylated and active Cdk1\text{Cdk1} in MM phase as dephosphorylated at Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Before tcritt_{\text{crit}}, the cell is in late G2G_2, where the inhibitory kinase Wee1\text{Wee1} maintains an inhibitory phosphate group on Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} of Cdk1\text{Cdk1}. Thus, Cdk1\text{Cdk1} is phosphorylated.

  2. At tcritt_{\text{crit}}, the threshold is crossed and Cdc25\text{Cdc25} phosphatase is activated while Wee1\text{Wee1} is inactivated.

  3. Therefore, immediately after tcritt_{\text{crit}}, Cdc25\text{Cdc25} removes the phosphate group from Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15}, leaving active Cdk1\text{Cdk1} dephosphorylated at this residue.

Final answer

Immediately before tcritt_{\text{crit}}, Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} is phosphorylated; immediately after tcritt_{\text{crit}}, Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} is dephosphorylated.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the opposing roles of Wee1\text{Wee1} (kinase) and Cdc25\text{Cdc25} (phosphatase) at the G2/MG_2/M checkpoint.

  • Create a concept map highlighting residues where phosphorylation causes inhibition (such as Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} and Thr-14\text{Thr-14}) versus activation (such as Thr-161\text{Thr-161} by CAK\text{CAK}).

  • Practice identifying molecular switches governed by dephosphorylation-driven activation.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student forgets the negative sign when taking the natural logarithm or inverting the exponential function, adding the logarithmic term instead of subtracting it.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1201+e−0.60(t−14.0)=45.0  ⟹  1+e−0.60(t−14.0)=83  ⟹  e−0.60(t−14.0)=53\frac{120}{1 + e^{-0.60(t - 14.0)}} = 45.0 \implies 1 + e^{-0.60(t - 14.0)} = \frac{8}{3} \implies e^{-0.60(t - 14.0)} = \frac{5}{3}

  2. Step 2

    0.60(t−14.0)=ln⁡(53)0.60(t - 14.0) = \ln\left(\frac{5}{3}\right)

    Correct

    −0.60(t−14.0)=ln⁡(53)-0.60(t - 14.0) = \ln\left(\frac{5}{3}\right)

    When applying the natural logarithm identity ln⁡(eu)=u\ln(e^u) = u, the full exponent −0.60(t−14.0)-0.60(t - 14.0) must be retained, including its leading negative sign.

  3. Step 3

    t−14.0=ln⁡(5/3)0.60  ⟹  tcrit=14.0+ln⁡(5/3)0.60≈14.85 mint - 14.0 = \frac{\ln(5/3)}{0.60} \implies t_{\text{crit}} = 14.0 + \frac{\ln(5/3)}{0.60} \approx 14.85\text{ min}

    Correct

    tcrit=14.0−ln⁡(5/3)0.60≈13.1 minutest_{\text{crit}} = 14.0 - \frac{\ln(5/3)}{0.60} \approx 13.1\text{ minutes}

    Because the negative sign was omitted in the previous step, you added ≈0.85\approx 0.85 to 14.014.0 rather than subtracting it.

  4. Step 4

    Before tcrit, Tyr-15 is phosphorylated. After tcrit, Tyr-15 is dephosphorylated.\text{Before } t_{\text{crit}},\text{ Tyr-15 is phosphorylated. After } t_{\text{crit}},\text{ Tyr-15 is dephosphorylated.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly equated the threshold value to the activation function and simplified the fraction.

You accurately understood the biological regulatory mechanism of Cdk1\text{Cdk1} phosphorylation at Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} by Wee1\text{Wee1} and Cdc25\text{Cdc25}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted negative sign in logarithmic inversion

You dropped the negative sign from the exponent when taking the natural logarithm of both sides.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Loss of the negative sign during the inverse operation ln⁡(e−k(t−t0))\ln(e^{-k(t - t_0)}), treating −k(t−t0)-k(t - t_0) as positive and leading to an addition rather than a subtraction.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Inverse Exponential Property
  • ln⁡(eu)=u\ln(e^u) = u for any real expression uu, including negative coefficients.

  • Always copy the entire exponent with its sign into parentheses before applying further algebraic steps.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. −0.60(tcrit−14.0)=ln⁡(53)≈0.5108-0.60(t_{\text{crit}} - 14.0) = \ln\left(\frac{5}{3}\right) \approx 0.5108

  2. tcrit−14.0=−0.51080.60≈−0.8514t_{\text{crit}} - 14.0 = -\frac{0.5108}{0.60} \approx -0.8514

  3. tcrit=14.0−0.8514≈13.1 minutest_{\text{crit}} = 14.0 - 0.8514 \approx 13.1\text{ minutes}

Final answer

(a) tcrit≈13.1 minutest_{\text{crit}} \approx 13.1\text{ minutes}; (b) Before tcritt_{\text{crit}}, Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} is phosphorylated; after tcritt_{\text{crit}}, Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} is dephosphorylated.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check signs whenever inverting exponential decay or logistic functions of the form e−k(t−t0)e^{-k(t - t_0)}.

  • Verify that since the threshold 45 nM45\text{ nM} is below the midpoint 60 nM60\text{ nM} (120/2120/2), the critical time must occur before the inflection point at t=14.0 mint = 14.0\text{ min}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a fission yeast mutant lacking the Wee1\text{Wee1} kinase gene (Δwee1\Delta wee1), cells enter mitosis prematurely at a smaller size. Explain why this happens in terms of Cdk1\text{Cdk1} phosphorylation at Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15}.

Answer

Without Wee1\text{Wee1}, Cdk1\text{Cdk1} cannot receive the inhibitory phosphorylation at Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15}. As a result, newly formed cyclin-Cdk1\text{Cdk1} complexes remain prematurely uninhibited and trigger mitotic entry before the cell has achieved normal size.

02

Fully active Cdk1\text{Cdk1} requires two phosphorylation-related events: one modification by CAK\text{CAK} and one by Cdc25\text{Cdc25}. State which residue each enzyme targets and whether it adds or removes a phosphate group.

Answer
  1. CAK\text{CAK} adds an activating phosphate group to threonine-161 (Thr-161\text{Thr-161} / Thr-160\text{Thr-160}).
  2. Cdc25\text{Cdc25} removes an inhibitory phosphate group from tyrosine-15 (Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15}, and Thr-14\text{Thr-14} in metazoans).
03

Suppose a mutant cell expresses a non-phosphorylatable variant of Cdk1\text{Cdk1} where Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} is replaced by phenylalanine (Cdk1Y15F\text{Cdk1}^{\text{Y15F}}). If the threshold concentration of active Cdk1\text{Cdk1} needed for mitosis is still 45.0 nM45.0\text{ nM} and cyclin Clb2\text{Clb2} accumulation follows [Clb2](t)=5.0t nM/min[\text{Clb2}](t) = 5.0 t\text{ nM/min} (assuming 1:11:1 complex formation directly into active kinase without Wee1\text{Wee1} inhibition), at what time tt will the cell enter mitosis?

Answer

t=9.0 minutest = 9.0\text{ minutes}. Key steps: Because Tyr-15\text{Tyr-15} cannot be phosphorylated, Wee1\text{Wee1} cannot inhibit the complex. Every synthesized Cdk1-Clb2\text{Cdk1-Clb2} complex is active immediately. Set [active Cdk1]=5.0t=45.0 nM  ⟹  t=45.05.0=9.0 min[\text{active Cdk1}] = 5.0 t = 45.0\text{ nM} \implies t = \frac{45.0}{5.0} = 9.0\text{ min}.

Loading workspace…