Resources

An adult male presenting with mild cognitive delay, reduced secondary sex characteristics, and hypergonadotropic hypogonadism undergoes high-resolution karyotyping. Metaphase spreads reveal 2222 standard autosomal bivalents alongside sex chromosomes consisting of two complete X\text{X} chromosomes and one Y\text{Y} chromosome. Rather than simply naming the syndrome, calculate: (1) the total number of autosomal chromatids present per cell at mitotic metaphase, (2) the total number of Barr bodies (sex chromatin condensations) visible in interphase somatic nuclei, and (3) the exact ratio of active X\text{X} chromosomes to total autosomes in a diploid G1 cell.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(1) Autosomal chromatids at metaphase: 8888 chromatids; (2) Barr bodies in interphase nuclei: 11; (3) Ratio of active X\text{X} chromosomes to total autosomes: 1:441:44 (or 144\frac{1}{44}).

Steps

01

Identify the Chromosome Composition

From the clinical presentation and karyotype findings, the individual has the karyotype 47,XXY47,\text{XXY} (Klinefelter syndrome):

  • Autosomes: 2222 pairs =44= 44 autosomes.
  • Sex chromosomes: 2 X2\ \text{X} chromosomes and 1 Y1\ \text{Y} chromosome =3= 3 sex chromosomes.
  • Total chromosome count: 44+3=4744 + 3 = 47.

02

Calculate Autosomal Chromatids at Mitotic Metaphase

  • During the S phase of interphase, each chromosome replicates into two identical sister chromatids held together at the centromere.
  • At mitotic metaphase, the autosomes are fully condensed, and each of the 4444 autosomes consists of 22 chromatids. Autosomal chromatids=44×2=88\text{Autosomal chromatids} = 44 \times 2 = 88

Common Pitfall: Do not include sex chromosomes in this count. Replicated sex chromosomes contribute an additional 3×2=63 \times 2 = 6 chromatids (totaling 9494 chromatids in the entire cell), but the question strictly asks for autosomal chromatids.


03

Determine the Number of Barr Bodies

  • Under the Lyon hypothesis of dosage compensation, all X\text{X} chromosomes in excess of one are inactivated via heterochromatinization to form facultative heterochromatin visible as Barr bodies along the periphery of interphase nuclei.
  • The general formula is: Number of Barr bodies=NX−1\text{Number of Barr bodies} = N_{\text{X}} - 1 where NXN_{\text{X}} is the total number of X\text{X} chromosomes per nucleus.
  • For an XXY\text{XXY} individual (NX=2N_{\text{X}} = 2): Barr bodies=2−1=1\text{Barr bodies} = 2 - 1 = 1

04

Calculate the Ratio of Active X\text{X} Chromosomes to Total Autosomes

  • In a diploid G1\text{G}_1 somatic cell:
    • Exactly 11 X\text{X} chromosome remains transcriptionally active, while the other is inactivated.
    • There are 4444 individual autosomes.
  • The ratio of active X\text{X} chromosomes to total autosomes is therefore: Ratio=1:44(or 144)\text{Ratio} = 1 : 44\quad \left(\text{or } \frac{1}{44}\right)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that chromosomes have duplicated into two sister chromatids by mitotic metaphase, counting only 44 autosomal chromatids.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    22 pairs of autosomes\text{ pairs of autosomes} = 44 autosomes\text{ autosomes}   ⟹  \implies Number of autosomal chromatids at metaphase\text{Number of autosomal chromatids at metaphase} = 44

    Correct

    44 autosomes\text{ autosomes} ×\times 2 chromatids per chromosome\text{ chromatids per chromosome} = 88 autosomal chromatids\text{ autosomal chromatids}

    You correctly identified that there are 4444 autosomes (2222 pairs). However, by mitotic metaphase, DNA has already undergone replication during S phase, so each chromosome consists of two identical sister chromatids.

  2. Step 2

    Number of Barr bodies\text{Number of Barr bodies} = 2 - 1 = 1

  3. Step 3

    1 active X chromosome\text{ active X chromosome},\ 44 total autosomes\text{ total autosomes}   ⟹  \implies Ratio\text{Ratio} = 144\frac{1}{44}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the karyotype as having 2222 autosomal pairs (4444 autosomes) and two X\text{X} chromosomes.

You correctly applied the Lyon hypothesis formula (NX−1N_{\text{X}} - 1) to find 11 Barr body.

You correctly calculated the ratio of active X\text{X} chromosomes to total autosomes in a G1\text{G}_1 cell as 1:441:44.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Chromosome vs. Chromatid Metaphase Duplication

You equated the number of unreplicated chromosomes directly with the number of chromatids at metaphase.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked that mitotic metaphase occurs after DNA synthesis (S phase), so every individual chromosome is composed of two sister chromatids joined at the centromere.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Chromosome vs. Chromatid Count
  • Before S phase (G1\text{G}_1), 1 chromosome=1 chromatid1\text{ chromosome} = 1\text{ chromatid}. After S phase through metaphase, 1 chromosome=2 sister chromatids1\text{ chromosome} = 2\text{ sister chromatids}.

  • Always multiply the number of chromosomes by 22 when calculating chromatids in mitotic prophase or metaphase.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the number of autosomes: 22 pairs=44 autosomes22\text{ pairs} = 44\text{ autosomes}.

  2. Account for DNA replication occurring in interphase (S phase): each chromosome enters mitosis as a duplicated chromosome composed of 22 sister chromatids.

  3. Multiply total autosomes by 22: 44×2=88 autosomal chromatids44 \times 2 = 88\text{ autosomal chromatids}.

Final answer

(1) 8888 autosomal chromatids; (2) 11 Barr body; (3) 1:441:44 (or 144\frac{1}{44})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review cell-cycle stages (G1\text{G}_1, S, G2\text{G}_2, M) and distinguish when chromosomes transition from single chromatids to sister chromatid pairs.

  • Practice distinguishing 'chromosomes' (counted by centromeres) from 'chromatids' (individual DNA strands in duplicated chromosomes).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the ratio of active X chromosomes to autosome pairs rather than total individual autosomes, yielding 1/22.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    44 autosomes×2 chromatids per chromosome=88 autosomal chromatids44\text{ autosomes} \times 2\text{ chromatids per chromosome} = 88\text{ autosomal chromatids}

  2. Step 2

    Number of Barr bodies=1\text{Number of Barr bodies} = 1

  3. Step 3

    Active X chromosomes=1  ⟹  Autosomes=22  ⟹  Ratio=1/22\text{Active X chromosomes} = 1 \implies \text{Autosomes} = 22 \implies \text{Ratio} = 1/22

    Correct

    Active X=1,  Total autosomes=44  ⟹  Ratio=1:44 (or 144)\text{Active X} = 1,\; \text{Total autosomes} = 44 \implies \text{Ratio} = 1:44\text{ (or }\frac{1}{44}\text{)}

    You used the number of homologous autosome pairs (2222) instead of the total number of individual autosomes (4444). Because humans have 4444 total autosomes, the ratio of active X\text{X} chromosomes to total autosomes is 1:441:44.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that each of the 4444 autosomes consists of 22 sister chromatids at mitotic metaphase, yielding 8888 chromatids.

You correctly applied dosage compensation to find that 11 of the 22 X\text{X} chromosomes condenses into a Barr body.

You correctly identified that exactly 11 X\text{X} chromosome remains transcriptionally active.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Pair vs. Total Count Confusion

You substituted the number of autosome pairs (2222) in place of the total number of autosomes (4444) in your ratio.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the haploid number of autosomal pairs (n=22n = 22) with the total count of diploid autosomes (2n−2=442n - 2 = 44) when a question specifies 'total autosomes'.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Chromosome vs. Pair Terminology
  • In human diploid somatic cells, there are 2222 pairs of autosomes, which equals 4444 individual autosomes.

  • Always verify whether a prompt asks for 'autosomal pairs' or 'total autosomes' before forming a ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the total number of autosomes: a human somatic cell possesses 2222 pairs of autosomes, giving 22×2=4422 \times 2 = 44 autosomes.

  2. Identify the number of active X\text{X} chromosomes: exactly 11 X\text{X} chromosome remains active per diploid genome.

  3. Calculate the requested ratio: active Xtotal autosomes=144\frac{\text{active X}}{\text{total autosomes}} = \frac{1}{44}.

Final answer

(1) 8888 autosomal chromatids; (2) 11 Barr body; (3) 1:441:44 (or 144\frac{1}{44})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice distinguishing between chromosome pairs (nn) and total individual chromosomes (2n2n) in quantitative karyotype problems.

  • Double-check denominator labels in genetics ratios to ensure individual chromosome units match throughout.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student includes the sex chromosomes when counting chromatids, calculating the total chromatids of the cell instead of only autosomal chromatids.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Total chromosomes=44 autosomes+3 sex chromosomes=47  ⟹  Total chromatids=47×2=94\text{Total chromosomes} = 44\text{ autosomes} + 3\text{ sex chromosomes} = 47 \implies \text{Total chromatids} = 47 \times 2 = 94

    Correct

    Autosomal chromatids=44×2=88\text{Autosomal chromatids} = 44 \times 2 = 88

    You multiplied all 4747 chromosomes by 22 to find the total chromatids in the cell, but the prompt asked specifically for autosomal chromatids. Replicated sex chromosomes (3×2=63 \times 2 = 6 chromatids) must be excluded, giving 44×2=8844 \times 2 = 88.

  2. Step 2

    Number of Barr bodies=2−1=1\text{Number of Barr bodies} = 2 - 1 = 1

  3. Step 3

    Active X=1, Autosomes=44  ⟹  Ratio=144\text{Active X} = 1, \text{ Autosomes} = 44 \implies \text{Ratio} = \frac{1}{44}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the karyotype composition of 4444 autosomes and 33 sex chromosomes (47,XXY47,\text{XXY}).

You accurately applied dosage compensation principles to compute the number of Barr bodies.

You set up and evaluated the ratio of active X\text{X} chromosomes to autosomes properly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Scope Confusion (Autosomes vs. Total Chromosomes)

You calculated total cellular chromatids rather than focusing only on autosomal chromatids.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked the modifier 'autosomal' in sub-question (1), leading you to multiply the total chromosome count (4747) rather than the autosome count (4444) by 22 sister chromatids per metaphase chromosome.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Filter by Chromosome Subtype
  • Total chromosomes in a human cell consist of autosomes plus allosomes (sex chromosomes): Ntotal=Nauto+NsexN_{\text{total}} = N_{\text{auto}} + N_{\text{sex}}.

  • Whenever a problem specifies 'autosomal', isolate only the autosome count (4444 in humans) and completely exclude X\text{X} and Y\text{Y} chromosomes from the calculation.

Metaphase Chromatid Counting
  • At mitotic metaphase, each replicated chromosome consists of exactly 22 sister chromatids joined at the centromere.

  • Multiply only the requested chromosome group by 22: Autosomal chromatids=44×2=88\text{Autosomal chromatids} = 44 \times 2 = 88.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the number of autosomes: 22 pairs=44 autosomes22\text{ pairs} = 44\text{ autosomes}.

  2. Account for DNA replication prior to metaphase: each autosome contains 22 sister chromatids.

  3. Calculate autosomal chromatids: 44×2=8844 \times 2 = 88.

Final answer

(1) 8888 autosomal chromatids; (2) 11 Barr body; (3) 1:441:44 (or 144\frac{1}{44})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Underline modifying terms like 'autosomal' or 'sex chromosomal' before doing arithmetic.

  • Practice distinguishing total chromosome count, autosome count, and chromatid count across various aneuploidies.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A female patient with Turner syndrome (45,X45,\text{X}) undergoes karyotype evaluation. Calculate: (1) the number of total chromatids present at mitotic metaphase, and (2) the number of Barr bodies observed in interphase nuclei.

Answer

(1) 9090 total chromatids (45 chromosomes×245\text{ chromosomes} \times 2). (2) 00 Barr bodies, because NX−1=1−1=0N_{\text{X}} - 1 = 1 - 1 = 0.

02

A patient is diagnosed with Down syndrome due to standard trisomy 2121 (47,XY,+2147,\text{XY},+21). Determine: (1) the total number of autosomal chromatids at mitotic metaphase, and (2) the total number of sex chromosome chromatids at the same stage.

Answer

(1) 9090 autosomal chromatids (45 autosomes×245\text{ autosomes} \times 2). (2) 44 sex chromosome chromatids (2 sex chromosomes [X and Y]×22\text{ sex chromosomes } [\text{X and Y}] \times 2).

03

An individual with karyotype 48,XXXY48,\text{XXXY} is evaluated. At mitotic metaphase, calculate the ratio of sex chromosome chromatids to autosomal chromatids. Additionally, determine the number of Barr bodies in interphase somatic cells.

Answer

Chromatid ratio: 4 sex chromosomes×2=8 chromatids4\text{ sex chromosomes} \times 2 = 8\text{ chromatids}; 44 autosomes×2=88 chromatids44\text{ autosomes} \times 2 = 88\text{ chromatids}, giving a ratio of 8:888:88 (or 1:111:11). Barr bodies: NX−1=3−1=2N_{\text{X}} - 1 = 3 - 1 = 2 Barr bodies.

Loading workspace…