Resources

In a population of black-tailed prairie dogs (Cynomys ludovicianus), an adult female emits an acoustic alarm call upon detecting an approaching terrestrial predator (coyote). Emitting this alarm call increases the caller's direct mortality risk by c=0.08c = 0.08, while reducing the mortality risk of each nearby full sibling by b=0.22b = 0.22. Assuming the coefficient of relatedness between full siblings is r=0.50r = 0.50, determine whether this cooperative altruistic behavior is favored by natural selection according to Hamilton's rule (rb−c>0r b - c > 0), and calculate the net inclusive fitness benefit.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Yes, altruism is favored; net inclusive fitness change is +0.03+0.03 (since rb−c=(0.50)(0.22)−0.08=0.11−0.08=+0.03>0r b - c = (0.50)(0.22) - 0.08 = 0.11 - 0.08 = +0.03 > 0).

Steps

01

Understand Hamilton's Rule

Hamilton's rule explains how natural selection can favor an altruistic trait through kin selection (inclusive fitness). An altruistic behavior is favored when:

rb−c>0orrb>cr b - c > 0 \quad \text{or} \quad r b > c

Where:

  • rr is the coefficient of relatedness between the altruist (caller) and the beneficiary (recipient).
  • bb is the reproductive or survival benefit conferred to the recipient.
  • cc is the direct fitness cost incurred by the altruist.
  • The quantity rb−cr b - c represents the net change in inclusive fitness.

02

Identify the Given Values

From the problem statement:

  • Direct cost to the caller: c=0.08c = 0.08
  • Survival benefit to a full sibling: b=0.22b = 0.22
  • Coefficient of relatedness for full siblings: r=0.50r = 0.50

03

Calculate the Net Inclusive Fitness Benefit

Substitute these parameters into Hamilton's formula:

rb−c=(0.50⋅0.22)−0.08r b - c = (0.50 \cdot 0.22) - 0.08

Calculate the indirect benefit (rbr b): rb=0.11r b = 0.11

Subtract the direct cost (cc): rb−c=0.11−0.08=+0.03r b - c = 0.11 - 0.08 = +0.03


04

Conclusion and Interpretation

Because the net inclusive fitness change is positive (+0.03>0+0.03 > 0), the indirect fitness gained through the survival of a close relative outweighs the direct fitness cost to the individual caller. Therefore, this alarm-calling behavior is favored by natural selection.

Common Pitfall: Do not simply compare bb and cc directly (0.22>0.080.22 > 0.08). Hamilton's rule requires devaluing the benefit bb by the genetic relatedness factor rr, because only a proportion of the recipient's genes are identical by descent to the caller's genes.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the roles of benefit and cost by applying the formula as rc - b > 0 instead of rb - c > 0, mistakenly concluding that the behavior is not favored.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Hamilton’s rule: rc−b>0  ⟹  (0.50)(0.08)−0.22=0.04−0.22=−0.18\text{Hamilton's rule: } rc - b > 0 \implies (0.50)(0.08) - 0.22 = 0.04 - 0.22 = -0.18

    Correct

    rb−c>0  ⟹  (0.50)(0.22)−0.08=0.11−0.08=+0.03rb - c > 0 \implies (0.50)(0.22) - 0.08 = 0.11 - 0.08 = +0.03

    Hamilton's rule is rb−c>0rb - c > 0 (or rb>crb > c). The coefficient of relatedness rr scales the reproductive benefit bb received by the relative, not the direct cost cc paid by the actor.

  2. Step 2

    Net benefit is −0.18, so the behavior is not favored.\text{Net benefit is } -0.18\text{, so the behavior is not favored.}

    Correct

    Net inclusive fitness change is +0.03>0, so the behavior is favored by natural selection.\text{Net inclusive fitness change is } +0.03 > 0\text{, so the behavior is favored by natural selection.}

    Because you swapped the variables in the first step and obtained a negative value, your conclusion that the behavior is not favored was an error propagated from that initial formula mistake.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly extracted the values for relatedness (r=0.50r = 0.50), cost (c=0.08c = 0.08), and benefit (b=0.22b = 0.22) from the problem text.

You accurately calculated the arithmetic result of the expression you wrote down.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variable placement / formula inversion

You multiplied the relatedness factor rr by the direct cost cc instead of the indirect benefit bb.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating direct fitness costs with indirect fitness benefits. In kin selection, the actor pays the direct cost cc in full, while the benefit bb enjoyed by kin must be discounted by rr because relatives share only a fraction of identical-by-descent alleles.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Assigning Relatedness in Hamilton's Rule
  • Hamilton's rule states that an altruistic gene increases in frequency when rb>crb > c (or rb−c>0rb - c > 0).

  • Always attach the relatedness coefficient rr to the beneficiary's benefit bb, and keep the actor's personal cost cc unscaled: Inclusive Fitness Change=rb−c\text{Inclusive Fitness Change} = r b - c.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write down the standard form of Hamilton's rule: rb−c>0rb - c > 0.

  2. Substitute the given parameters: (0.50)(0.22)−0.08(0.50)(0.22) - 0.08.

  3. Compute the discounted indirect benefit: 0.50×0.22=0.110.50 \times 0.22 = 0.11.

  4. Subtract the direct cost: 0.11−0.08=+0.030.11 - 0.08 = +0.03.

Final answer

Yes, the altruistic behavior is favored by natural selection; the net inclusive fitness benefit is +0.03+0.03.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize Hamilton's rule conceptually: Indirect Benefit (rb)>Direct Cost (c)\text{Indirect Benefit } (rb) > \text{Direct Cost } (c).

  • Practice identifying who pays the cost (the altruist, bearing 100%100\% of cc) versus who receives the benefit (the relative, sharing fraction rr of genes).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student weights the direct cost to the actor by the relatedness coefficient as well, mistakenly evaluating r(b - c) instead of rb - c.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Net benefit=r(b−c)  ⟹  0.50(0.22−0.08)  ⟹  0.50(0.14)=0.07\text{Net benefit} = r(b-c) \implies 0.50(0.22 - 0.08) \implies 0.50(0.14) = 0.07

    Correct

    Net benefit=rb−c=(0.50)(0.22)−0.08=0.11−0.08=+0.03\text{Net benefit} = r b - c = (0.50)(0.22) - 0.08 = 0.11 - 0.08 = +0.03

    You multiplied the relatedness coefficient rr by both the benefit and the cost. In Hamilton's rule, the actor incurs the direct fitness cost entirely (1⋅c1 \cdot c), while only the recipient's survival benefit is discounted by genetic relatedness (rbr b).

  2. Step 2

    0.07>00.07 > 0, so the net benefit is 0.070.07 and the behavior is favored.

    Correct

    Since +0.03>0+0.03 > 0, the net inclusive fitness benefit is +0.03+0.03 and the alarm-calling behavior is favored by natural selection.

    Your qualitative conclusion that the behavior is favored is correct, but your stated net inclusive fitness value of 0.070.07 reflects the calculation error from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly extracted the parameters r=0.50r = 0.50, b=0.22b = 0.22, and c=0.08c = 0.08 from the problem statement.

You correctly recognized that a positive net value means the altruistic behavior is favored by natural selection.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Hamilton's Rule Cost Weighting Misconception

You factored out rr across the entire expression (b−c)(b - c) instead of applying rr solely to the recipient's benefit bb.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing direct fitness costs with indirect fitness benefits in inclusive fitness theory. The actor is related to itself by rself=1.0r_{\text{self}} = 1.0, meaning the full direct cost cc is borne by the actor without discounting. Only the benefit bb received by the relative is scaled by the coefficient of relatedness rr.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Inclusive Fitness Formula
  • Δwinclusive=rb−c\Delta w_{\text{inclusive}} = r b - c, where rr scales the indirect benefit bb, and cc is the direct cost.

  • Always apply rr strictly to the recipient's benefit bb, leaving cc unscaled: rb−cr b - c, never r(b−c)r(b-c).

Genetic Perspective of Costs
  • An individual is genetically identical to itself (r=1r = 1), so direct survival or reproductive losses represent an undiscounted cost of 1⋅c1 \cdot c.

  • Verify that the actor's direct cost appears as −c-c in the net inclusive fitness calculation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the standard expression for net inclusive fitness: Δw=rb−c\Delta w = r b - c.

  2. Substitute the given values: Δw=(0.50)(0.22)−0.08\Delta w = (0.50)(0.22) - 0.08.

  3. Calculate the indirect benefit: (0.50)(0.22)=0.11(0.50)(0.22) = 0.11.

  4. Subtract the direct cost: 0.11−0.08=+0.030.11 - 0.08 = +0.03.

Final answer

The net inclusive fitness benefit is +0.03+0.03, and because +0.03>0+0.03 > 0, the behavior is favored by natural selection.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between direct fitness (impact on self, weighted by r=1r = 1) and indirect fitness (impact on kin, weighted by rr).

  • Practice setting up Hamilton's rule problems with multiple recipients or varying degrees of relatedness.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student neglects the coefficient of relatedness entirely by evaluating simple individual cost-benefit b - c, calculating a net benefit of 0.14.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Net benefit=b−c=0.22−0.08=0.14\text{Net benefit} = b - c = 0.22 - 0.08 = 0.14

    Correct

    Net inclusive fitness benefit=rb−c=(0.50)(0.22)−0.08=0.11−0.08=+0.03\text{Net inclusive fitness benefit} = r b - c = (0.50)(0.22) - 0.08 = 0.11 - 0.08 = +0.03

    Hamilton's rule accounts for kin selection by discounting the recipient's benefit (bb) by the coefficient of relatedness (rr). You omitted r=0.50r = 0.50, calculating b−cb - c instead of rb−cr b - c.

  2. Step 2

    0.14>0, so the net benefit is 0.14 and the behavior is favored.0.14 > 0\text{, so the net benefit is } 0.14 \text{ and the behavior is favored.}

    Correct

    +0.03>0, so the net inclusive fitness benefit is +0.03 and the behavior is favored.+0.03 > 0\text{, so the net inclusive fitness benefit is } +0.03 \text{ and the behavior is favored.}

    Your final qualitative conclusion that the behavior is favored is correct, but your stated net fitness benefit of 0.140.14 directly propagates the missing relatedness factor from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that positive net fitness indicates the behavior will be favored by natural selection.

You accurately subtracted the cost parameter from the benefit parameter in your arithmetic.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Relatedness Coefficient in Hamilton's Rule

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You evaluated altruism using an absolute individual cost-benefit difference (b−cb - c) rather than weighting the beneficiary's fitness gain by genetic relatedness (rb−cr b - c) to measure inclusive fitness.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Weighting Benefit by Relatedness
  • Hamilton's rule requires that the indirect fitness benefit to relatives be weighted by the coefficient of relatedness: Indirect benefit=rb\text{Indirect benefit} = r b.

  • Always multiply the recipient's benefit bb by the fraction of shared genes rr before subtracting the actor's direct cost cc.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write out Hamilton's rule: Net inclusive fitness change=rb−c\text{Net inclusive fitness change} = r b - c.

  2. Substitute the given parameters: r=0.50r = 0.50, b=0.22b = 0.22, and c=0.08c = 0.08.

  3. Calculate the indirect benefit: rb=(0.50)(0.22)=0.11r b = (0.50)(0.22) = 0.11.

  4. Subtract the direct cost: 0.11−0.08=+0.030.11 - 0.08 = +0.03.

  5. Since +0.03>0+0.03 > 0, the altruistic behavior is favored by natural selection.

Final answer

Yes, the behavior is favored; the net inclusive fitness benefit is +0.03+0.03.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the concept of inclusive fitness and understand why indirect fitness depends on genetic relatedness (rr).

  • Practice identifying whether a stated fitness change affects the actor directly (cc) or relatives indirectly (rbr b).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A Florida scrub jay helps its parents rear full siblings (r=0.50r = 0.50). Helping increases the total fledging success of the siblings by b=1.4b = 1.4 offspring, but costs the helper c=0.5c = 0.5 personal offspring due to delayed dispersal. According to Hamilton's rule, is helping behavior favored by natural selection?

Answer

Yes, helping behavior is favored. Net inclusive fitness change is rb−c=(0.50)(1.4)−0.5=0.7−0.5=+0.2>0rb - c = (0.50)(1.4) - 0.5 = 0.7 - 0.5 = +0.2 > 0.

02

A Belding's ground squirrel emits a trill alarm call to warn nearby first cousins (r=0.125r = 0.125). The call reduces the cousins' combined mortality risk by b=0.72b = 0.72, but increases the caller's mortality risk by c=0.11c = 0.11. Calculate the net inclusive fitness change and state whether selection favors calling.

Answer

No, calling is not favored. Net inclusive fitness change is rb−c=(0.125)(0.72)−0.11=0.09−0.11=−0.02<0rb - c = (0.125)(0.72) - 0.11 = 0.09 - 0.11 = -0.02 < 0.

03

In a social insect colony, a sterile worker can help raise full sisters (r=0.75r = 0.75) instead of producing her own offspring (r=0.50r = 0.50). If foregoing reproduction costs her 22 personal offspring (c=0.50×2=1.0c = 0.50 \times 2 = 1.0), what is the minimum benefit bb (in equivalent sibling offspring) she must help raise for this altruism to be favored?

Answer

b>1.33b > 1.33 sisters. Setting rsisterb>cdirectr_{\text{sister}} b > c_{\text{direct}} gives 0.75b>1.0  ⟹  b>1.00.75=43≈1.330.75 b > 1.0 \implies b > \frac{1.0}{0.75} = \frac{4}{3} \approx 1.33.

Loading workspace…