Resources
In fruit flies (), red eye color is an X-linked dominant trait determined by the allele , whereas white eye color is determined by the recessive allele . A homozygous red-eyed female is crossed with a white-eyed male to produce an generation. The individuals are then intercrossed to produce an generation. If flies are collected, calculate the expected number of: (a) red-eyed females, (b) white-eyed females, (c) red-eyed males, and (d) white-eyed males.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) red-eyed females, (b) white-eyed females, (c) red-eyed males, and (d) white-eyed males.
Steps
Determine the Genotypes of the Parental Generation ()
Eye color in Drosophila is an X-linked trait:
- Dominant allele (red eyes):
- Recessive allele (white eyes):
- Females have two X chromosomes (), while males have one X chromosome and one Y chromosome (). The Y chromosome does not carry an allele for eye color.
A homozygous red-eyed female has the genotype .
A white-eyed male has the genotype .
Determine the Generation
The female parent produces only gametes. The male parent produces and gametes in equal proportions.
- Female offspring: Receive from the mother and from the father (heterozygous red-eyed females).
- Male offspring: Receive from the mother and from the father (hemizygous red-eyed males).
Perform the Intercross to Find the Generation
The flies are intercrossed:
The gametes produced are:
- Female gametes: ,
- Male gametes: ,
Using a Punnett square:
The phenotypic breakdown of the offspring is:
- Red-eyed females: ()
- White-eyed females: ()
- Red-eyed males: ()
- White-eyed males: ()
Pitfall Alert: In X-linked inheritance, phenotypic ratios must be analyzed separately for each sex. Do not apply Mendelian autosomal ratios (such as a generic ratio ignoring sex), because males inherit their single X chromosome exclusively from their mother and show the phenotype of whatever allele is present on that X chromosome.
Calculate the Expected Counts out of Flies
Multiply each fraction by the total population of :
- (a) Red-eyed females:
- (b) White-eyed females:
- (c) Red-eyed males:
- (d) White-eyed males:
Typical errors
01 The student treats the eye color trait as autosomal instead of X-linked, resulting in a standard Mendelian 3:1 phenotypic ratio evenly split across sexes.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
The problem states that red eye color is X-linked. Females carry two X chromosomes () while males carry one X chromosome and one Y chromosome (). Consequently, all females receive from the mother and from the father (), whereas all males receive from the mother and from the father ().
- Step 2Correct
Because you modeled the cross as autosomal, you derived an overall ratio that does not account for sex-specific inheritance. In an X-linked cross between an female and an male, all female progeny receive a dominant allele from the father, meaning of females have red eyes and have white eyes.
- Step 3Correct
400, ; 0, ; 200, ; 200
Multiplying the autosomal fractions by 400 yielded incorrect final counts due to the initial autosomal modeling error.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that a total population of 800 flies divides evenly into 400 females and 400 males under standard sex determination.
You accurately executed Mendelian arithmetic for an autosomal monohybrid cross.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo, this is a conceptual misunderstanding of sex-linked inheritance rather than an arithmetic slip.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked the prompt's specification that the trait is X-linked and represented the cross with autosomal alleles ( and ). In hemizygous males (), the single X chromosome directly determines the phenotype because the Y chromosome carries no corresponding allele for eye color. In females, receiving an from the father ensures red eyes regardless of the maternal allele.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Sex Chromosome Accounting
Always write genotypes with sex chromosome notation (, , and ) for sex-linked genes.
Check whether a trait is described as X-linked before choosing allele symbols.
- Male Hemizygosity
Males inherit their X chromosome exclusively from their mother and their Y chromosome from their father.
Assign male genotypes as rather than homozygous or heterozygous pairs.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the parental genotypes using sex chromosomes: Female , Male .
Cross the parents to find : Females are (red-eyed) and males are (red-eyed).
Perform the cross: .
Construct the Punnett square gametes: Female contributes ; Male contributes .
Determine female offspring: of total flies (all 400 females have red eyes; 0 white eyes).
Determine male offspring: (200 red-eyed males) and (200 white-eyed males).
(a) 400 red-eyed females, (b) 0 white-eyed females, (c) 200 red-eyed males, (d) 200 white-eyed males
02 The student misidentifies the reciprocal cross by assuming the initial cross was between a white-eyed female (X^r X^r) and a red-eyed male (X^R Y).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
The problem states that the female parent is homozygous red-eyed () and the male parent is white-eyed (). You reversed these parental genotypes to , which represents the reciprocal cross and gives males the genotype instead of .
- Step 2Correct
Your Punnett square logic matches your genotypes, but because the true male is , all female offspring receive an allele from their father and are red-eyed.
- Step 3Correct
Your multiplication arithmetic was accurate, but the counts were calculated from the incorrect reciprocal phenotypic ratios.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly represented X-linked alleles on sex chromosomes rather than treating them as autosomal genes.
You accurately tracked allele segregation through gamete formation and Punnett square combinations.
You correctly converted offspring fractions into expected population counts out of flies.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally swapped the sexes of the parents when setting up the P generation, writing instead of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisIn X-linked inheritance, reciprocal crosses yield entirely different phenotypic patterns because males inherit their single X chromosome exclusively from their mother, so confusing parent-of-origin phenotypes leads to inverted generational ratios.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Match sex to phenotype before writing genotypes
In X-linked traits, females have two X chromosomes () and males have one X and one Y chromosome ().
Write out the parent labels explicitly (e.g., 'Mother: red-eyed homozygous ' and 'Father: white-eyed ') before writing the cross.
- Track the father's X contribution to daughters
Daughters inherit their father's only X chromosome.
In an intercross where the male is , confirm that all daughters inherit , making white-eyed females impossible in the generation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the true parental cross: homozygous red-eyed female () crossed with white-eyed male ().
Determine the generation: female gametes are all ; male gametes are and . Thus, consists of heterozygous red-eyed females () and hemizygous red-eyed males ().
Cross the individuals: .
Find female genotypes: (all red-eyed females, or of total flies). White-eyed females .
Find male genotypes: (red-eyed males, or of total flies) and (white-eyed males, or of total flies).
Multiply the phenotypic fractions by to get the counts.
(a) red-eyed females, (b) white-eyed females, (c) red-eyed males, and (d) white-eyed males.
03 The student confuses fractions of a specific sex with fractions of the total population, applying the 1/2 female ratio to 800 twice or multiplying the sex-specific 100% by 400 instead of calculating total counts correctly.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: females, males females: (100% red) males: (red), (white)
- Step 2
All females are flies Expected red-eyed females = , Expected white-eyed females =
- Step 3
Expected red-eyed males = Expected white-eyed males =
CorrectExpected red-eyed males = (or ) Expected white-eyed males = (or )
The fraction represents the proportion of males that are red-eyed or white-eyed, not the proportion of the entire population. Because males constitute only half of the flies ( flies), each male phenotype accounts for flies (or flies). Notice that your counts would total , which exceeds the total flies.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the parental and genotypes for this X-linked cross.
You accurately determined the within-sex phenotypic ratios for both females and males in the generation.
You correctly calculated the counts for red-eyed and white-eyed females by applying the sex ratio to the population.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally multiplied the male within-sex proportion of by the total population () rather than by the total number of males ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing within-sex conditional probabilities with overall population probabilities in sex-linked crosses.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Within-Sex vs. Whole-Population Probabilities
In a sex ratio, each sex represents of the total population. Therefore, .
Either multiply the within-sex fraction by the number of individuals of that sex, or use the 4-cell Punnett square fraction out of the total population.
- Total Population Sanity Check
The sum of all phenotypic subgroup counts must equal the given total sample size.
Add up your final counts: . If the sum exceeds the total, check whether a subpopulation fraction was applied to the entire group.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationTotal number of males = .
Expected red-eyed males = (or ).
Expected white-eyed males = (or ).
(a) red-eyed females, (b) white-eyed females, (c) red-eyed males, and (d) white-eyed males.
Lock it in
Why cannot a male fruit fly be heterozygous for an X-linked eye-color gene?
Males are hemizygous (); they carry only one X chromosome and therefore only one allele for any X-linked locus, while the Y chromosome carries none.
Similar question
A white-eyed female fruit fly () is crossed with a red-eyed male (). Out of total offspring, determine the expected number of red-eyed females, white-eyed females, red-eyed males, and white-eyed males.
Answer
red-eyed females, white-eyed females, red-eyed males, and white-eyed males. (All daughters inherit from the father and from the mother ; all sons inherit from the father and from the mother .)
In Drosophila, an red-eyed female () is backcrossed to her white-eyed father (). If offspring are produced, how many are expected to be white-eyed flies in total, and how are they distributed by sex?
Answer
white-eyed flies in total ( white-eyed females and white-eyed males). Females: (red), (white) white. Males: (red), (white) white.
In humans, red-green color blindness is an X-linked recessive trait (). A woman with normal vision whose father was color-blind marries a man with normal vision. If they have two sons and one daughter, what is the probability that both sons are color-blind and the daughter is a carrier?
Answer
. The mother's genotype is and the father's is . The probability of each son being color-blind () is . The probability of the daughter being a carrier () is . Since these events are independent, .