Resources

During the complete aerobic respiration of one molecule of glucose (C6H12O6\text{C}_6\text{H}_{12}\text{O}_6), cellular respiration proceeds through glycolysis, pyruvate oxidation, the citric acid cycle (Krebs cycle), and oxidative phosphorylation. Assuming standard biochemical stoichiometry (1 NADH→2.5 ATP1\text{ NADH} \to 2.5\text{ ATP} and 1 FADH2→1.5 ATP1\text{ FADH}_2 \to 1.5\text{ ATP} via the malate-aspartate shuttle in liver cells), calculate the total net yield of ATP produced per glucose molecule. Break down your calculation by specifying: (1) net substrate-level ATP from glycolysis, (2) net substrate-level ATP/GTP from the citric acid cycle, (3) total moles of NADH\text{NADH} and FADH2\text{FADH}_2 generated across all four stages, and (4) total ATP generated via oxidative phosphorylation.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Net substrate-level ATP from glycolysis = 2 ATP2\text{ ATP}; Net substrate-level ATP/GTP from the citric acid cycle = 2 ATP2\text{ ATP}; Total electron carriers = 10 NADH10\text{ NADH} (22 from glycolysis, 22 from pyruvate oxidation, 66 from the citric acid cycle) and 2 FADH22\text{ FADH}_2 (from the citric acid cycle); Total ATP from oxidative phosphorylation = (10×2.5)+(2×1.5)=25+3=28 ATP(10 \times 2.5) + (2 \times 1.5) = 25 + 3 = 28\text{ ATP}; Total net yield = 2+2+28=32 ATP2 + 2 + 28 = 32\text{ ATP}.

Steps

01

Glycolysis (Cytosol)

To determine the total net ATP\text{ATP} yield from the complete aerobic respiration of one glucose molecule (CX6HX12OX6\ce{C6H12O6}), we trace the carbon flow and energy carriers stage by stage.

Glycolysis breaks down 11 molecule of glucose into 22 molecules of pyruvate:

  • Substrate-level phosphorylation: Consumes 2 ATP2\text{ ATP} during the energy investment phase and produces 4 ATP4\text{ ATP} during the payoff phase: Net substrate-level ATP=4−2=2 ATP\text{Net substrate-level ATP} = 4 - 2 = 2\text{ ATP}
  • Electron carriers: Produces 2 NADH2\text{ NADH}.
02

Pyruvate Oxidation (Mitochondrial Matrix)

Each of the 22 pyruvate molecules is converted into acetyl-CoA\text{CoA}, producing:

  • Substrate-level phosphorylation: 0 ATP0\text{ ATP}.
  • Electron carriers: 2 NADH2\text{ NADH} (1 NADH1\text{ NADH} per pyruvate).
03

The Citric Acid Cycle / Krebs Cycle (Mitochondrial Matrix)

Two molecules of acetyl-CoA\text{CoA} enter the citric acid cycle (two turns per glucose molecule):

  • Substrate-level phosphorylation: Each turn generates 1 GTP1\text{ GTP} (energetically equivalent to ATP\text{ATP}): Net substrate-level ATP/GTP=2×1=2 ATP\text{Net substrate-level ATP/GTP} = 2 \times 1 = 2\text{ ATP}
  • Electron carriers: Each turn produces 3 NADH3\text{ NADH} and 1 FADH21\text{ FADH}_2, so two turns produce: 2×3=6 NADH2 \times 3 = 6\text{ NADH} 2×1=2 FADH22 \times 1 = 2\text{ FADH}_2
04

Summary of Electron Carriers

Adding up the reduced coenzymes across all stages:

  • Total NADH\text{NADH}: 2 (glycolysis)+2 (pyruvate oxidation)+6 (citric acid cycle)=10 NADH2\text{ (glycolysis)} + 2\text{ (pyruvate oxidation)} + 6\text{ (citric acid cycle)} = 10\text{ NADH}
  • Total FADH2\text{FADH}_2: 2 (citric acid cycle)=2 FADH22\text{ (citric acid cycle)} = 2\text{ FADH}_2
05

Oxidative Phosphorylation

Using the standard modern stoichiometry where each NADH\text{NADH} yields 2.5 ATP2.5\text{ ATP} (with cytosolic NADH\text{NADH} transported via the malate-aspartate shuttle) and each FADH2\text{FADH}_2 yields 1.5 ATP1.5\text{ ATP}:

  • From 10 NADH10\text{ NADH}: 10×2.5=25 ATP10 \times 2.5 = 25\text{ ATP}
  • From 2 FADH22\text{ FADH}_2: 2×1.5=3 ATP2 \times 1.5 = 3\text{ ATP}
  • Total ATP from oxidative phosphorylation: 25+3=28 ATP25 + 3 = 28\text{ ATP}

Total Net ATP Yield

Summing substrate-level phosphorylation and oxidative phosphorylation: Total Net ATP=2 (glycolysis)+2 (citric acid cycle)+28 (oxidative phosphorylation)=32 ATP\text{Total Net ATP} = 2\text{ (glycolysis)} + 2\text{ (citric acid cycle)} + 28\text{ (oxidative phosphorylation)} = 32\text{ ATP}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the electron carrier yield for only one turn of the citric acid cycle instead of two per glucose molecule, resulting in an undercount of NADH and FADH2 and lower oxidative phosphorylation yield.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    4 ATP produced−2 ATP invested=2 net ATP4\text{ ATP produced} - 2\text{ ATP invested} = 2\text{ net ATP}

  2. Step 2

    1 glucose gives 2 acetyl-CoA  ⟹  2 turns×1 ATP=2 ATP1\text{ glucose gives } 2\text{ acetyl-CoA} \implies 2\text{ turns} \times 1\text{ ATP} = 2\text{ ATP}

  3. Step 3

    Glycolysis: 2 NADH  ⟹  Pyruvate oxidation: 2 NADH  ⟹  Citric acid cycle: 3 NADH and 1 FADH2  ⟹  Total NADH=2+2+3=7 NADH  ⟹  Total FADH2=1 FADH2\text{Glycolysis: } 2\text{ NADH} \implies \text{Pyruvate oxidation: } 2\text{ NADH} \implies \text{Citric acid cycle: } 3\text{ NADH and } 1\text{ FADH}_2 \implies \text{Total NADH} = 2 + 2 + 3 = 7\text{ NADH} \implies \text{Total FADH}_2 = 1\text{ FADH}_2

    Correct

    Citric acid cycle: 2×3 NADH=6 NADH,2×1 FADH2=2 FADH2  ⟹  Total NADH=2+2+6=10 NADH,Total FADH2=2 FADH2\text{Citric acid cycle: } 2 \times 3\text{ NADH} = 6\text{ NADH}, 2 \times 1\text{ FADH}_2 = 2\text{ FADH}_2 \implies \text{Total NADH} = 2 + 2 + 6 = 10\text{ NADH}, \text{Total FADH}_2 = 2\text{ FADH}_2

    While you factored in two turns of the citric acid cycle for substrate-level phosphorylation, you listed the electron carrier yield for only one turn (3 NADH3\text{ NADH} and 1 FADH21\text{ FADH}_2) rather than multiplying by two for both acetyl-CoA molecules.

  4. Step 4

    7 NADH×2.5 ATP=17.5 ATP  ⟹  1 FADH2×1.5 ATP=1.5 ATP  ⟹  Total oxidative phosphorylation=17.5+1.5=19 ATP7\text{ NADH} \times 2.5\text{ ATP} = 17.5\text{ ATP} \implies 1\text{ FADH}_2 \times 1.5\text{ ATP} = 1.5\text{ ATP} \implies \text{Total oxidative phosphorylation} = 17.5 + 1.5 = 19\text{ ATP}

    Correct

    (10×2.5 ATP)+(2×1.5 ATP)=25+3=28 ATP(10 \times 2.5\text{ ATP}) + (2 \times 1.5\text{ ATP}) = 25 + 3 = 28\text{ ATP}

    You applied the conversion factors (2.5 ATP/NADH2.5\text{ ATP/NADH} and 1.5 ATP/FADH21.5\text{ ATP/FADH}_2) correctly, but the result was lower than expected due to the carrier count from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly accounted for the two-turn multiplier when finding substrate-level ATP in the citric acid cycle.

You used the correct stoichiometric conversion factors of 2.5 ATP per NADH2.5\text{ ATP per NADH} and 1.5 ATP per FADH21.5\text{ ATP per FADH}_2 for oxidative phosphorylation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Stoichiometric Under-counting in Multi-Turn Pathways

You knew that one glucose yields two turns of the citric acid cycle, but you recorded carrier yields for only a single turn.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Failing to systematically carry the per-glucose stoichiometric factor of 2 through all outputs of the citric acid cycle, leading to an isolated calculation of one turn for electron carriers.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Per-Turn vs. Per-Glucose Accounting
  • Every turn of the citric acid cycle processes 11 acetyl-CoA, producing 3 NADH3\text{ NADH}, 1 FADH21\text{ FADH}_2, and 1 ATP/GTP1\text{ ATP/GTP}. Because 1 glucose→2 acetyl-CoA1\text{ glucose} \to 2\text{ acetyl-CoA}, every yield must be multiplied by 22.

  • Whenever calculating yields per glucose molecule, multiply each citric acid cycle intermediate product by 22 turns.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Citric acid cycle yields per glucose (2 turns2\text{ turns}): 2×3=6 NADH2 \times 3 = 6\text{ NADH} and 2×1=2 FADH22 \times 1 = 2\text{ FADH}_2.

  2. Total carriers across all stages: NADH=2 (glycolysis)+2 (pyruvate oxidation)+6 (citric acid cycle)=10 NADH\text{NADH} = 2\text{ (glycolysis)} + 2\text{ (pyruvate oxidation)} + 6\text{ (citric acid cycle)} = 10\text{ NADH}; FADH2=2 FADH2\text{FADH}_2 = 2\text{ FADH}_2.

  3. Oxidative phosphorylation yield: (10×2.5)+(2×1.5)=25+3=28 ATP(10 \times 2.5) + (2 \times 1.5) = 25 + 3 = 28\text{ ATP}.

  4. Total net ATP yield: 2 (glycolysis)+2 (citric acid cycle)+28 (oxidative phosphorylation)=32 ATP2\text{ (glycolysis)} + 2\text{ (citric acid cycle)} + 28\text{ (oxidative phosphorylation)} = 32\text{ ATP}.

Final answer

Net substrate-level ATP = 4 ATP4\text{ ATP} (22 from glycolysis, 22 from the citric acid cycle); Total electron carriers = 10 NADH10\text{ NADH} and 2 FADH22\text{ FADH}_2; Total oxidative phosphorylation = 28 ATP28\text{ ATP}; Total net yield = 32 ATP32\text{ ATP}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Create a summary balance table with columns for each stage and rows for substrate-level ATP, NADH, and FADH2.

  • Highlight the 'per glucose' factor of 2 before entering the citric acid cycle to avoid computing single-turn values.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the net ATP yield of glycolysis with the gross yield by ignoring the two ATP invested in the preparatory phase.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Energy payoff phase produces 4 ATP  ⟹  Net ATP=4 ATP\text{Energy payoff phase produces } 4\text{ ATP} \implies \text{Net ATP} = 4\text{ ATP}

    Correct

    Net substrate-level ATP=4 ATP (produced)−2 ATP (invested)=2 ATP\text{Net substrate-level ATP} = 4\text{ ATP (produced)} - 2\text{ ATP (invested)} = 2\text{ ATP}

    You correctly noted that the energy payoff phase produces 4 ATP4\text{ ATP}, but you crossed out the correct net yield of 2 ATP2\text{ ATP}. Glycolysis consumes 2 ATP2\text{ ATP} during the energy investment phase, so the net ATP yield is 4−2=2 ATP4 - 2 = 2\text{ ATP}.

  2. Step 2

    2 acetyl-CoA enter cycle  ⟹  2×1 GTP=2 ATP2\text{ acetyl-CoA enter cycle} \implies 2 \times 1\text{ GTP} = 2\text{ ATP}

  3. Step 3

    Glycolysis: 2 NADH\text{Glycolysis: } 2\text{ NADH}; Pyruvate oxidation: 2 NADH\text{Pyruvate oxidation: } 2\text{ NADH}; Citric acid cycle: 6 NADH and 2 FADH2  ⟹  Total NADH=10 NADH,Total FADH2=2 FADH2\text{Citric acid cycle: } 6\text{ NADH and } 2\text{ FADH}_2 \implies \text{Total NADH} = 10\text{ NADH}, \text{Total FADH}_2 = 2\text{ FADH}_2

  4. Step 4

    10×2.5 ATP=25 ATP10 \times 2.5\text{ ATP} = 25\text{ ATP}, 2×1.5 ATP=3 ATP  ⟹  Total oxidative phosphorylation=25+3=28 ATP2 \times 1.5\text{ ATP} = 3\text{ ATP} \implies \text{Total oxidative phosphorylation} = 25 + 3 = 28\text{ ATP}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the energy payoff phase of glycolysis produces 4 ATP4\text{ ATP}.

You accounted for two turns of the citric acid cycle per glucose molecule to find 2 ATP2\text{ ATP} of substrate-level phosphorylation.

You tracked all 10 NADH10\text{ NADH} and 2 FADH22\text{ FADH}_2 molecules across every stage.

You applied the standard 2.5 ATP/NADH2.5\text{ ATP/NADH} and 1.5 ATP/FADH21.5\text{ ATP/FADH}_2 ratios accurately to obtain 28 ATP28\text{ ATP} from oxidative phosphorylation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Gross vs. Net Yield Confusion in Glycolysis

You originally wrote the correct net yield of 2 ATP2\text{ ATP}, but crossed it out in favor of the gross production of 4 ATP4\text{ ATP}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You equated the gross ATP generated during the energy payoff phase with the net ATP yield of glycolysis, forgetting to deduct the two ATP molecules invested in phosphorylation during the preparatory phase.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Net vs. Gross Glycolysis ATP
  • Net ATP=Gross ATP produced−ATP invested\text{Net ATP} = \text{Gross ATP produced} - \text{ATP invested}

  • Always subtract the 2 ATP2\text{ ATP} used by hexokinase and phosphofructokinase from the 4 ATP4\text{ ATP} formed by substrate-level phosphorylation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the true net yield of glycolysis: 4 ATP (payoff)−2 ATP (investment)=2 ATP4\text{ ATP (payoff)} - 2\text{ ATP (investment)} = 2\text{ ATP}.

  2. Add the net contributions from all stages: 2 ATP (glycolysis)+2 ATP (citric acid cycle)+28 ATP (oxidative phosphorylation)2\text{ ATP (glycolysis)} + 2\text{ ATP (citric acid cycle)} + 28\text{ ATP (oxidative phosphorylation)}.

Final answer

Total Net ATP=32 ATP\text{Total Net ATP} = 32\text{ ATP}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the two ATP-consuming reactions of the energy investment phase of glycolysis (catalyzed by hexokinase and PFK-1).

  • Always sum the substrate-level ATP and oxidative phosphorylation yields at the end to state the final total net yield.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student omits the two NADH generated during pyruvate oxidation when summing the total electron carriers.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    4 ATP produced−2 ATP invested=2 net ATP\text{4 ATP produced} - \text{2 ATP invested} = 2\text{ net ATP}

  2. Step 2

    2 acetyl-CoA×1 ATP=2 ATP2\text{ acetyl-CoA} \times 1\text{ ATP} = 2\text{ ATP}

  3. Step 3

    Glycolysis: 2 NADH  ⟹  Citric acid cycle: 6 NADH and 2 FADH2  ⟹  Total NADH=2+6=8 NADH, Total FADH2=2 FADH2\text{Glycolysis: } 2\text{ NADH} \implies \text{Citric acid cycle: } 6\text{ NADH and } 2\text{ FADH}_2 \implies \text{Total NADH} = 2 + 6 = 8\text{ NADH}, \text{ Total FADH}_2 = 2\text{ FADH}_2

    Correct

    Total NADH=2 (glycolysis)+2 (pyruvate oxidation)+6 (citric acid cycle)=10 NADH;Total FADH2=2 FADH2\text{Total NADH} = 2\text{ (glycolysis)} + 2\text{ (pyruvate oxidation)} + 6\text{ (citric acid cycle)} = 10\text{ NADH}; \quad \text{Total FADH}_2 = 2\text{ FADH}_2

    You omitted the pyruvate oxidation stage (the link reaction). Converting 22 molecules of pyruvate into 22 molecules of acetyl-CoA produces an additional 2 NADH2\text{ NADH}, so the correct total is 10 NADH10\text{ NADH} rather than 8 NADH8\text{ NADH}.

  4. Step 4

    8 NADH×2.5 ATP=20 ATP  ⟹  2 FADH2×1.5 ATP=3 ATP  ⟹  Total oxidative phosphorylation=20+3=23 ATP8\text{ NADH} \times 2.5\text{ ATP} = 20\text{ ATP} \implies 2\text{ FADH}_2 \times 1.5\text{ ATP} = 3\text{ ATP} \implies \text{Total oxidative phosphorylation} = 20 + 3 = 23\text{ ATP}

    Correct

    Total ATP from oxidative phosphorylation=(10×2.5)+(2×1.5)=25+3=28 ATP\text{Total ATP from oxidative phosphorylation} = (10 \times 2.5) + (2 \times 1.5) = 25 + 3 = 28\text{ ATP}

    Your conversion factors (2.5 ATP/NADH2.5\text{ ATP/NADH} and 1.5 ATP/FADH21.5\text{ ATP/FADH}_2) were applied correctly, but the total ATP is underestimated because of the missing 2 NADH2\text{ NADH} from Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the net substrate-level ATP from both glycolysis and the citric acid cycle.

You accurately identified the yield of electron carriers produced directly in the citric acid cycle as 6 NADH6\text{ NADH} and 2 FADH22\text{ FADH}_2.

You applied the correct stoichiometric P/O ratios of 2.5 ATP per NADH2.5\text{ ATP per NADH} and 1.5 ATP per FADH21.5\text{ ATP per FADH}_2 during oxidative phosphorylation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of intermediate metabolic stage

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You skipped the transition step (pyruvate oxidation) between cytosolic glycolysis and the mitochondrial citric acid cycle, forgetting that each of the two pyruvate molecules produces one molecule of NADH during decarboxylation to acetyl-CoA.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Account for all four stages
  • Aerobic respiration consists of four distinct stages: (1) Glycolysis, (2) Pyruvate Oxidation, (3) Citric Acid Cycle, and (4) Oxidative Phosphorylation.

  • Always verify that you have inventoried the reduced coenzymes from the intermediate link reaction (2 pyruvate→2 acetyl-CoA+2 CO2+2 NADH2\text{ pyruvate} \to 2\text{ acetyl-CoA} + 2\text{ CO}_2 + 2\text{ NADH}) before summing total NADH.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Include pyruvate oxidation: 2 pyruvate→2 acetyl-CoA+2 CO2+2 NADH2\text{ pyruvate} \to 2\text{ acetyl-CoA} + 2\text{ CO}_2 + 2\text{ NADH}.

  2. Recalculate total NADH\text{NADH}: 2 (glycolysis)+2 (pyruvate oxidation)+6 (citric acid cycle)=10 NADH2\text{ (glycolysis)} + 2\text{ (pyruvate oxidation)} + 6\text{ (citric acid cycle)} = 10\text{ NADH}.

  3. Recalculate ATP from oxidative phosphorylation: (10×2.5)+(2×1.5)=25+3=28 ATP(10 \times 2.5) + (2 \times 1.5) = 25 + 3 = 28\text{ ATP}.

  4. Sum all contributions: 2 (net glycolysis)+2 (citric acid cycle)+28 (oxidative phosphorylation)=32 ATP2\text{ (net glycolysis)} + 2\text{ (citric acid cycle)} + 28\text{ (oxidative phosphorylation)} = 32\text{ ATP}.

Final answer

Total net ATP yield = 32 ATP32\text{ ATP} (2 net ATP2\text{ net ATP} from glycolysis, 2 ATP2\text{ ATP} from the citric acid cycle, and 28 ATP28\text{ ATP} from oxidative phosphorylation via 10 NADH10\text{ NADH} and 2 FADH22\text{ FADH}_2).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Create a 4-row tracking table listing Glycolysis, Pyruvate Oxidation, Krebs Cycle, and Oxidative Phosphorylation whenever solving respiration stoichiometry problems.

  • Practice tracking carbon number transitions (6C→2×3C→2×2C→released CO26\text{C} \to 2 \times 3\text{C} \to 2 \times 2\text{C} \to \text{released } \text{CO}_2) to ensure no intermediate steps are skipped.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

If a cell metabolizes 33 molecules of glucose completely via aerobic respiration, how many molecules of FADH2\text{FADH}_2 and citric acid cycle-derived NADH\text{NADH} are produced?

Answer

6 FADH26\text{ FADH}_2 and 18 NADH18\text{ NADH}. Each glucose results in 22 turns of the citric acid cycle (66 turns total for 33 glucose). Carrier yields: 6×1 FADH2=6 FADH26 \times 1\text{ FADH}_2 = 6\text{ FADH}_2 and 6×3 NADH=18 NADH6 \times 3\text{ NADH} = 18\text{ NADH}.

02

A cell utilizes the glycerol-3-phosphate shuttle instead of the malate-aspartate shuttle in skeletal muscle, causing cytosolic NADH\text{NADH} from glycolysis to yield 1.5 ATP1.5\text{ ATP} each instead of 2.5 ATP2.5\text{ ATP}. Assuming all other steps proceed normally, calculate the new total net ATP\text{ATP} yield per glucose molecule.

Answer

30 ATP30\text{ ATP}. The 2 NADH2\text{ NADH} from glycolysis yield 2×1.5=3 ATP2 \times 1.5 = 3\text{ ATP} instead of 5 ATP5\text{ ATP} (a reduction of 2 ATP2\text{ ATP}). Total yield decreases from 32 ATP32\text{ ATP} to 32−2=30 ATP32 - 2 = 30\text{ ATP}.

03

Suppose a mutant cell line completely blocks pyruvate oxidation, preventing pyruvate from entering mitochondria. Under aerobic conditions where glycolysis still runs, what is the net ATP\text{ATP} yield per glucose molecule produced solely by substrate-level phosphorylation?

Answer

2 ATP2\text{ ATP}. Without pyruvate entry into the mitochondria, the citric acid cycle cannot run, yielding 0 ATP0\text{ ATP}. Glycolysis produces a net of 2 ATP2\text{ ATP} via substrate-level phosphorylation (4 ATP synthesized−2 ATP invested4\text{ ATP synthesized} - 2\text{ ATP invested}).

Loading workspace…