Resources
In maize (a diploid organism with ), gene (aleurone color, alleles and ) and gene (plant height, alleles and ) are situated on the same autosome (Chromosome ), separated by a genetic map distance of (map units). A dihybrid plant with the cis (coupling) linkage conformation undergoes gametogenesis. (a) Distinguish between the terms 'homologous chromosomes' and 'sister chromatids' during prophase I of meiosis in this plant. (b) Calculate the expected theoretical percentage of gametes produced that will contain the recombinant chromosome allele combination . (c) If this plant is test-crossed to a homozygous recessive individual (), what proportion of the progeny will display the recombinant phenotype associated with genotype ?
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Homologous chromosomes are maternal and paternal chromosome pairs with the same genes at identical loci but potentially different alleles; sister chromatids are identical duplicated copies of a single chromosome joined at the centromere; (b) ; (c) (or ).
Steps
Part (a): Distinguishing Homologous Chromosomes and Sister Chromatids
During prophase I of meiosis:
- Homologous chromosomes are pairs of chromosomes—one inherited from the maternal parent and one from the paternal parent—that have the same length, centromere position, and carry the same gene loci in the same order. However, they may carry different alleles at those loci (for example, one homolog carries alleles and , while the other carries and ). During prophase I, they pair up to form bivalents (tetrads).
- Sister chromatids are the two identical copies of a single replicated chromosome produced during the S phase of interphase. They share identical DNA sequences (identical alleles at all loci) and remain joined together at the centromere until anaphase II.
Common Pitfall: Crossing over occurs between non-sister chromatids of homologous chromosomes, not between sister chromatids, which generates genetic variation.
Part (b): Calculating the Percentage of Gametes
- Relate map distance to recombinant frequency: A genetic map distance of corresponds to a recombination frequency of . Therefore, a map distance of between gene and gene means:
-
Identify parental and recombinant gamete types: The dihybrid parent is in the cis (coupling) conformation, .
- Parental (non-recombinant) gametes: and
- Recombinant gametes: and
- Calculate the proportion of each recombinant class: Recombination generates the two recombinant classes in equal proportions:
Part (c): Determining the Proportion of Test-Cross Progeny
- Understand the test-cross: The dihybrid is crossed with a homozygous recessive tester : The tester individual contributes only recessive alleles () with a probability of ().
- Determine the progeny genotype frequency: The phenotype and genotype of each offspring are determined entirely by the gamete contributed by the dihybrid parent:
Typical errors
01 The student forgets to divide the total recombination frequency between the two reciprocal recombinant gamete classes, equating the frequency of a single recombinant gamete directly to the full map distance.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homologous chromosomes are parental chromosome pairs carrying the same gene loci. Sister chromatids are two identical copies of a replicated chromosome attached at the centromere.
- Step 2
Recombinant frequency $= 18.0 = 18.0% Ab = 18.0%
CorrectA map distance of represents the total frequency of all recombinant gametes combined ( and ). Because crossing over produces both reciprocal recombinant classes in equal frequencies, each recombinant class represents half of the total recombination frequency: .
- Step 3
Testcross progeny genotype Ab/ab frequency equals the Ab gamete frequency. Ab/ab = 18.0%
CorrectP = P(Ab) 1.0 = 0.090 9.0%
Your reasoning that the testcross progeny frequency equals the dihybrid parent's gamete frequency is completely sound, but the final value was affected by the unpartitioned recombinant percentage from the previous step.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly distinguished homologous chromosomes from sister chromatids with accurate biological terminology.
You correctly converted the genetic map distance in centimorgans directly to total recombination frequency percentage.
You correctly established that the frequency of testcross offspring genotypes directly mirrors the gamete frequencies of the heterozygous parent.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the total recombinant frequency as the proportion of one specific recombinant gamete type, overlooking that crossing over produces two reciprocal recombinant products in equal amounts.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Partition Total Recombinant Frequency
For linked genes with two alleles each, .
Always identify both reciprocal recombinant genotypes and divide the total recombination frequency by to find the expected percentage of each.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the parental gamete types from the cis conformation : and .
Identify the two reciprocal recombinant gamete types: and .
Divide the total recombination frequency () equally between the two recombinant types: .
Determine testcross progeny frequency: (or ).
(a) Homologous chromosomes are maternal and paternal chromosome pairs with the same genes at identical loci; sister chromatids are identical duplicated copies of a single chromosome joined at the centromere; (b) ; (c) (or )
02 The student assumes independent assortment of 25% per recombinant class instead of using the given map distance for linked genes.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homologous chromosomes are paired maternal and paternal chromosomes sharing gene loci. Sister chromatids are identical duplicated strands joined at a single centromere.
- Step 2
Dihybrid produces four gamete classes : , , , . Frequency of gametes =
CorrectBecause genes and are linked on Chromosome 3 at a map distance of , they do not assort independently. The total recombinant frequency is , which is shared equally between the two recombinant gamete types ( and ), giving for .
- Step 3
In a testcross, each of the four phenotypic classes appears with equal probability. Proportion of progeny =
CorrectYour calculation followed logically from your gamete frequency, but because the genes are linked, the test-cross progeny proportions reflect the linked gametic frequencies rather than a ratio.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou accurately distinguished homologous chromosomes from sister chromatids.
You correctly identified that the tester contributes only recessive alleles in a test-cross.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou applied Mendel's Law of Independent Assortment (which yields equal gamete frequencies) to syntenic genes on the same chromosome, ignoring the given genetic map distance ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Map Distance and Recombination
Check whether genes are linked on the same chromosome. If they are, use the map distance to find the total recombinant frequency rather than assuming total recombinants.
- Splitting Recombinant Classes
Total recombinant frequency is split equally between the two reciprocal recombinant gamete types.
Divide the total recombinant frequency by to find the expected proportion of a specific recombinant gamete class.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationNote that corresponds to a total recombination frequency of .
Identify parental classes (, ) totaling ( each).
Identify recombinant classes (, ) totaling , giving each.
Apply the gamete frequency to the test-cross: the proportion of progeny equals (or ).
(a) Homologous chromosomes share gene loci but may carry different alleles; sister chromatids are identical copies joined at the centromere; (b) ; (c) (or $9.0%).
03 The student subtracts the map distance from 100% to calculate parental gamete frequency and then divides that by 2, mistaking the recombinant class Ab for a parental gamete class.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homologous chromosomes are non-identical matching chromosomes from each parent. ⟹ Sister chromatids are identical replicated chromatids joined at the centromere.
- Step 2
Recombination frequency = ⟹ Non-recombinant frequency = ⟹ Frequency of
CorrectRecombinant gametes ( and ) total . Therefore, the frequency of gamete .
Because the dihybrid is in coupling (cis) conformation , the non-recombinant (parental) gametes are and , while is a recombinant gamete. You calculated the parental frequency () instead of dividing the recombination frequency () by .
- Step 3
Proportion of matches the frequency of the from the dihybrid. ⟹ Proportion of
CorrectProportion of
Your reasoning that the test-cross offspring ratio directly mirrors the gamete frequency from the dihybrid parent is correct, but the final value was affected by the mistake in part (b).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly defined and contrasted homologous chromosomes with sister chromatids.
You correctly recognized that a map distance of corresponds to an recombination frequency.
You correctly identified that test-cross progeny proportions match the gamete frequencies produced by the heterozygous parent.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou misclassified the gamete genotype as non-recombinant (parental) rather than recombinant for a cis dihybrid , leading you to divide the non-recombinant frequency () by instead of the recombination frequency ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify Parental vs. Recombinant Gametes
For linkage phase (cis/coupling), the parental chromosomes are and . Any gamete carrying a mix of alleles from different homologs ( or ) is recombinant.
Always write down the two original parental chromosome genotypes first before assigning frequencies to specific gamete genotypes.
- Allocate Map Distance to Recombinants
The total recombination frequency equals the map distance in . Each individual recombinant gamete type occurs at a frequency of .
Divide the map distance directly by to find the expected proportion of a single recombinant gamete class.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the parental alleles from the cis conformation : Parental gametes are and ; recombinant gametes are and .
Use the map distance of as the total recombination frequency: .
Divide by to obtain the frequency for the single recombinant class : .
Multiply by the tester's contribution () to determine the test-cross progeny frequency: (or ).
(a) Homologous chromosomes are maternal and paternal chromosome pairs with the same gene loci; sister chromatids are identical replicated copies joined at the centromere. (b) . (c) (or ).
Lock it in
How does map distance in centimorgans (cM) relate to the frequency of an individual recombinant gamete class?
Map distance equals the total percentage of all recombinants combined; each of the two reciprocal recombinant classes is .
Similar question
In tomato plants, gene (tall stem) and gene (smooth fruit) are linked on chromosome 2 at a distance of . A dihybrid plant with linkage arrangement is test-crossed to a homozygous recessive tester . What percentage of the progeny is expected to be dwarf with smooth fruit (genotype )?
Answer
. The allele combination is recombinant. Total recombination frequency is , so the frequency of the gamete is . Because the tester contributes with probability , the expected proportion of progeny is .
In Drosophila melanogaster, gene (curved wings) and gene (striped thorax) are linked on an autosome separated by . A female fly has repulsion (trans) linkage: . If this female is crossed to a homozygous recessive male (), what proportion of the progeny will exhibit the wild-type phenotype for both traits (genotype )?
Answer
. With repulsion linkage , the parental gametes are and , while the recombinant gametes are and . The total recombination frequency is , so the proportion of recombinant gamete is , yielding (or ) wild-type testcross progeny.
A plant of genotype ( apart) is crossed with a plant of genotype ( apart, repulsion/heterozygous tester). What proportion of the resulting progeny will have the completely homozygous recessive genotype ?
Answer
. For parent 1 (), gamete is parental: . For parent 2 (), gamete is recombinant: . The probability of receiving from both parents is , or .