Resources
A complex pedigree investigation examines the inheritance of non-syndromic sensorineural deafness. In Family , two deaf parents (Individual and Individual ), each originating from separate multi-generation pedigrees where deafness is inherited as a classic autosomal recessive trait with complete penetrance, have six biological children. Strikingly, all six children (three sons and three daughters) possess completely normal hearing. Assuming no non-paternity, new germline mutations, or epigenetic silencing, (a) identify the genetic phenomenon responsible for this phenotypic outcome, and (b) state the expected proportion of deaf offspring from a cross between two individuals who are both double heterozygotes () for these two complementary loci.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Locus heterogeneity (or genetic complementation); (b) (or )
Steps
Part (a): Identifying the Genetic Phenomenon
-
Analyze the Parental Genotypes:
- Both parents are deaf due to an autosomal recessive condition with complete penetrance. If deafness were caused by mutations at the exact same genetic locus (allelic), both parents would have the same homozygous recessive genotype (e.g., ).
- A cross of must produce deaf children (). However, all six children have completely normal hearing.
-
Deduce the Mechanism (Complementation and Locus Heterogeneity):
- Normal hearing requires functional products from multiple genes involved in the auditory pathway.
- Each parent is homozygous recessive for a mutation at a different gene locus:
- Each parent contributes a normal dominant allele for the gene that is defective in the other parent. Therefore, all offspring have the genotype .
- Because the offspring carry at least one functional wild-type allele at both loci ( and ), normal hearing is restored.
- This phenomenon where identical phenotypes are caused by mutations in different genes is called locus heterogeneity, and the restoration of a wild-type phenotype by combining two different recessive mutations is called genetic complementation.
Part (b): Calculating the Proportion of Deaf Offspring from a Dihybrid Cross
-
Determine the Cross:
- Two double heterozygotes are mated:
-
Determine the Phenotypic Requirement:
- Normal hearing requires at least one dominant allele at both loci ().
- A deaf phenotype results if an individual is homozygous recessive at locus (), locus (), or both ().
-
Calculate Probabilities Using Independent Assortment:
- For locus : ,
- For locus : ,
- Probability of having normal hearing ():
- Probability of deafness (complementary gene interaction):
Thus, the expected proportion of deaf offspring is (or ).
Typical errors
01 The student confuses complementation with incomplete dominance, treating the wild-type offspring as intermediate heterozygotes and predicting a simple monohybrid 1/4 recessive ratio.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Because both parents have a confirmed autosomal recessive condition with complete penetrance, a single-locus model () would yield deaf children. Having all hearing offspring reveals that the parents carry homozygous recessive mutations at different gene loci (), so each parent supplies a wild-type allele that complements the other.
- Step 2Correct
You treated the dihybrid cross as a simple monohybrid recessive trait (). In complementary gene interaction, normal hearing requires at least one functional dominant allele at both loci (), so an individual homozygous recessive at locus (), locus (), or both () will be deaf, giving a deaf proportion of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly noted the dihybrid genotype cross specified in part (b).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the offspring as intermediate heterozygotes for a single gene rather than complementary dihybrids across two separate genes.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked that identical recessive phenotypes arising in separate pedigrees can be caused by mutations at different gene loci (locus heterogeneity). When two such individuals reproduce, their offspring inherit functional wild-type alleles at both loci, restoring the wild-type phenotype via genetic complementation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Two Recessive Parents Yielding Wild-Type Offspring
If two individuals with the same recessive phenotype mate and have wild-type offspring, the mutations reside in different genes (complementation), not the same gene.
Check whether the parents are homozygous mutant at different loci ( and ) rather than heterozygous intermediates.
- Dihybrid Complementary Gene Interaction Ratio
When a phenotype requires a dominant allele at both loci (), the wild-type ratio is and the mutant ratio is ().
Calculate the wild-type proportion first as , then subtract from to find the mutant proportion.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that each deaf parent is homozygous recessive at a distinct locus: and .
Combine their gametes ( and ) to produce double-heterozygous offspring (), demonstrating genetic complementation due to locus heterogeneity.
For the cross , calculate the probability of normal hearing (): .
Determine the deaf fraction by subtracting normal offspring from the total: .
(a) Locus heterogeneity (or genetic complementation); (b) (or )
02 The student correctly identifies complementation but calculates the proportion of hearing offspring with at least one dominant allele at both loci (9/16) instead of the deaf offspring.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Complementation ⟹ Parents have mutations in different genes: gives children with normal hearing
- Step 2
dihybrid cross ⟹ Hearing requires
- Step 3
Deaf proportion
Correct(or )
You set the deaf proportion equal to the hearing proportion (). Because deafness occurs when an individual is homozygous recessive at locus (), locus (), or both (), the deaf fraction is the complement: .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified genetic complementation as the phenomenon explaining normal-hearing children from deaf parents.
You accurately modeled the dihybrid cross and calculated that of the offspring inherit the genotype.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou crossed out the correct fraction and replaced it with , confusing the proportion of hearing offspring with the proportion of deaf offspring.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating the wild-type phenotype probability () with the mutant/affected phenotype in a complementary gene interaction, overlooking that any recessive homozygous pair (, , or ) results in deafness.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Phenotype-to-Genotype Mapping
In complementary gene action ( ratio), gives the normal phenotype, while , , and all exhibit the mutant phenotype.
Always verify whether the question asks for the wild-type class () or the mutant class before reporting the final ratio.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState the genotypic requirement for deafness: deafness occurs when an offspring has genotype , , or .
Calculate the proportion of affected individuals using the complement rule: .
Evaluate the subtraction: .
03 The student misidentifies complementary gene action as duplicate recessive epistasis where only double homozygous recessives (aabb) are affected, giving an expected proportion of 1/16.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Genetic complementation ⟹ Offspring inherit normal functional alleles from the other parent
- Step 2
AaBb AaBb aabb
CorrectNormal hearing requires at least one functional dominant allele at both loci (). Any homozygous recessive locus (, , or ) results in deafness.
Because hearing requires both functional gene products ( and ), being homozygous recessive at either locus alone ( or ) also results in deafness, not just the double recessive genotype .
- Step 3
= 1/16
CorrectP() = 1 - P(A_B_) = 1 - =
Because the genotype criterion in the previous step was too narrow, your final calculated fraction was instead of the correct value .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that the normal hearing in all children is due to genetic complementation across distinct loci.
You correctly set up the dihybrid cross between two double heterozygotes ().
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused complementary gene action (duplicate recessive epistasis, a 9:7 ratio where a recessive defect at either locus causes the mutant phenotype) with a standard Mendelian dihybrid cross where only the double recessive class () exhibits the alternative trait (a 15:1 ratio).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define the Functional Requirement
In complementary gene interactions, normal function requires at least one functional allele at every collaborating locus ().
Always write out which genotypes produce the wild-type phenotype first (), then take the complement () for the mutant phenotype.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the wild-type condition: Normal hearing requires , which occurs with probability .
Identify the mutant condition: Deafness occurs whenever an individual lacks a functional allele at locus (, probability ), locus (, probability ), or both (, probability ).
Sum the mutant probabilities: (or calculate ).
(a) Locus heterogeneity (or genetic complementation); (b)
Lock it in
What genetic phenomenon occurs when two parents with the same recessive trait produce offspring that all exhibit the normal wild-type phenotype?
Genetic complementation (resulting from locus heterogeneity), because the parents carry mutations in different genes.
Similar question
Two true-breeding mutant strains of white-flowered sweet peas are crossed. All progeny have purple flowers. When the plants are self-fertilized, what fraction of the generation will have white flowers, assuming two complementary genes are required for purple pigment production?
Answer
. Purple flower color requires , which occurs with probability . White flowers result from any genotype lacking a dominant allele at either locus (, , or ), giving .
In Drosophila, two independent recessive mutations, (cinnabar, on chromosome 2) and (scarlet, on chromosome 3), both cause bright red eyes when homozygous, while wild-type flies have dull red eyes. A true-breeding cinnabar fly () is mated to a true-breeding scarlet fly (). State (a) the eye color of the progeny and (b) the proportion of progeny expected to have bright red eyes if the flies intercross.
Answer
(a) Dull red (wild-type), due to genetic complementation (). (b) . Wild-type eyes require at least one functional copy of both genes (), which occurs in of progeny. The remaining are homozygous mutant for at least one gene and display bright red eyes.
A woman with congenital recessive blindness whose parents were first cousins marries a man with an identical clinical form of congenital recessive blindness from an unrelated family. They have four children, all of whom have normal vision. If one of their daughters marries a man who has the exact same double-heterozygous genotype as her (), what is the probability that their first child will be blind?
Answer
. The normal vision of the four children shows that the parents carry mutations at different loci ( and ), making their children . A mating between two individuals produces normal vision () with probability . Therefore, the probability of blindness is .