Resources

An isolated population of 800800 pocket mice exhibits two heritable phenotypes: dark-furred and light-furred. A volcanic eruption deposits dark basalt rock across the valley floor. Initially, the population has 160160 dark-furred mice and 640640 light-furred mice. Over several generations under visual predation, the number of dark-furred individuals increases to 600600 while the light-furred count drops to 200200. Calculate: (a) the relative change in frequency (percentage point change) of the dark-fur adaptation, and (b) identify the specific selective agent acting as the selection pressure that altered the phenotypic distribution.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Initial frequency of dark-furred phenotype = 160800=0.20\frac{160}{800} = 0.20 (20.0%20.0\%); Final frequency = 600800=0.75\frac{600}{800} = 0.75 (75.0%75.0\%); Relative change = +55.0+55.0 percentage points (an increase of 0.5500.550). (b) The specific selective agent is visual predators (e.g., predatory birds/owls) that selectively hunt conspicuous light-furred mice on the dark basalt rock.

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Frequency Change of the Dark-Fur Phenotype

  1. Calculate the initial frequency: The total population size is 800800. Before selection, there are 160160 dark-furred mice: Initial frequency=160800=0.20(20.0%)\text{Initial frequency} = \frac{160}{800} = 0.20 \quad (20.0\%)
  2. Calculate the final frequency: After several generations, the total population size remains 600+200=800600 + 200 = 800. There are now 600600 dark-furred mice: Final frequency=600800=0.75(75.0%)\text{Final frequency} = \frac{600}{800} = 0.75 \quad (75.0\%)
  3. Determine the change in frequency: Subtract the initial frequency from the final frequency to find the net change: ΔFrequency=0.75−0.20=+0.550\Delta \text{Frequency} = 0.75 - 0.20 = +0.550 Expressed in percentage points: 75.0%−20.0%=+55.0 percentage points75.0\% - 20.0\% = +55.0 \text{ percentage points}

Common Pitfall: Do not confuse percentage point change with relative percentage change. A shift from 20%20\% to 75%75\% is an absolute increase of 5555 percentage points, not a 55%55\% increase (which would only raise the frequency to 20%×1.55=31%20\% \times 1.55 = 31\%).


Part (b): Identifying the Selective Agent

  • Environmental Context: The volcanic eruption altered the substrate to dark basalt rock.
  • Phenotypic Variation and Adaptation: Pre-existing genetic variation produced both light and dark morphs. On the newly blackened substrate, dark fur provides camouflage (crypsis), making it an advantageous adaptation, whereas light fur makes mice highly conspicuous.
  • Selection Pressure and Selective Agent: The selective pressure is differential mortality due to predation. The specific selective agent directly responsible for exerting this pressure is visual predators (such as predatory birds, owls, or hawks) that preferentially spot and capture the conspicuous light-furred mice, resulting in higher survival and reproductive success for the dark-furred mice.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the relative percent change of the dark-fur population instead of the percentage point change in frequency.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Initial count=160  ⟹  Final count=600  ⟹  Change=600−160=440  ⟹  Relative change=440/160=2.75=275%\text{Initial count} = 160 \implies \text{Final count} = 600 \implies \text{Change} = 600 - 160 = 440 \implies \text{Relative change} = 440 / 160 = 2.75 = 275\%

    Correct

    Initial frequency=160800=0.20 (20%)  ⟹  Final frequency=600800=0.75 (75%)  ⟹  ΔFrequency=75%−20%=+55 percentage points (or +0.55)\text{Initial frequency} = \frac{160}{800} = 0.20\ (20\%) \implies \text{Final frequency} = \frac{600}{800} = 0.75\ (75\%) \implies \Delta\text{Frequency} = 75\% - 20\% = +55\text{ percentage points (or } +0.55\text{)}

    You calculated the relative percentage increase in the absolute count of dark-furred mice rather than finding their proportion out of the total population (800800) to determine the change in frequency.

  2. Step 2

    Visual predators\text{Visual predators}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly extracted the initial and final counts of dark-furred mice from the problem statement.

You correctly identified visual predators as the specific selective agent acting on the population.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Count vs. Frequency Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the relative change in an absolute population count with the change in phenotypic frequency (the proportion of the phenotype within the total population, expressed in percentage points).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Phenotypic Frequency
  • Frequency of phenotype=Number of individuals with phenotypeTotal population size\text{Frequency of phenotype} = \frac{\text{Number of individuals with phenotype}}{\text{Total population size}}

  • Always divide the specific phenotypic count by the total population count before analyzing changes across generations.

Percentage Point Change vs. Percent Change
  • ΔFrequency (percentage points)=Final %−Initial %\Delta \text{Frequency (percentage points)} = \text{Final }\% - \text{Initial }\%

  • When a question asks for percentage point change in frequency, subtract the initial frequency from the final frequency directly rather than computing ΔNNinitial×100%\frac{\Delta N}{N_{\text{initial}}}\times 100\%.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the initial frequency of dark-furred mice: 160800=0.20 (or 20.0%)\frac{160}{800} = 0.20\text{ (or }20.0\%\text{)}.

  2. Find the final frequency of dark-furred mice: 600800=0.75 (or 75.0%)\frac{600}{800} = 0.75\text{ (or }75.0\%\text{)}.

  3. Calculate the percentage point change: 75.0%−20.0%=+55.0 percentage points (an increase of 0.550)75.0\% - 20.0\% = +55.0\text{ percentage points (an increase of }0.550\text{)}.

  4. State the selective agent: visual predators.

Final answer

(a) +55.0 percentage points+55.0\text{ percentage points} (or an increase of 0.5500.550); (b) Visual predators

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between raw population counts, relative percent change of a count, and phenotypic frequencies within a gene pool.

  • Practice calculating allele and phenotypic frequencies from raw counts before computing evolutionary shifts.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies the environmental change (the volcanic eruption / dark basalt rock) as the selective agent rather than the biological predator exerting the selection pressure.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Initial frequency=160800=20%  ⟹  Final frequency=600800=75%  ⟹  Percentage point change=75%−20%=55 percentage points\text{Initial frequency} = \frac{160}{800} = 20\% \implies \text{Final frequency} = \frac{600}{800} = 75\% \implies \text{Percentage point change} = 75\% - 20\% = 55\text{ percentage points}

  2. Step 2

    Volcanic eruption depositing dark basalt rock

    Correct

    Visual predators (e.g., predatory birds, owls, or hawks)

    You identified the environmental change (the substrate background) instead of the selective agent. The selective agent is the specific organism or factor directly causing differential survival or reproductive success.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the initial frequency of the dark-furred mice as 20%20\%.

You accurately computed the final frequency after selection as 75%75\%.

You found the correct net difference of 55 percentage points55\text{ percentage points}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Selective agent vs. environmental condition confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the abiotic environmental context (the dark basalt substrate created by a volcanic eruption) with the selective agent. A selective agent is the specific biological entity or force directly causing differential mortality—in this case, visual predators hunting conspicuous light-furred mice.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distinguish substrate context from selective agent
  • An environmental change creates the context where traits become advantageous or disadvantageous, but the selective agent is the specific entity actively removing less fit phenotypes.

  • Ask yourself: 'Who or what is directly causing the non-random death or reproductive failure of the individuals?'

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the cause of differential mortality described in the problem: visual predation.

  2. State the entity carrying out the visual predation as the selective agent: visual predators (such as predatory birds or owls).

Final answer

(a) +55.0 percentage points+55.0\text{ percentage points}; (b) Visual predators (e.g., predatory birds/owls)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between environmental context (substrate/climate) and selective agents (predators, pathogens, competitors).

  • Practice identifying selective agents across different natural selection scenarios.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student computes the change in raw count of dark mice instead of calculating phenotypic frequency.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Initial dark mice=160  ⟹  Final dark mice=600  ⟹  Change in dark-fur adaptation=600−160=440\text{Initial dark mice} = 160 \implies \text{Final dark mice} = 600 \implies \text{Change in dark-fur adaptation} = 600 - 160 = 440

    Correct

    Initial frequency=160800=0.20 (20.0%)  ⟹  Final frequency=600800=0.75 (75.0%)  ⟹  Δ=75.0%−20.0%=+55.0 percentage points\text{Initial frequency} = \frac{160}{800} = 0.20\ (20.0\%) \implies \text{Final frequency} = \frac{600}{800} = 0.75\ (75.0\%) \implies \Delta = 75.0\% - 20.0\% = +55.0\text{ percentage points}

    You calculated the change in the raw number of dark mice rather than their frequency. Phenotypic frequency represents the proportion of that phenotype within the total population (N=800N = 800).

  2. Step 2

    Visual predators\text{Visual predators}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly extracted the initial and final counts of dark-furred mice from the problem text.

You accurately identified visual predators as the selective agent driving natural selection in this environment.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Raw Count vs. Frequency Confusion

No, this was not a simple arithmetic slip; you computed raw abundance change rather than dividing by total population size to find phenotypic frequency.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the phrase 'change in frequency (percentage point change)' as a change in raw individual count, omitting the step of dividing by total population size (N=800N = 800) to convert counts into proportions or percentages.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Phenotypic Frequency Definition
  • Phenotypic frequency is calculated as Frequency=Number of individuals with phenotypeTotal population size\text{Frequency} = \frac{\text{Number of individuals with phenotype}}{\text{Total population size}}.

  • Always divide the count of a specific phenotype by the total population before calculating frequency changes.

Percentage Point Change
  • A change in frequency expressed in percentage points is Δ=Final percentage−Initial percentage\Delta = \text{Final percentage} - \text{Initial percentage}.

  • Convert each frequency to a percentage out of 100%100\% first, then subtract the initial percentage from the final percentage.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Initial frequency of dark fur=160800=0.20=20.0%\text{Initial frequency of dark fur} = \frac{160}{800} = 0.20 = 20.0\%

  2. Final frequency of dark fur=600800=0.75=75.0%\text{Final frequency of dark fur} = \frac{600}{800} = 0.75 = 75.0\%

  3. ΔFrequency=75.0%−20.0%=+55.0 percentage points (or +0.550)\Delta \text{Frequency} = 75.0\% - 20.0\% = +55.0\text{ percentage points (or } +0.550 \text{)}

Final answer

(a) +55.0 percentage points+55.0\text{ percentage points} (an increase of 0.5500.550); (b) Visual predators

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between raw population counts and relative allele/phenotype frequencies.

  • Practice calculating percentage point shifts by always finding the ratio of individuals to the total population first.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A population of 500500 peppered moths initially contains 5050 melanic (dark) moths. Following industrial soot deposition, the count of melanic moths increases to 350350 out of 500500. Calculate the percentage point change in the frequency of the melanic phenotype.

Answer

Initial frequency: 50500=0.10 (10%)\frac{50}{500} = 0.10\ (10\%). Final frequency: 350500=0.70 (70%)\frac{350}{500} = 0.70\ (70\%). Change: 70%−10%=+60 percentage points70\% - 10\% = +60\text{ percentage points} (or +0.60+0.60).

02

In a population of 1,2001{,}200 land snails, banding pattern is controlled genetically. Initially, 960960 snails are unbanded. After thrush predation over several seasons, the unbanded count drops to 360360 while the total population remains 1,2001{,}200. (a) Determine the change in frequency of the unbanded phenotype in percentage points. (b) Identify the selective agent.

Answer

(a) Initial frequency: 9601,200=0.80 (80%)\frac{960}{1{,}200} = 0.80\ (80\%). Final frequency: 3601,200=0.30 (30%)\frac{360}{1{,}200} = 0.30\ (30\%). Change: 30%−80%=−50 percentage points30\% - 80\% = -50\text{ percentage points} (or −0.50-0.50). (b) The selective agent is song thrushes (visual avian predators).

03

A population of 400400 desert plants has 8080 individuals with deep root systems (drought-resistant). A prolonged drought increases the frequency of deep-rooted plants by 4545 percentage points. If the total population size stays constant at 400400, calculate the new number of deep-rooted plants.

Answer

Initial frequency: 80400=0.20 (20%)\frac{80}{400} = 0.20\ (20\%). Final frequency: 20%+45%=65% (0.65)20\% + 45\% = 65\%\ (0.65). Final count: 0.65×400=260 plants0.65 \times 400 = 260\text{ plants}.

Loading workspace…