Resources

Consider the asymptotic dynamics of an allele-editing CRISPR gene drive introduced into a wild pest population. The change in drive allele frequency qq per generation under strong non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) resistance formation is governed by Δq=q(1−q)[sd−crq]1+sdq\Delta q = \frac{q(1 - q)[s_d - c_r q]}{1 + s_d q}, where sd=0.400s_d = 0.400 is the selective drive advantage and cr=0.500c_r = 0.500 is the fitness cost coefficient associated with drive-resistant target site mutations. (a) Determine the non-trivial asymptotic steady-state equilibrium frequency q∗q^* where Δq=0\Delta q = 0 for 0<q<10 < q < 1, and (b) evaluate the limiting value of the selection differential ratio R(q)=sd−crq1+sdqR(q) = \frac{s_d - c_r q}{1 + s_d q} as the drive allele approaches total fixation (q→1q \to 1).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) q∗=sdcr=0.4000.500=0.800q^* = \frac{s_d}{c_r} = \frac{0.400}{0.500} = 0.800; (b) lim⁡q→1R(q)=0.400−0.500(1)1+0.400(1)=−0.1001.400=−114≈−0.0714\lim_{q \to 1} R(q) = \frac{0.400 - 0.500(1)}{1 + 0.400(1)} = -\frac{0.100}{1.400} = -\frac{1}{14} \approx -0.0714

Steps

Part (a): Finding the Non-Trivial Equilibrium Frequency q∗q^*

An equilibrium frequency occurs when there is no net change in allele frequency from one generation to the next, which means Δq=0\Delta q = 0:

Δq=q(1−q)(sd−crq)1+sdq=0\Delta q = \frac{q(1 - q)(s_d - c_r q)}{1 + s_d q} = 0

  1. Identify the roots of the equation: For a fraction to equal zero, its numerator must equal zero (provided the denominator is non-zero). Setting the numerator to zero gives: q(1−q)(sd−crq)=0q(1 - q)(s_d - c_r q) = 0
  2. Distinguish trivial from non-trivial equilibria:

    • q=0q = 0 represents the loss (extinction) of the gene drive allele.
    • q=1q = 1 represents the complete fixation of the gene drive allele. Both q=0q = 0 and q=1q = 1 are boundary (trivial) fixed points.
  3. Solve for the internal non-trivial equilibrium: For 0<q<10 < q < 1, neither qq nor (1−q)(1 - q) is zero. Therefore, the remaining factor must vanish: sd−crq=0s_d - c_r q = 0 q∗=sdcrq^* = \frac{s_d}{c_r}
  4. Substitute the given values: q∗=0.4000.500=0.800q^* = \frac{0.400}{0.500} = 0.800

Since 0<0.800<10 < 0.800 < 1, this represents a stable polymorphic equilibrium where drive transmission advantage is balanced by the emergence and selection of drive-resistant target site alleles.


Part (b): Evaluating the Limiting Selection Ratio as q→1q \to 1

The selection differential ratio function is defined as:

R(q)=sd−crq1+sdqR(q) = \frac{s_d - c_r q}{1 + s_d q}

  1. Evaluate the direct limit as q→1q \to 1: Since the function is rational and continuous at q=1q = 1 (the denominator 1+sd(1)=1.400≠01 + s_d(1) = 1.400 \neq 0), evaluate the limit by direct substitution: lim⁡q→1R(q)=sd−cr(1)1+sd(1)\lim_{q \to 1} R(q) = \frac{s_d - c_r(1)}{1 + s_d(1)}
  2. Substitute the numerical parameters: lim⁡q→1R(q)=0.400−0.5001+0.400=−0.1001.400=−114≈−0.0714\lim_{q \to 1} R(q) = \frac{0.400 - 0.500}{1 + 0.400} = \frac{-0.100}{1.400} = -\frac{1}{14} \approx -0.0714

Biological insight: A negative selection ratio near q=1q = 1 indicates that the drive allele experiences negative selection pressure as it nears fixation, preventing it from completely replacing wild alleles due to resistance allele accumulation.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the ratio when solving for the equilibrium frequency, calculating c_r / s_d instead of s_d / c_r.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δq=0  ⟹  sd−crq∗=0\Delta q = 0 \implies s_d - c_r q^* = 0

  2. Step 2

    q∗=crsd  ⟹  q∗=0.5000.400=1.25q^* = \frac{c_r}{s_d} \implies q^* = \frac{0.500}{0.400} = 1.25

    Correct

    crq∗=sd  ⟹  q∗=sdcr=0.4000.500=0.800c_r q^* = s_d \implies q^* = \frac{s_d}{c_r} = \frac{0.400}{0.500} = 0.800

    When rearranging sd−crq∗=0s_d - c_r q^* = 0, you divided the coefficient of q∗q^* by the constant term instead of dividing the constant by the coefficient. Additionally, an allele frequency q∗q^* must satisfy 0<q∗<10 < q^* < 1, so 1.251.25 is out of bounds.

  3. Step 3

    lim⁡q→1R(q)=sd−cr(1)1+sd(1)  ⟹  =0.400−0.5001+0.400  ⟹  =−0.1001.400=−114≈−0.0714\lim_{q \to 1} R(q) = \frac{s_d - c_r(1)}{1 + s_d(1)} \implies = \frac{0.400 - 0.500}{1 + 0.400} \implies = \frac{-0.100}{1.400} = -\frac{1}{14} \approx -0.0714

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You identified the correct factor sd−crq=0s_d - c_r q = 0 responsible for the non-trivial equilibrium.

You evaluated the limit in part (b) cleanly and accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic Inversion Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You inverted the numerator and denominator when solving the linear equation sd−crq∗=0s_d - c_r q^* = 0, dividing crc_r by sds_d rather than sds_d by crc_r, and missed the biological domain constraint that allele frequencies must lie in the interval [0,1][0, 1].

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolate the Variable First
  • For a−bx=0a - b x = 0, add bxb x to both sides to get bx=ab x = a, then divide both sides by the coefficient bb to obtain x=abx = \frac{a}{b}.

  • Write the intermediate step crq∗=sdc_r q^* = s_d explicitly before dividing.

Check Biological Bounds
  • Allele frequencies represent population proportions and must always lie within [0,1][0, 1].

  • Whenever you calculate a frequency q>1q > 1 or q<0q < 0, stop immediately and check your algebraic manipulation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Rearrange sd−crq∗=0s_d - c_r q^* = 0 by adding crq∗c_r q^* to both sides: crq∗=sdc_r q^* = s_d.

  2. Divide both sides by crc_r: q∗=sdcrq^* = \frac{s_d}{c_r}.

  3. Substitute the given numerical parameters: q∗=0.4000.500=0.800q^* = \frac{0.400}{0.500} = 0.800.

Final answer

(a) q∗=0.800q^* = 0.800; (b) lim⁡q→1R(q)=−114≈−0.0714\lim_{q \to 1} R(q) = -\frac{1}{14} \approx -0.0714

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice solving simple two-parameter linear equilibrium equations a−bx=0a - bx = 0 without skipping the addition step.

  • Always verify that calculated allele frequencies satisfy 0≤q≤10 \le q \le 1.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits the baseline fitness term 1 in the denominator when taking the limit of R(q) as q approaches 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δq=0  ⟹  sd−crq∗=0  ⟹  q∗=sdcr  ⟹  q∗=0.4000.500=0.800\Delta q = 0 \implies s_d - c_r q^* = 0 \implies q^* = \frac{s_d}{c_r} \implies q^* = \frac{0.400}{0.500} = 0.800

  2. Step 2

    lim⁡(q→1)R(q)=sd−crsd=0.400−0.5000.400=−0.1000.400=−0.250\lim_{(q \to 1)} R(q) = \frac{s_d - c_r}{s_d} = \frac{0.400 - 0.500}{0.400} = \frac{-0.100}{0.400} = -0.250

    Correct

    lim⁡q→1R(q)=sd−cr(1)1+sd(1)=0.400−0.5001+0.400=−0.1001.400=−114≈−0.0714\lim_{q \to 1} R(q) = \frac{s_d - c_r(1)}{1 + s_d(1)} = \frac{0.400 - 0.500}{1 + 0.400} = -\frac{0.100}{1.400} = -\frac{1}{14} \approx -0.0714

    You omitted the constant 11 from the denominator 1+sdq1 + s_d q. When substituting q=1q = 1, the denominator is 1+sd=1.4001 + s_d = 1.400, not sd=0.400s_d = 0.400.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the non-trivial equilibrium requires setting sd−crq∗=0s_d - c_r q^* = 0.

You accurately substituted the numerical values sd=0.400s_d = 0.400 and cr=0.500c_r = 0.500 to obtain q∗=0.800q^* = 0.800.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Denominator Constant Term

You dropped the leading 1+1 + in the mean fitness denominator 1+sdq1 + s_d q when evaluating the limit.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In population genetics selection models, the denominator 1+sdq1 + s_d q represents the population's normalized mean fitness wˉ\bar{w}. Dropping the baseline relative fitness term 11 treats the denominator as an additive selection increment rather than the full mean fitness.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Inspect the denominator structure
  • For a rational function f(q)=N(q)D(q)f(q) = \frac{N(q)}{D(q)}, evaluate the limit by substituting into the complete expression for D(q)D(q), including all constant baseline terms.

  • Always copy the entire denominator D(q)=1+sdqD(q) = 1 + s_d q before taking limits by direct substitution.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the complete expression for R(q)R(q): R(q)=sd−crq1+sdqR(q) = \frac{s_d - c_r q}{1 + s_d q}.

  2. Evaluate the limit by direct substitution at q=1q = 1: lim⁡q→1R(q)=sd−cr(1)1+sd(1)\lim_{q \to 1} R(q) = \frac{s_d - c_r(1)}{1 + s_d(1)}.

  3. Substitute the given parameters: 0.400−0.5001+0.400=−0.1001.400=−114≈−0.0714\frac{0.400 - 0.500}{1 + 0.400} = \frac{-0.100}{1.400} = -\frac{1}{14} \approx -0.0714.

Final answer

(a) q∗=0.800q^* = 0.800; (b) lim⁡q→1R(q)=−114≈−0.0714\lim_{q \to 1} R(q) = -\frac{1}{14} \approx -0.0714

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that the denominator representing mean fitness wˉ=1+sq\bar{w} = 1 + s q retains its base value of 11.

  • Practice computing asymptotic limits on population genetic recursion models by substituting q→1q \to 1 and q→0q \to 0 into full rational expressions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts terms in the wrong order in the numerator of R(q), reversing the sign of the limit.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    sd−crq∗=0  ⟹  q∗=sdcr=0.4000.500  ⟹  q∗=0.800s_d - c_r q^* = 0 \implies q^* = \frac{s_d}{c_r} = \frac{0.400}{0.500} \implies q^* = 0.800

  2. Step 2

    R(1)=cr(1)−sd1+sd(1)=0.500−0.4001+0.400=0.0714R(1) = \frac{c_r(1) - s_d}{1 + s_d(1)} = \frac{0.500 - 0.400}{1 + 0.400} = 0.0714

    Correct

    lim⁡q→1R(q)=sd−cr(1)1+sd(1)=0.400−0.5001+0.400=−0.1001.400≈−0.0714\lim_{q \to 1} R(q) = \frac{s_d - c_r(1)}{1 + s_d(1)} = \frac{0.400 - 0.500}{1 + 0.400} = -\frac{0.100}{1.400} \approx -0.0714

    You inverted the order of subtraction in the numerator as cr(1)−sdc_r(1) - s_d instead of the given sd−cr(1)s_d - c_r(1), which reversed the sign of the selection differential ratio.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly isolated the non-trivial root sd−crq∗=0s_d - c_r q^* = 0 for part (a).

You correctly calculated the numerical equilibrium value q∗=0.800q^* = 0.800.

You correctly substituted q=1q = 1 into the denominator in part (b).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
reversal of terms in subtraction

In part (b), you wrote the numerator of R(q)R(q) as crq−sdc_r q - s_d instead of sd−crqs_d - c_r q, which inverted the sign of your final limit.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Subtractions that result in negative differences are easy to accidentally invert, especially when intuitively expecting a positive physical or biological rate. In this dynamic, selection pressure becomes negative near fixation because resistant alleles outcompete the drive.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Preserve Formula Order
  • When evaluating a−ba - b, substituting values must retain the exact minuend aa and subtrahend bb; a−b=−(b−a)a - b = -(b - a).

  • Write down the formula exactly as given, sd−crqs_d - c_r q, before plugging in numbers so the original term order is not switched.

Biological Sanity Check
  • When q>q∗q > q^* (0.800<q<10.800 < q < 1), the net selection rate Δq\Delta q and selection differential R(q)R(q) must be negative, pushing allele frequency back down toward equilibrium.

  • Check whether the sign of R(1)R(1) matches the direction of selection above the stable equilibrium.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. lim⁡q→1R(q)=sd−cr(1)1+sd(1)\lim_{q \to 1} R(q) = \frac{s_d - c_r(1)}{1 + s_d(1)}

  2. Substitute sd=0.400s_d = 0.400 and cr=0.500c_r = 0.500: 0.400−0.5001+0.400=−0.1001.400\frac{0.400 - 0.500}{1 + 0.400} = \frac{-0.100}{1.400}

  3. Simplify the fraction: −114≈−0.0714-\frac{1}{14} \approx -0.0714

Final answer

(a) q∗=0.800q^* = 0.800; (b) lim⁡q→1R(q)=−114≈−0.0714\lim_{q \to 1} R(q) = -\frac{1}{14} \approx -0.0714

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check term ordering whenever a difference can produce a negative result.

  • Interpret the biological meaning of negative selection differentials above an internal equilibrium point.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A gene drive system has a drive advantage sd=0.350s_d = 0.350 and resistance mutation fitness cost cr=0.700c_r = 0.700. Determine the internal polymorphic equilibrium frequency q∗q^* from the condition sd−crq∗=0s_d - c_r q^* = 0.

Answer

q∗=sdcr=0.3500.700=0.500q^* = \frac{s_d}{c_r} = \frac{0.350}{0.700} = 0.500 (or 0.50.5).

02

For the dynamic equation Δq=q(1−q)(sd−crq)1+sdq\Delta q = \frac{q(1 - q)(s_d - c_r q)}{1 + s_d q}, let sd=0.200s_d = 0.200 and cr=0.500c_r = 0.500. (a) Calculate the non-trivial equilibrium frequency q∗q^*. (b) Determine the sign of Δq\Delta q when q=0.200q = 0.200, and state whether the frequency increases or decreases.

Answer

(a) q∗=sdcr=0.2000.500=0.400q^* = \frac{s_d}{c_r} = \frac{0.200}{0.500} = 0.400. (b) When q=0.200<q∗q = 0.200 < q^*, the factor (sd−crq)=0.200−0.500(0.200)=+0.100>0(s_d - c_r q) = 0.200 - 0.500(0.200) = +0.100 > 0, so Δq>0\Delta q > 0. The frequency increases toward q∗q^*.

03

A CRISPR drive has transmission advantage sd=0.450s_d = 0.450 and resistance target fitness cost cr=0.300c_r = 0.300. Does an internal steady-state equilibrium q∗q^* exist in the open interval (0,1)(0, 1)? Explain what happens to the drive frequency over time.

Answer

Calculating q∗=sdcr=0.4500.300=1.500>1q^* = \frac{s_d}{c_r} = \frac{0.450}{0.300} = 1.500 > 1, which lies outside (0,1)(0, 1). Thus, no internal equilibrium exists. Since sd−crq>0s_d - c_r q > 0 for all q∈(0,1)q \in (0, 1), Δq>0\Delta q > 0 everywhere on (0,1)(0, 1), and the drive allele proceeds to fixation (q→1q \to 1).

Loading workspace…