Resources
An investigator isolates a mutant strain of Escherichia coli exhibiting continuous, high-level constitutive expression of the gene ( maximal activity) even in the complete absence of lactose or allolactose, while glucose is omitted from the medium. Genetic sequencing reveals that the structural genes and promoter elements are intact, but a single nucleotide substitution is present in either the regulatory gene or the operator locus . To determine the exact genetic lesion, a partial diploid (merodiploid) is constructed. The merodiploid exhibits constitutive expression in the absence of lactose. Deduce whether the original chromosomal mutation resided in (e.g., ) or in (e.g., ), and justify using the concept of trans-acting versus cis-acting regulatory elements.
Answer and steps
Final answer
The chromosomal mutation resides in the operator locus (). Because the wild-type allele produces a diffusible, trans-acting repressor protein that fails to repress the constitutive chromosome, the mutation is cis-acting and localized to the physical operator site () on the chromosome adjacent to the functional gene.
Steps
Understand cis- vs. trans-Acting Regulatory Elements
In the lac operon:
- encodes a trans-acting factor: The gene produces a diffusible repressor protein. Once synthesized, the repressor can diffuse through the cytoplasm to bind any compatible operator sequence in the cell, regardless of whether that operator is located on the plasmid or on the main chromosome.
- is a cis-acting element: The operator is a physical sequence of DNA on the operon. It does not produce a diffusible molecule; instead, it regulates only the contiguous structural genes () located on the same physical DNA strand.
Predict the Merodiploid Phenotype under Each Hypothesis
The merodiploid has the genotype:
Notice that the functional -galactosidase gene () is located solely on the chromosome, while the plasmid carries an inactive allele () but supplies a wild-type regulatory system ().
Hypothesis A: The chromosomal mutation is in ()
- If the chromosome is , the genotype is:
- The plasmid produces wild-type repressor protein ().
- Because the repressor acts in trans, it diffuses to the chromosomal operator and binds to it, blocking transcription of in the absence of lactose.
- Expected outcome: The cells would be inducible ( is dominant to in trans), meaning expression would remain shut off without lactose.
Hypothesis B: The chromosomal mutation is in ()
- If the chromosome is , the genotype is:
- The wild-type repressor protein produced by the plasmid (and chromosome, if ) cannot bind to the mutant operator site () due to an altered nucleotide sequence.
- Because the operator acts strictly in cis, the presence of a functional on the plasmid cannot compensate for the mutated chromosomal operator.
- RNA polymerase continually transcribes the adjacent chromosomal gene.
- Expected outcome: The cells exhibit constitutive expression even in the absence of lactose.
Conclusion
Because the experimental merodiploid continues to display constitutive expression without lactose, the diffusible wild-type repressor from the plasmid is unable to turn off transcription of the chromosomal gene. Therefore, the mutation is -acting and resides in the operator locus ().
Common Pitfall: Always track which DNA molecule carries the functional reporter gene. If had been on the plasmid alongside , a chromosomal mutation would not cause constitutive -galactosidase synthesis because only affects genes physically linked to it on the same DNA strand.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the definitions of cis-acting and trans-acting elements, mistakenly assuming the repressor acts in cis and the operator acts in trans.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Merodiploid: shows constitutive expression.
- Step 2
LacI repressor acts in cis to control adjacent genes. lacO acts in trans to regulate genes across different DNA molecules.
Correctencodes a diffusible repressor protein that acts in trans, whereas is a non-diffusible DNA binding site that acts strictly in cis.
You inverted the actions of and . A diffusible gene product like the LacI protein diffuses across the cytoplasm to act in trans, whereas an operator site like is a physical sequence of DNA that regulates only contiguous genes on the same physical strand (cis).
- Step 3
The episomal cannot rescue the chromosomal defect because it cannot diffuse.
CorrectBecause the episomal produces wild-type repressor that diffuses in trans, it would successfully repress a chromosomal defect, making a strain inducible rather than constitutive.
Because this deduction relied on the reversed definition from Step 2, you incorrectly concluded that the wild-type episomal repressor cannot act on the chromosomal operon.
- Step 4
The original mutation is in .
CorrectThe original mutation resides in the operator locus ().
Because wild-type repressor protein fails to shut down expression from the chromosomal allele, the defect is an operator mutation () acting in cis.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the merodiploid genotype and recognized that the experimental strain shows constitutive phenotype.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the fundamental definitions of cis-acting and trans-acting elements, treating the diffusible protein product (LacI) as cis-acting and the physical DNA sequence (the operator ) as trans-acting.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Diffusible Product vs. Physical DNA Binding Site
A regulatory element that encodes a diffusible molecule (protein or RNA) acts in trans and can regulate targets anywhere in the cell. A regulatory sequence of DNA (promoter, operator) acts strictly in cis and controls only genes on the same physical chromosome.
Check whether the regulatory component produces a diffusible factor (like LacI, acting in trans) or is an intact DNA binding sequence (like , acting in cis).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that produces a diffusible repressor protein that acts in trans, so an episomal gene can provide repressor to both the plasmid and the chromosome.
Recognize that is a physical operator site on DNA that acts strictly in cis, controlling only the structural genes adjacent to it on the same DNA molecule.
Observe that if the mutation were , the diffusible repressor from would bind the chromosomal operator and turn off in the absence of lactose (making it inducible).
Deduce that because expression remains constitutive, the repressor cannot bind the chromosomal operator, confirming the mutation is in ().
The chromosomal mutation is in the operator locus ().
02 The student incorrectly assumes that wild-type alleles are universally dominant over mutant alleles regardless of whether the element acts in cis or trans, concluding the phenotype must be caused by a super-repressor mutation in lacI.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
provides normal alleles that should complement any loss-of-function mutation.
- Step 2
Since is wild-type, a normal or mutation would be repressed.
CorrectWild-type repressor from represses a allele in trans, but it cannot repress a operator mutation because operators act strictly in cis and the repressor cannot bind the mutant operator sequence.
A mutation is a damaged DNA-binding sequence on the chromosome itself. Because operators are non-diffusible, cis-acting elements, providing wild-type and on a separate plasmid cannot restore repression to a chromosome carrying .
- Step 3
Expression remains constitutive, so the chromosomal mutation must be a dominant mutation.
CorrectBecause the merodiploid remains constitutive in the presence of diffusible , the defect must reside in a cis-acting site controlling the functional gene, namely .
This conclusion stems directly from the incorrect assumption in step 2 that would be repressed by wild-type repressor.
- Step 4
The original mutation is in .
CorrectThe chromosomal mutation resides in the operator locus ().
The mutation resides in , not .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou recognized that introducing the episome creates a partial diploid to test allele dominance and regulation.
You noted that the merodiploid phenotype remained constitutive in the absence of lactose.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the operator locus () as if it were a diffusible factor subject to standard diploid complementation, overlooking that operators are non-coding, physical DNA-binding sites that act strictly in cis on adjacent structural genes.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Diffusible vs. Localized Action
Proteins (like LacI) act in trans via diffusion across the cell, whereas regulatory DNA sequences (like promoters and operators) act strictly in cis only on the contiguous DNA strand.
Always determine whether an element produces a diffusible molecule or is a non-coding physical binding site on DNA before predicting partial diploid phenotypes.
- Behavior of $lacO^c$ in Merodiploids
is cis-dominant: a functional located downstream of a site cannot be shut off by wild-type repressor protein supplied in trans from another chromosome or plasmid.
When a merodiploid with remains constitutive, trace which physical DNA molecule carries the active structural gene () and verify its adjacent operator.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationThe plasmid carries , which synthesizes functional repressor protein that diffuses freely through the cytoplasm (trans-acting).
If the chromosome had an ordinary mutation, the diffusible repressor would bind to the chromosomal site and turn off expression without lactose (inducible phenotype).
Because expression remains constitutive, the repressor cannot turn off transcription of the chromosomal gene. This means the chromosomal operator site has mutated () so that repressor cannot bind.
Because operators act only in cis, the functional site on the plasmid cannot act across molecules to restore control over chromosomal .
The chromosomal mutation resides in the operator locus ().
Lock it in
What is the defining mechanistic difference between a cis-acting element and a trans-acting factor?
A trans-acting factor is a diffusible molecule (e.g., protein or RNA) that can affect targets throughout the cell. A cis-acting element is a physical DNA sequence that only affects contiguous genes on the same DNA molecule.
Similar question
An E. coli strain has the partial diploid genotype . In the absence of lactose and glucose, will -galactosidase be expressed constitutively, or will it be repressed? Explain using trans-complementation.
Answer
-galactosidase will be repressed (inducible, not constitutive). The chromosome carries a functional allele, which produces diffusible LacI repressor protein acting in trans. This repressor diffuses to the episome and binds , shutting down transcription of until lactose is present.
Predict the phenotype (constitutive, inducible, or uninducible for -galactosidase) of the following partial diploid: , where encodes a super-repressor that cannot bind allolactose. Explain your reasoning based on trans-dominance.
Answer
The phenotype is uninducible (permanently repressed). The allele produces a mutant, diffusible repressor that acts in trans. Because it can bind all operator sites () but cannot be inactivated by inducer (allolactose), it permanently represses on both the plasmid and the chromosome regardless of lactose presence.
You isolate a mutant with constitutive expression of the operon structural genes (). To determine whether the mutation is in the regulatory repressor gene () or in the operator (), you introduce a plasmid carrying wild-type and , but lacking functional structural genes (). What result would indicate that the chromosomal mutation is in rather than ?
Answer
Persistent constitutive expression of the structural genes indicates the mutation is in (). If the lesion were in , the plasmid-derived wild-type TrpR repressor protein would act in trans to restore corepressor-mediated repression. Because acts in cis, the plasmid's cannot fix the defective operator on the chromosome controlling the functional genes.