Resources

In snapdragons (Antirrhinum majus), flower color displays incomplete dominance where homozygous CRCRC^R C^R plants produce red flowers, heterozygous CRCWC^R C^W plants produce pink flowers, and homozygous CWCWC^W C^W plants produce white flowers. A biology student claims that crossing a pink-flowered plant with a white-flowered plant will produce offspring that all have intermediate, blended phenotypes. Using a Punnett square, evaluate this cross and calculate: (a) the expected phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White), and (b) the probability that an offspring chosen at random will carry the CRC^R allele.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) 0:1:10 : 1 : 1 (or 0% Red:50% Pink:50% White0\%\text{ Red} : 50\%\text{ Pink} : 50\%\text{ White}), (b) 12\frac{1}{2}

Steps

01

Determine Parental Genotypes and Gametes

In snapdragons, flower color shows incomplete dominance:

  • Red phenotype: CRCRC^R C^R
  • Pink phenotype: CRCWC^R C^W
  • White phenotype: CWCWC^W C^W

The cross is between a pink parent and a white parent:

  • Pink parent: CRCWC^R C^W produces two types of gametes in equal proportion: CRC^R (50%50\%) and CWC^W (50%50\%).
  • White parent: CWCWC^W C^W produces only one type of gamete: CWC^W (100%100\%).

02

Construct the Punnett Square

Set up a Punnett square combining the gametes from both parents:

CWC^W (White parent)CWC^W (White parent)
CRC^R (Pink parent)CRCWC^R C^W (Pink)CRCWC^R C^W (Pink)
CWC^W (Pink parent)CWCWC^W C^W (White)CWCWC^W C^W (White)

Out of 44 equal boxes:

  • 22 boxes are CRCWC^R C^W (Pink)
  • 22 boxes are CWCWC^W C^W (White)
  • 00 boxes are CRCRC^R C^R (Red)

Common Pitfall: Incomplete dominance results in a blended phenotypic appearance in heterozygotes, but the alleles themselves do not blend or permanently fuse. They segregate discretely during gamete formation according to Mendel's Law of Segregation. Therefore, the student's claim that all offspring will be intermediate is incorrect; half of the offspring inherit two CWC^W alleles and remain white.


03

Determine the Phenotypic Ratio and Probability

(a) Phenotypic Ratio (Red:Pink:White\text{Red} : \text{Pink} : \text{White}):

  • Red (CRCRC^R C^R): 00
  • Pink (CRCWC^R C^W): 22 (or 50%50\%)
  • White (CWCWC^W C^W): 22 (or 50%50\%)

Expressed in lowest whole-number terms, the ratio is: Red:Pink:White=0:1:1(or 0% Red:50% Pink:50% White)\text{Red} : \text{Pink} : \text{White} = 0 : 1 : 1 \quad (\text{or } 0\%\text{ Red} : 50\%\text{ Pink} : 50\%\text{ White})

(b) Probability of Carrying the CRC^R Allele: An offspring carries the CRC^R allele if its genotype is either CRCRC^R C^R or CRCWC^R C^W.

  • Offspring with genotype CRCRC^R C^R: 00
  • Offspring with genotype CRCWC^R C^W: 22 out of 44

P(carrying CR)=24=12P(\text{carrying } C^R) = \frac{2}{4} = \frac{1}{2}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the cross with a monohybrid heterozygous cross (pink × pink), yielding a 1 : 2 : 1 phenotypic ratio instead of using the white-flowered parent.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Cross: CRCW×CRCW\text{Cross: } C^R C^W \times C^R C^W

    Correct

    Cross: CRCW×CWCW\text{Cross: } C^R C^W \times C^W C^W

    The problem specifies crossing a pink-flowered plant (CRCWC^R C^W) with a white-flowered plant (CWCWC^W C^W). You wrote both parents as heterozygous pink plants.

  2. Step 2

    Punnett square: 1 CRCR,2 CRCW,1 CWCW  ⟹  Phenotypes: 1 Red:2 Pink:1 White\text{Punnett square: } 1\,C^R C^R, 2\,C^R C^W, 1\,C^W C^W \implies \text{Phenotypes: } 1\text{ Red} : 2\text{ Pink} : 1\text{ White}

    Correct

    Punnett square: 2 CRCW,2 CWCW  ⟹  Phenotypes: 0 Red:2 Pink:2 White\text{Punnett square: } 2\,C^R C^W, 2\,C^W C^W \implies \text{Phenotypes: } 0\text{ Red} : 2\text{ Pink} : 2\text{ White}

    Your Punnett square combination and phenotype mapping are consistent with your chosen parents, but they inherit the error from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Expected phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White)=1:2:1\text{Expected phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White)} = 1 : 2 : 1

    Correct

    Expected phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White)=0:1:1\text{Expected phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White)} = 0 : 1 : 1

    Because of the parental genotype mismatch in Step 1, your phenotypic ratio is 1:2:11 : 2 : 1 instead of 0:1:10 : 1 : 1 (or 0% Red:50% Pink:50% White0\%\text{ Red} : 50\%\text{ Pink} : 50\%\text{ White}).

  4. Step 4

    Genotypes with CR allele: CRCR (1/4) and CRCW (2/4)  ⟹  P(carrying CR)=1/4+2/4=3/4\text{Genotypes with } C^R \text{ allele: } C^R C^R\ (1/4) \text{ and } C^R C^W\ (2/4) \implies P(\text{carrying } C^R) = 1/4 + 2/4 = 3/4

    Correct

    Genotypes with CR allele: CRCW (2/4)  ⟹  P(carrying CR)=2/4=1/2\text{Genotypes with } C^R \text{ allele: } C^R C^W\ (2/4) \implies P(\text{carrying } C^R) = 2/4 = 1/2

    You correctly identified which genotypes carry the CRC^R allele in your square and added their probabilities properly, but using the correct cross yields P(carrying CR)=1/2P(\text{carrying } C^R) = 1/2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly associated each genotype with its corresponding incomplete dominance phenotype.

You accurately populated and interpreted the offspring genotypes from your stated cross.

You correctly used the addition rule to calculate the total probability of carrying a specific allele.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect parental genotype selection

You accidentally crossed two pink plants (CRCW×CRCWC^R C^W \times C^R C^W) instead of crossing a pink plant with a white plant (CRCW×CWCWC^R C^W \times C^W C^W).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Defaulting to the classic monohybrid heterozygous cross (F1×F1F_1 \times F_1) habit instead of extracting and writing down each parent's specific phenotype and genotype stated in the prompt.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Parental Phenotype-to-Genotype Audit
  • Every genetic cross problem begins by explicitly translating each parent's stated phenotype into its exact diploid genotype before building a grid.

  • Write Parent 1: phenotype →\rightarrow genotype, Parent 2: phenotype →\rightarrow genotype, and reread the question prompt to verify both before drawing the Punnett square.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify parental genotypes: Pink parent is CRCWC^R C^W; White parent is CWCWC^W C^W.

  2. Set up the 2×22 \times 2 Punnett square pairing gametes CRC^R and CWC^W from Parent 1 with gamete CWC^W from Parent 2.

  3. Combine gametes to find the four offspring squares: two CRCWC^R C^W (pink) and two CWCWC^W C^W (white).

  4. Determine the phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White): 0:2:20 : 2 : 2, which reduces to 0:1:10 : 1 : 1.

  5. Identify offspring carrying at least one CRC^R allele: only the two CRCWC^R C^W boxes carry CRC^R, giving P(carrying CR)=24=12P(\text{carrying } C^R) = \frac{2}{4} = \frac{1}{2}.

Final answer

(a) 0:1:10 : 1 : 1 (or 0% Red:50% Pink:50% White0\%\text{ Red} : 50\%\text{ Pink} : 50\%\text{ White}), (b) 12\frac{1}{2}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Annotate the question by circling each parent's phenotype and writing its corresponding genotype directly above it before setting up the cross.

  • Practice distinguishing testcrosses and backcrosses from heterozygous self-crosses.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes incomplete dominance follows simple Mendelian complete dominance where the pink phenotype is treated as fully dominant over white, resulting in a 1 : 1 ratio of Red to White.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Cross: CRCW×CWCW  ⟹  Offspring: 2 CRCW, 2 CWCW\text{Cross: } C^R C^W \times C^W C^W \implies \text{Offspring: } 2\,C^R C^W,\, 2\,C^W C^W

  2. Step 2

    CRCW expresses red because CR dominates CW  ⟹  Expected phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White)=1:0:1C^R C^W\text{ expresses red because } C^R\text{ dominates } C^W \implies \text{Expected phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White)} = 1 : 0 : 1

    Correct

    CRCW expresses pink due to incomplete dominance  ⟹  Expected phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White)=0:1:1C^R C^W\text{ expresses pink due to incomplete dominance} \implies \text{Expected phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White)} = 0 : 1 : 1

    Snapdragons exhibit incomplete dominance where heterozygotes (CRCWC^R C^W) display an intermediate pink phenotype rather than a red phenotype. Because 22 of the 44 offspring are CRCWC^R C^W (pink) and 22 are CWCWC^W C^W (white), the correct phenotypic ratio is 0 Red:2 Pink:2 White0\text{ Red} : 2\text{ Pink} : 2\text{ White}, which simplifies to 0:1:10 : 1 : 1.

  3. Step 3

    Offspring carrying \text{Offspring carrying } C^R are \text{ are } C^R C^W (2 out of 4)\text{ (2 out of 4)}   ⟹  \implies P(carrying \text{carrying } C^R) = 24\frac{2}{4} = 12\frac{1}{2}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the parental genotypes as CRCWC^R C^W and CWCWC^W C^W.

You accurately determined the genotypic counts of the offspring as 2 CRCW2\,C^R C^W and 2 CWCW2\,C^W C^W.

You correctly calculated the probability of an offspring carrying the CRC^R allele as 12\frac{1}{2}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incomplete dominance misclassified as complete dominance

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You applied complete Mendelian dominance rules instead of incomplete dominance, overlooking the problem statement that heterozygotes (CRCWC^R C^W) form an intermediate pink phenotype rather than expressing the red allele dominantly.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Recognizing Incomplete Dominance
  • In incomplete dominance, neither allele is dominant, and heterozygous individuals show an intermediate, blended phenotype between both homozygotes.

  • Always check the problem description for non-Mendelian inheritance patterns before assigning phenotypes to heterozygous genotypes.

Mapping Genotypes to Phenotypes
  • For snapdragons: CRCR=RedC^R C^R = \text{Red}, CRCW=PinkC^R C^W = \text{Pink}, and CWCW=WhiteC^W C^W = \text{White}.

  • Directly label each Punnett square cell with its corresponding phenotype before compiling the phenotypic ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the phenotype for each offspring genotype: CRCWC^R C^W produces pink flowers, and CWCWC^W C^W produces white flowers.

  2. Count the phenotypes across all 44 outcomes: 00 red, 22 pink, and 22 white.

  3. Write the simplified phenotypic ratio: Red:Pink:White=0:1:1\text{Red} : \text{Pink} : \text{White} = 0 : 1 : 1.

Final answer

(a) 0:1:10 : 1 : 1 (or 0% Red:50% Pink:50% White0\%\text{ Red} : 50\%\text{ Pink} : 50\%\text{ White}), (b) 12\frac{1}{2}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how incomplete dominance differs from complete dominance in terms of heterozygous phenotypes.

  • Practice writing the phenotype directly inside each cell of a Punnett square to avoid defaulting to simple dominance rules.

  • Solve crosses involving co-dominance and incomplete dominance to reinforce distinct non-Mendelian patterns.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets 'carrying the C^R allele' as requiring homozygosity (C^R C^R), arriving at a probability of 0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Cross: CRCW×CWCW  ⟹  Punnett square outcomes: 2 CRCW, 2 CWCW\text{Cross: } C^R C^W \times C^W C^W \implies \text{Punnett square outcomes: } 2\ C^R C^W,\ 2\ C^W C^W

  2. Step 2

    Phenotypic ratio: 0 Red, 2 Pink, 2 White  ⟹  Expected phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White)=0:1:1\text{Phenotypic ratio: } 0\text{ Red},\ 2\text{ Pink},\ 2\text{ White} \implies \text{Expected phenotypic ratio (Red : Pink : White)} = 0 : 1 : 1

  3. Step 3

    Carrying the CR allele means homozygous CRCR  ⟹  Number of CRCR offspring=0  ⟹  P(carrying CR)=04=0\text{Carrying the } C^R \text{ allele means homozygous } C^R C^R \implies \text{Number of } C^R C^R \text{ offspring} = 0 \implies P(\text{carrying } C^R) = \frac{0}{4} = 0

    Correct

    Carrying the CR allele includes both CRCR and CRCW  ⟹  P(carrying CR)=24=12\text{Carrying the } C^R \text{ allele includes both } C^R C^R \text{ and } C^R C^W \implies P(\text{carrying } C^R) = \frac{2}{4} = \frac{1}{2}

    Carrying an allele means having at least one copy of that allele in the genotype. Both homozygous individuals (CRCRC^R C^R) and heterozygous carriers (CRCWC^R C^W) carry the CRC^R allele.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the genotypes of the pink and white parent plants.

You accurately executed the Punnett square to find the offspring genotypes and phenotypic ratio.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Allele Carrier Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You equated 'carrying an allele' with being homozygous for that allele, overlooking that heterozygotes also possess and transmit the allele.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Definition of an Allele Carrier
  • An individual carries an allele if their genotype contains at least one copy of it (either homozygous or heterozygous).

  • When a question asks for the probability of carrying an allele AA, count all offspring with genotypes AAAA and AaAa.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify all genotypes containing at least one copy of CRC^R: CRCRC^R C^R and CRCWC^R C^W.

  2. Count the number of offspring with these genotypes from your Punnett square: 00 are CRCRC^R C^R and 22 are CRCWC^R C^W, giving 22 total carriers out of 44.

  3. Compute the probability: P(carrying CR)=24=12P(\text{carrying } C^R) = \frac{2}{4} = \frac{1}{2}.

Final answer

(a) 0:1:10 : 1 : 1, (b) 12\frac{1}{2}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the genetic definition of a carrier versus a homozygous individual.

  • Practice distinguishing between phenotypic questions (e.g., 'What fraction are red?') and allelic questions (e.g., 'What fraction carry allele CRC^R?').

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In Andalusian fowls, black feathers (FBFBF^B F^B) and white feathers (FWFWF^W F^W) show incomplete dominance, producing blue-feathered heterozygotes (FBFWF^B F^W). A blue hen is crossed with a black rooster. Determine: (a) the expected phenotypic ratio (Black : Blue : White), and (b) the probability of obtaining a white chick.

Answer

(a) Cross is FBFW×FBFBF^B F^W \times F^B F^B. Punnett square produces 2 FBFB2\,F^B F^B (black) and 2 FBFW2\,F^B F^W (blue). Phenotypic ratio is 1 Black:1 Blue:0 White1\text{ Black} : 1\text{ Blue} : 0\text{ White} (or 1:1:01 : 1 : 0). (b) P(White)=0P(\text{White}) = 0.

02

In radishes, root shape is controlled by incomplete dominance: long (RLRLR^L R^L), oval (RLRSR^L R^S), and round (RSRSR^S R^S). A farmer crosses an oval radish with a round radish. If 200200 offspring are grown, how many are expected to be: (a) oval, (b) round, and (c) long?

Answer

Cross: RLRS×RSRSR^L R^S \times R^S R^S. Offspring genotypes are 50% RLRS50\%\ R^L R^S (oval) and 50% RSRS50\%\ R^S R^S (round). Out of 200200 plants: (a) 100100 oval, (b) 100100 round, (c) 00 long.

03

In snapdragons, flower color shows incomplete dominance (CRCR=redC^R C^R = \text{red}, CRCW=pinkC^R C^W = \text{pink}, CWCW=whiteC^W C^W = \text{white}) and plant height shows complete dominance (T=tallT = \text{tall}, t=dwarft = \text{dwarf}). A plant heterozygous for both traits is testcrossed with a dwarf, white-flowered plant. Determine the proportion of offspring expected to be dwarf and pink.

Answer

Cross: CRCWTt×CWCWttC^R C^W Tt \times C^W C^W tt. Considering each gene independently: P(pink from CRCW×CWCW)=1/2P(\text{pink from } C^R C^W \times C^W C^W) = 1/2; P(dwarf from Tt×tt)=1/2P(\text{dwarf from } Tt \times tt) = 1/2. By the multiplication rule, P(dwarf and pink)=1/2×1/2=1/4P(\text{dwarf and pink}) = 1/2 \times 1/2 = 1/4 (or 25%25\%).

Loading workspace…