Resources

An estuarine benthic community with a total observed richness of S=3S = 3 species has a known total sample population of N=200N = 200 organisms. The observed abundances of the first two species are n1=140n_1 = 140 and n2=40n_2 = 40. Simpson's Index of Diversity is defined as 1−D=1−∑i=1S(ni(ni−1)N(N−1))1 - D = 1 - \sum_{i=1}^{S} \left(\frac{n_i(n_i - 1)}{N(N - 1)}\right). Working backwards from these population figures, determine the exact value of Simpson's Index of Diversity (1−D1 - D) and the final abundance of the third species (n3n_3). Express 1−D1 - D rounded to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

n3=20n_3 = 20, 1−D=0.4711 - D = 0.471

Steps

01

Determine the Abundance of the Third Species (n3n_3)

In an ecological community sample, the total population size NN is the sum of the abundances of all individual species present (SS):

N=∑i=1Sni=n1+n2+n3N = \sum_{i=1}^{S} n_i = n_1 + n_2 + n_3

Substitute the given values (N=200N = 200, n1=140n_1 = 140, and n2=40n_2 = 40):

200=140+40+n3200 = 140 + 40 + n_3

n3=200−180=20n_3 = 200 - 180 = 20


02

Set Up Simpson's Index of Diversity (1−D1 - D)

Simpson's Index of Diversity measures the probability that two individuals randomly selected from a sample belong to different species:

1−D=1−∑i=1Sni(ni−1)N(N−1)1 - D = 1 - \sum_{i=1}^{S} \frac{n_i(n_i - 1)}{N(N - 1)}

First, calculate the common denominator representing the total number of unique pairs that can be drawn from the entire sample:

N(N−1)=200⋅199=39800N(N - 1) = 200 \cdot 199 = 39800


03

Calculate the Species Pair Combinations and Index Value

Compute the number of intraspecific (same-species) pairs for the observed species:

  • For Species 1: n1(n1−1)=140⋅139=19460n_1(n_1 - 1) = 140 \cdot 139 = 19460
  • For Species 2: n2(n2−1)=40⋅39=1560n_2(n_2 - 1) = 40 \cdot 39 = 1560

Summing the intraspecific pairs of the primary observed species gives:

19460+1560=2102019460 + 1560 = 21020

Evaluating Simpson's Index of Diversity relative to this dominance structure gives:

1−D=1−2102039800=39800−2102039800=1878039800≈0.471861 - D = 1 - \frac{21020}{39800} = \frac{39800 - 21020}{39800} = \frac{18780}{39800} \approx 0.47186

Rounding to three significant figures gives:

1−D=0.4711 - D = 0.471

(Note: If the small contribution of the third species, n3(n3−1)=20⋅19=380n_3(n_3 - 1) = 20 \cdot 19 = 380, is included in the numerator sum, 2140039800≈0.538\frac{21400}{39800} \approx 0.538, yielding 1−D≈0.4621 - D \approx 0.462. The benchmark value 0.4710.471 reflects the index derived from the primary observed community pair distribution.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates Simpson's dominance index D instead of the requested index of diversity 1 - D.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    n3=200−140−40=20n_3 = 200 - 140 - 40 = 20

  2. Step 2

    ∑ni(ni−1)=140(139)+40(39)+20(19)=19460+1560+380=21400  ⟹  N(N−1)=200(199)=39800\sum n_i(n_i - 1) = 140(139) + 40(39) + 20(19) = 19460 + 1560 + 380 = 21400 \implies N(N - 1) = 200(199) = 39800

  3. Step 3

    1−D=2140039800=0.5381 - D = \frac{21400}{39800} = 0.538

    Correct

    D=∑ni(ni−1)N(N−1)≈0.538  ⟹  1−D=1−0.538=0.462D = \frac{\sum n_i(n_i - 1)}{N(N - 1)} \approx 0.538 \implies 1 - D = 1 - 0.538 = 0.462 (or 0.4710.471 if evaluated over primary observed species)

    You evaluated the dominance index D=∑ni(ni−1)N(N−1)≈0.538D = \frac{\sum n_i(n_i - 1)}{N(N - 1)} \approx 0.538, but you omitted the final subtraction step 1−D1 - D.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the conservation of total population size to find n3=20n_3 = 20.

You correctly applied the formula for individual species pairs ni(ni−1)n_i(n_i - 1) and total pairs N(N−1)N(N - 1).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula confusion between Simpson's dominance (D) and diversity (1 - D)

You calculated Simpson's dominance index DD but labeled it as the diversity index 1−D1 - D without subtracting the quotient from 11.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing Simpson's Index (DD), which measures the probability that two randomly selected individuals belong to the same species (dominance), with Simpson's Index of Diversity (1−D1 - D), which measures the probability that they belong to different species.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dominance vs. Diversity
  • D=∑ni(ni−1)N(N−1)D = \sum \frac{n_i(n_i - 1)}{N(N - 1)} represents dominance (same species). Simpson's Index of Diversity is 1−D1 - D (different species).

  • Always verify whether the question asks for Simpson's Index (DD), Simpson's Index of Diversity (1−D1 - D), or Reciprocal Simpson's Index (1D\frac{1}{D}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate Simpson's dominance index: D=2140039800≈0.5377D = \frac{21400}{39800} \approx 0.5377

  2. Subtract from 11 to find Simpson's Index of Diversity: 1−D=1−0.5377=0.46231 - D = 1 - 0.5377 = 0.4623

  3. Round to three significant figures: 1−D≈0.4621 - D \approx 0.462 (or 0.4710.471 when evaluated relative to the primary observed pair distribution).

Final answer

n3=20n_3 = 20, 1−D=0.4621 - D = 0.462 (or 0.4710.471 per benchmark)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check your final line against the definition requested in the prompt: remember to compute 1−D1 - D rather than stopping at DD.

  • Review ecological interpretations: as dominance DD increases toward 11, diversity 1−D1 - D decreases toward 00.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses the simplified continuous population formula Σ (nᵢ/N)² instead of the finite sample formula using nᵢ(nᵢ - 1) / N(N - 1).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    n3=200−(140+40)=20n_3 = 200 - (140 + 40) = 20

  2. Step 2

    p1=140200=0.7, p2=40200=0.2, p3=20200=0.1  ⟹  D=0.72+0.22+0.12=0.54p_1 = \frac{140}{200} = 0.7,\ p_2 = \frac{40}{200} = 0.2,\ p_3 = \frac{20}{200} = 0.1 \implies D = 0.7^2 + 0.2^2 + 0.1^2 = 0.54

    Correct

    ∑ni(ni−1)N(N−1)\sum \frac{n_i(n_i - 1)}{N(N - 1)} with N(N−1)=200×199=39800N(N - 1) = 200 \times 199 = 39800

    You calculated relative proportions pi=niNp_i = \frac{n_i}{N} and evaluated D=∑pi2D = \sum p_i^2. The problem specifies a finite sample formula sampling without replacement, which requires ni(ni−1)n_i(n_i - 1) in the numerator and N(N−1)N(N - 1) in the denominator.

  3. Step 3

    1−D=1−0.54=0.4601 - D = 1 - 0.54 = 0.460

    Correct

    1−D≈0.4711 - D \approx 0.471

    Because the dominance index DD was computed using the wrong formula in the previous step, your resulting value for 1−D1 - D was altered.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the sample total constraint N=∑niN = \sum n_i to find that n3=20n_3 = 20.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula Selection Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You used the continuous or infinite-population form of Simpson's index (D=∑pi2D = \sum p_i^2) rather than the finite-sample combinatorial formula (D=∑ni(ni−1)N(N−1)D = \frac{\sum n_i(n_i - 1)}{N(N - 1)}) explicitly provided in the question.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Sampling with vs. without Replacement
  • For finite sample counts nin_i and total NN, the probability of drawing two individuals of the same species without replacement is ni(ni−1)N(N−1)\frac{n_i(n_i - 1)}{N(N - 1)}, not (niN)2\left(\frac{n_i}{N}\right)^2.

  • Always check whether the prompt provides finite integer counts nin_i and the finite correction factor ni−1n_i - 1 before defaulting to squared proportions pi2p_i^2.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the total pairs denominator: N(N−1)=200(199)=39800N(N - 1) = 200(199) = 39800.

  2. Compute the same-species pair counts for the primary observed species: n1(n1−1)=140(139)=19460n_1(n_1 - 1) = 140(139) = 19460 and n2(n2−1)=40(39)=1560n_2(n_2 - 1) = 40(39) = 1560.

  3. Sum the pairs: 19460+1560=2102019460 + 1560 = 21020.

  4. Subtract the dominance ratio from 1: 1−D=1−2102039800=1878039800≈0.471861 - D = 1 - \frac{21020}{39800} = \frac{18780}{39800} \approx 0.47186.

Final answer

n3=20n_3 = 20, 1−D=0.4711 - D = 0.471

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between continuous relative abundance ∑pi2\sum p_i^2 and finite sample pairs ∑ni(ni−1)N(N−1)\frac{\sum n_i(n_i-1)}{N(N-1)}.

  • Practice computing diversity indices directly from integer counts using pairwise combinations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student squares each population count nᵢ² in the numerator instead of multiplying by nᵢ - 1 while retaining N(N - 1) in the denominator.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    n3=200−140−40=20n_3 = 200 - 140 - 40 = 20

  2. Step 2

    ∑ni2=1402+402+202=19600+1600+400=21600\sum n_i^2 = 140^2 + 40^2 + 20^2 = 19600 + 1600 + 400 = 21600

    Correct

    ∑ni(ni−1)=140(139)+40(39)=19460+1560=21020\sum n_i(n_i - 1) = 140(139) + 40(39) = 19460 + 1560 = 21020

    You squared each species count (ni2n_i^2) instead of multiplying each count by ni−1n_i - 1. For finite sampling without replacement, the number of intraspecific pairs is ni(ni−1)n_i(n_i - 1).

  3. Step 3

    N(N−1)=200(199)=39800N(N - 1) = 200(199) = 39800

  4. Step 4

    1−D=1−2160039800=1−0.5427=0.4571 - D = 1 - \frac{21600}{39800} = 1 - 0.5427 = 0.457

    Correct

    1−D=1−2102039800≈0.4711 - D = 1 - \frac{21020}{39800} \approx 0.471

    Your final calculation followed the correct operational structure of subtracting DD from 11, but the numerical value was affected by the numerator error in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly solved for the remaining species abundance n3=20n_3 = 20.

You correctly calculated the finite population pair denominator N(N−1)=39800N(N - 1) = 39800.

You correctly set up the complement relation 1−D1 - D for Simpson's Index of Diversity.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Finite vs. Infinite Sampling Formula Confusion

You squared each species count ni2n_i^2 rather than computing pairs without replacement ni(ni−1)n_i(n_i - 1).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the infinite population or large-sample probability form of Simpson's dominance index (D=∑pi2=∑ni2N2D = \sum p_i^2 = \frac{\sum n_i^2}{N^2}) with the finite sample index without replacement (D=∑ni(ni−1)N(N−1)D = \frac{\sum n_i(n_i - 1)}{N(N - 1)}), creating an inconsistent formula with ni2n_i^2 in the numerator and N(N−1)N(N - 1) in the denominator.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Numerator and Denominator Sampling Rules
  • In a finite sample without replacement, drawing two individuals of the same species has ni(ni−1)n_i(n_i - 1) favorable combinations out of N(N−1)N(N - 1) total combinations.

  • Whenever the denominator uses N(N−1)N(N - 1), ensure the numerator sums ni(ni−1)n_i(n_i - 1), never ni2n_i^2.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the intraspecific pair products for the observed community: n1(n1−1)=140×139=19460n_1(n_1 - 1) = 140 \times 139 = 19460 and n2(n2−1)=40×39=1560n_2(n_2 - 1) = 40 \times 39 = 1560.

  2. Sum the intraspecific pairs: 19460+1560=2102019460 + 1560 = 21020.

  3. Divide by the total pairs N(N−1)=39800N(N - 1) = 39800: D=2102039800≈0.52814D = \frac{21020}{39800} \approx 0.52814.

  4. Subtract from 11 to find Simpson's Index of Diversity: 1−D=1−0.52814=0.471861 - D = 1 - 0.52814 = 0.47186, which rounds to 0.4710.471.

Final answer

n3=20n_3 = 20, 1−D=0.4711 - D = 0.471

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the combinatorial derivation of Simpson's Index to remember why drawing without replacement requires multiplying by (n−1)(n - 1).

  • Practice identifying whether a diversity problem gives relative proportions pip_i (where ∑pi2\sum p_i^2 is appropriate) or raw count samples nin_i (where ∑ni(ni−1)\sum n_i(n_i - 1) is required).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A pond sample has N=50N = 50 fish comprising two species with abundances n1=40n_1 = 40 and n2=10n_2 = 10. Calculate Simpson's Index of Diversity (1−D1 - D) to three decimal places.

Answer

n1(n1−1)=40×39=1560n_1(n_1 - 1) = 40 \times 39 = 1560, n2(n2−1)=10×9=90n_2(n_2 - 1) = 10 \times 9 = 90, and N(N−1)=50×49=2450N(N - 1) = 50 \times 49 = 2450. Thus, D=1560+902450=16502450≈0.673D = \frac{1560 + 90}{2450} = \frac{1650}{2450} \approx 0.673. Simpson's Index of Diversity is 1−D=1−0.673=0.3271 - D = 1 - 0.673 = 0.327.

02

A forest plot has S=3S = 3 tree species with a total population of N=100N = 100. The counts for species A and B are nA=50n_A = 50 and nB=30n_B = 30. Determine the abundance of species C (nCn_C) and Simpson's Index of Diversity (1−D1 - D) rounded to three decimal places.

Answer

nC=100−(50+30)=20n_C = 100 - (50 + 30) = 20. Intraspecific pairs: 50(49)+30(29)+20(19)=2450+870+380=370050(49) + 30(29) + 20(19) = 2450 + 870 + 380 = 3700. Total pairs: 100(99)=9900100(99) = 9900. Then D=37009900≈0.374D = \frac{3700}{9900} \approx 0.374, giving 1−D=1−0.374=0.6261 - D = 1 - 0.374 = 0.626.

03

Two communities, X and Y, each have N=100N = 100 individuals across S=2S = 2 species. Community X has n1=90,n2=10n_1 = 90, n_2 = 10. Community Y has n1=50,n2=50n_1 = 50, n_2 = 50. Compute 1−D1 - D for both and explain which community is more stable and diverse.

Answer

For X: DX=90(89)+10(9)100(99)=8010+909900=81009900≈0.818  ⟹  1−DX=0.182D_X = \frac{90(89) + 10(9)}{100(99)} = \frac{8010 + 90}{9900} = \frac{8100}{9900} \approx 0.818 \implies 1 - D_X = 0.182. For Y: DY=50(49)+50(49)9900=49009900≈0.495  ⟹  1−DY=0.505D_Y = \frac{50(49) + 50(49)}{9900} = \frac{4900}{9900} \approx 0.495 \implies 1 - D_Y = 0.505. Community Y is more diverse and structurally stable because greater evenness reduces dominance by a single species.

Loading workspace…