Resources

A mammalian neurocyte maintains an intracellular sodium ion concentration of [Na+]in=12 mM[\text{Na}^+]_{\text{in}} = 12\text{ mM} and an extracellular concentration of [Na+]out=145 mM[\text{Na}^+]_{\text{out}} = 145\text{ mM}, while its intracellular potassium concentration is [K+]in=140 mM[\text{K}^+]_{\text{in}} = 140\text{ mM} and extracellular concentration is [K+]out=4.5 mM[\text{K}^+]_{\text{out}} = 4.5\text{ mM}. The membrane maintains a resting potential of Vm=−70 mVV_m = -70\text{ mV} (relative to the outside). The Na+/K+\text{Na}^+/\text{K}^+-ATPase hydrolyzes 1 mol1\text{ mol} of ATP\text{ATP} (ΔGATP=−50.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = -50.0\text{ kJ/mol} under intracellular conditions) to export 3 mol3\text{ mol} of Na+\text{Na}^+ and import 2 mol2\text{ mol} of K+\text{K}^+. Using the electrochemical potential equation ΔG=RTln⁡(CdestCsource)+zFΔV\Delta G = R T \ln\left(\frac{C_{\text{dest}}}{C_{\text{source}}}\right) + z F \Delta V with T=310 KT = 310\text{ K}, R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}), and F=96485 C/molF = 96485\text{ C/mol}, calculate: (a) the net electrochemical free energy change ΔGtransport\Delta G_{\text{transport}} required to move 3 mol3\text{ mol} of Na+\text{Na}^+ out and 2 mol2\text{ mol} of K+\text{K}^+ in, and (b) whether one mole of ATP\text{ATP} hydrolysis provides thermodynamically sufficient energy to drive this single pump cycle.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) ΔGtransport=+42.9 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +42.9\text{ kJ/mol}; (b) Yes, one mole of ATP\text{ATP} hydrolysis is thermodynamically sufficient because ∣ΔGATP∣=50.0 kJ/mol>42.9 kJ/mol|\Delta G_{\text{ATP}}| = 50.0\text{ kJ/mol} > 42.9\text{ kJ/mol} (net ΔGcoupled=−7.1 kJ/mol<0\Delta G_{\text{coupled}} = -7.1\text{ kJ/mol} < 0).

Steps

01

Understand the Free Energy of Electrochemical Transport

Moving an ion across a biological membrane involves both a concentration gradient (chemical component) and an electrical potential difference (electrical component). The molar free energy change ΔG\Delta G for transporting an ion from a source compartment to a destination compartment is given by:

ΔG=RTln⁡(CdestCsource)+zFΔV\Delta G = R T \ln\left(\frac{C_{\text{dest}}}{C_{\text{source}}}\right) + z F \Delta V

where:

  • R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})
  • T=310 KT = 310\text{ K}, so RT=8.314⋅310≈2577 J/mol=2.577 kJ/molR T = 8.314 \cdot 310 \approx 2577\text{ J/mol} = 2.577\text{ kJ/mol}
  • zz is the valence (charge) of the ion (+1+1 for both NaX+\ce{Na^+} and KX+\ce{K^+})
  • F=96485 C/mol≈96.5 kJ/(V⋅mol)F = 96485\text{ C/mol} \approx 96.5\text{ kJ}/(\text{V}\cdot\text{mol})
  • ΔV=Vdest−Vsource\Delta V = V_{\text{dest}} - V_{\text{source}} is the electrical potential difference experienced by the moving ion

02

Calculate the Free Energy Change for NaX+\ce{Na^+} Export

The pump exports 3 mol3\text{ mol} of NaX+\ce{Na^+} from inside (Vin=−70 mV=−0.070 VV_{\text{in}} = -70\text{ mV} = -0.070\text{ V}) to outside (Vout=0 VV_{\text{out}} = 0\text{ V}):

  • ΔV=Vout−Vin=0−(−0.070 V)=+0.070 V\Delta V = V_{\text{out}} - V_{\text{in}} = 0 - (-0.070\text{ V}) = +0.070\text{ V}
  • Concentration ratio: [NaX+]out[NaX+]in=14512≈12.08\frac{[\ce{Na^+}]_{\text{out}}}{[\ce{Na^+}]_{\text{in}}} = \frac{145}{12} \approx 12.08

Calculate the individual molar free energy change for NaX+\ce{Na^+}:

  1. Chemical work: ΔGchem(NaX+)=RTln⁡(14512)=2.577⋅ln⁡(12.08)≈2.577⋅2.492≈+6.42 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}}(\ce{Na^+}) = R T \ln\left(\frac{145}{12}\right) = 2.577 \cdot \ln(12.08) \approx 2.577 \cdot 2.492 \approx +6.42\text{ kJ/mol}
  2. Electrical work: ΔGelec(NaX+)=zFΔV=(+1)⋅96.485⋅(+0.070)≈+6.75 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}}(\ce{Na^+}) = z F \Delta V = (+1) \cdot 96.485 \cdot (+0.070) \approx +6.75\text{ kJ/mol}

Both concentration and electrical gradients oppose NaX+\ce{Na^+} export: ΔG(NaX+)=+6.42 kJ/mol+6.75 kJ/mol=+13.17 kJ/mol\Delta G(\ce{Na^+}) = +6.42\text{ kJ/mol} + 6.75\text{ kJ/mol} = +13.17\text{ kJ/mol}

For 3 mol3\text{ mol} of NaX+\ce{Na^+}: ΔG3NaX+=3⋅(+13.17 kJ/mol)≈+39.5 kJ\Delta G_{3\ce{Na^+}} = 3 \cdot (+13.17\text{ kJ/mol}) \approx +39.5\text{ kJ}


03

Calculate the Free Energy Change for KX+\ce{K^+} Import

The pump imports 2 mol2\text{ mol} of KX+\ce{K^+} from outside (Vout=0 VV_{\text{out}} = 0\text{ V}) to inside (Vin=−0.070 VV_{\text{in}} = -0.070\text{ V}):

  • ΔV=Vin−Vout=−0.070 V−0=−0.070 V\Delta V = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}} = -0.070\text{ V} - 0 = -0.070\text{ V}
  • Concentration ratio: [KX+]in[KX+]out=1404.5≈31.11\frac{[\ce{K^+}]_{\text{in}}}{[\ce{K^+}]_{\text{out}}} = \frac{140}{4.5} \approx 31.11

Calculate the individual molar free energy change for KX+\ce{K^+}:

  1. Chemical work: ΔGchem(KX+)=RTln⁡(1404.5)=2.577⋅ln⁡(31.11)≈2.577⋅3.438≈+8.86 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}}(\ce{K^+}) = R T \ln\left(\frac{140}{4.5}\right) = 2.577 \cdot \ln(31.11) \approx 2.577 \cdot 3.438 \approx +8.86\text{ kJ/mol}
  2. Electrical work: ΔGelec(KX+)=zFΔV=(+1)⋅96.485⋅(−0.070)≈−6.75 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}}(\ce{K^+}) = z F \Delta V = (+1) \cdot 96.485 \cdot (-0.070) \approx -6.75\text{ kJ/mol}

Common Pitfall: Notice that the interior-negative membrane potential favors the influx of positive ions (ΔGelec<0\Delta G_{\text{elec}} < 0). This partially offsets the unfavorable concentration gradient.

Net free energy change for 1 mol1\text{ mol} of KX+\ce{K^+} imported: ΔG(KX+)=+8.45 kJ/mol−6.75 kJ/mol≈+1.7 kJ/mol\Delta G(\ce{K^+}) = +8.45\text{ kJ/mol} - 6.75\text{ kJ/mol} \approx +1.7\text{ kJ/mol}

For 2 mol2\text{ mol} of KX+\ce{K^+}: ΔG2KX+=2⋅(+1.7 kJ/mol)≈+3.4 kJ\Delta G_{2\ce{K^+}} = 2 \cdot (+1.7\text{ kJ/mol}) \approx +3.4\text{ kJ}


04

Determine Total Transport Free Energy ΔGtransport\Delta G_{\text{transport}}

Summing the energy required for both ions per pump cycle: ΔGtransport=ΔG3NaX++ΔG2KX+=+39.5 kJ+3.4 kJ=+42.9 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = \Delta G_{3\ce{Na^+}} + \Delta G_{2\ce{K^+}} = +39.5\text{ kJ} + 3.4\text{ kJ} = +42.9\text{ kJ/mol}


05

Thermodynamic Feasibility of Coupling to ATP\ce{ATP} Hydrolysis

Hydrolysis of 1 mol1\text{ mol} of ATP\ce{ATP} releases ΔGATP=−50.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\ce{ATP}} = -50.0\text{ kJ/mol} under intracellular conditions.

The overall coupled process free energy change is: ΔGcoupled=ΔGtransport+ΔGATP=+42.9 kJ/mol+(−50.0 kJ/mol)=−7.1 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{coupled}} = \Delta G_{\text{transport}} + \Delta G_{\ce{ATP}} = +42.9\text{ kJ/mol} + (-50.0\text{ kJ/mol}) = -7.1\text{ kJ/mol}

Because ΔGcoupled<0\Delta G_{\text{coupled}} < 0 (and ∣ΔGATP∣=50.0 kJ/mol>ΔGtransport=42.9 kJ/mol|\Delta G_{\ce{ATP}}| = 50.0\text{ kJ/mol} > \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 42.9\text{ kJ/mol}), the reaction is exergonic, meaning one mole of ATP\ce{ATP} hydrolysis is thermodynamically sufficient to drive the transport cycle.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misassigns the sign of the electrical potential difference by using Vm = -70 mV for export rather than recognizing that moving a positive ion from inside (-70 mV) to outside (0 mV) experiences a potential increase of +70 mV.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ΔG(Na+)=3×(8.314×310×ln⁡(14512)+1×96485×(−0.070)) J  ⟹  ΔG(Na+)=3×(6423.8−6754.0)=3×(−330.2)=−990.6 J=−0.99 kJ\Delta G(\text{Na}^+) = 3 \times \left(8.314 \times 310 \times \ln\left(\frac{145}{12}\right) + 1 \times 96485 \times (-0.070)\right)\text{ J} \implies \Delta G(\text{Na}^+) = 3 \times (6423.8 - 6754.0) = 3 \times (-330.2) = -990.6\text{ J} = -0.99\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    ΔG(Na+)=3×(RTln⁡([Na+]out[Na+]in)+zF(Vout−Vin))=3×(6423.8+6754.0) J=+39.53 kJ\Delta G(\text{Na}^+) = 3 \times \left(R T \ln\left(\frac{[\text{Na}^+]_{\text{out}}}{[\text{Na}^+]_{\text{in}}}\right) + z F (V_{\text{out}} - V_{\text{in}})\right) = 3 \times (6423.8 + 6754.0)\text{ J} = +39.53\text{ kJ}

    You substituted ΔV=−0.070 V\Delta V = -0.070\text{ V} for sodium export. Because sodium is moving from the negative interior (−70 mV-70\text{ mV}) to the neutral exterior (0 mV0\text{ mV}), the potential change is ΔV=Vdest−Vsource=0−(−0.070)=+0.070 V\Delta V = V_{\text{dest}} - V_{\text{source}} = 0 - (-0.070) = +0.070\text{ V}. Moving a positive ion out of a negatively charged cell requires electrical work.

  2. Step 2

    ΔG(K+)=2×(8.314×310×ln⁡(1404.5)+1×96485×(−0.070)) J  ⟹  ΔG(K+)=2×(8856.1−6754.0)=2×2102.1=4204.2 J=4.20 kJ\Delta G(\text{K}^+) = 2 \times \left(8.314 \times 310 \times \ln\left(\frac{140}{4.5}\right) + 1 \times 96485 \times (-0.070)\right)\text{ J} \implies \Delta G(\text{K}^+) = 2 \times (8856.1 - 6754.0) = 2 \times 2102.1 = 4204.2\text{ J} = 4.20\text{ kJ}

  3. Step 3

    ΔGtransport=−0.99 kJ+4.20 kJ=+3.21 kJ\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = -0.99\text{ kJ} + 4.20\text{ kJ} = +3.21\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    ΔGtransport=+39.53 kJ+4.21 kJ=+43.74 kJ\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +39.53\text{ kJ} + 4.21\text{ kJ} = +43.74\text{ kJ} (or ≈+42.9 kJ\approx +42.9\text{ kJ} with intermediate rounding)

    Your sum correctly added your previous results, but it inherited the sign error from Step 1.

  4. Step 4

    ∣ΔGATP∣=50.0 kJ>3.21 kJ|\Delta G_{\text{ATP}}| = 50.0\text{ kJ} > 3.21\text{ kJ}, so ATP hydrolysis is thermodynamically sufficient.

    Correct

    ∣ΔGATP∣=50.0 kJ>43.7 kJ|\Delta G_{\text{ATP}}| = 50.0\text{ kJ} > 43.7\text{ kJ}, so ATP hydrolysis is thermodynamically sufficient (+43.7 kJ−50.0 kJ=−6.3 kJ<0+43.7\text{ kJ} - 50.0\text{ kJ} = -6.3\text{ kJ} < 0).

    Your qualitative conclusion is correct, but your quantitative comparison relied on the understated transport energy of +3.21 kJ+3.21\text{ kJ} instead of ≈+43 kJ\approx +43\text{ kJ}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and structured the electrochemical potential equation ΔG=RTln⁡(Cdest/Csource)+zFΔV\Delta G = R T \ln(C_{\text{dest}}/C_{\text{source}}) + z F \Delta V.

You accurately converted units, evaluated natural logarithms, and multiplied by the stoichiometric coefficients for both ions.

You correctly assigned ΔV=−0.070 V\Delta V = -0.070\text{ V} for potassium import into the negative cell interior.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in electrical potential difference ($\Delta V$)

You copied the resting membrane potential Vm=−70 mVV_m = -70\text{ mV} directly into the sodium term without defining ΔV\Delta V relative to the direction of ion movement.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the absolute membrane potential Vm=Vin−VoutV_m = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}} with the directional potential difference ΔV=Vdest−Vsource\Delta V = V_{\text{dest}} - V_{\text{source}} experienced by a translocating ion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Directional Potential Difference
  • Always define ΔV=Vdestination−Vsource\Delta V = V_{\text{destination}} - V_{\text{source}}.

  • For export (in →\to out), set ΔV=Vout−Vin=0−(−70 mV)=+70 mV\Delta V = V_{\text{out}} - V_{\text{in}} = 0 - (-70\text{ mV}) = +70\text{ mV}. For import (out →\to in), set ΔV=Vin−Vout=−70 mV−0=−70 mV\Delta V = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}} = -70\text{ mV} - 0 = -70\text{ mV}.

Physical Reality Check
  • Cations are attracted to negative regions and repelled by positive regions.

  • Moving a positive Na+\text{Na}^+ ion away from the negatively charged interior must require electrical energy input (ΔGelec>0\Delta G_{\text{elec}} > 0).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recalculate the electrical work for Na+\text{Na}^+ export: zFΔV=(+1)(96485 C/mol)(+0.070 V)=+6754.0 J/molz F \Delta V = (+1)(96485\text{ C/mol})(+0.070\text{ V}) = +6754.0\text{ J/mol}.

  2. Find total molar free energy for Na+\text{Na}^+: ΔGmolar(Na+)=6423.8+6754.0=13177.8 J/mol=+13.18 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{molar}}(\text{Na}^+) = 6423.8 + 6754.0 = 13177.8\text{ J/mol} = +13.18\text{ kJ/mol}.

  3. Multiply by 3 mol3\text{ mol}: ΔG(Na+)=3×13.178 kJ=+39.53 kJ\Delta G(\text{Na}^+) = 3 \times 13.178\text{ kJ} = +39.53\text{ kJ}.

  4. Add the energy for 2 mol2\text{ mol} of K+\text{K}^+: ΔGtransport=+39.53 kJ+4.21 kJ=+43.74 kJ\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +39.53\text{ kJ} + 4.21\text{ kJ} = +43.74\text{ kJ} (or +42.9 kJ+42.9\text{ kJ} using unrounded components).

  5. Compare with ATP: 50.0 kJ>43.7 kJ50.0\text{ kJ} > 43.7\text{ kJ}, confirming net ΔG=−6.3 kJ/mol<0\Delta G = -6.3\text{ kJ/mol} < 0.

Final answer

(a) ΔGtransport=+42.9 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +42.9\text{ kJ/mol} (or +43.7 kJ/mol+43.7\text{ kJ/mol}); (b) Yes, one mole of ATP hydrolysis is thermodynamically sufficient because ∣ΔGATP∣=50.0 kJ/mol>ΔGtransport|\Delta G_{\text{ATP}}| = 50.0\text{ kJ/mol} > \Delta G_{\text{transport}}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice establishing an explicit 'Destination minus Source' coordinate system before computing electrical work for membrane transport.

  • Perform a qualitative sanity check: moving cations from negative inside to positive/neutral outside must always yield positive electrical work ΔGelec>0\Delta G_{\text{elec}} > 0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the free energy changes per mole of ion correctly but neglects to multiply by the stoichiometry of 3 Na⁺ and 2 K⁺ per pump cycle.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ΔG(NaX+)=8.314×310×ln⁡(14512)+1×96485×0.070  ⟹  =6424 J/mol+6754 J/mol  ⟹  =13.18 kJ/mol\Delta G(\ce{Na^+}) = 8.314 \times 310 \times \ln\left(\frac{145}{12}\right) + 1 \times 96485 \times 0.070 \implies = 6424\text{ J/mol} + 6754\text{ J/mol} \implies = 13.18\text{ kJ/mol}

  2. Step 2

    ΔG(KX+)=8.314×310×ln⁡(1404.5)+1×96485×(−0.070)  ⟹  =8856 J/mol−6754 J/mol  ⟹  =2.10 kJ/mol\Delta G(\ce{K^+}) = 8.314 \times 310 \times \ln\left(\frac{140}{4.5}\right) + 1 \times 96485 \times (-0.070) \implies = 8856\text{ J/mol} - 6754\text{ J/mol} \implies = 2.10\text{ kJ/mol}

  3. Step 3

    ΔGtransport=13.18 kJ+2.10 kJ=15.28 kJ\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 13.18\text{ kJ} + 2.10\text{ kJ} = 15.28\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    ΔGtransport=3 ΔG(NaX+)+2 ΔG(KX+)=3(13.18 kJ/mol)+2(2.10 kJ/mol)≈+42.9 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 3\,\Delta G(\ce{Na^+}) + 2\,\Delta G(\ce{K^+}) = 3(13.18\text{ kJ/mol}) + 2(2.10\text{ kJ/mol}) \approx +42.9\text{ kJ/mol}

    You added the free energy changes in a 1:11:1 ratio instead of multiplying by the actual transport stoichiometry (3 mol NaX+3\text{ mol }\ce{Na+} out and 2 mol KX+2\text{ mol }\ce{K+} in per pump cycle).

  4. Step 4

    Because 15.28 kJ<50.0 kJ,1 mol ATP hydrolysis is sufficient.\text{Because } 15.28\text{ kJ} < 50.0\text{ kJ}, 1\text{ mol ATP}\text{ hydrolysis is sufficient.}

    Correct

    Because 42.9 kJ/mol<50.0 kJ/mol (net ΔGcoupled=−7.1 kJ/mol<0),1 mol ATP hydrolysis is sufficient.\text{Because } 42.9\text{ kJ/mol} < 50.0\text{ kJ/mol} \text{ (net } \Delta G_{\text{coupled}} = -7.1\text{ kJ/mol} < 0\text{)}, 1\text{ mol }\ce{ATP}\text{ hydrolysis is sufficient.}

    Your qualitative conclusion is correct, but your quantitative comparison relied on the unweighted total from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the Nernst-Planck electrochemical potential formula combining chemical and electrical free energy components.

You accurately identified the signs of ΔV\Delta V for export versus import across the −70 mV-70\text{ mV} resting potential.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Missing stoichiometric multiplier

You summed the per-mole ion energies directly without scaling by the number of moles moved per pump cycle.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the total pump cycle free energy as a simple sum of unit ion transport values, overlooking that the cycle moves ions in a fixed 3NaX+:2KX+3\ce{Na+} : 2\ce{K+} stoichiometry.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check pump stoichiometry
  • Total cycle free energy must weight each ion's molar ΔG\Delta G by its stoichiometric coefficient: ΔGcycle=nNaX+ΔG(NaX+)+nKX+ΔG(KX+)\Delta G_{\text{cycle}} = n_{\ce{Na+}}\Delta G(\ce{Na+}) + n_{\ce{K+}}\Delta G(\ce{K+}).

  • Always write down the stoichiometric equation (3NaX+in+2KX+out+ATP→3NaX+out+2KX+in+ADP+PXi3\ce{Na+}_{\text{in}} + 2\ce{K+}_{\text{out}} + \ce{ATP} \rightarrow 3\ce{Na+}_{\text{out}} + 2\ce{K+}_{\text{in}} + \ce{ADP} + \ce{P_i}) before summing molar quantities.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply the molar free energy of NaX+\ce{Na+} export by 33: 3×13.18 kJ/mol=39.54 kJ/mol3 \times 13.18\text{ kJ/mol} = 39.54\text{ kJ/mol}.

  2. Multiply the molar free energy of KX+\ce{K+} import by 22: 2×2.10 kJ/mol=4.20 kJ/mol2 \times 2.10\text{ kJ/mol} = 4.20\text{ kJ/mol}.

  3. Sum both contributions: ΔGtransport=39.54 kJ/mol+4.20 kJ/mol=43.74 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 39.54\text{ kJ/mol} + 4.20\text{ kJ/mol} = 43.74\text{ kJ/mol} (or +42.9 kJ/mol+42.9\text{ kJ/mol} using unrounded values).

  4. Compare with ATP\ce{ATP} hydrolysis: since 42.9 kJ/mol<50.0 kJ/mol42.9\text{ kJ/mol} < 50.0\text{ kJ/mol} (net ΔG=−7.1 kJ/mol<0\Delta G = -7.1\text{ kJ/mol} < 0), one mole of ATP\ce{ATP} is sufficient.

Final answer

(a) ΔGtransport=+42.9 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +42.9\text{ kJ/mol}; (b) Yes, 1 mol1\text{ mol} of ATP\ce{ATP} hydrolysis is sufficient because ∣ΔGATP∣=50.0 kJ/mol>42.9 kJ/mol|\Delta G_{\ce{ATP}}| = 50.0\text{ kJ/mol} > 42.9\text{ kJ/mol}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the stoichiometric coefficients of membrane transport proteins before calculating total thermodynamic cost.

  • Practice coupling stoichiometric transport equations directly to ATP hydrolysis free energy.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the concentration ratios in the chemical potential term, using source over destination instead of destination over source.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔG(NaX+)=3×(8.314×310×ln⁡(12/145)+1×96485×0.070) J⟹ΔG(NaX+)=3×(−6423.8+6754.0)=3×330.2=990.6 J=0.99 kJ\Delta G(\ce{Na+}) = 3 \times (8.314 \times 310 \times \ln(12/145) + 1 \times 96485 \times 0.070)\text{ J} \Longrightarrow \Delta G(\ce{Na+}) = 3 \times (-6423.8 + 6754.0) = 3 \times 330.2 = 990.6\text{ J} = 0.99\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    ΔG(NaX+)=3×[8.314×310×ln⁡(145/12)+1×96485×0.070] J=3×(6423.8+6754.0) J=+39.5 kJ\Delta G(\ce{Na+}) = 3 \times [8.314 \times 310 \times \ln(145/12) + 1 \times 96485 \times 0.070]\text{ J} = 3 \times (6423.8 + 6754.0)\text{ J} = +39.5\text{ kJ}

    You inverted the concentration ratio in the chemical potential term. Sodium is exported from inside (12 mM12\text{ mM}) to outside (145 mM145\text{ mM}), so CdestCsource=14512\frac{C_{\text{dest}}}{C_{\text{source}}} = \frac{145}{12}. Because the ion is moving against its chemical gradient, this term must be positive (+6.42 kJ/mol+6.42\text{ kJ/mol}). Your calculation yielded −6.42 kJ/mol-6.42\text{ kJ/mol}, making the net energy change much too small.

  2. Step 2

    ΔG(KX+)=2×(8.314×310×ln⁡(4.5/140)+1×96485×(−0.070)) J⟹ΔG(KX+)=2×(−8856.1−6754.0)=2×(−15610.1)=−31220.2 J=−31.22 kJ\Delta G(\ce{K+}) = 2 \times (8.314 \times 310 \times \ln(4.5/140) + 1 \times 96485 \times (-0.070))\text{ J} \Longrightarrow \Delta G(\ce{K+}) = 2 \times (-8856.1 - 6754.0) = 2 \times (-15610.1) = -31220.2\text{ J} = -31.22\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    ΔG(KX+)=2×[8.314×310×ln⁡(140/4.5)+1×96485×(−0.070)] J=2×(8856.1−6754.0) J=+3.4 kJ\Delta G(\ce{K+}) = 2 \times [8.314 \times 310 \times \ln(140/4.5) + 1 \times 96485 \times (-0.070)]\text{ J} = 2 \times (8856.1 - 6754.0)\text{ J} = +3.4\text{ kJ}

    You inverted the concentration ratio for potassium as well. Potassium is imported from outside (4.5 mM4.5\text{ mM}) to inside (140 mM140\text{ mM}), so CdestCsource=1404.5\frac{C_{\text{dest}}}{C_{\text{source}}} = \frac{140}{4.5}. Moving potassium uphill into the cell requires chemical work (+8.86 kJ/mol+8.86\text{ kJ/mol}). With your inverted ratio, the chemical term became negative, erroneously suggesting transport was strongly spontaneous.

  3. Step 3

    ΔGtransport=0.99 kJ−31.22 kJ=−30.23 kJ\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 0.99\text{ kJ} - 31.22\text{ kJ} = -30.23\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    ΔGtransport=+39.5 kJ+3.4 kJ=+42.9 kJ\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +39.5\text{ kJ} + 3.4\text{ kJ} = +42.9\text{ kJ}

    You correctly summed your calculated values for sodium and potassium, but the total is negative due to the sign errors propagated from the previous two steps.

  4. Step 4

    Since ΔGtransport is negative (−30.23 kJ), ATP is not needed, but comparing magnitudes 50.0 kJ>−30.23 kJ, so ATP is sufficient.\text{Since }\Delta G_{\text{transport}}\text{ is negative }(-30.23\text{ kJ}),\text{ ATP is not needed, but comparing magnitudes }50.0\text{ kJ} > -30.23\text{ kJ},\text{ so ATP is sufficient.}

    Correct

    Because ∣ΔGATP∣=50.0 kJ/mol>ΔGtransport=+42.9 kJ/mol (net ΔGcoupled=−7.1 kJ/mol<0), one mole of ATP hydrolysis is thermodynamically sufficient.\text{Because }|\Delta G_{\text{ATP}}| = 50.0\text{ kJ/mol} > \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +42.9\text{ kJ/mol}\text{ (net }\Delta G_{\text{coupled}} = -7.1\text{ kJ/mol} < 0),\text{ one mole of ATP hydrolysis is thermodynamically sufficient.}

    Your conclusion was clouded by the negative sign from earlier steps. Transport across gradients is an active, endergonic process requiring input energy (ΔGtransport>0\Delta G_{\text{transport}} > 0), which is why coupling to ATP hydrolysis (ΔGATP=−50.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = -50.0\text{ kJ/mol}) is necessary.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the stoichiometric coefficients of 3 mol NaX+3\text{ mol }\ce{Na+} and 2 mol KX+2\text{ mol }\ce{K+}.

You assigned the correct electrical potential differences ΔV\Delta V and signs for the moving cations.

You accurately converted between joules and kilojoules throughout your scratchwork.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted concentration ratio in chemical potential

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You used the ratio CsourceCdest\frac{C_{\text{source}}}{C_{\text{dest}}} instead of CdestCsource\frac{C_{\text{dest}}}{C_{\text{source}}} in the chemical work term RTln⁡(CdestCsource)RT\ln\left(\frac{C_{\text{dest}}}{C_{\text{source}}}\right). Remember that moving a solute from low concentration to high concentration (uphill) requires work, which means the concentration term must be greater than 1 so that ln⁡(>1)>0\ln(>1) > 0.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Destination over Source Ratio
  • In thermodynamic transport equations, the chemical free energy term is ΔGchem=RTln⁡(CdestCsource)\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = RT\ln\left(\frac{C_{\text{dest}}}{C_{\text{source}}}\right).

  • Always identify the starting compartment as 'source' and the arrival compartment as 'dest'. If an ion is pumped against its gradient (Cdest>CsourceC_{\text{dest}} > C_{\text{source}}), verify that the ratio is >1> 1 and ΔGchem>0\Delta G_{\text{chem}} > 0.

Thermodynamic Reality Check
  • Primary active transport is endergonic (ΔGtransport>0\Delta G_{\text{transport}} > 0); it always requires exergonic energy input like ATP hydrolysis.

  • If your total transport ΔG\Delta G comes out negative for a primary active pump, immediately stop and check the signs and ratios of your chemical terms.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the chemical ratio as CdestCsource=[NaX+]out[NaX+]in=14512≈12.08\frac{C_{\text{dest}}}{C_{\text{source}}} = \frac{[\ce{Na+}]_{\text{out}}}{[\ce{Na+}]_{\text{in}}} = \frac{145}{12} \approx 12.08.

  2. Compute ΔG(NaX+)=3×[2.577×ln⁡(12.08)+96.485×0.070]=3×[6.42+6.75]=+39.5 kJ\Delta G(\ce{Na+}) = 3 \times [2.577 \times \ln(12.08) + 96.485 \times 0.070] = 3 \times [6.42 + 6.75] = +39.5\text{ kJ}.

  3. Set up potassium ratio as [KX+]in[KX+]out=1404.5≈31.11\frac{[\ce{K+}]_{\text{in}}}{[\ce{K+}]_{\text{out}}} = \frac{140}{4.5} \approx 31.11, giving ΔG(KX+)=2×[2.577×ln⁡(31.11)+96.485×(−0.070)]=2×[8.86−6.75]=+3.4 kJ\Delta G(\ce{K+}) = 2 \times [2.577 \times \ln(31.11) + 96.485 \times (-0.070)] = 2 \times [8.86 - 6.75] = +3.4\text{ kJ}.

  4. Sum the transport energies: ΔGtransport=+39.5 kJ+3.4 kJ=+42.9 kJ\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +39.5\text{ kJ} + 3.4\text{ kJ} = +42.9\text{ kJ}.

  5. Compare with ATP hydrolysis: ∣ΔGATP∣=50.0 kJ/mol>42.9 kJ/mol|\Delta G_{\text{ATP}}| = 50.0\text{ kJ/mol} > 42.9\text{ kJ/mol}, confirming ATP hydrolysis provides sufficient energy.

Final answer

(a) ΔGtransport=+42.9 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +42.9\text{ kJ/mol}; (b) Yes, one mole of ATP hydrolysis is thermodynamically sufficient.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice labeling 'source' and 'dest' explicitly above your concentrations before plugging them into the logarithm.

  • Perform a physical sanity check: pumping a solute against its concentration gradient must always give a positive chemical work value.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A cell has a resting potential of Vm=−60 mVV_m = -60\text{ mV}. Calculate the electrical component of the free energy change (ΔGelec=zFΔV\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = z F \Delta V) for exporting 1 mol1\text{ mol} of Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+} (z=+2z = +2) from the cytoplasm to the extracellular fluid. Use F=96500 C/molF = 96500\text{ C/mol}.

Answer

ΔGelec=+11.58 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = +11.58\text{ kJ/mol}. Key steps: For export, ΔV=Vout−Vin=0−(−0.060 V)=+0.060 V\Delta V = V_{\text{out}} - V_{\text{in}} = 0 - (-0.060\text{ V}) = +0.060\text{ V}. Then ΔGelec=(+2)(96500 C/mol)(+0.060 V)=+11580 J/mol=+11.58 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = (+2)(96500\text{ C/mol})(+0.060\text{ V}) = +11580\text{ J/mol} = +11.58\text{ kJ/mol}.

02

A proton pump in a plant vacuole translocates H+\text{H}^+ from the cytoplasm (V=0 mVV = 0\text{ mV}, pH=7.2\text{pH} = 7.2) into the vacuole (V=+30 mVV = +30\text{ mV}, pH=5.2\text{pH} = 5.2) at T=298 KT = 298\text{ K}. Calculate the total ΔG\Delta G required to import 1 mol1\text{ mol} of H+\text{H}^+. (R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}), F=96485 C/molF = 96485\text{ C/mol}).

Answer

ΔG=+14.3 kJ/mol\Delta G = +14.3\text{ kJ/mol}. Key steps: ΔpH=5.2−7.2=−2.0\Delta \text{pH} = 5.2 - 7.2 = -2.0, so Cdest/Csource=102=100C_{\text{dest}}/C_{\text{source}} = 10^2 = 100. Chemical work: RTln⁡(100)=(8.314)(298)(4.605)≈+11.41 kJ/molR T \ln(100) = (8.314)(298)(4.605) \approx +11.41\text{ kJ/mol}. Electrical work: ΔV=Vvacuole−Vcytoplasm=+0.030−0=+0.030 V\Delta V = V_{\text{vacuole}} - V_{\text{cytoplasm}} = +0.030 - 0 = +0.030\text{ V}; zFΔV=(+1)(96485)(+0.030)≈+2.89 kJ/molz F \Delta V = (+1)(96485)(+0.030) \approx +2.89\text{ kJ/mol}. Total ΔG=11.41+2.89=+14.3 kJ/mol\Delta G = 11.41 + 2.89 = +14.3\text{ kJ/mol}.

03

An active transporter couples the symport of 2 mol2\text{ mol} of Na+\text{Na}^+ down its electrochemical gradient into an intestinal epithelial cell to the uptake of 1 mol1\text{ mol} of glucose against a 100-fold100\text{-fold} concentration gradient at 310 K310\text{ K}. In this cell, [extNa+]out=140 mM[ ext{Na}^+]_{\text{out}} = 140\text{ mM}, [extNa+]in=14 mM[ ext{Na}^+]_{\text{in}} = 14\text{ mM}, and Vm=−60 mVV_m = -60\text{ mV}. (a) Calculate the free energy available from the influx of 2 mol2\text{ mol} of Na+\text{Na}^+. (b) Determine if this is sufficient to import 1 mol1\text{ mol} of glucose.

Answer

(a) ΔG(2Na+)=−23.4 kJ\Delta G(2\text{Na}^+) = -23.4\text{ kJ}; (b) Yes, sufficient. Key steps: For Na+\text{Na}^+ influx, ΔV=Vin−Vout=−0.060 V\Delta V = V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}} = -0.060\text{ V}. Molar ΔG(Na+)=RTln⁡(14/140)+(+1)F(−0.060)=(2.577)(−2.303)+(96.5)(−0.060)=−5.93−5.79=−11.72 kJ/mol\Delta G(\text{Na}^+) = R T \ln(14/140) + (+1)F(-0.060) = (2.577)(-2.303) + (96.5)(-0.060) = -5.93 - 5.79 = -11.72\text{ kJ/mol}. For 2 mol2\text{ mol}, ΔG=2(−11.72)=−23.4 kJ\Delta G = 2(-11.72) = -23.4\text{ kJ}. Glucose import requires RTln⁡(100)=2.577×4.605=+11.87 kJ/molR T \ln(100) = 2.577 \times 4.605 = +11.87\text{ kJ/mol}. Since ∣−23.4 kJ∣>11.87 kJ|-23.4\text{ kJ}| > 11.87\text{ kJ}, the free energy is more than sufficient.

Loading workspace…