Resources

In an agroecosystem study, cattle graze on alfalfa forage. The standing alfalfa provides an available energy density of 1.80×107 J/m21.80\times 10^7\text{ J}/\text{m}^2. A steer ingests 45.0 kg45.0\text{ kg} of dry matter per unit area over a trial period, where the combustion energy of the dry forage is 18.4 MJ/kg18.4\text{ MJ}/\text{kg}. Over the same period, the animal loses 3.72×105 kJ3.72\times 10^5\text{ kJ} via fecal egestion and 1.05×108 cal1.05\times 10^8\text{ cal} via metabolic respiration (1 cal=4.184 J1\text{ cal} = 4.184\text{ J}). Calculate: (a) the total ingested energy in megajoules (MJ\text{MJ}), and (b) the energy incorporated into new cattle biomass (secondary production) in megajoules (MJ\text{MJ}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) 828 MJ828\text{ MJ}; (b) 17.0 MJ17.0\text{ MJ}

Steps

Part (a): Total Ingested Energy (II)

  1. Identify the governing relationship: The total ingested energy equals the mass of dry matter consumed multiplied by the energy density per unit mass of that dry matter: I=mdry⋅EdryI = m_{\text{dry}} \cdot E_{\text{dry}}
  2. Calculate II: Substitute the given values (mdry=45.0 kgm_{\text{dry}} = 45.0\text{ kg} and Edry=18.4 MJ/kgE_{\text{dry}} = 18.4\text{ MJ/kg}): I=45.0 kg⋅18.4 MJ/kg=828 MJI = 45.0\text{ kg} \cdot 18.4\text{ MJ/kg} = 828\text{ MJ}

(Note: The standing crop energy density of 1.80×107 J/m21.80 \times 10^7\text{ J/m}^2 is background agroecosystem context and is not needed for the animal's individual energy budget.)


Part (b): Energy Incorporated into New Biomass (Secondary Production, PP)

  1. Understand consumer energy partitioning: In an animal energy budget, the ingested chemical energy (II) is partitioned into:

    • Energy lost via egestion (feces, FF)
    • Energy lost via cellular respiration/heat (RR)
    • Energy assimilated into new tissue/growth (secondary production, PP)

    The energy balance is given by: I=P+R+F  ⟹  P=I−F−RI = P + R + F \implies P = I - F - R

  2. Convert all energy terms to the same unit (MJ\text{MJ}):

    • Fecal loss (FF): F=3.72×105 kJ=3.72×105×10−3 MJ=372 MJF = 3.72 \times 10^5\text{ kJ} = 3.72 \times 10^5 \times 10^{-3}\text{ MJ} = 372\text{ MJ}
    • Respiration loss (RR): Convert calories to joules using 1 cal=4.184 J1\text{ cal} = 4.184\text{ J}: R=1.05×108 cal⋅4.184 J/cal=4.3932×108 JR = 1.05 \times 10^8\text{ cal} \cdot 4.184\text{ J/cal} = 4.3932 \times 10^8\text{ J} Convert joules to megajoules (1 MJ=106 J1\text{ MJ} = 10^6\text{ J}): R=4.3932×108 J106 J/MJ≈439 MJR = \frac{4.3932 \times 10^8\text{ J}}{10^6\text{ J/MJ}} \approx 439\text{ MJ}
  3. Compute secondary production (PP): Subtract the metabolic and fecal losses from the total ingested energy: P=828 MJ−372 MJ−439 MJ=17.0 MJP = 828\text{ MJ} - 372\text{ MJ} - 439\text{ MJ} = 17.0\text{ MJ}

    (Using unrounded intermediate values gives 828−372−439.32=16.68 MJ828 - 372 - 439.32 = 16.68\text{ MJ}, which rounds to 17.0 MJ17.0\text{ MJ} according to the standard three-significant-figure precision of the input data).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the energy available in the standing crop per square meter with the actual energy ingested by the steer.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Ingested energy = standing alfalfa energy density   ⟹  18 MJ\implies 18\text{ MJ}

    Correct

    I=mdry⋅Edry=45.0 kg×18.4 MJ/kg=828 MJI = m_{\text{dry}} \cdot E_{\text{dry}} = 45.0\text{ kg} \times 18.4\text{ MJ/kg} = 828\text{ MJ}

    You used the energy density of the standing alfalfa crop instead of calculating the energy actually consumed by the steer from its dry matter intake.

  2. Step 2

    Fecal energy=3.72×105 kJ=372 MJ\text{Fecal energy} = 3.72 \times 10^5\text{ kJ} = 372\text{ MJ}

  3. Step 3

    Respiration energy=1.05×108×4.184 J=439.32 MJ\text{Respiration energy} = 1.05 \times 10^8 \times 4.184\text{ J} = 439.32\text{ MJ}

  4. Step 4

    Secondary production=18 MJ−372 MJ−439.32 MJ=−793.32 MJ\text{Secondary production} = 18\text{ MJ} - 372\text{ MJ} - 439.32\text{ MJ} = -793.32\text{ MJ}

    Correct

    P=I−F−R=828 MJ−372 MJ−439.32 MJ=16.68 MJ≈17.0 MJP = I - F - R = 828\text{ MJ} - 372\text{ MJ} - 439.32\text{ MJ} = 16.68\text{ MJ} \approx 17.0\text{ MJ}

    Your energy budget equation (P=I−F−RP = I - F - R) is conceptually sound, but the calculation was thrown off by the incorrect value of ingested energy from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted both fecal energy (3.72×105 kJ3.72 \times 10^5\text{ kJ}) and respiration energy (1.05×108 cal1.05 \times 10^8\text{ cal}) into consistent units of MJ\text{MJ}.

You set up the consumer energy balance relationship correctly by subtracting egestion and respiration losses from ingested energy.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Standing Crop vs. Ingestion Confusion

No, this is a conceptual misunderstanding regarding which parameter determines animal ingestion.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You mistook the environmental pool of energy (the standing crop's energy density per unit area) for the amount of energy actually taken in by the consumer. An animal only ingests the biomass it physically consumes (mdry×Edrym_{\text{dry}} \times E_{\text{dry}}), not the total energy present in the surrounding standing vegetation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Standing Crop vs. Ingested Biomass
  • Standing crop energy (J/m2\text{J}/\text{m}^2) describes the resource pool in the habitat, while ingested energy (II) depends strictly on the quantity of food eaten (mm) and its caloric density (EE).

  • Always find the ingested energy by multiplying the mass of forage consumed by its specific energy content: I=m×EforageI = m \times E_{\text{forage}}.

Sanity Check on Secondary Production
  • Under normal feeding conditions, secondary production (P=I−F−RP = I - F - R) represents net growth or storage and should be positive.

  • If your computed secondary production is negative, verify whether ingested energy (II) is greater than the sum of metabolic and fecal losses (F+RF + R).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate total ingested energy using intake mass and energy content: I=45.0 kg×18.4 MJ/kg=828 MJI = 45.0\text{ kg} \times 18.4\text{ MJ/kg} = 828\text{ MJ}.

  2. Substitute the correct ingested energy into your budget equation: P=828 MJ−372 MJ−439.32 MJ=16.68 MJP = 828\text{ MJ} - 372\text{ MJ} - 439.32\text{ MJ} = 16.68\text{ MJ}.

  3. Round to three significant figures: P=17.0 MJP = 17.0\text{ MJ}.

Final answer

(a) 828 MJ828\text{ MJ}; (b) 17.0 MJ17.0\text{ MJ}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying the difference between ambient primary producer energy (standing crop) and consumer dietary intake in ecosystem word problems.

  • Double-check that total ingested energy (II) exceeds respiratory and egestive losses before completing consumer energy budget calculations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates assimilated energy instead of secondary production by omitting the energy lost to metabolic respiration.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ingested energy=45.0 kg×18.4 MJ/kg=828 MJ\text{Ingested energy} = 45.0\text{ kg} \times 18.4\text{ MJ/kg} = 828\text{ MJ}

  2. Step 2

    Fecal energy=3.72×105 kJ=372 MJ\text{Fecal energy} = 3.72 \times 10^5\text{ kJ} = 372\text{ MJ}

  3. Step 3

    Biomass energy=Ingested energy−Fecal energy  ⟹  Secondary production=828 MJ−372 MJ=456 MJ\text{Biomass energy} = \text{Ingested energy} - \text{Fecal energy} \implies \text{Secondary production} = 828\text{ MJ} - 372\text{ MJ} = 456\text{ MJ}

    Correct

    P=I−F−R=828 MJ−372 MJ−439 MJ=17.0 MJP = I - F - R = 828\text{ MJ} - 372\text{ MJ} - 439\text{ MJ} = 17.0\text{ MJ}

    Secondary production represents only the net energy stored as new growth or tissue. Ingested energy minus fecal loss gives assimilated energy (AA), not secondary production (PP). You must also subtract metabolic respiration (RR).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated total ingested energy as 828 MJ828\text{ MJ}.

You correctly converted the fecal energy loss from kilojoules to megajoules (372 MJ372\text{ MJ}).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Assimilated Energy with Secondary Production

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated assimilated energy (A=I−FA = I - F) as the final biomass produced, omitting the metabolic heat and maintenance costs lost through cellular respiration (RR). In an animal energy budget, secondary production is net production: P=A−R=I−F−RP = A - R = I - F - R.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Consumer Energy Partitioning
  • I=F+R+PI = F + R + P, or P=I−F−RP = I - F - R

  • Always distinguish between gross intake (II), assimilated energy (A=I−FA = I - F), and secondary production (P=A−RP = A - R).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert metabolic respiration (RR) from calories to megajoules: R=1.05×108 cal×4.184 J/cal=4.3932×108 J≈439.32 MJR = 1.05 \times 10^8\text{ cal} \times 4.184\text{ J/cal} = 4.3932 \times 10^8\text{ J} \approx 439.32\text{ MJ}.

  2. Subtract both fecal energy (FF) and respiration (RR) from ingested energy (II): P=828 MJ−372 MJ−439.32 MJ=16.68 MJP = 828\text{ MJ} - 372\text{ MJ} - 439.32\text{ MJ} = 16.68\text{ MJ}.

  3. Round to three significant figures to match the given data: P=17.0 MJP = 17.0\text{ MJ}.

Final answer

(a) 828 MJ828\text{ MJ}; (b) 17.0 MJ17.0\text{ MJ}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review consumer energy allocation diagrams, noting the branch point between assimilation and respiration.

  • Practice writing down the full energy budget formula I=F+R+PI = F + R + P before substituting numerical values.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to convert calories to joules when converting metabolic respiration to megajoules, treating calories directly as joules.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ingested energy=45.0 kg×18.4 MJ/kg=828 MJ\text{Ingested energy} = 45.0\text{ kg} \times 18.4\text{ MJ/kg} = 828\text{ MJ}

  2. Step 2

    Fecal energy=3.72×105 kJ=372 MJ\text{Fecal energy} = 3.72 \times 10^5\text{ kJ} = 372\text{ MJ}

  3. Step 3

    Respiration energy=1.05×108 J=105 MJ\text{Respiration energy} = 1.05 \times 10^8\text{ J} = 105\text{ MJ}

    Correct

    R=1.05×108 cal×4.184 J/cal=4.3932×108 J≈439 MJR = 1.05 \times 10^8\text{ cal} \times 4.184\text{ J/cal} = 4.3932 \times 10^8\text{ J} \approx 439\text{ MJ}

    The problem provided respiration energy as 1.05×108 cal1.05 \times 10^8\text{ cal}, but you copied the numerical value with the unit joules (J\text{J}) instead of converting calories to joules using 1 cal=4.184 J1\text{ cal} = 4.184\text{ J}.

  4. Step 4

    Secondary production=828 MJ−372 MJ−105 MJ=351 MJ\text{Secondary production} = 828\text{ MJ} - 372\text{ MJ} - 105\text{ MJ} = 351\text{ MJ}

    Correct

    P=828 MJ−372 MJ−439.32 MJ≈17.0 MJP = 828\text{ MJ} - 372\text{ MJ} - 439.32\text{ MJ} \approx 17.0\text{ MJ}

    You correctly set up the energy partition balance P=I−F−RP = I - F - R, but your final numerical answer was thrown off by the incorrect respiration value from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated total ingested energy as 828 MJ828\text{ MJ}.

You correctly converted fecal energy from kilojoules to megajoules.

You applied the correct consumer energy partitioning equation: P=I−F−RP = I - F - R.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted calorie-to-joule unit conversion

You treated calories directly as joules without multiplying by the conversion factor 4.184 J/cal4.184\text{ J/cal}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When given quantities in non-SI units such as calories, you need to explicitly carry out dimensional analysis before converting prefixes like kilo- or mega- to ensure all terms match SI units.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Unit Verification Check
  • Always track the original given unit (1 cal=4.184 J1\text{ cal} = 4.184\text{ J}) before applying metric prefixes like mega (10610^6).

  • Write out conversion factors with canceling units explicitly: (1.05×108 cal)×(4.184 J1 cal)×(1 MJ106 J)(1.05 \times 10^8\text{ cal}) \times \left(\frac{4.184\text{ J}}{1\text{ cal}}\right) \times \left(\frac{1\text{ MJ}}{10^6\text{ J}}\right).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert respiration energy from calories to joules: R=1.05×108 cal×4.184 J/cal=4.3932×108 JR = 1.05 \times 10^8\text{ cal} \times 4.184\text{ J/cal} = 4.3932 \times 10^8\text{ J}

  2. Convert joules to megajoules: R=4.3932×108 J106 J/MJ=439.32 MJR = \frac{4.3932 \times 10^8\text{ J}}{10^6\text{ J/MJ}} = 439.32\text{ MJ}

  3. Substitute into the secondary production formula: P=828 MJ−372 MJ−439.32 MJ=16.68 MJ≈17.0 MJP = 828\text{ MJ} - 372\text{ MJ} - 439.32\text{ MJ} = 16.68\text{ MJ} \approx 17.0\text{ MJ}

Final answer

(a) 828 MJ828\text{ MJ}; (b) 17.0 MJ17.0\text{ MJ}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that all energy terms are converted to the target unit (MJ\text{MJ}) using given conversion factors before adding or subtracting.

  • Practice dimensional analysis by writing unit fractions so units clearly cancel out.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sheep consumes 12.0 kg12.0\text{ kg} of dry grass containing 17.5 MJ/kg17.5\text{ MJ/kg}. During digestion and metabolism, it loses 84.0 MJ84.0\text{ MJ} in feces and 112.0 MJ112.0\text{ MJ} through respiration. Calculate: (a) total ingested energy, and (b) secondary production in MJ\text{MJ}.

Answer

(a) I=12.0 kg×17.5 MJ/kg=210 MJI = 12.0\text{ kg} \times 17.5\text{ MJ/kg} = 210\text{ MJ}. (b) P=I−F−R=210 MJ−84.0 MJ−112.0 MJ=14.0 MJP = I - F - R = 210\text{ MJ} - 84.0\text{ MJ} - 112.0\text{ MJ} = 14.0\text{ MJ}.

02

A deer feeds in a forest clearing where standing vegetation contains 5.0×106 J/m25.0 \times 10^6\text{ J/m}^2. The deer ingests 8.0 kg8.0\text{ kg} of browse (16.0 MJ/kg16.0\text{ MJ/kg}). Its assimilation efficiency is 40%40\% (A=0.40×IA = 0.40 \times I). If respiration accounts for 42.0 MJ42.0\text{ MJ}, find: (a) assimilated energy (AA), and (b) secondary production (PP) in MJ\text{MJ}.

Answer

(a) I=8.0 kg×16.0 MJ/kg=128 MJI = 8.0\text{ kg} \times 16.0\text{ MJ/kg} = 128\text{ MJ}; A=0.40×128 MJ=51.2 MJA = 0.40 \times 128\text{ MJ} = 51.2\text{ MJ}. (b) P=A−R=51.2 MJ−42.0 MJ=9.2 MJP = A - R = 51.2\text{ MJ} - 42.0\text{ MJ} = 9.2\text{ MJ}.

03

A captive herbivore ingests 500 MJ500\text{ MJ} of feed over a month. Fecal losses are 220 MJ220\text{ MJ} and urinary excretion is 20 MJ20\text{ MJ}. If 35%35\% of the metabolizable energy (I−F−UI - F - U) is allocated to secondary production, calculate: (a) energy lost to respiration (RR), and (b) secondary production (PP) in MJ\text{MJ}.

Answer

(a) Metabolizable energy ME=500−220−20=260 MJ\text{ME} = 500 - 220 - 20 = 260\text{ MJ}. Production P=0.35×260=91.0 MJP = 0.35 \times 260 = 91.0\text{ MJ}. Respiration R=260−91.0=169 MJR = 260 - 91.0 = 169\text{ MJ}. (b) P=91.0 MJP = 91.0\text{ MJ}.

Loading workspace…