Resources
Consider two dividing cell lineages derived from an organism with chromosomes: Lineage A is undergoing mitotic anaphase, while Lineage B is undergoing anaphase I of meiosis. Let and represent the total number of individual chromosomes and individual chromatids present in Lineage A during anaphase, respectively. Let and represent the total number of individual chromosomes and individual chromatids present in Lineage B during anaphase I, respectively. Determine the numerical values of the dimensionless ratios and .
Answer and steps
Final answer
; (or , ).
Steps
Determine chromosome and chromatid counts in Lineage A (Mitotic Anaphase)
- Initial state: The organism has a diploid chromosome number of . Following DNA replication during interphase, the cell enters mitosis with duplicated chromosomes, each consisting of sister chromatids (a total of chromatids).
- Event during mitotic anaphase: The centromere of each duplicated chromosome divides, and sister chromatids separate toward opposite spindle poles.
- Counts:
- Once separated, each sister chromatid is functionally and terminologically an independent, individual chromosome (daughter chromosome). Therefore, the total number of individual chromosomes is:
- Each of these single-stranded chromosomes represents one individual chromatid:
Determine chromosome and chromatid counts in Lineage B (Meiotic Anaphase I)
- Initial state: Prior to meiosis I, DNA replicates so that the cell contains duplicated chromosomes ( chromatids) arranged into homologous pairs (tetrads/bivalents).
- Event during anaphase I: Spindle fibers separate homologous chromosomes to opposite poles. Crucially, the centromeres do not split, meaning sister chromatids remain joined at their centromeres.
- Counts:
- Because centromeres have not divided, there are still individual (duplicated) chromosomes moving within the cell:
- Each chromosome still consists of sister chromatids:
Calculate the dimensionless ratios and
- Ratio of chromosomes ():
- Ratio of chromatids ():
Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is confusing the chromosome count with the chromatid count during mitotic anaphase. Remember that a chromosome is counted by its functional centromere: when centromeres split in mitotic anaphase, the chromosome count doubles temporarily (). In contrast, anaphase I separates homologous pairs without splitting centromeres, leaving the chromosome count at .
Typical errors
01 The student forgets that sister chromatids separate into distinct chromosomes in mitotic anaphase, counting CA as 12 instead of 24.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Lineage A: , so
CorrectIn mitotic anaphase, centromeres split and sister chromatids separate into distinct daughter chromosomes. Because each separated chromatid is now counted as an individual chromosome, the count doubles from to .
- Step 2
Lineage B: , homologous chromosomes separate, so
- Step 3Correct
You set up the ratio formula correctly, but substituting your incorrect value instead of produced instead of .
- Step 4
Lineage A: sister chromatids separate,
CorrectSeparated sister chromatids do not disappear from the total count. Each of the newly formed daughter chromosomes consists of one chromatid (one double-stranded DNA molecule), so .
- Step 5
Lineage B: chromosomes with chromatids each,
- Step 6Correct
Your ratio calculation followed logically from your value of , but because , the correct ratio is .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that homologous chromosomes separate in meiotic anaphase I without centromere division.
You correctly determined that each duplicated chromosome in anaphase I consists of two sister chromatids, yielding .
You correctly applied the ratio formulas and .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated 'sister chromatids' as an entity that vanishes once separation occurs rather than recognizing that each separated chromatid immediately becomes an independent, single-chromatid chromosome possessing its own centromere.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Chromosome Counting Rule
Count the number of functional centromeres to count chromosomes.
Whenever centromeres split during mitotic anaphase or anaphase II, temporarily double the chromosome count of the cell.
- Chromatid Definition
A chromatid represents one DNA double helix within a chromosome.
Count total DNA strands or chromatid units present in the cell; separation turns sister chromatids into individual chromatids, not zero.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCount chromosomes in mitotic anaphase: the centromeres split, yielding chromosomes.
Count chromatids in mitotic anaphase: each of the daughter chromosomes contains chromatid, so .
Compute the chromosome ratio: .
Compute the chromatid ratio: .
,
02 The student confuses anaphase I with anaphase II, believing homologous pairs have already separated and halved the chromosome count in anaphase I.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
In meiotic anaphase I, homologous chromosomes separate toward opposite poles, but the cell has not yet divided and centromeres do not split. All duplicated chromosomes remain within the single dividing cell, so .
- Step 3Correct
Your division followed your values, but this step is affected by your earlier count of .
- Step 4Correct
In Lineage A, the single-stranded chromosomes each constitute one chromatid strand, so . In Lineage B, all chromosomes are still in the cell, each consisting of sister chromatids, so .
- Step 5Correct
Your division followed your values, but this step is affected by your incorrect chromatid totals and .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that centromeres split during mitotic anaphase, doubling the number of independent chromosomes in Lineage A to .
You correctly applied the ratio formulas and using your calculated values.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo, this was a conceptual misunderstanding rather than a clerical slip.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou counted only one pole or assumed cytokinesis had already occurred when evaluating anaphase I, reducing the chromosome count to . Additionally, you assumed that once sister chromatids separate in mitosis, the chromatid count drops to rather than counting each separated strand as an individual chromatid.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Whole-cell counting during anaphase
Until cytokinesis completes, all chromosomes and chromatids moving toward both poles remain inside one single cell.
Count the total number of centromeres and chromatids in the entire cell, not just at one pole.
- Counting chromatids vs chromosomes
A duplicated chromosome has centromere and chromatids; anaphase I does not split centromeres (). When centromeres split in mitotic anaphase, each sister chromatid becomes an individual single-stranded chromosome ().
Multiply duplicated chromosomes by to find total chromatids, and treat separated single-stranded chromosomes as chromatid each.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIn Lineage B (anaphase I), the cell still contains all duplicated chromosomes moving toward opposite poles ( to each pole): .
Each of these chromosomes consists of sister chromatids: .
In Lineage A (mitotic anaphase), the separated chromosomes are single chromatid units: .
Compute .
Compute .
,
03 The student counts separated sister chromatids in mitotic anaphase as continuing to be chromatids rather than individual chromosomes, setting SA = 24 and CA = 12.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
During mitotic anaphase, centromeres split and sister chromatids separate. As soon as they separate, each sister chromatid is considered an independent daughter chromosome, giving individual chromosomes.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
Your calculation followed logically from your previous values, but it is affected by the incorrect value of .
- Step 4
- Step 5
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the chromosomes and chromatids present during anaphase I of meiosis.
You correctly calculated the ratio of chromatids .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated chromosomes in mitotic anaphase as if their count remains equal to the diploid number , overlooking that separating sister chromatids at split centromeres each count as an individual chromosome.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Centromere Counting Rule
The number of individual chromosomes always equals the number of functional centromeres.
Whenever sister chromatids separate at anaphase of mitosis (or anaphase II of meiosis), count each separated chromatid as a distinct chromosome.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that in mitotic anaphase, centromeres split, yielding individual daughter chromosomes.
Keep the anaphase I chromosome count because homologous pairs separate while sister centromeres remain joined.
Recompute the ratio: .
Lock it in
How do you count the number of chromosomes in a cell during any stage of division?
Count the number of functional centromeres. One functional centromere equals one chromosome, whether it has one chromatid or two.
Similar question
An organism has a diploid chromosome number of . Determine the number of chromosomes () and chromatids () present in a single cell during: (a) metaphase of mitosis, and (b) anaphase of mitosis.
Answer
(a) Metaphase: chromosomes (each duplicated), chromatids. (b) Anaphase: centromeres divide, so chromosomes, and chromatids.
A cell from a species with undergoes meiosis. Find the ratio of the number of chromosomes in anaphase I to the number of chromosomes in anaphase II within one dividing cell.
Answer
Ratio is (or ). In anaphase I, homologous pairs separate without centromere splitting, so . In anaphase II, each secondary spermatocyte/oocyte starts with , but centromeres split during anaphase II, giving within that dividing cell. Thus, .
Let denote chromosome count and denote total chromatid (DNA molecule) count. For an organism with , calculate the quantity .
Answer
. In mitotic anaphase, centromeres split: and . In meiotic anaphase I, centromeres do not split: and . Substituting gives .