Resources
Phytochromes mediate the photoperiodic floral transition in plants. A short-day (long-night) plant has a critical dark period threshold of of continuous uninterrupted darkness required to induce flowering. In an experimental growth chamber, four separate cohorts of this plant are maintained under a photoperiod regime with the following scotophase (night) schedules: Treatment A: continuous darkness; Treatment B: continuous darkness; Treatment C: dark period interrupted at hour by a flash of red light (); Treatment D: dark period interrupted at hour by a red light flash immediately followed by a pulse of far-red light (). Identify which treatment cohort(s) will successfully initiate floral induction.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Treatment B and Treatment D
Steps
Photoperiodic Mechanism in Short-Day Plants
In photoperiodism, short-day plants are physiologically long-night plants. They require an uninterrupted scotophase (dark period) that equals or exceeds a critical night length () to initiate flowering:
This response is mediated by the phytochrome pigment system, which exists in two photo-reversible conformations:
- : Inactive form that absorbs red light () and rapidly converts into .
- : Active form that absorbs far-red light () and rapidly reverts to . In darkness, also slowly degrades or reverts to .
In short-day plants, active acts as an inhibitor of flowering. A prolonged, uninterrupted dark period allows levels to fall below an inhibitory threshold, enabling floral induction.
Evaluation of Each Treatment
-
Treatment A ( continuous darkness):
- The dark period lasts , which is shorter than the critical threshold of ().
- Because the uninterrupted dark period is insufficient, no flowering is induced.
-
Treatment B ( continuous darkness):
- The continuous dark period is , exceeding the critical threshold ().
- With no light interruption, inhibitory drops sufficiently to trigger flowering.
- Therefore, Treatment B initiates floral induction.
-
Treatment C ( darkness with a Red light pulse at hour ):
- Although the total scotophase is , a red light pulse converts inactive into active, inhibitory .
- This "night break" resets the dark-measuring mechanism, dividing the night into two shorter continuous segments of roughly and , neither of which meets .
- As a result, no flowering occurs.
-
Treatment D ( darkness with Red followed by Far-Red light at hour ):
- The initial red light flash converts to , but the immediate subsequent pulse of far-red light () photoreverses back into inactive .
- The biological effect of the light interruption depends on the final wavelength received. Because the last pulse is far-red, the inhibitory effect of the red flash is canceled.
- The plant behaves as if it experienced an uninterrupted dark period exceeding , so Treatment D initiates floral induction.
Common Pitfall
A common mistake is treating the total number of dark hours as additive regardless of interruptions. Photoperiodic timing requires a single, continuous, uninterrupted block of darkness unless the night break is reversed by a subsequent pulse of far-red light.
Conclusion
The cohorts that successfully initiate floral induction are Treatment B and Treatment D.
Typical errors
01 The student misinterprets far-red light as another night break rather than the reversal of the red light pulse, incorrectly concluding that Treatment D will not flower.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Treatment A: 9.25 h < 9.50 h -> no flowering
- Step 2
Treatment B: 9.75 h > 9.50 h -> flowers
- Step 3
Treatment C: red light flash interrupts dark period -> no flowering
- Step 4
Treatment D: interrupted by two light flashes -> no flowering
CorrectTreatment D: Red flash followed immediately by far-red flash photoreverses , canceling the night break flowers
Far-red light () immediately following red light () photoreverses active back to inactive . This cancels the night break, so the plant perceives an uninterrupted long night and flowers.
- Step 5
Flowering cohort: Treatment B only
CorrectFlowering cohorts: Treatment B and Treatment D
Because Treatment D also successfully initiates floral induction after the far-red reversal, your final cohort selection was missing Treatment D.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly compared the continuous dark duration of Treatments A and B to the critical dark period threshold of .
You correctly identified that a red light flash during the dark period prevents flowering in a short-day plant.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou viewed far-red light as a second disruptive light break rather than a reversal signal that cancels the preceding red flash.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked the photoreversible nature of the phytochrome system: red light converts to the active inhibitor , but an immediate far-red pulse converts back to , nullifying the night-break effect.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Phytochrome Photo-Reversibility Rule
Phytochromes exist in two interconvertible forms: and . In short-day plants, inhibits flowering.
Check the wavelength of the very last light flash in the sequence: if the final pulse is far-red light, the interruption is canceled and returns to .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIn Treatment D, the red light pulse converts to active , which would normally act as a night break and inhibit flowering.
The immediate subsequent pulse of far-red light () photoreverses back into inactive , canceling the effect of the red flash.
Because the night break is effectively canceled, the plant perceives the entire scotophase as continuous darkness (), inducing flowering.
Treatment B and Treatment D
02 The student sums total cumulative hours of darkness rather than requiring continuous uninterrupted darkness, incorrectly concluding that Treatment C will flower.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Treatment A: 9.25 h darkness -> no flowering ⟹ Treatment B: 9.75 h darkness -> flowers
- Step 2
Treatment C: total dark hours = 10.33 h > 9.50 h -> flowers
CorrectRed light () converts to , resetting the scotophase into two blocks of and . Because neither block reaches , Treatment C does not flower.
You treated the dark period as additive. A brief pulse of red light interrupts the dark period and resets the plant's time measurement, preventing flowering.
- Step 3
Treatment D: total dark hours = 10.17 h > 9.50 h -> flowers
CorrectThe far-red flash () immediately photoreverses active back to inactive , canceling the night break and allowing floral induction.
Although your conclusion that Treatment D flowers is correct, your reasoning relied on cumulative dark hours rather than the photoreversibility of phytochrome by far-red light.
- Step 4
Flowering cohorts: Treatment B, Treatment C, and Treatment D
CorrectTreatment B and Treatment D
Treatment C will not flower because its continuous dark requirement was broken by the red flash.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the critical threshold of for floral induction.
You correctly evaluated that continuous darkness below prevents flowering in Treatment A.
You correctly concluded that continuous darkness exceeding induces flowering in Treatment B.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou did not make an arithmetic calculation slip; rather, you applied an additive rule to interrupted dark periods.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated total darkness over 24 hours as cumulative rather than requiring a single, uninterrupted continuous block. In photoperiodism, phytochrome measures uninterrupted darkness: a red-light pulse converts to active inhibitory , which resets the dark clock unless a subsequent far-red pulse reverts it back to .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Uninterrupted Scotophase Rule
Short-day plants require continuous, uninterrupted darkness , not cumulative dark hours.
Check whether any light interruption divides the dark period into segments shorter than .
- Phytochrome Photoreversibility
Red light () converts (inhibits flowering in short-day plants); far-red light () converts (cancels the interruption).
Look at the final wavelength pulse: if the night break ends with far-red, treat the dark period as continuous.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIn Treatment C, the red pulse converts to active , breaking the dark period into two intervals of and . Since neither continuous interval meets , Treatment C does not flower.
In Treatment D, the red pulse is immediately followed by a far-red pulse, which reverts back to inactive , effectively canceling the night break.
Because the night break is negated in Treatment D, the plant perceives a full continuous dark period , so Treatment D initiates flowering.
Treatment B and Treatment D
03 The student confuses short-day plant requirements with long-day plant requirements, assuming light flashes promote flowering instead of inhibiting it.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Short-day plant flowers when dark period is shorter than critical night
CorrectA short-day (long-night) plant flowers when the continuous dark period is greater than or equal to the critical night length: .
Short-day plants are physiologically long-night plants. They require a continuous dark period that meets or exceeds the critical night threshold () to lower active levels below the inhibitory threshold.
- Step 2
Treatment A: 9.25 h darkness < 9.50 h -> flowers
CorrectTreatment A: No flowering
Because of darkness is less than the required , the continuous night is too short to permit floral induction.
- Step 3
Treatment B: 9.75 h darkness > 9.50 h -> no flowering
CorrectTreatment B: Floral induction occurs
The continuous dark period of exceeds the critical night length without interruption, so flowering is induced.
- Step 4
Treatment C: night break reduces dark interval below 9.50 h -> flowers
CorrectTreatment C: Red flash at hour resets dark measurement No flowering
You recognized that the red light flash interrupts the night, but in short-day plants, active formed by red light inhibits flowering, preventing floral induction.
- Step 5
Treatment D: far-red restores long dark period -> no flowering
CorrectTreatment D: Far-red pulse reverses to , canceling the night break Floral induction occurs
You correctly determined that far-red light cancels the effect of red light and restores the long dark period. Because short-day plants need a long dark period, this successful restoration induces flowering.
- Step 6
Flowering cohorts: Treatment A and Treatment C
CorrectFlowering cohorts: Treatment B and Treatment D
Carrying through the correct requirement that uninterrupted darkness must be at least shows that Treatment B and Treatment D are the cohorts that flower.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that a red light flash functions as a night break that interrupts dark timing.
You demonstrated an accurate understanding of phytochrome photoreversibility by recognizing that a subsequent far-red pulse negates the effect of the red flash.
You compared the given durations systematically against the critical threshold of .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated 'short-day plant' with requiring a 'short night', when photoperiodic responses are governed by scotophase length: short-day plants require a continuous dark period that equals or exceeds the critical night length.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Short-Day vs. Long-Night
Short-day plants are physiologically long-night plants: they flower only when the continuous dark period .
Always reframe 'short-day plant' as 'requires a long, uninterrupted night' before evaluating any scotophase schedule.
- Phytochrome Action in Short-Day Plants
Active phytochrome () inhibits flowering in short-day plants, whereas prolonged darkness removes this inhibition.
Verify whether the final light flash leaves phytochrome in the active state (inhibitory) or inactive state (permissive of flowering).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState the physiological condition: Short-day plants require continuous darkness .
Evaluate Treatment A: Continuous darkness is , so it does not flower.
Evaluate Treatment B: Continuous darkness is without interruption, so it flowers.
Evaluate Treatment C: A red flash converts , interrupting the dark period into two sub-critical intervals; active inhibits flowering, so it does not flower.
Evaluate Treatment D: The far-red pulse photoreverses back to inactive , canceling the night break and preserving the effective dark duration , so it flowers.
Treatment B and Treatment D
Lock it in
How do red light () and far-red light () affect the interconversion of phytochrome forms?
Red light rapidly converts inactive to active , while far-red light rapidly reverses active back to inactive .
Similar question
A short-day plant requires at least of continuous darkness to flower. It receives a dark period interrupted at hour by the sequence: Red Far-Red Red Far-Red light flashes. Will this plant flower? Explain why.
Answer
Yes, it will flower. The final flash in the sequence is far-red light (), which converts active back into inactive . This cancels the night break, allowing the plant to measure an uninterrupted night of , exceeding the threshold.
A long-day plant requires a night shorter than to flower (or an effective night break during a longer night). It is exposed to a dark period with a flash of red light at hour , immediately followed by a flash of far-red light. Will this plant flower?
Answer
No, it will not flower. In long-day plants, active promotes flowering. While the red flash creates , the subsequent far-red flash reverses it back to , canceling the night break. The plant therefore experiences a continuous dark period, which exceeds its critical night length and prevents flowering.
An experiment exposes four cohorts of a short-day plant ( continuous darkness) to a night with different mid-night interruptions: (1) Far-red flash only; (2) Red flash only; (3) Red followed by Far-red; (4) Far-red followed by Red. Which cohort(s) will flower?
Answer
Cohorts (1) and (3) will flower. In darkness, phytochrome is primarily in the form. A far-red flash alone (1) leaves it as , causing no disruption. In (3), the final far-red flash reverses the red flash back to , canceling the night break. In contrast, cohorts (2) and (4) end with a red flash, producing inhibitory that breaks the dark period and blocks flowering.